Research Article | Open Access

Quan Xu, Xiao Tan, Yunzhen Zhang, Han Bao, Yihua Hu, Bocheng Bao, Mo Chen, "Riddled Attraction Basin and Multistability in Three-Element-Based Memristive Circuit", *Complexity*, vol. 2020, Article ID 4624792, 13 pages, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/4624792

# Riddled Attraction Basin and Multistability in Three-Element-Based Memristive Circuit

**Guest Editor:**Jesus Manuel Muñoz-Pacheco

#### Abstract

By coupling a diode bridge-based second-order memristor and an active voltage-controlled memristor with a capacitor, a three-element-based memristive circuit is synthesized and its system model is then built. The boundedness of the three-element-based memristive circuit is theoretically proved by employing the contraction mapping principle. Besides, the stability distributions of equilibrium points are theoretically and numerically expounded in a 2D parameter plane. The results imply the memristive circuit has a zero unstable saddle focus and a pair of nonzero stable node-foci or unstable saddle-foci depending on the considered parameters. The dynamical behaviors include point attractor, period, chaos, coexisting bifurcation mode, period-doubling bifurcation route, and crisis scenarios, which are explored using some common dynamical methods. Of particular concern, riddled attraction basins and multistability are uncovered under two sets of specified model parameters nearing the tiny neighborhood of crisis scenarios by local attraction basins and phase plane plots. The riddled attraction basins with island-like structure demonstrate that their dynamical behaviors are extremely sensitive to the initial conditions, resulting in the coexistence of limit cycles with period-2 and period-6, as well as the coexistence of period-1 limit cycles and single-scroll chaotic attractors. Moreover, a feasible on-breadboard hardware circuit is manually made and the experimental measurements are executed, upon which phase plane trajectories for some discrete model parameters are captured to further confirm the numerically simulated ones.

#### 1. Introduction

Chaos has attracted appreciable attention due to its potential applications in weather forecasting, aircraft control, and secure communications [1]. Besides, nonlinear electronic circuits have been counted as powerful candidates in supplying experimental and analytical surveys for people to understand chaotic behaviors in these engineering applications. Nonlinear elements including Chua’s diode, PN-junction diode, and memristor, just to refer a few, play a vital role for generating chaos in nonlinear electronic circuits and neuron system [2–8]. To possess the emblematic characteristics of both nonlinearity and nonvolatile memory [2, 3], memristor described by the relation between magnetic flux and electric charge has demonstrated prominent potential in memristor-based applications [4–10]. Particularly, memristor is universally regarded as a basic circuit element that it owns more excellent nonlinearity in constructing chaotic/hyperchaotic electronic circuits [11–27] and systems [28–32] than classical nonlinearities. Namely, a memristor-based circuit is a nonlinear circuit that can display chaos/hyperchaos [11, 12, 15], hidden dynamics [14], and other complex dynamics [16–21]. Thus, the memristor-based circuit is one of the most important application circuits and has received much attention in recent years. Moreover, the memristor-based chaotic circuits have inspired immense research attention in many chaos-based engineering fields including cryptosystem [33], cyber security communication [34], and signal processing [35], just to mention a few. Thus, it is a quite pregnant work to construct a memristive chaotic circuit with an extremely simple topology and feasible hardware realization to promote the chaos-based engineering applications [27]. However, due to the technical drawbacks and high cost in fabricating nanoscale devices, most of the memristors employed in these memristive circuits are equivalently implemented by operational amplifiers and analog multipliers [16–18] as well as memristive diode bridges cascaded with RC [20, 21], LC [23], or RLC filters [36]. Nowadays, numerous memristive circuits are raised by employing these memristor emulators, from which some unique initial conditions associated phenomena are explored [13, 14].

The most vital experience to construct a memristor-based chaotic circuit is to lead one memristor or more with different nonlinearities into an existing linear or nonlinear electronic circuit [11–27]. Some memristive chaotic/hyperchaotic circuits with relatively simple topologies were derived from Chua’s family electronic circuits by replacing linear resistor or Chua’s diode with different memristors [11–16]. Moreover, by leading memristors into classical linear oscillating circuits or filter circuits, some novel memristive chaotic/hyperchaotic circuits including memristor-based Shinriki’s circuit [20], jerk circuit [21], Wien-bridge circuits [22–24], Sallen–Key filter [25], and bandpass filter [26] have been implemented. Extendedly, the two-memristor-based chaotic circuits developed from Chua's circuit topology have been proposed [17, 18]. Generally speaking, most of these memristive circuits have the same topologies as the classical oscillating circuits. Herein, a simple three-element-based memristive circuit is synthesized, which only consists of a passive diode bridge-based second-order memristor, an active voltage-controlled memristor, and a coupling capacitor.

