Case Report | Open Access
Arpit Amin, Yuriy Zhurov, George Ibrahim, Anthony Maffei, Jonathan Giannone, Thomas Cerabona, Ashutosh Kaul, "Combined Endoscopic and Laparoscopic Management of Postcholecystectomy Mirizzi Syndrome from a Remnant Cystic Duct Stone: Case Report and Review of the Literature", Case Reports in Surgery, vol. 2016, Article ID 1896368, 9 pages, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/1896368
Combined Endoscopic and Laparoscopic Management of Postcholecystectomy Mirizzi Syndrome from a Remnant Cystic Duct Stone: Case Report and Review of the Literature
Mirizzi syndrome has been defined in the literature as common bile duct obstruction resulting from calculi within Hartmann’s pouch or cystic duct. We present a case of a 78-year-old female, who developed postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome from a remnant cystic duct stone. Diagnosis of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome was made on endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERCP) performed postoperatively. The patient was treated with a novel strategy by combining advanced endoscopic and laparoscopic techniques in three stages as follows: Stage 1 (initial presentation): endoscopic sphincterotomy with common bile duct stent placement; Stage 2 (6 weeks after Stage 1): laparoscopic ultrasonography to locate the remnant cystic duct calculi followed by laparoscopic retrieval of the calculi and intracorporeal closure of cystic duct stump; Stage 3 (6 weeks after Stage 2): endoscopic removal of common bile duct stent along with performance of completion endoscopic retrograde cholangiogram. In addition, we have performed an extensive review of the various endoscopic and laparoscopic management techniques described in the literature for the treatment of postcholecystectomy syndrome occurring from retained cystic duct stones.
Mirizzi syndrome has been defined as bile duct obstruction from stone impaction in Hartman’s pouch or cystic duct . Mirizzi syndrome has been well-described in the literature in patients with a reported incidence of 0.7–1.4% . However, there is a paucity of literature describing Mirizzi syndrome after patients have undergone cholecystectomy and subsequent management of this entity.
We describe a minimally invasive combined endoscopic and laparoscopic management of Mirizzi syndrome occurring from a retained cystic duct stump stone in a patient after laparoscopic cholecystectomy. In addition, a literature review on the topic of retained cystic duct stone after cholecystectomy was performed to highlight the diagnostic and therapeutic options available in management of this entity.
2. Case Presentation
A 78-year-old female was referred to the surgical service for elective cholecystectomy after suffering from a 2nd episode of right upper quadrant abdominal pain due to chronic cholecystitis within three months. The patient’s past medical history was significant for hypertension and gastroesophageal reflux. Her vital signs were normal. Physical exam revealed minimal right upper quadrant tenderness with palpation and no jaundice. Her preoperative lab profile, including white blood cell count and liver function tests, was normal (Table 1). Preoperative ultrasound revealed gallstones, normal gallbladder wall thickness, and a normal common bile duct diameter.
During laparoscopic cholecystectomy, dissection of the cystohepatic triangle was noted to be challenging due to inflammation. An intraoperative cholangiogram was attempted; however some resistance was noted when the cholangiogram catheter was being fed into the cystic duct. At this point, the cholangiogram was aborted and the cystic duct was closed with 2-0 Vicryl suture in a running fashion. Subtotal cholecystectomy was performed. A Jackson Pratt (JP) drain was placed in the gallbladder fossa. The patient was discharged home on postoperative day one with a JP drain in place after tolerating a fat-restricted diet. The JP drain was removed during outpatient follow-up visit a week after the surgery due to minimal output.
Five days after removal of the JP drain, the patient returned to the emergency department with right upper quadrant abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, and intermittent fevers. Laboratory studies revealed elevation of liver function tests with normal lipase (Table 1). Abdominal ultrasound did not reveal any gallbladder fossa collection (Figure 1). Computerized tomography of the abdomen and pelvis revealed central intrahepatic biliary duct dilation and the common hepatic duct was dilated measuring up to 1.2 cm (Figure 2). Based on this presentation, the decision was made to perform an endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP). The ERCP revealed a single large 2 cm stone in the cystic duct remnant causing stenosis of the common bile duct consistent with Mirizzi syndrome along with extravasation of contrast from cystic duct stump (Figure 3). Sphincterotomy and common bile duct stent placement was performed to temporarily relieve the obstructive pathology and biliary leak. The patient’s symptoms and liver function tests showed improvement after the placement of common bile duct stent (Table 1). The patient was discharged home on a fat-restricted diet and brought to the operating room for laparoscopic treatment of Mirizzi syndrome from retained cystic duct stone 6 weeks after the initial operation.
