Acromioclavicular Dislocation Associated with Coracoid Process Fracture: Report of Two Cases and Review of the Literature

Table 1

Previously published cases of AC dislocation associated with CP fracture in English literature (M: male, F: female, and K: Kirschner).

Author	Case #	Year	Age	Sex	Mechanism of injury	Treatment		Functional outcome
						Coracoid fracture	AC dislocation
Urist [2]	1	1946	11	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Good
	2		?	M	Fall	Conservative		Good
Protass et al. [3]	3	1975	17	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		?
	4		22	F	Traffic accident	None	AC joint K wiring	?
	5		14	M	Fall	Conservative		?
Smith [4]	6	1975	?	M	Fall	None	AC joint K wiring	Good
Zettas and Muchnic [5]	7	1976	13	M	Sport trauma	Screw fixation	CC ligament repair	Excellent
	8		26	F	Fall	Screw fixation	None	Excellent
Montgomery and Loyd [6]	9	1977	15	M	Sport trauma	Suture fixation	None	Excellent
	10		15	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Poor
Lasda and Murray [7]	11	1978	51	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Good
Ishizuki et al. [8]	12	1981	18	M	?	None	AC joint K wiring	Good
	13		29	M	Traffic accident	Dewar-Barrington procedure		Good
	14		48	F	Traffic accident	Dewar-Barrington procedure		Good
	15		27	M	Fall	Dewar-Barrington procedure		Good
Bernard et al. [9]	16	1983	13	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Good
	17		15	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Excellent
	18		17	M	Traffic accident	None	AC joint K wiring	Good
	19		28	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Good
Taga et al. [10]	20	1986	9	F	Fall	Conservative		Good
Barentsz and Driessen [11]	21	1989	19	M	Sport trauma	Screw fixation	AC joint tension band wiring	Good
Wilson and Colwill [12]	22	1989	20	M	Sport trauma	Screw fixation	Screw fixation and Dacron loop	Excellent
Carr and Broughton [13]	23	1989	46	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Excellent
	24		23	F	Fall	Conservative		Excellent
Martín-Herrero et al. [14]	25	1990	16	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Excellent
	26		24	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Excellent
	27		17	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Excellent
	28		60	M	Traffic accident	Conservative		Good
Hak and Johnson [15]	29	1993	24	M	Bicycle accident	Conservative		Excellent
Wang et al. [16]	30	1994	28	M	Traffic accident	Screw fixation	AC joint K wiring, Marlex loop	Excellent
Combalia et al. [17]	31	1995	12	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Excellent
Eyres et al. [18]	32	1995	27	F	Assault	Screw fixation		Excellent
	33		?	?	?	?	?	?
	34		?	?	?	?	?	?
Yu et al. [19]	35	2002	37	M	Traffic accident	Screw fixation	AC joint K wiring, CC ligament repair	Excellent
Güneş et al. [20]	36	2006	30	M	Fall	Screw fixation	Screw fixation	Excellent
DiPaola and Marchetto [21]	37	2009	15	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Excellent
Kim et al. [22]	38	2009	?	?	?	Screw fixation		?
Duan et al. [23]	39	2010	40	M	Traffic accident	Screw fixation	Clavicular hook-plate fixation	Excellent
Jettoo et al. [24]	40	2010	12	M	Fall	Screw fixation	AC joint K wiring	Excellent
Li et al. [25]	41	2010	37	M	Fall	Screw fixation	Clavicular hook plate	Excellent
Thomas et al. [26]	42	2010	22	F	Fall	Conservative		Excellent
Bhatia [27]	43	2012	77	M	Fall	Screw fixation		Excellent
Kawasaki et al. [28]	44	2014	33	M	Traffic accident	Screw fixation	Clavicular hook plate	Excellent
Pedersen et al. [29]	45	2014	14	M	Sport trauma	Conservative		Excellent
Naik et al. [30]	46	2015	24	M	Traffic accident	Screw fixation	AC joint K wiring	Excellent
Current cases	47	2015	21	M	Traffic accident	None	AC joint K wiring	Excellent
	48	2015	34	M	Traffic accident	None	AC joint K wiring	Excellent