Interestingly, the novel dynamical behaviors including riddled attraction basin [37] and multistability [13, 14, 17, 20, 21, 30, 31, 38] have been numerically explored in some of these memristive circuits/systems. The riddled attraction basin means that if an attractive basin is riddled, an arbitrarily tiny perturbation in any initial condition can lead the dynamics to change from one to another [39]. Besides, this special phenomenon owning island-like attraction basin has been found in coupled neuron system [40], sea-level rise system [41], coupled chaotic oscillators [42], and integrate-and-fire circuit [43], just to refer a few. Furthermore, the multistability is a striking phenomenon in many memristor-based circuits/systems, which involves the coexistence of more than one long-time behavior for a given set of parameters under different initial conditions [29, 30]. Namely, riddled attraction basin often interplays with multistability naturally. In the previous literature [37], these two novel phenomena are numerically investigated in a 4D memristor-based chaotic system, but the experimental measurements are executed by employing a complex discrete component-based equivalent circuit of the memristor-based system. These gave us the inspiration of that the memristor-based circuit can generate the initial conditions associated behaviors of riddled attraction basin and multistability simultaneously. Besides, hardware level experimental measurements of these novel phenomena can effectively narrow the gap between theoretical investigations and memristor-based engineering applications [29].

Considering that a simple memristive chaotic circuit can serve as an elegant paradigm for better understanding of bifurcation and chaotic dynamics, it is a significant research topic to simplify memristive chaotic circuits by minimizing the number of dynamic elements and physical components [44]. Statistically speaking, most of the aforementioned memristive chaotic circuits can be regarded as two oscillating units coupled directly, linearly, or nonlinearly. Besides, an interesting work addresses the fact that two oscillators can share a common element to construct a chaotic circuit [1]. Inspired by these two considerations, a simple three-element-based memristive circuit including two memristors and one capacitor connected in parallel is presented, which can be regarded as two memristor-capacitor oscillating units with a sharing capacitor. As far as the present authors’ knowledge goes, the three-element-based memristive circuit with such a simple topology has not been reported in any previous literature.

The aim of this work is to reveal the unknown features in the proposed memristive circuit. Toward this purpose, the remainder of this paper is organized as follows. The mathematical model in a dimensionless form is built, and then the equilibrium points and their stabilities are explored, as well as the boundedness is proved in Section 2. MATLAB-based numerical simulations for two considered model parameters are executed in Section 3 by bifurcation plots, dynamical maps, finite-time Lyapunov exponents, and phase plane plots, from which the dynamical behaviors associated with two adjustable model parameters are explored. Besides, riddled attraction basins and multistability are disclosed under two sets of specified model parameters in Section 4. An on-breadboard hardware circuit is manually welded, upon which experimental measurements are executed to verify the numerical simulations in Section 5. The conclusions are drawn in the last section.

#### 2. Three-Element-Based Memristive Circuit and Its Boundedness

The proposed three-element-based memristive circuit contains only a capacitor *C*_{1}, a passive diode bridge-based second-order memristor *M*_{1} [23], and an active voltage-controlled memristor *M*_{2} [16], as located in the middle of Figure 1. The circuit schematics of the memristors *M*_{1} and *M*_{2} are illustrated at the left- and right-hand sides, respectively, with dotted rectangles in Figure 1. The resistor *R*_{3} is implemented by an NIC [17]. From the viewpoint of circuit topology and compositions, the proposed three-element-based memristive circuit is one of the simplest chaotic circuits in the literature.

For a passive diode bridge-based second-order memristor *M*_{1} [23], and *i*_{1} are the voltage and current at input terminal, respectively; and *i* are the voltage across capacitor *C* and the current through inductor *L*, respectively. The mathematical model of the memristor *M*_{1} can be described aswhere *ρ* = 1/(2*nV*_{T}), *I*_{S}, *n*, and *V*_{T} are three diode model parameters standing for the reverse saturation current, emission coefficient, and thermal voltage, respectively.

The active voltage-controlled memristor *M*_{2} [16], as shown in the right of Figure 1, contains *U*_{1} to realize a voltage follower for restraining load effect, *U*_{2} to implement an integrator with *R*_{2} to avoid DC voltage integral drift, two multipliers *U*_{3} and *U*_{4}, and a current inverter. Denoting the integral capacitor voltage as , the voltage at the output terminal of multiplier *U*_{4} can be deduced aswhere is the total gain of two multipliers *U*_{3} and *U*_{4}. Thus, the current *i*_{2} at the input terminal of the memristor *M*_{2} can be obtained and simplified as

By employing Kirchhoff's current law to the inverting input terminal of *U*_{2}, we can obtain

Consequently, the mathematical model for the voltage-controlled memristor can be described aswhere is the voltage at the input terminal of the memristor *M*_{2} and is the memristor inner state variable.

Applying Kirchhoff's current law to node A and allying (1) and (5), the proposed memristive circuit in Figure 1 can be mathematically modeled as

The parameters of the linear circuit elements are determined as *R*_{1} = 2 kΩ, *R*_{2} = 4 kΩ, *R*_{3} = 1.5 kΩ, *C*_{0} = *C*_{1} = *C* = 4.7 nF, *L* = 10 mH, and = 0.1 V^{–2}, and the model parameters of four 1N4148 diodes utilized in the diode bridge are assigned as *I*_{S} = 5.84 nA, *n* = 1.94, and *V*_{T} = 25 mV. These circuit parameters are collectively named as the typical circuit parameters in the following sections.

Denote

Equation (6) can be rewritten as

Thus, the mathematical model of the proposed memristive circuit in dimensionless form can be built.

Herein, we discuss the boundedness of the solutions of system (8) by using the following theorem, which can be found in [45]. For the reference, it may be stated as follows.