During the 2nd operation, we utilized intraoperative laparoscopic ultrasonography to clearly define the presence of cystic duct remnant stone and the common bile duct stent to guide the laparoscopic dissection (Figure 4). An incision was made directly over the cystic duct remnant and the cystic duct stone was removed (Figure 5). The cystic duct remnant was then closed with 2-0 Vicryl sutures via intracorporeal suturing technique. A drain was placed in the gallbladder fossa. The patient was placed on fat-restricted diet postoperatively. No bile leak was detected from the drain and the drain was removed prior to discharge. The patient returned to the hospital electively six weeks after discharge for repeat ERCP. On repeat ERCP, the common bile duct stent was removed. Post-stent-removal cholangiogram revealed normal biliary tract appearance with resolution of previously noted Mirizzi syndrome (Figure 6). On outpatient follow-up, the patient is asymptomatic and has normal liver function tests after removal of the stent (Table 1).
An estimated 750,000 cholecystectomies are performed in the United States every year . Approximately 10–30% of patients continue to suffer from the same constellation of symptoms that were present before their operation. This group of patients is categorized as suffering from postcholecystectomy syndrome . Patients with postcholecystectomy syndrome may present with wide spectrum of persistent signs and symptoms such as abdominal pain, fever, jaundice, pruritus, nausea, and vomiting after cholecystectomy [3, 4, 9, 10]. It is important to consider the possibility of biliary as well as extrabiliary etiologies while evaluating patients with postcholecystectomy syndrome. Extrabiliary sources of postcholecystectomy syndrome include pneumonia, acute coronary syndrome, hepatocellular disease, pancreatic disease, gastroesophageal reflux, and peptic ulcer disease . Similarly, biliary sources of postcholecystectomy syndrome like biliary injury, biliary stricture, retained stone within the common bile duct, sphincter of Oddi stenosis, retained stone within remnant gallbladder, and retained stone within cystic duct remnant must be entertained . Our case reports highlight the fact that Mirrizzi syndrome from retained cystic duct stump stone should, also, be considered as part of the differential diagnosis of postcholecystectomy syndrome.
The role of cystic duct remnant length as a cause of postcholecystectomy syndrome has been debated and studied within the literature. Cystic duct stump remnant has been defined as residual cystic duct stump length greater than 1 cm in the literature . Bodvall and Overgaard have reported that a cystic duct remnant larger than 1 cm was present in 67% of patients with common bile duct stones after cholecystectomy . Rogy et al. reported that the role of cystic duct stump remnant as a reason for reoperation after cholecystectomy is negligible . While a long cystic duct stump remnant by itself may not be related to postcholecystectomy syndrome, presence of any remnant stones within the cystic duct stump may lead to postcholecystectomy syndrome. This is an important issue to consider in the laparoscopic era wherein the tendency to leave a long cystic duct stump and/or perform subtotal cholecystectomy is increasingly favored to avoid injury to the common bile duct. Palanivelu et al. have reported an incidence of remnant cystic duct calculi of 4.19% in patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy as compared to an incidence of 0.02% in patients undergoing conventional open cholecystectomy .
Diagnosis of remnant cystic duct stone as the source of postcholecystectomy syndrome requires high index of suspicion. Patients may either present immediately within the first week after the operation as reported in our case report or present as late as after 32 years as reported in the literature . Laboratory testing may demonstrate leukocytosis along with derangements in liver function tests (total and direct bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, gamma-glutamyl transferase, aspartate aminotransferase, and alanine aminotransferase) . Phillips et al. demonstrated that 75% of these patients had derangement of at least one standard liver function test parameter and noted that gamma-glutamyl transferase was the most common abnormality observed in 80% of patients with remnant cystic duct stone .
