Abstract
While erythromycin has caused numerous cases of acute liver failure (ALF), clarithromycin, a similar macrolide antibiotic, has caused only six reported cases of ALF. A new case of clarithromycin-associated ALF is reported with hepatic histopathology and exclusion of other etiologies by extensive workup, and the syndrome of clarithromycin-associated ALF is better characterized by systematic review. A 60-year-old nonalcoholic man, with normal baseline liver function tests, was admitted with diffuse abdominal pain and AST = 499 U/L and ALT = 539 U/L, six days after completing a 7-day course of clarithromycin 500 mg twice daily for suspected upper respiratory infection. AST and ALT each rose to about 1,000 U/L on day-2 of admission, and rose to ≥6,000 U/L on day-3, with development of severe hepatic encephalopathy and severe coagulopathy. Planned liver biopsy was cancelled due to coagulopathies. Extensive evaluation for infectious, immunologic, and metabolic causes of liver disease was negative. Abdominal computerized tomography and abdominal ultrasound with Doppler were unremarkable. The patient developed massive, acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding associated with coagulopathies. Esophagogastroduodenoscopy was planned after massive blood product transfusions, but the patient rapidly expired from hemorrhagic shock. Autopsy revealed a golden-brown heavy liver with massive hepatic necrosis and sinusoidal congestion. Rise of AST/ALT to about 1,000 U/L each was temporally incompatible with shock liver because this rise preceded the hemorrhagic shock, but the subsequent AST/ALT rise to ≥6,000 U/L each may have had a component of shock liver. The six previously reported cases were limited by failure to exclude hepatitis E (4), lack of liver biopsy (2), and uninterpretable liver biopsy (1) and by confounding potential etiologies including disulfiram, israpidine, or recent acetaminophen use (3), clarithromycin overdose (1), active alcohol use (1), and severe heart failure (1). Review of 6 previously reported and current case of clarithromycin-associated ALF revealed that patients had AST and ALT values in the thousands. Five patients died and 2 survived.
1. Introduction
Acute liver failure (ALF) refers to severe acute liver injury with encephalopathy and impaired liver synthetic function developing within 4 weeks in a patient with prior normal liver function or well-compensated liver disease [1]. ALF is commonly due to drug-induced liver injury (DILI), with implicated drugs in the United States including acetaminophen overdose (46%), idiosyncratic reactions to various drugs (12%), and occasionally (14% of cases) in which a drug is a possible cause of ALF of uncertain origin [2]. Clarithromycin is a macrolide antibiotic widely used to treat respiratory, skin, or soft tissue infections and infections by Mycobacterium avium complex or Helicobacter pylori.While erythromycin, a related macrolide antibiotic, has caused numerous cases of ALF [3, 4], comprehensive literature review revealed only 6 reported cases of clarithromycin-induced ALF [5–10], in addition to moderate liver injury with moderately elevated liver enzymes and cholestatic hepatitis ascribed to clarithromycin [11, 12]. A case of ALF secondary to clarithromycin is reported, and the syndrome is systematically reviewed.
2. Methods
Systematic literature search on liver injury from clarithromycin using PubMed and Medline with the following medical subject headings/keywords: [(“liver injury”) OR (“drug induced liver injury”) OR (“DILI”) OR (“acute hepatic failure”) OR (“fulminant liver failure”) OR (“acute liver failure”)] AND [(“clarithromycin”)] and by reviewing sections on DILI in medical, hepatology, or pathology textbooks. All articles, including case reports, were reviewed. Two authors independently performed literature searches, independently reviewed prior case reports, and reconciled differences to minimize errors. Two authors abstracted the case report from the electronic medical record and reconciled differences to reduce errors.
3. Case Report
A 60-year-old nonalcoholic man with no known liver disease who was chronically administered the following drugs: albuterol and budesonide-formoterol inhalers for asthma; levothyroxine 100 mcg once daily for hypothyroidism; and amlodipine 5 mg once daily, metoprolol 25 mg once daily, and lisinopril 20 mg twice daily for hypertension, presented with atypical chest pain, dyspnea, and productive cough. Physical examination revealed normal vital signs, bilateral wheezing in both lung fields, and no hepatosplenomegaly or stigmata of chronic liver disease. Serial cardiac enzymes and electrocardiograms were within normal limits. Chest roentgenogram revealed no pulmonic consolidation or infiltrates. Laboratory analysis revealed leukocytosis, normal hemoglobin and platelet counts, and normal blood urea nitrogen and creatinine levels. Liver function tests were initially normal, except for an alanine aminotransferase (ALT) level of 72 U/L (Table 1, column 2). He was diagnosed with asthma exacerbation secondary to upper respiratory tract infection and treated with clarithromycin 500 mg twice daily orally for 7 days; intravenous corticosteroids, which were subsequently converted to a tapering dose of oral prednisone; and resumption of home medications. He was discharged on hospital day 6 when his symptoms subsided after completing 3 days of clarithromycin therapy.