Theorem 1. *(see 45, Theorem 1.1.1, page 14, Contraction Mapping Principle). Let ( S, ρ) be a complete metric space and let P: S ⟶ S. If there is a constant α < 1 such that for each pair ϕ_{1}, ϕ_{2} ∈ S, we haveand then there is one and only one point ϕ ∈ S with Pϕ = ϕ.*

We use the supremum metric denoted by . Defining **X** = [*x*, *y*, *z*, ]^{T} and takingsystem (8) is rewritten by

Fixed point method [45] is used to draw the boundedness for system (11). The following theorem gives the boundedness of system (11).

Theorem 2. *Let (·) satisfy the Lipschitz condition ( L_{0} is the Lipschitz constant), and let hold. If the initial state X(0) is bounded, then the solution X(t) of system (11) is bounded for t ≥ 0.*

*Proof. *For a given **X**(0), applying the variation of parameters formula to obtainWe use the supremum metric and define the complete metric space bywhere *ϕ* ∈ *C* represents *ϕ* to be continuous.

For *ϕ* ∈ *S*, define (*Pϕ*) (0) = **X**(0). And for *t* ≥ 0 yieldThen, *Pϕ* is continuous and bounded, and it is now clear that *P*: *S* ⟶ *S*. As (·) satisfy the Lipschitz condition and , if , thenTherefore, by the contraction mapping principle, there is a unique fixed point *ϕ* residing in *S*, and that is the solution of system (11). Hence, the solution of three-element-based memristive circuit (8) is bounded.

The normalized typical model parameters in (8) are calculated from the typical circuit parameters by (7) asIn the following investigations, the model parameters *d* and *e* are selected as two adjustable parameters with the other model parameters in (16) fixed.

Making the left-hand side of (8) equal to 0, the equilibrium point of (8) can be determined, which is given aswhere is the solution of the following transcendental equation:According to (8) and (17), the Jacobian matrix at the equilibrium point *P* is obtained and digested asThe characteristic equation of (19) is then obtained aswhereThe model parameters *d* and *f* are selected as two adjustable parameters within the regions of 0.1 ≤ *d* ≤ 0.9 and 0.1 ≤ *f* ≤ 6 to disclose the dynamical behaviors in (8). By numerical simulations, the solutions to for the equilibrium points in the considered model parameter ranges are solved and plotted in Figure 2(a), which implies that (8) has one zero equilibrium point (marked as *P*_{0}) and two nonzero equilibrium points (marked as *P*_{±}) being symmetric about the origin. The distributions for *P*_{±} are changed with the variation of the model parameter *d*, but independent of the model parameter *f*. Besides, four eigenvalues for *P*_{0} and *P*_{±} by applying different model parameters *d* and *f* are numerically obtained from (20), from which the stabilities can be determined.

For the zero equilibrium point *P*_{0}, (20) always owns a pair of conjugate roots with negative real parts and two real roots with opposite signs, which manifests that *P*_{0} is an unstable saddle focus. For the nonzero equilibrium points *P*_{±}, the stabilities for them are the same. Thus, only the corresponding stability distributions for the equilibrium point *P*_{+} are shown in Figure 2(b) in the considered model parameter ranges, where the yellow and green regions represent stable node-foci (marked as SNF), and the red region stands for the unstable saddle-foci (marked as USF), respectively. The yellow and green regions behave with the same stability, but (20) has two pairs of conjugate roots with negative real parts in the yellow region, whereas it has a pair of conjugate roots with negative real parts and two real roots with negative sign in the green region. The unstable saddle-foci in the red region has a pair of conjugate roots with positive real parts and two real roots with negative signs. Obviously, the sign for the real parts of the conjugate roots transmits from negative to positive when the two parameters changed from green region to red region, leading to the occurrence of Hopf bifurcation [27]. That is to say, system (8) loses its stability at the boundary between the green and red regions, leading to the occurrence of state transitions. Since the stabilities of the nonzero equilibrium points are associated with the two model parameters, system (8) can display rich dynamical behaviors when varying these model parameters.

**(a)**

**(b)**

#### 3. Numerically Uncovered Dynamical Behaviors

As aforementioned, the model parameters *d* and *f* are selected as two adjustable parameters to numerically explore the dynamical behaviors in (8). In addition, MATLAB ODE23 algorithm with the time step 0.1 s and time interval [4.5 ks, 5 ks] is utilized for drawing bifurcation plots, and ODE23-based Wolf’s Jacobi method [46] with the time step 1 s and time span 30 ks is applied for plotting the dynamical maps and Lyapunov exponents.

To fully demonstrate the dynamical behaviors, two-dimensional (2D) bifurcation plots depicted by the periodicities of the variable *x* and dynamical maps described by the largest Lyapunov exponent in the *d*–*f* parameter plane are drawn in Figures 3(a) and 3(b), respectively, where the initial conditions (0.1, 0.1, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) are utilized.

**(a)**

**(b)**

In Figure 3(a), different colors labeled by different marks on the colorbar located at the right-hand side represent the corresponding dynamical behaviors, among which the color regions labeled by SS and DS denote the chaotic behaviors with single-scroll and double-scroll attractors, respectively. Besides, the color region labeled by P00 denotes the point attractor [47] and the other color regions labeled by P01 ∼ P09 represent the periodic behaviors with different periodicities from period-1 to period-9. Whereas in Figure 3(b), the different colors on the colorbar located at the right-hand side represent the corresponding values of the largest Lyapunov exponent, among which the red and deep yellow colors with the positive largest Lyapunov exponent denote the chaotic behaviors, and the other colors with the values of zero and negative ones represent the periodic behavior and point attractor, respectively.

