Research Article

Multichannel Deep Attention Neural Networks for the Classification of Autism Spectrum Disorder Using Neuroimaging and Personal Characteristic Data

Table 4

Comparison of multichannel DANN on different data combinations using 10-fold cross validation on the entire dataset.

DataAccuracySensitivityPrecisionF-scoreSpecificity

AAL + HO + CC + Demo0.732 ± 0.0240.745 ± 0.1150.730 ± 0.0530.736 ± 0.0420.717 ± 0.101
AAL + HO + Demo0.700 ± 0.0350.698 ± 0.0680.701 ± 0.0350.702 ± 0.0040.673 ± 0.401
AAL + CC + Demo0.703 ± 0.0090.721 ± 0.0840.686 ± 0.0710.699 ± 0.0670.697 ± 0.060
HO + CC + Demo0.691 ± 0.0180.696 ± 0.0980.686 ± 0.1060.690 ± 0.0540.687 ± 0.065
AAL + Demo0.666 ± 0.0020.683 ± 0.0800.650 ± 0.0710.659 ± 0.0060.679 ± 0.031
HO + Demo0.689 ± 0.0270.681 ± 0.0780.696 ± 0.1060.691 ± 0.0110.685 ± 0.057
CC + Demo0.692 ± 0.0530.703 ± 0.0920.681 ± 0.1410.689 ± 0.0430.704 ± 0.055
AAL + HO + CC0.720 ± 0.0620.696 ± 0.0970.738 ± 0.2120.724 ± 0.0780.695 ± 0.056
AAL + HO0.684 ± 0.0270.636 ± 0.0840.730 ± 0.0180.699 ± 0.0350.673 ± 0.050
AAL + CC0.695 ± 0.0180.683 ± 0.0830.706 ± 0.1240.700 ± 0.0300.683 ± 0.052
HO + CC0.688 ± 0.0270.666 ± 0.0860.711 ± 0.0530.697 ± 0.0200.683 ± 0.055
AAL0.658 ± 0.0090.641 ± 0.0780.674 ± 0.1410.663 ± 0.0350.658 ± 0.032
HO0.679 ± 0.0090.683 ± 0.0650.674 ± 0.0710.677 ± 0.0070.691 ± 0.029
CC0.682 ± 0.0050.651 ± 0.0710.713 ± 0.1060.693 ± 0.0340.677 ± 0.046

AAL: AAL atlas-based FC; HO: HO atlas-based FC; CC: CC200 atlas-based FC; Demo: PC data. All data are mean and standard deviation.