Ten days after discharge and 6 days after completing a seven-day course of clarithromycin, the patient represented with diffuse abdominal pain for 4 days. Physical examination revealed blood pressure of 147/92 mmHg; otherwise normal vital signs; a soft, distended, diffusely tender abdomen with hypoactive bowel sounds and no rebound tenderness or guarding; and no stigmata of chronic liver disease. There was mild leukocytosis and normal hemoglobin level, while the aminotransferase levels were significantly elevated, and international normalized ratio (INR) was 0.9 (Table 1, column 3). The lactic acid was 0.6 mmol/L (normal: 0.5–2.2 mmol/L), ammonia was 22 µmol/L (normal 11–35 µmol/L), and acetaminophen level was <4.0 µg/ml. The next day vital signs were stable, with no change in abdominal exam. The AST and ALT levels rose to >1,000 U/L, and lactate dehydrogenase was 4,200 U/L. Extensive tests for viral hepatitis, including anti-HAV, anti-HBs, anti-HBc, HBs antigen, anti-HCV, HCV-RNA, and anti-HEV, were negative, as were tests for human immunodeficiency virus, cytomegalovirus, and Herpes simplex virus. Blood cultures were sterile. The autoimmune hepatitis panel, including anti-nuclear antibody (ANA), anti-mitochondrial antibody (AMA), anti-smooth muscle antibody (ASMA), anti-liver-kidney microsomal (LKM) antibodies, and total immunoglobulin, was negative or within normal limits. Tests for genetic hemochromatosis were negative. Ceruloplasmin level was normal. Slit-lamp ophthalmologic examination did not reveal Kayser-Fleischer rings. Abdominal computerized tomography (CT) with IV contrast and abdominal ultrasound with Doppler studies were unremarkable. Echocardiography was normal.
On day 3, the patient was transferred to an intensive care unit because of altered mental status, asterixis, and ammonia of 96 µmol/L, findings consistent with grade III hepatic encephalopathy. The AST and ALT rose to ≥6,000 U/L (Table 1, column 5), and the hemoglobin declined to 5.5 g/dL, with severe melena from acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding and development of borderline hypotension (Supplementary Table 1). Bleeding was associated with 35,000 platelets/µL, prothrombin time >100 seconds, activated partial thromboplastin time >124 seconds, D-dimer >9,999 ng/ml, and fibrinogen <35 mg/dL. Massive blood products were transfused. EGD, planned because of acute melena, and liver biopsy, planned for worsening liver failure, were both postponed due to hemodynamic instability and coagulopathy. Despite aggressive resuscitation, the patient rapidly deteriorated, suffered cardiac arrest, and expired.
The family consented to autopsy confined to liver, kidneys, lungs, and pancreas. Liver postmortem examination grossly revealed a golden-brown soft liver weighing 1,980 gm. Histopathologic hepatic examination revealed massive hepatocyte necrosis, occasional sparing of periportal hepatocytes, and diffuse sinusoidal congestion (Figures 1 and 2). No lobular or portal inflammation, fibrosis, viral cytopathic effect, thromboemboli, or malignancy was evident. Immunohistochemistry revealed no Herpes simplex virus types 1 and 2 or cytomegalovirus.
4. Discussion
DILI accounts for approximately 10% of acute hepatitis, but is the most common cause of ALF in the United States and the most frequent reason for drug withdrawal from the marketplace [13]. DILI is classified as predictable, as for acetaminophen, or idiosyncratic, as for amoxicillin/clavulanate. DILI is also classified according to the liver injury pattern as (1) hepatocellular (primarily elevated ALT and AST), (2) cholestatic (primarily elevated alkaline phosphatase), and (3) mixed (elevated AST, ALT, and alkaline phosphatase).
This patient developed ALF 10 days after initiating clarithromycin therapy. Other causes of ALF including viral, ischemic, autoimmune, and Wilson’s disease and hemochromatosis were excluded. Echocardiography revealed a normal ejection fraction. The rise of AST and ALT to about 1,000 U/L each on second hospitalization day 2 preceded the hypotension from hemorrhagic shock which began 1 day later (AST and ALT rised to >6,000 U/L each; Table 1, Supplementary Table 1). The initial rise in AST and ALT could not be attributed to shock liver, but the sharp rise in AST and ALT on day 3 might have been partly due to hepatic ischemia, from massive upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage associated with profound coagulopathy from hepatic failure. This may have contributed to finding hepatic necrosis at autopsy. Concomitant medications were unlikely causes of ALF because they were all chronically administered, except for prednisone which is not believed to cause ALF and has been previously used to treat one case of severe clarithromycin-induced hepatotoxicity [14]. Although renal insufficiency promotes clarithromycin-induced hepatotoxicity [15], the patient had normal renal function throughout the course of clarithromycin therapy.
Clarithromycin is synthesized by substituting a methoxy group for the C-6 hydroxyl group of erythromycin to improve oral bioavailability and gastrointestinal tolerance [16]. ALF has been reported secondary to other macrolides, especially erythromycin and roxithromycin [3, 4, 17, 18]. Clarithromycin is generally well tolerated, with dose reduction required in patients with renal insufficiency [15]. Clarithromycin-induced hepatotoxicity is attributed to (1) dose-related hepatotoxicity with elevated liver enzymes with ≥2 gm/day of clarithromycin in the elderly [19] and (2) possible idiosyncratic or hypersensitivity reactions with no evident dose-dependent relationship [11].
