Research Article

On the Safe-Haven Ability of Bitcoin, Gold, and Commodities for International Stock Markets: Evidence from Spillover Index Analysis

Table 4

Dynamic from spillover with different rolling windows.

Window = 80Window = 100Window = 120

Phase I:December 2, 2010–March 13, 2012December 31, 2010–March 13, 2012February 1, 2011–March 13, 2012
Bitcoin2.0281.7471.451
Gold6.3305.5194.741
Commodities9.4449.5229.349
World11.48511.42311.331
Developed11.31811.24711.149
Emerging10.99811.01510.917

Phase II: March 14, 2012–January 13, 2020
Bitcoin2.1481.6831.423
Gold3.0453.1963.005
Commodities4.9295.2835.199
World10.47010.54610.520
Developed10.20910.29310.264
Emerging9.2659.4219.404

Phase III: January 14, 2020–June 23, 2021
Bitcoin5.6185.4975.469
Gold5.1414.7634.518
Commodities6.7676.6726.652
World11.06311.04811.063
Developed10.83310.82810.853
Emerging9.5989.6299.690

Note. The values are produced by the average value of total directional spillover from others on the basis of Figure 7. All abbreviations are as follows: bitcoin, gold, and commodities indices (commodities); the world stock index (world); the developed stock index (developed); and the emerging stock index (emerging).