It is clearly uncovered that the dynamical behaviors exhibited by the 2D bifurcation plots in Figure 3(a) match perfectly with those depicted by the dynamical maps in Figure 3(b), verifying the occurrence of complex dynamics for the three-element-based memristive circuit with the evolvement in the *d*–*f* parameter plane.

To further brighten the dynamical behaviors in (8), one-dimensional (1D) bifurcation plots and finite-time Lyapunov exponents for the parameter *d* in the region [0.1, 0.9] with the fixed parameter *f* = 1.88 and another parameter *f* in the region [0.1, 6] with the fixed parameter *d* = 0.5 are drawn in Figures 4(a) and 4(b), respectively. Remark that the numerical algorithms for drawing the 1D bifurcation plots and finite-time Lyapunov exponents in Figure 4 are the same as those employed in Figure 3. Herein, to clearly demonstrate the Lyapunov exponents, only the first three Lyapunov exponents are given. The trajectories colored in red are those starting from the initial conditions (0.1, 0.1, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) and the trajectories colored in blue are those starting from the initial conditions (−0.1, 0.1, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) in the bifurcation plots, whereas the initial conditions (0.1, 0.1, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) are employed in the calculation process of finite-time Lyapunov exponents.

**(a)**

**(b)**

In Figure 4(a), we consider the parameter *d* as the bifurcation control parameter. The bifurcation diagram is plotted by checking the local maxima of variable *x*. The orbit begins with a stable point. After Hopf bifurcation happens at Hopf bifurcation point (HBP) [27] with *d* = 0.3487, the orbit loses its stability and runs in a limit cycle with period-1. Afterwards, the orbit evolves to single-scroll chaos following the period-doubling bifurcation route. It is noted that when considering two sets of initial conditions, two symmetric coexisting attractors can be revealed as *d* < 0.4440, indicating the occurrence of coexisting bifurcation mode. Thus, dynamical behaviors including stable point, period, chaos, coexisting bifurcation mode, and period-doubling bifurcation route are explored as the parameter *d* changes.

When the parameter *f* is increased from 0.1, the orbit of system (8) starts from period and goes into chaos via crisis scenario at *f* = 0.2159. When *f* increases to 0.3846, the orbit enters into period again. Thereafter, the orbit enters into chaos again via crisis scenario at *f* = 0.4886. The reverse period-doubling bifurcation scenarios occur at *f* = 4.7408, 4.8730, and 5.6980, respectively, and the orbit enters into period, as illustrated in Figure 4(b). The bifurcation diagrams show some narrow periodic windows in the chaos regions with the zero largest Lyapunov exponent. Moreover, the coexisting bifurcation mode occurs in the parameter regions of 0.1 ≤ *f* ≤ 1.177 and 2.834 ≤ *f* ≤ 6. Consequently, rich dynamical behaviors including period, chaos, coexisting bifurcation mode, period-doubling bifurcation route, and crisis scenarios are explored with the variation of the parameter *f*.

As shown in Figure 4, the 1D bifurcation plots coincide well with finite-time Lyapunov exponents, which further indicate the occurrence of period, chaos, period-doubling bifurcation route, and coexisting bifurcation mode with the variations of the adjustable parameters and initial conditions.

With respect to some discrete *d* and *f*, the phase plane plots of the model (8) in the *x-y* plane are numerically simulated to further confirm the emerging dynamical behaviors, as shown in Figures 5(a)–5(d), respectively, where the initial conditions of the trajectories colored in red and blue are the same as those utilized for the 1D bifurcation plots in Figure 4.

**(a)**

**(b)**

**(c)**

**(d)**

When *d* *=* 0.1 and *f* *=* 1.88, two coexisting point attractors are shown in Figure 5(a), with LE_{1} = 0.0011, LE_{2} = –0.0046, LE_{3} = –0.0515, and LE_{4} = –0.1044; when *d* *=* 0.35 and *f* *=* 1.88, two coexisting limit cycles with period-2 are displayed in Figure 5(b), with LE_{1} = 0.0011, LE_{2} = –0.0283, LE_{3} = –0.0394, and LE_{4} = –8.8207; when *d* *=* 0.5 and *f* *=* 1.88, a double-scroll chaotic attractor is demonstrated in Figure 5(c), with LE_{1} = 0.1339, LE_{2} = 0.0001, LE_{3} = –0.4610, and LE_{4} = –8.6482; when *d* *=* 0.5 and *f* *=* 3, two coexisting single-scroll chaotic attractors are illustrated in Figure 5(d), with LE_{1} = 0.1660, LE_{2} = 0.0006, LE_{3} = –0.4701, and LE_{4} = –11.1751.

#### 4. Riddled Attraction Basin and Multistability

It is interesting that the occurrence of crisis scenarios leads to the appearance of imperfect bifurcation routes in the 1D bifurcation plots, as shown in Figure 4. The dynamical behavior switches from one to another suddenly when the crisis scenario happens [16], which may lead to the occurrence of multistability [48]. Additionally, the generated multistability mechanism in our proposed memristive circuit must be different from the ones in the chaotic systems owning the special structure of symmetry or with offset boosting [49, 50]. For clarity, two narrow parameter ranges are chosen as representative examples to further disclose the dynamical behaviors near the tiny neighborhood of the parameters with crisis scenarios happening. 1D bifurcation plots in the two considered narrow parameter ranges are illustrated in Figure 6, which indicates that the three-element-based circuit can really possess the initial conditions-associated periodic and chaotic behaviors.