Given the broad differential diagnosis for the cause of postcholecystectomy syndrome, a combination of noninvasive radiologic imaging in the form of abdominal ultrasonography, abdominal CT scan with IV contrast, and magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography (MRCP) should be considered to identify remnant cystic duct calculus as the cause of postcholecystectomy syndrome. Abdominal ultrasonography will demonstrate intrahepatic and extrahepatic biliary ductal dilation proximal to remnant cystic duct calculus along with normal caliber biliary duct distal to the site of obstruction . In the case series reported by Palanivelu et al., abdominal ultrasonography was able to identify remnant cystic duct calculus in 9 out of 15 patients (sensitivity 60%) . Similarly, in the case series by Phillips et al., remnant cystic duct calculus was identified with abdominal ultrasonography in 5 out of 9 patients (sensitivity 55%) . MRCP will demonstrate the characteristic finding of remnant cystic duct calculus compressing the common hepatic duct with proximal ductal dilation and normal size distal common bile duct . In the case series reported by Palanivelu et al., MRCP was able to identify remnant cystic duct calculus in all 15 patients (sensitivity 100%) . On the other hand, in the case series by Phillips et al., remnant cystic duct calculus was identified in 8 out of 9 patients (sensitivity 89%) . Interestingly, in the case series reported by Walsh et al., MRCP was utilized only in 1 out of 7 patients and it failed to demonstrate remnant cystic duct calculus . Abdominal computed tomography (CT) may, also, be considered as an alternative in institutions where MRCP is not available. Abdominal CT may reveal a smooth tapering of the common bile duct in the absence of pancreatic mass along with identifying any remnant cystic duct calculus or gallbladder bed collections . In addition, abdominal CT with IV contrast may identify any vascular injury to hepatic pedicle. In the case series by Phillips et al., 7 patients underwent abdominal CT and a remnant cystic duct calculus was identified in 5 patients (sensitivity 71%) . In conclusion, MRCP appears to be the most sensitive noninvasive imaging modality available currently to identify remnant cystic duct calculi in patients suffering from postcholecystectomy syndromes. However, abdominal ultrasonography can still be employed as the initial noninvasive modality to identify remnant cystic duct calculi in patients presenting with postcholecystectomy syndrome since it is more readily available and less expensive than MRCP.
Management options for postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome are largely determined based on underlying problem (i.e., stone within gallbladder remnant or stone within remnant cystic duct stump). It is imperative to attempt to determine the etiology of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome based on review of initial operative reports and preoperative imaging studies. Special attention should be paid to operative details like hostile operative conditions due to acute inflammation, performance of intraoperative cholangiogram, milking of cystic duct towards gallbladder before ligation, presence of dilated or long cystic duct, utilization of special techniques like stapling or ligation loops for cystic duct ligation, and performance of subtotal cholecystectomy [3, 9]. Close attention to these intraoperative details may help differentiate if postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome is due to a stone within gallbladder remnant or due to a stone within remnant cystic duct.
If the postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome is due to stone within gallbladder remnant after subtotal cholecystectomy, surgical treatment with completion cholecystectomy and retrieval of gallbladder calculi with either laparoscopic or open techniques should be offered . Endoscopic retrieval of retained gallbladder remnant calculi should not be entertained .
On the other hand, if there is high index of suspicion that postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome is due to stone within remnant cystic duct stump, endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERCP) techniques may be employed initially . Examples of ERCP techniques that have been described in the literature for remnant cystic duct stone retrieval include (i) sphincterotomy combined with traditional balloon and basket use for stone retrieval, (ii) sphincterotomy combined with application of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) followed by endoscopic retrieval of fragments, and (iii) sphincterotomy combined with endoscopic transpapillary application of holmium laser for stone fragmentation followed by endoscopic retrieval of fragments (Table 2) [3–7]. Technical factors like size of the remnant cystic duct, location of stone within the cystic duct, and presence of acute inflammation may contribute to difficulty with stone extraction with traditional balloon or basket use . In difficult cases, stepwise endoscopic treatment starting with sphincterotomy and/or endobiliary stenting followed by remnant cystic duct stone fragmentation with ESWL or laser application and subsequent endoscopic removal of fragmented calculi may be employed . However, it must be mentioned that availability of endoscopic treatment of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome from remnant cystic duct calculi may be institution specific due to high level of endoscopic expertise required to execute this management strategy. Historically, open surgical treatment has been offered for remnant cystic duct stump stones (Table 3) [3, 4, 12]. However, with the advent of minimally invasive techniques, laparoscopic retrieval of remnant cystic duct stump calculi and intracorporeal laparoscopic suturing has been shown to be effective treatment for remnant cystic duct stump calculi causing postcholecystectomy syndrome (Table 3) .
