Research Article

Comparing Asset Pricing Factor Models under Multivariate t-Distribution: Evidence from China

Table 2

Anomalies and definitions.

AcronymNameReferenceDetails

Panel A: value-versus-growth
AMAsset-to-marketFama and French [35]Total assets/fiscal-year-end market capitalization
DERDebt-to-equity ratioBhandari [36]Total liabilities/fiscal-year-end market capitalization
LGLiability growthLitzenberger and Ramaswamy [37]Annual growth in total liabilities
OCFPOperating cash flow-to-priceDesai et al. [38]Operating cash flows/fiscal-year-end market capitalization
PYPayout yieldBoudoukh et al. [39](Income before extraordinary items - the change of book equity)/fiscal-year-end market capitalization
Rev1ReversalDe Bondt and Thaler [40]Cumulative returns from months t-60 to t-13
SGSustainable growthLockwood and Prombutr [41]Annual growth in book equity
SMISales growth minus inventory growthAbarbanell and Bushee [42]Annual growth in sales - annual growth in inventory
TGTax growthThomas and Zhang [43]Annual growth in taxes payable
EPEarnings-to-priceCakici et al. [31]net profit excluding nonrecurrent gains/losses (in most recent quarterly financial statement)/last month-end market capitalization
BMBook-to-market equityWang and Xu [44]Book value of equity (in most recent quarterly financial statement)/last month-end market capitalization
CPCash flow-to-priceCakici et al. [31]net change in cash or cash equivalents (between the two most recent quarterly financial statements)/last month-end market capitalization
SPSales-to-priceBarbee et al. [45]The annual operating revenue divided by fiscal-year-end market capitalization

Panel B: investment
ACCAccrualsSloan [46](Income before extraordinary items - operating cash flows)/average total assets
PACCPercent accrualsHafzalla et al. [47](Total profit - operating cash flow)/net profit
dBEChange in shareholders’ equityRichardson et al. [48]Annual change in book equity/one-year-lagged total assets
dPIAChanges in PPE and inventory-to-assetsLyandres et al. [49](Annual change in gross property, plant, and equipment + the annual change in inventory)/one-year-lagged total assets
IAInvestment-to-assetsCooper et al. [50]Annual change in total assets/one-year-lagged total assets
IVCInventory changeThomas and Zhang [51]Annual change in inventory/average total assets
IVGInventory growthBelo and Lin [52]Annual growth in inventory
Panel C: profitability
NOANet operating assetsHirshleifer et al. [53](Operating assets - operating liabilities)/total assets
ATOAsset turnoverSoliman [54]Sales/net operating assets
CFOACash flow over assetsAsness et al. [55]Cash flow from operation/total assets
CTOCapital turnoverHaugen and Baker [56]Sales/total assets
EBITEarnings before interests and taxesGreenblatt [57]net profit + income tax expenses + financial expenses
EYEarnings yieldGreenblatt [57]EBIT/enterprise value
GMGross marginsNovy-Marx [58](Operating revenue - operating expenses)/operating revenue
GPGross profitability ratioNovy-Marx [58]
Jiang et al. [59]
(Operating revenue - operating expenses)/average total assets
NPOPNet payout over profitsAsness et al. [55](net income - changes in book equity)/total profits
ROICReturn on invested capitalGreenblatt [57](EBIT - nonoperating income)/noncash enterprise value
TBITaxable income-to-book incomeGreen et al. [60]Pretax income/net income
ZZ-scoreDichev [61]Z-score = 1.2 × (working capital/total assets) + 1.4 × (retained earnings/total assets) + 3.3 × (EBIT/total assets) + 0.6 × (market value of equity/book value of total liabilities) + (sales/total assets)
ROEReturn on equityGuo et al. [62]Net earnings (in most recent quarterly financial statement)/book equity

Panel D: momentum
CHMOMChange in 6-month momentumGettleman and Marks [63]Cumulative returns from months t-6 to t-1 minus those from months t-12 to t-7
MOM6M6-month momentumJegadeesh and Titman [64]Cumulative returns from months t-6 to t-2
MOM12M12-month momentumJegadeesh and Titman [64]Cumulative returns from months t-12 to t-2
MOM36M36-month momentumJegadeesh and Titman [64]Cumulative returns from months t-36 to t-13
VOLTVolume trendHaugen and Baker [56]Five-year trend in monthly trading volume/five-year average trading volume
REV1-month reversalCakici et al. [31]Cumulative returns over the month t-1

Panel E: trading frictions
PRCPriceBlume and Husic [65]Share price at month t-1
RVOLRMB trading volumeChordia et al. [66]Natural log of RMB trading volume from month t-2
STD_RVOLVolatility of RMB trading volumeChordia et al. [66]Standard deviation of daily RMB trading volume at month t-1
STD_TURNVolatility of turnoverChordia et al. [66]Standard deviation of daily share turnover at month t-1
B_DIMThe Dimson betaDimson [67]Estimated using lead, lag, and current market returns
B_DNDownside betaAng et al. [68]Conditional covariance between a stock’s excess return and market excess return/the conditional variance of market excess return (condition: Market excess return is lower than the average level)
B_FFFama and French betaFama and French [35]Calculated by regressing monthly returns on the current and recent lag market return with a five-year rolling window
B_FPFrazzini and Pedersen betaFrazzini and Pedersen [69]Return volatilities for the stock/the market return volatilities × their return correlation
IVOLIdiosyncratic return volatilityAli et al. [70]Standard deviation of residuals of weekly returns on weekly equal-weighted market returns from months t-36 to t-1
BETAMarket betaFama and MacBeth [71]Estimated market beta from weekly returns and market returns from months t-36 to t-1
B_HSHong and Sraer betaHong and Sraer [72]Summed-coefficients computed by daily returns with a one-year rolling window
ILLIQIlliquidityAmihud [9]Average of (absolute daily return/daily RMB trading volume) over the past 12 months ending on June 30
PRCDELPrice delayHou and Moskowitz [73]The proportion of variation in weekly returns from months t-36 to t-1 explained by 4 lags of weekly market returns incremental to contemporaneous market returns
TURN33-month share turnoverDatar et al. [74]Average monthly trading volume for 3 months/number of shares outstanding
MVFirm sizeWang and Xu [44]Market value at month t-1
STDOne-month volatilityCakici et al. [31]Standard deviation of daily returns over the month t-1
MAXMaximum daily returnsCarpenter et al. [75]Maximum of daily returns over month t-1
TURNTwelve-month turnoverLiu et al. [4]Average daily share turnover over the past one year
ABTURNOne-month abnormal turnoverLiu et al. [4]Average daily turnover over the past one month/average daily turnover over the past one year

Panel F: intangibles
AGEFirm ageJiang et al. [76]Number of years since IPO year
CFDCash flow-to-debtOu and Penman [77]Earnings before depreciation and extraordinary items/average total liabilities
CRCurrent ratioOu and Penman [77]Current assets/current liabilities
CRGCurrent ratio growthOu and Penman [77]Annual growth in current ratio
QRQuick ratioOu and Penman [77](Current assets – inventory)/current liabilities
QRGQuick ratio growthOu and Penman [77]Annual growth in quick ratio
SISales-to-inventoryOu and Penman [77]Sales/total inventory