The epidemiology, presenting symptoms, signs, liver function tests, clarithromycin use, outcome, and confounding factors in the prior six cases of ALF associated with clarithromycin and the currently reported case are summarized in Table 2 [5–10]. Review of these 7 patients show that 5 were males (71%), on average were 41.7 ± 14.5 (SD) years old, and had onset of ALF 7.0 ± 3.4 days after onset of clarithromycin use. All patients had peak AST and ALT levels >1,000 U/L. Peak alkaline phosphatase levels ranged from 220–358 U/L, except 1 patient had a level of 1,095 U/L. Peak total bilirubin ranged from 1.7–33.4 mg/dL. All patients had predominantly hepatocellular injury, except that one patient had mixed hepatocellular and cholestatic injury [6]. All patients had significant coagulopathies (peak INR ≥1.9). In four patients having interpretable liver biopsies, performed premortem during ALF or postmortem, findings included moderate to massive hepatic necrosis in 3 and one each with bile duct proliferation, focal nodular regeneration, microvesicular steatosis, eosinophilic infiltration, or diffuse sinusoidal congestion.
Histopathologic analysis of the current patient’s liver revealed diffuse hepatocellular necrosis, consistent with prior reported cases and idiosyncratic DILI as previously reported [20], but had no eosinophilic infiltrates characteristic of certain DILI pathology. Two prior patients also lacked eosinophilic infiltrates [5, 8]. Prominent eosinophilic infiltrates can suggest drug-induced hypersensitivity, but rarely occur in idiosyncratic drug reactions. No histopathologic findings are pathognomonic of DILI; a high index of clinical suspicion and compatible histopathologic findings are required for the diagnosis.
This review suffers from limitations of the 6 previously reported cases, including lack of liver biopsy (2) [7, 9], uninterpretable liver biopsy (1) [10], and administration of confounding potentially hepatotoxic drugs (3), including disulfiram [7], israpidine [8], or acetaminophen [5]. Other confounding variables included alcoholism (1) [7], heart failure (1) [9], and clarithromycin overdose (1) [10]. Also, hepatitis E, which can mimic DILI, [21] was not excluded in 4 prior cases [5, 7, 9, 10]. This work is also subject to limitations as one retrospectively reported case. The clinical picture of clarithromycin-induced hepatotoxicity might have been modified by terminal ischemic hepatitis from massive gastrointestinal bleeding during his last 24 hours of life that produced very high AST and ALT levels. However, the AST and ALT rise to about 1,000 U/L each one day earlier was associated with normal blood pressure readings and cannot be ascribed to shock liver/hepatic ischemia.
5. Conclusions
A 60-year-old nonalcoholic man, with normal baseline liver function tests, was admitted with diffuse abdominal pain and AST = 499 U/L and ALT = 539 U/L, 6 days after completing a 7-day course of clarithromycin 500 mg twice daily. AST and ALT each rose to ≥6,000 U/L two days later, accompanied by severe hepatic encephalopathy and coagulopathy. Extensive workup revealed no infectious, metabolic, or immunologic etiology of liver failure. The patient died soon thereafter from hemorrhagic shock from massive upper gastrointestinal bleeding and coagulopathy. Postmortem histopathologic hepatic examination revealed massive hepatocyte necrosis and diffuse sinusoidal congestion. Systematic review of 6 prior reported cases and this case of clarithromycin-associated ALF promotes further understanding of this syndrome.
Disclosure
Dr. Cappell, as a consultant of the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Advisory Committee for Gastrointestinal Drugs, affirms that this paper does not discuss any proprietary confidential pharmaceutical data submitted to the FDA. Dr. Cappell was also until 2 years ago a member of the speaker’s bureau for AstraZeneca and Daiichi Sankyo, co-marketers of Movantik. This work does not discuss any drug manufactured or marketed by AstraZeneca or Daiichi Sankyo.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
Authors’ Contributions
Dr. Edhi and Dr. Cappell are the primary authors. Dr. Edhi and Dr. Hakim wrote early drafts of the case report and discussion sections. Dr. Cappell as a mentor edited the case report section and wrote the bulk of the other sections. Dr. Amin performed all the microscopic pathology and wrote the pathologic sections of the paper. Dr. Shams and Dr. Bedi participated in the patient care.
Supplementary Materials
Supplementary Table 1 reports the daily blood pressure recordings every morning on the first hospitalization and reports all the blood pressure recordings for the second hospitalization. This table demonstrates that the blood pressure throughout the first hospitalization was stable (and not hypotensive) and throughout the second hospitalization was stable (not hypotensive) until late in the evening of day 3 of the second hospitalization 16 hours before the patient’s demise. These recordings demonstrate that the patient developed hypotension from hemorrhagic shock as a terminal event (associated with profound coagulopathy) after suffering acute liver failure associated with clarithromycin. Therefore, the hypotension did not directly cause the acute liver failure but was a consequence of the acute liver failure. (Supplementary Materials)