Mandibular Brown Tumor of Secondary Hyperparathyroidism Requiring Extensive Resection: A Forgotten Entity in the Developed World?

Table 1

Summary of cases of brown tumor of hyperparathyroidism in the literature.

Author	Year	Country	Patient age	Patient gender	Tumor location	Type of HPT	Treatment	Lesion size (CM)
Chowdhury et al.; [33]	2013	Brazil	20	F	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE	3 3
Pawlak et al. [34]	2013	Poland	32	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
			57	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
			42	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
			66	F	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
			32	M	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
de Ávila et al. [35]	2012	Brazil	21	M	MAND	3° HPT	PTE + CUR BT	na
Pace and Crosher; [3]	2010	UK	27	F	MAX & MAND	2° HPT	MED MGMT	na
Angadi et al. [36]	2010	India	38	M	MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT
Benhammou et al. [37]	2009	France	23	F	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE	na
Selvi et al. [38]	2009	Turkey	19	M	MAX & MAND	3° HPT	MED MGMT
Karabekmez et al.; [39]	2008	Turkey	11	M	MAX & MAND	2° HPT	na
Tarrass et al. [40]	2008	Morocco	18	M	MAND	2° HPT	PTE
Jebasingh et al. [41]	2008	India	68	M	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	na
Dinkar et al. [42]	2007	India	36	F	MAND	1° HPT	na	na
Desigan et al. [43]	2007	UK	27	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE
Pinto et al. [31]	2006	Brazil	12	F	MAND	3° HPT	ICCT	na
Prado et al. [27]	2006	Brazil	45	F	MAND	2° HPT	PTE
Triantafillidou; et al. [7]	2006	Greece	76	F	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE	na
			71	M	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	na
			21	F	MAND	2° HPT	CUR BT + MED MGMT	na
			70	F	MAND	2° HPT	CUR BT + MED MGMT	na
			68	F	MAND	2° HPT	CUR BT + MED MGMT	na
Grulois et al. [44]	2005	Belgium	57	F	MAND	1° HPT	na	na
Fernández-Sanromán et al.; [45]	2005	Spain	16	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE + CUR BT	na
Jović et al. [46]	2004	Serbia	25	M	MAX	2° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
Sumer et al.; [32]	2004	Saudi Arabia	41	F	MAND	2° HPT	PTE
Emin et al. [47]	2004	Turkey	62	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT
Suarez-Cunqueiro et al. [18]	2004	Germany	26	M	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	na
Gangidi et al. [19]	2012	UK	83	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	na
Placed et al. [48]	2010	Spain	33	F	MAX	2° HPT	na	na
Pinto et al. [22]	2010	Brazil	37	F	MAX	2° HPT	PTE	na
Pérez-Guillermo; et al. [49]	2006	Spain	61	M	MAX	2° HPT	PTE + EX BT
Daniels [16]	2004	Saudi Arabia	25	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE + CUR BT	na
Reséndiz-Colosia; et al. [20]	2008	Mexico	51	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	5
			27	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	4
			62	M	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	4
			77	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	3
			48	M	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	4
			57	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	4
			64	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	4
			28	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	3
			55	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	3
			57	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	4
			41	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	3
			45	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	2
			68	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	2
			45	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	5
			41	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	2
			67	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	2
			53	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	4
			35	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	2
			42	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	3
			54	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	3
			36	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	5
			70	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	4
Praveen and Thriveni [50]	2012	India	21	F	MAX & MAND	2° HPT	RECON BAR	; ;
Arunkumar et al. [51]	2012	India	12	F	MAND	2° HPT	EX BT + MED MGMT	na
Soundarya et al.; [52]	2011	India	60	M	MAX	1° HPT	EX BT	na
Jakubowski et al. [8]	2011	USA	49	M	MAND	2° HPT	na
Sutbeyaz et al. [53]	2009	Turkey	53	M	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE	;
Proimos et al. [15]	2009	Greece	42	F	MAX	1° HPT	EX BT	2
Rafizadeh et al. [10]	2013	USA	43	M	MAX	1° HPT	na	na
Wilson et al. [12]	2013	USA	26	F	MAX	1° HPT	ICT	na
Mantar et al. [54]	2012	Turkey	23	M	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	na
Nabi et al. [55]	2010	Saudi Arabia	24	F	MAX	2° HPT	PTE	na
Di Daniele et al. [21]	2009	Italy	40	F	MAX	2° HPT	PTE	4
Leal et al. [24]	2006	Brazil	31	F	MAX	2° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
Oh et al. [9]	2006	USA	53	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	0.8
Pechalova and Poriazova [17]	2013	Bulgaria	19	M	MAND	2° HPT	EX BT	5
			49	F	MAX	2° HPT	EX BT	na
Sia et al. [56]	2012	China	29	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT
Bahrami et al. [57]	2012	Iran	38	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
Walsh et al. [11]	2005	USA	13	F	MAX & MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
Di Fede et al. [58]	2013	Italy	71	M	MAND	1° HPT	na	na
Alhusban and Baqain [59]	2011	Jordan	45	F	MAND	1° HPT	PTE + EX BT	na
Pahlavan and Severin [60]	2006	Germany	21	M	MAND	1° HPT	PTE	na
Altay et al. [61]	2013	Turkey	59	M	MAX	3° HPT	PTE
Artul et al. [62]	2013	Israel	46	F	MAX	2° HPT	MED MGMT	2.2
Guldfred et al. [63]	2012	Denmark	34	F	MAX	1° HPT	EX BT	na
Nair et al. [25]	2011	India	35	F	MAND	2° HPT	MED MGMT
Magalhães et al. [64]	2010	Brazil	58	F	MAX & MAND	3° HPT	PTE	na
Pati et al. [65]	2014	India	34	M	MAX	1° HPT	na
Mori et al. [66]	2013	Japan	52	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	na
Benjelloun et al. [67]	2007	Morocco	17	F	MAX	2° HPT	PTE	na
Thomas et al. [68]	2011	India	27	F	MAND	2° HPT	EX BT + MED MGMT	4 × 6
Guerrouani et al. [69]	2013	Morocco	41	F	MAX	1° HPT	PTE	na

Mandible = MAND, maxilla = MAX, hyperparathyroidism = HPT, not available = na, male = M, female = F, parathyroidectomy = PTE, excision of brown tumor = EX BT, curettage of brown tumor = CUR BT, medical management = MED MGMT, intralesional corticosteroid and calcitonin therapy = ICCT, mandibulectomy and reconstruction bar placement = RECON BAR, and intralesional corticosteroid therapy = ICT.