In our case report, we have described a hybrid endoscopic and laparoscopic approach to the management of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome from remnant cystic duct calculi. Based on our review of the published literature of endoscopic and surgical management of postcholecystectomy syndrome from remnant cystic duct calculi, this approach has not been described before. In our case, we opted to first perform endoscopic sphincterotomy with endobiliary stent placement to temporarily relieve the patient’s symptoms from Mirizzi syndrome while allowing for acute inflammation and biliary leak within the postcholecystectomy operative bed to resolve. Secondly, we opted to utilize laparoscopic intraoperative ultrasonography to localize the endobiliary stent and remnant cystic duct calculi. The combination of direct laparoscopic visualization and intraoperative ultrasonography ensured that our dissection stayed on top of the remnant cystic duct stump and away from the common bile duct. We believe that intraoperative laparoscopic ultrasonography should be utilized liberally in these cases of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome to avoid any injury to common bile duct. Lastly, intracorporeal closure of the remnant cystic duct stump was performed after stone retrieval leaving the endobiliary prosthesis in place for additional six weeks. We believe that preoperative endobiliary prosthesis can help avoid common bile duct exploration in a hostile operative field along with resolving any cystic stump leak that may occur after intracorporeal closure. Subsequently, endobiliary prosthesis can be removed postoperatively once adequate time (i.e., six weeks) has elapsed after intracorporeal closure of the cystic duct stump. The advantage of this combined endoscopic and laparoscopic approach is that it allows for the acute inflammatory stage to resolve thereby allowing for minimally invasive treatment of a complex problem while avoiding common bile duct exploration. In addition, this approach may also be employed at institutions where endoscopic expertise regarding extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy and laser fragmentation techniques may not be available. The disadvantage of this hybrid approach is that the patient will likely have to undergo three procedures (preoperative ERCP with sphincterotomy with stent, laparoscopic stone retrieval, postoperative ERCP, and stent removal) when compared to single-stage laparoscopic approach recommended by Palanivelu et al. in their case series.
Prevention of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome from remnant cystic duct stump calculi requires meticulous attention to operative technique during index laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Close attention to correct identification of cystic duct-gallbladder junction, milking of the cystic duct back to gallbladder prior to ligation, consideration for performance of selective intraoperative cholangiography in cases with long or dilated cystic duct, and intraoperative removal of any detected cystic duct stump calculi during index operation may help prevent occurrence of remnant cystic duct stump calculi [3, 4, 9]. However, if the operative field is hostile with obliteration of cystohepatic triangle, a subtotal laparoscopic cholecystectomy or conversion to open cholecystectomy in combination with intraoperative cholangiography may be a safer option since postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome from remnant cystic duct calculi can be managed endoscopically in these cases while avoiding risk of common bile duct injury [3, 4, 9].
Mirizzi syndrome due to remnant cystic duct calculi should be considered in the differential diagnosis of patients presenting with postcholecystectomy syndrome. Diagnosis of this rare entity can be confirmed with the help of abdominal ultrasonography and MRCP in the correct clinical scenario. ERCP with sphincterotomy and stenting in combination with ESWL or laser lithotripsy may be offered as first-line therapy if endoscopic expertise is available for this complex problem. While laparoscopic removal of remnant cystic duct calculi with common bile duct exploration and closure has been described in the literature, this approach as first-line therapy may only be possible at high-volume centers with advanced laparoscopic expertise. In this case report, we have described hybrid stepwise endoscopic and laparoscopic management in combination with use of intraoperative laparoscopic ultrasonography highlighting a novel approach to the management of postcholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome from remnant cystic duct calculi.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
- M. Ibrarullah, T. Mishra, and A. P. Das, “Mirizzi syndrome,” Indian Journal of Surgery, vol. 70, no. 6, pp. 281–287, 2008.