**(a)**

**(b)**

With the generality and comparison, four sets of typical model parameters *d* = 0.35 and *f* = 1.88, *d* = 0.5 and *f* = 3, *d* = 0.3593 and *f* *=* 1.88, and *d* = 0.5 and *f* *=* 0.2155 are selected to further explore if the initial conditions associated dynamical behavior is near the crisis scenario or not. The local attraction basins defined as the region of the initial conditions [51] (*x*_{0}, *y*_{0}, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) for the four sets of model parameters are plotted in Figures 7(a)–7(d), respectively. The adjustable initial conditions *x*_{0} and *y*_{0} are all scanned in the region of [–15, 15]. Remark that the local attraction basins in Figure 7 are drawn with the identical time step and time interval utilized in the bifurcation plots in Figure 6, and different attraction regions are padded by different colors to distinguish the attractor types. The color regions labeled by L-SS and R-SS denote the chaotic attractors with single-scroll located at the top left and bottom right corners in the *x*–*y* plane, respectively. Besides, the color regions labeled by L-P1, L-P2, and L-P6, as well as R-P1, R-P2, and R-P6 denote the limit cycles with different periodicities of period-1, period-2, and period-6 located at the top left and bottom right corners in the *x–y* phase plane, respectively.

**(a)**

**(b)**

**(c)**

**(d)**

For comparison, two sets of the model parameters *d* = 0.35 and *f* = 1.88, *d* = 0.5 and *f* = 3 away from the crisis scenarios utilized in Figures 5(b) and 5(d) are employed to sketch the attraction basins in Figures 7(a) and 7(b), with which only the coexistence of limit cycles with period-2 and single-scroll chaotic attractors are generated in the proposed memristive circuit, respectively. The riddled attraction basins merely appear within some initial condition ranges, which divides the attraction basins into unriddled zone and small riddled ones [43]. Whereas for the model parameters *d* = 0.3593 and *f* *=* 1.88 that are near the crisis scenario, it is interesting that the riddled attraction basin with the island-like structure is formed in the whole initial conditions plane, as shown in Figure 7(c). For the model parameters *d* = 0.5 and *f* *=* 0.2155, the attraction basin is divided into finite zones, revealing the dynamical behaviors of coexistence of limit cycles with period-1 and single-scroll chaotic attractors. Obviously, the riddled attraction basins and multistability easily appeared under the set of model parameters near the tiny neighborhood of the parameters with crisis scenarios, which can help us to find or to avoid them in the engineering applications of the proposed memristive circuit. To the best knowledge of the authors, the behavior of riddled attraction basin has been reported in many dynamical systems, but rarely in memristor-based physical circuit.

By numerical simulations, the coexistence of limit cycles with period-2 and period-6 are demonstrated corresponding to the dynamical behaviors revealed in the riddled attraction basins, as shown in Figure 8(a), where the initial conditions (±3, 4.01, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) for period-2 and (±3, 4, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) for period-6 located in different adjacent islands are employed. Note that the initial conditions are symmetrical about the origin and arbitrarily tiny perturbation in the initial conditions, which lead to the fact that the periodic behaviors change from period-2 to period-6, or vice versa. For *d* = 0.5 and *f* *=* 0.2155, the attraction basin of multistability behaviors is depicted in Figure 7(d). The coexistence of limit cycles with period-1 and single-scroll chaotic attractors are demonstrated, as shown in Figure 8(b), where the initial conditions (±5, 5, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) for limit cycles with period-1 and (±5, 2.5, 10^{−9}, 10^{−9}) for the single-scroll chaotic attractors are utilized. The numerical simulations show that the riddled attraction basin and multistability emerge in such a simple memristive circuit under specified model parameters near the crisis scenarios happening.

**(a)**

**(b)**

#### 5. Hardware Experiments

A hardware experimental circuit is manually welded on a breadboard using commercially available discrete components, upon which the circuit running trajectories can be captured to verify the MATLAB numerical simulations. The hardware experimental circuit employs seven potentiometers (two of the seven potentiometers are utilized to adjust the gain of multiplier *U*_{4}), a manually winding inductor, three monolithic capacitors, four N4148 diodes as well as three operational amplifiers TL082CP, and two multipliers AD633 with bipolar ±15 V supply, as shown in Figure 9. The typical circuit parameters are employed in hardware measurements. All the resistor values in our hardware experiments are measured by Tonghui TH2816A Precision LCR Meter. Additionally, the running trajectories are captured by a four-channel digital oscilloscope in XY mode.

