A Hybrid Discrete Grey Wolf Optimizer to Solve Weapon Target Assignment Problems

Table 5

Three indicators of the HDGWO, the DPSO, the GAWGE and the AIGA for each case.

		Case  1	Case  2	Case  3	Case  4	Case  5	Case  6	Case  7	Case  8	Case  9	Case  10
Lingo_ref		142.00	216.96	322.97	395.97	625.96	670.97	793.95	931.98	974.14	1060.98
HDGWO	AVMFV	141.55	212.85	312.96	379.41	602.94	635.12	746.25	880.25	920.50	989.13
	(std.)	(0.57)	(3.65)	(1.99)	(5.46)	(6.40)	(6.30)	(8.46)	(7.47)	(6.21)	(6.09)
	TCR ()	99.68	98.10	96.90	95.82	96.32	94.66	93.99	94.45	94.49	93.23
	ISRQ1 ()	-0.18	-0.55	-1.07	-1.64	-0.64	-2.23	-2.08	-2.15	-1.93	-3.07
	ISRQ2()	-0.31	-1.80	-2.91	-3.87	-3.26	-4.81	-5.25	-4.83	-4.74	-5.81
	ISRQ3 ()	0.60	2.87	1.75	2.61	2.98	3.69	7.96	3.25	2.76	4.63
DPSO	AVMFV	141.81	214.03	316.34	385.73	606.82	649.57	762.12	899.56	938.58	1020.48
	(std.)	(0.03)	(0.39)	(0.25)	(0.60)	(1.10)	(0.88)	(1.48)	(1.70)	(1.89)	(1.80)
	TCR ()	99.86	98.65	97.95	97.42	96.94	96.81	96.00	96.52	96.35	96.18
GAWGE	AVMFV	141.99	216.75	322.35	394.69	623.28	667.18	787.60	924.89	966.36	1050.18
	(std.)	(0.00)	(0.03)	(0.05)	(0.11)	(0.19)	(0.27)	(0.29)	(0.34)	(0.56)	(0.90)
	TCR ()	99.99	99.90	99.81	99.68	99.57	99.44	99.20	99.24	99.20	98.98
AIGA	AVMFV	140.71	206.91	307.57	369.77	585.51	612.54	691.21	852.55	895.76	945.37
	(std.)	(0.77)	(3.81)	(1.80)	(6.67)	(8.06)	(7.01)	(7.11)	(8.78)	(7.24)	(10.91)
	TCR ()	99.09	95.37	95.23	93.38	93.54	91.29	87.06	91.48	91.95	89.10