- M. Pemberton and A. D. Wells, “The Mirizzi syndrome,” Postgraduate Medical Journal, vol. 73, no. 862, pp. 487–490, 1997.
- M. R. Phillips, M. Joseph, E. S. Dellon, I. Grimm, T. M. Farrell, and C. C. Rupp, “Surgical and endoscopic management of remnant cystic duct lithiasis after cholecystectomy—a case series,” Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery, vol. 18, no. 7, pp. 1278–1283, 2014.
- R. M. Walsh, J. L. Ponsky, and J. Dumot, “Retained gallbladder/cystic duct remnant calculi as a cause of postcholecystectomy pain,” Surgical Endoscopy and Other Interventional Techniques, vol. 16, no. 6, pp. 981–984, 2002.
- J. Benninger, T. Rabenstein, M. Farnbacher, J. Keppler, E. G. Hahn, and H. T. Schneider, “Extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy of gallstones in cystic duct remnants and Mirizzi syndrome,” Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, vol. 60, no. 3, pp. 454–459, 2004.
- V. P. Kodali and B. T. Petersen, “Endoscopic therapy of post-cholecystectomy Mirizzi syndrome,” Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 86–90, 1996.
- S. Janes, L. Berry, and B. Dijkstra, “Management of post cholecystectomy Mirizzi's syndrome,” Journal of Minimal Access Surgery, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 34–36, 2005.
- N. Wani, N. Khan, A. Shah, and A. Khan, “Post-cholecystectomy Mirizzi's syndrome: magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography demonstration,” Saudi Journal of Gastroenterology, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 295–298, 2010.
- C. Palanivelu, M. Rangarajan, P. A. Jategaonkar, M. V. Madankumar, and N. V. Anand, “Laparoscopic management of remnant cystic duct calculi: a retrospective study,” Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England, vol. 91, no. 1, pp. 25–29, 2009.
- O. Tantia, M. Jain, S. Khanna, and B. Sen, “Post cholecystectomy syndrome: role of cystic duct stump and re-intervention by laparoscopic surgery,” Journal of Minimal Access Surgery, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 71–75, 2008.
- P. K. Chowbey, S. K. Bandyopadhyay, A. Sharma, R. Khullar, V. Soni, and M. Baijal, “Laparoscopic reintervention for residual gallstone disease,” Surgical Laparoscopy, Endoscopy and Percutaneous Techniques, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 31–35, 2003.
- I. Endo, N. Nagamine, Y. Nakamura et al., “On the Mirizzi syndrome—benign stenosis of the hepatic duct induced by a stone in the cystic duct or neck of the gallbladder,” Gastroenterologia Japonica, vol. 14, no. 2, pp. 155–161, 1979.
- M. Gurel, M. Sare, S. Gurer, and F. Hilmioglu, “Laparoscopic removal of a gallbladder remnant,” Surgical Laparoscopy and Endoscopy, vol. 5, no. 5, pp. 410–411, 1995.
- L. M. Pernice and F. Andreoli, “Laparoscopic treatment of stone recurrence in a gallbladder remnant: report of an additional case and literature review,” Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery, vol. 13, no. 11, pp. 2084–2091, 2009.
- M. R. Sahoo and A. Kumar, “Stump stone 6 years after cholecystectomy: a possibility,” BMJ Case Reports, 2013.
- C. Shaw, D. M. O'Hanlon, H. M. Fenlon, and G. P. McEntee, “Cystic duct remnant and the ‘post-cholecystectomy syndrome’,” Hepatogastroenterology, vol. 51, no. 55, pp. 36–38, 2004.
- B. Bodvall and B. Overgaard, “Computer analysis of post-cholecystectomy biliary tract symptoms,” Surgery Gynecology and Obstetrics, vol. 124, no. 4, pp. 723–732, 1967.
- M. A. Rogy, R. Fugger, F. Herbst, and F. Schulz, “Reoperation after cholecystectomy. The role of the cystic duct stump,” HPB Surgery, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 129–135, 1991.
Copyright © 2016 Arpit Amin et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.