**(a)**

**(b)**

By keeping the typical circuit parameters and tuning the potentiometer *R*_{2} and the inductor *L* to meet the model parameters utilized in the MATLAB numerical simulations, the experimentally captured trajectories in the – plane are shown in Figure 10 and Figure 11, respectively. The values of *R*_{2} and *L* can be calculated as *R*_{2} = 20 kΩ, 5.71 kΩ, and 4 kΩ with *L* *=* 10 mH as well as *R*_{2} = 4 kΩ with *L* *=* 6.27 mH by (7) corresponding to Figures 5(a)–5(d), respectively. In Figures 11(a) and 11(b), the circuit parameters are calculated as *R*_{2} = 5.57 kΩ with *L* *=* 10 mH and *R*_{2} = 4 kΩ with *L* *=* 87.24 mH corresponding to Figures 8(a) and 8(b). It is remarked that, to capture the coexisting attractors in the hardware experiments, the desired initial conditions are difficult to assign in the hardware experiments, which are randomly sensed through turning on the hardware circuit power supplies repeatedly [16, 20]. This randomly sensed way is different from the accurately assigned way in digitally FPGA-based hardware experiments [52]. Without considering the minor deviations by the calculation error, parameter error of the circuit components, and nonideality of the active device [53], the experimentally measured results shown in Figures 10 and 11 are well consistent with the MATLAB numerical simulations in Figures 5 and 8, respectively, which validate that the three-element-based memristive circuit can indeed generate these complex dynamical behaviors. Note that the trajectories of the coexisting attractors for different initial conditions are dividedly captured by the digital oscilloscope and are tackled by Adobe Photoshop to overlap them in one figure.

**(a)**

**(b)**

**(c)**

**(d)**

**(a)**

**(b)**

#### 6. Conclusion

This paper mainly presents a comprehensive investigation of the dynamical behaviors in theoretical, numerical, and experimental surveys in a three-element-based memristive circuit. The memristive circuit having fewer circuit elements with a simply connected topology contains only two memristors and one capacitor, which can be regarded as two memristor-capacitor oscillating units with a shared capacitor. The boundedness of the three-element-based memristive circuit is theoretically proved by employing the contraction mapping principle, which implies that the trajectories of the memristive circuit are all confined in a limited phase space. The memristive circuit has three equilibrium points including one zero equilibrium point and two nonzero ones. The zero equilibrium point is always an unstable saddle focus, but the stability is stable node-foci or unstable saddle-foci for the two nonzero equilibrium points with respect to two considered model parameters, which lead to the occurrence of rich dynamical behaviors in the proposed memristive circuit. Dynamical behaviors associated with the two adjustable model parameters including point attractor, limit cycles with different periodicities, single-scroll and double-scroll chaotic attractors, coexisting bifurcation mode, period-doubling bifurcation route, and crisis scenarios are numerically simulated by MATLAB-based programs for 2D/1D bifurcation plots, dynamical maps, finite-time Lyapunov exponents, and phase plane plots. Particularly, under two sets of specified model parameters near crisis scenarios, the phenomena of riddled attraction basins and multistability are numerically discovered by local attraction basins. This is the first time to demonstrate the riddled attraction basins and multistability in such a simple memristive circuit. Moreover, an on-breadboard circuit is manually made by the off-the-shelf components and hardware experiments are executed, from which the memristive circuit running trajectories under some discrete model parameters are captured to further validate the numerically simulated ones. Besides, the analog implementation of memristive circuit can effectively promote the integrated circuit design. These revealed results demonstrate that the presented three-element-based memristive circuit has a great potential for the application in real chaos-based engineering. Moreover, this memristive circuit is one of the simplest chaotic circuits in the literature, which also can provide powerful experimental and analytical platforms for people to understand the dynamical behaviors in electronic engineering and neurology. Moreover, the work done lets us conjecture that there are still some unknown features of this three-element-based memristive circuit, which are to be uncovered in our future research.

#### Data Availability

The data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

#### Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

#### Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant nos. 61801054, 51777016, 61601062, and 61504013, the Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province, China, under Grant nos. BK20160282 and BK20191451, and the Postgraduate Research and Practice Innovation Program of Jiangsu Province, China, under Grant no. KYCX19_1768.

#### References

- A. Jeevarekha, M. P. Asir, and P. Philominathan, “Chaotic dynamics and application of LCR oscillators sharing common nonlinearity,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 26, no. 6, Article ID 1650094, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - G. H. Kom, J. Kengne, J. R. Mboupda Pone, G. Kenne, and A. B. Tiedeu, “Asymmetric double strange attractors in a simple autonomous jerk circuit,”
*Complexity*, vol. 2018, Article ID 4658785, 16 pages, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - L. Chua, “Everything you wish to know about memristors but are afraid to ask,”
*Radioengineering*, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 319–368, 2015. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - S. P. Adhikari, M. P. Sah, H. Kim, and L. O. Chua, “Three fingerprints of memristor,”
*IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers*, vol. 60, no. 11, pp. 3008–3021, 2013. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - F. Corinto, A. Ascoli, and M. Gilli, “Analysis of current-voltage characteristics for memristive elements in pattern recognition systems,”
*International Journal of Circuit Theory and Applications*, vol. 40, no. 12, pp. 1277–1320, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - M. Chen, Y. Feng, H. Bao, B. C. Bao, H. G. Wu, and Q. Xu, “Hybrid state variable incremental integral for reconstructing extreme multistability in memristive jerk system with cubic nonlinearity,”
*Complexity*, vol. 2019, Article ID 8549472, 16 pages, 2019. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Z. Wang, S. Joshi, S. E. Savel’ev et al., “Memristors with diffusive dynamics as synaptic emulators for neuromorphic computing,”
*Nature Materials*, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 101–108, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - B. C. Bao, A. H. Hu, H. Bao, Q. Xu, M. Chen, and H. G. Wu, “Three-dimensional memristive Hindmarsh-Rose neuron model with hidden coexisting asymmetric behaviors,”
*Complexity*, vol. 2018, Article ID 3872573, 11 pages, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - H. Kim, M. P. Sah, C. Yang, S. Cho, and L. O. Chua, “Memristor emulator for memristor circuit applications,”
*IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I Regular Papers*, vol. 59, no. 10, pp. 2422–2431, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - A. Ascoli, F. Corinto, and R. Tetzlaff, “A class of versatile circuits, made up of standard electrical components, are memristors,”
*International Journal of Circuit Theory and Applications*, vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 127–146, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - A. Buscarino, L. Fortuna, M. Frasca, and L. V. Gambuzza, “A chaotic circuit based on Hewlett-Packard memristor,”
*Chaos*, vol. 22, no. 2, Article ID 023136, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - M. Itoh and L. O. Chua, “Memristor oscillators,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 18, no. 11, pp. 3183–3206, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - A. T. Azar, N. M. Adele, T. Alain, R. Kengne, and F. H. Bertrand, “Multistability analysis and function projective synchronization in relay coupled oscillators,”
*Complexity*, vol. 2018, Article ID 3286070, 12 pages, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - L. Wang, S. Zhang, Y.-C. Zeng, and Z.-J. Li, “Generating hidden extreme multistability in memristive chaotic oscillator via micro-perturbation,”
*Electronics Letters*, vol. 54, no. 13, pp. 808–810, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - A. L. Fitch, D. Yu, H. H. Iu, and V. Sreeram, “Hyperchaos in a memristor-based modified canonical Chua’s circuit,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 22, no. 6, pp. 490–908, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Q. Xu, Y. Lin, B. Bao, and M. Chen, “Multiple attractors in a non-ideal active voltage-controlled memristor based Chua’s circuit,”
*Chaos, Solitons & Fractals*, vol. 83, pp. 186–200, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - B. Bao, T. Jiang, G. Wang, P. Jin, H. Bao, and M. Chen, “Two-memristor-based Chua’s hyperchaotic circuit with plane equilibrium and its extreme multistability,”
*Nonlinear Dynamics*, vol. 89, no. 2, pp. 1157–1171, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Q. Tan, Y. Zeng, and Z. Li, “A simple inductor-free memristive circuit with three line equilibria,”
*Nonlinear Dynamics*, vol. 94, no. 3, pp. 1585–1602, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - H. G. Wu, Y. Ye, B. C. Bao, M. Chen, and Q. Xu, “Memristor initial boosting behaviors in a two-memristor-based hyperchaotic system,”
*Chaos, Solitons & Fractals*, vol. 121, pp. 178–185, 2019. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - J. Kengne, Z. N. Tabekoueng, V. K. Tamba, and A. N. Negou, “Periodicity, chaos, and multiple attractors in a memristor-based Shinriki’s circuit,”
*Chaos*, vol. 25, Article ID 103126, 2015. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Z. T. Njitacke, J. Kengne, H. B. Fotsin, A. N. Negou, and D. Tchiotsop, “Coexistence of multiple attractors and crisis route to chaos in a novel memristive diode bidge-based Jerk circuit,”
*Chaos, Solitons & Fractals*, vol. 91, pp. 180–197, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - X. Ye, J. Mou, C. Luo, and Z. Wang, “Dynamics analysis of Wien-bridge hyperchaotic memristive circuit system,”
*Nonlinear Dynamics*, vol. 92, no. 3, pp. 923–933, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - H. G. Wu, B. C. Bao, Z. Liu, Q. Xu, and P. Jiang, “Chaotic and periodic bursting phenomena in a memristive Wien-bridge oscillator,”
*Nonlinear Dynamics*, vol. 83, no. 1-2, pp. 893–903, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Z. J. Li and Y. C. Zeng, “A memristor chaotic circuit based on Wien-bridge oscillator,”
*Journal of Electronic and Information Technology*, vol. 36, no. 1, pp. 88–93, 2014. View at: Google Scholar - B.-C. Bao, P. Wu, H. Bao, M. Chen, and Q. Xu, “Chaotic bursting in memristive diode bridge-coupled Sallen-Key lowpass filter,”
*Electronics Letters*, vol. 53, no. 16, pp. 1104-1105, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - B. Bao, N. Wang, Q. Xu, H. Wu, and Y. Hu, “A simple third-order memristive band pass filter chaotic circuit,”
*IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems II: Express Briefs*, vol. 64, no. 8, pp. 977–981, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Q. Xu, Q. L. Zhang, H. Qian, H. G. Wu, and B. C. Bao, “Crisis-induced coexisting multiple attractors in a second-order nonautonomous memristive diode bridge-based circuit,”
*International Journal of Circuit Theory and Applications*, vol. 46, no. 10, pp. 1917–1927, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - M. Lv, C. Wang, G. Ren, J. Ma, and X. Song, “Model of electrical activity in a neuron under magnetic flow effect,”
*Nonlinear Dynamics*, vol. 85, no. 3, pp. 1479–1490, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - L. Zhou, C. H. Wang, X. Zhang, and W. Yao, “Various attractors, coexisting attractors and antimonotonicity in a simple fourth-order memristive Twin-T oscillator,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 28, no. 4, Article ID 1850050, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - H. Bao, T. Jiang, K. B. Chu, M. Chen, Q. Xu, and B. C. Bao, “Memristor-based canonical Chua’s circuit: extreme multistability in voltage-current domain and its controllability in flux-charge domain,”
*Complexity*, vol. 2018, Article ID 5935637, 13 pages, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - J. Kengne, Z. T. Njitacke, and H. B. Fotsin, “Dynamical analysis of a simple autonomous jerk system with multiple attractors,”
*Nonlinear Dynamics*, vol. 83, no. 1-2, pp. 751–765, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - V. T. Pham, C. Volos, and L. V. Gambuzza, “A memristive hyperchaotic system without equilibrium,”
*The Scientific World Journal*, vol. 2014, Article ID 36898, 9 pages, 2014. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Q. Lai, B. Norouzi, and F. Liu, “Dynamic analysis, circuit realization, control design and image encryption application of an extended Lü system with coexisting attractors,”
*Chaos, Solitons & Fractals*, vol. 114, pp. 230–245, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - B. Qiu, L. Li, H. Peng, and Y. Yang, “Synchronization of multi-links memristor-based switching networks under uniform random attacks,”
*Neural Processing Letters*, vol. 48, no. 3, pp. 1431–1458, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Y. Zhao, X. Zhang, J. Xu, and Y. Guo, “Identification of chaotic memristor systems based on piecewise adaptive Legendre filters,”
*Chaos, Solitons & Fractals*, vol. 81, pp. 315–319, 2015. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - F. Corinto and A. Ascoli, “Memristive diode bridge with LCR filter,”
*Electronics Letters*, vol. 48, no. 14, pp. 824-825, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - G. Y. Wang, F. Yuan, G. R. Chen, and Y. Zhang, “Coexisting multiple attractors and riddled basins of a memristive system,”
*Chaos*, vol. 28, no. 1, Article ID 013125, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - H. Bao, N. Wang, H. Wu, Z. Song, and B. Bao, “Bi-stability in an improved memristor-based third-order Wien-bridge oscillator,”
*IETE Technical Review*, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 109–116, 2019. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - H. L. Yang, “One-side riddled basin below and beyond the blowout bifurcation,”
*Physical Review E*, vol. 62, no. 4, Article ID R4509, 2000. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - A. Saha and U. Feudel, “Riddled basins of attraction in systems exhibiting extreme events,”
*Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science*, vol. 28, Article ID 033610, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - P. B. Goddard, J. J. Yin, S. M. Griffies, and S. Q. Zhang, “An extreme event of sea-level rise along the northeast coast of north America in 2009-2010,”
*Nature Communications*, vol. 6, 2015. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - S. R. Ujjwai, N. Punetha, R. Ramaswamy, and M. Agrawal, “Driving-induced multistability in coupled chaotic oscillators: Symmetries and riddled basins,”
*Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science*, vol. 26, no. 6, Article ID 063111, 2016. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - J. Dai, D.-R. He, X.-L. Xu, and C.-K. Hu, “A riddled basin escaping crisis and the universality in an integrate-and-fire circuit,”
*Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications*, vol. 500, pp. 72–79, 2018. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Q. Xu, Q. Zhang, B. Bao, and Y. Hu, “Non-Autonomous second-order memristive chaotic circuit,”
*IEEE Access*, vol. 5, pp. 21039–21045, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - T. A. Burton,
*Stability by Fixed Point Theory for Functional Differential Equations*, Courier Corporation, Chelmsford, MA, USA, 2013. - A. Wolf, J. B. Swift, H. L. Swinney, and J. A. Vastano, “Determining Lyapunov exponents from a time series,”
*Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena*, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 285–317, 1985. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - J. C. Sprott, X. Wang, and G. Chen, “Coexisting of point, periodic and strange attractors,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 23, no. 5, Article ID 1350093, 2013. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - Q. Lai, A. Akgul, X. W. Zhao, and H. Q. Pei, “Various types of coexisting attractors in a new 4D autonomous chaotic system,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 27, no. 9, Article ID 1750142, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - C. B. Li, J. C. Sportt, Y. J. Liu, Z. Y. Gu, and J. W. Zhang, “Offset boosting for breeding conditional symmetry,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 28, no. 14, Article ID 1850163, 2018. View at: Google Scholar - C. B. Li, T. N. Lu, G. R. Chen, and H. Y. Xing, “Doubling the coexisting attractors,”
*Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science*, vol. 29, Article ID 051102, 2019. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - B. C. Bao, C. J. Chen, H. Bao, X. Zhang, Q. Xu, and M. Chen, “Dynamical effects of neuron activation gradient on Hopfield neural network: numerical analyses and hardware experiments,”
*International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos*, vol. 29, no. 4, Article ID 1930010, 2019. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - F. Yu, L. Liu, B. He et al., “Analysis and FPGA realization of a novel 5D hyperchaotic four-wing memristive system,”
*Active Control Synchronization, and Secure Communication Application Complexity*, vol. 2019, Article ID 4047957, 2019. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar - N. V. Kuznetsov, G. A. Leonov, M. V. Yuldashev, and R. V. Yuldashev, “Hidden attractors in dynamical models of phase-locked loop circuits: limitations of simulation in MATLAB and SPICE,”
*Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation*, vol. 51, pp. 39–49, 2017. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar

#### Copyright

Copyright © 2020 Quan Xu et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.