- About this Journal ·
- Abstracting and Indexing ·
- Aims and Scope ·
- Annual Issues ·
- Article Processing Charges ·
- Articles in Press ·
- Author Guidelines ·
- Bibliographic Information ·
- Citations to this Journal ·
- Contact Information ·
- Editorial Board ·
- Editorial Workflow ·
- Free eTOC Alerts ·
- Publication Ethics ·
- Reviewers Acknowledgment ·
- Submit a Manuscript ·
- Subscription Information ·
- Table of Contents
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Volume 2011 (2011), Article ID 917541, 12 pages
Inflammatory Process Modulation by Homeopathic Arnica montana 6CH: The Role of Individual Variation
1Laboratory of Cell and Molecular Biology, Research Center of University Paulista, Avenue José Maria Whitaker, 290, 04057-000 São Paulo, SP, Brazil
2Laboratory of Veterinary Pathology, University of Santo Amaro, 04829-300 São Paulo, SP, Brazil
Received 21 May 2010; Accepted 30 November 2010
Copyright © 2011 Ana Paula Kawakami et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The effects of Arnica montana 6cH on the individual modulation of acute inflammation kinetics in rats were evaluated. Adult male Wistar rats were inoculated with 1% carrageenan into the footpad and treated with Arnica montana 6cH, dexamethasone (4.0 mg/kg; positive control) or 5% hydroalcoholic solution (negative control), per os, each 15 minutes, between 30 and 180 minutes after the irritant inoculation. Histopathological and immunohistochemistry procedures were done in order to get a panel of inflammatory positive cells for CD3 (T lymphocytes), CD45RA (B lymphocytes), CD18 (beta 2 integrin), CD163 (ED2 protein), CD54 (ICAM-1), and MAC 387 (monocytes and macrophages). The statistical treatment of data included a posteriori classification of animals from each group () in two subgroups presenting spontaneous precocious or late oedema. Animals that presented precocious oedema were less responsible to Arnica montana 6cH in relation to hemodynamic changes. Instead, rats that exhibited late oedema presented less intense oedema (), lower percentage of mast cell degranulation (), and increase in lymphatic vessels diameter (). The data suggest an individually qualitative adjustment of inflammatory vascular events by Arnica montana 6cH.
One of the most discussed controversies about the efficacy of homeopathic medicines is the necessity to identify a perfect symptomatic analogy between patient and drug pathogenesy, that is, the necessity of individual prescription according to the similia principle. This particular feature is one of the most difficult challenges of the scientific research in this field because of the technical difficulty of its experimental demonstration. Indeed, few experimental studies about are found in the literature [1–6]. Thus, the experimental demonstration of this particularity and the comprehension of its mechanisms can be useful tools to solve the chronic controversies about homeopathy efficacy, often seen in clinical trials [7, 8]. Recently, an elegant in vitro study demonstrated the importance of the regulatory and adaptive cell mechanisms in the magnitude of homeopathic remedies inducing cytotoxic effects on cancer cells .
From 1997 up to 2008, we have developed a step-by-step research trial about the biological effects of homeopathic Arnica montana, specially the Arnica montana 6cH, using animal models [10–13]. In short, the results obtained in these studies show that Arnica montana 6cH is able to modulate the acute inflammatory process in rats, since it can increase lymphatic oedema absorption and local blood flow, as well as to promote the array of polymorphonuclear cell migration. All these experiments are chronologically described in .
The Arnica montana is a plant belonging to the Compositae family that grows on the hills of East and Central Europe. Several active compounds are identified in its leaves, flowers, and roots, such as alcohols, tannin, flavonoids, and sesquirterpenic lactones, especially helenalin . The main action of helenalin is the inhibition of the transcription factor NFκβ, similarly to corticoid steroids . The incidental ingestion of the plant can cause vasodilatation, blood stasis, hemorrhage, oedema, and pain. These effects are the main topics described in the Arnica montana materia medica . Because of that, trauma pain and oedema absorption are the main indications for the clinical and experimental use of homeopathic preparations of Arnica montana [16–20]. Recently, other uses of high diluted Arnica montana have been proposed, like the agronomic use of Arnica in the potencies 3, 6, and 12cH to improve plants growth .
The aim of the present study was to check two hypotheses: (a) the putative modulation of vascular and cell events in acute inflammation by Arnica, focusing on the rate of neutrophils, monocytes, T and B lymphocytes present in the inflammatory site, and the intensity of adhesion molecules expression in inflamed connective tissue, using immunohistochemical and histomorphometrical techniques; (b) the putative interference on the outputs of the natural individual variations of inflammation kinetics.
2. Material and Methods
Male adult Wistar rats, weighting between 250 and 300 g, were used. Rats were maintained in conventional laboratory polypropylene cages (5 to 7 animals per cage), with controlled temperature (25 ± 3°C) and light cycle (lights on from 06:00 AM to 06:00 PM). Water and food were offered ad libitum. Prior to the beginning of the experiment, animals were randomly weighed, separated, and identified in three groups of 20 rats each.
2.2. Induction of Acute Inflammation
The acute inflammatory process was induced by the subcutaneous inoculation of 1% kappa carrageenan (SIGMA) diluted in sterile saline into the footpad, whose thickness was previously measured with a micrometer (MYTUTOYO).
After 30 and 180 minutes, new measurements were made, in order to evaluate the pre- and posttreatment oedema evolution in function of time. Thus, the first 30 minutes measured the spontaneous oedema formation and the remaining 150 minutes measured the drug effects, since treatments were done after the 30-minute measurement. At 180 minutes, animals were euthanized by cervical traction under deep anesthesia, and foot pads were harvested and fixed in buffered 10% formaldehyde during 24 hours—maximum—before being processed by conventional histological techniques, including paraffin embedding, hematoxylin-eosin, and toluidine blue staining. The same paraffin blocks were used to perform the immunohistochemical procedures. For each footpad, one single slide was done.
2.3. Groups and Treatments
Each group of rats was treated with a specific substance, according to Table 1. Rats treated with Arnica montana 6cH (experimental) and unsuccussed 5% hydroalcoholic solution (negative control) obtained from the same supplier were identified by codes, in a manner that all treatments and measurements were made in blind. These codes were created by a laboratory technician who did not participate of the study and kept in a sealed sheet up to the statistical analysis, when they were revealed.
The dexamethasone-treated rats (positive control) were made openly, because of the physical characteristics of the used formulation; it was quite different from the homeopathic ones and, thus, easily recognizable. The treatment and the microscopic analysis of samples were performed by two independent persons, always in blind. The total dose of dexamethasone used to produce anti-inflammatory effects was 4 mg/kg, according to the standards defined previously . This fractioned protocol was designed to reproduce a usual homeopathic clinical condition of acute inflammation treatment and was also used in the previous studies performed by our group . Dexamethasone was chosen as a positive control group because its mechanism of action mimics the mechanism of helenalin, the main active principle of Arnica montana [13, 15].
The commercial Arnica montana 6cH was prepared in 5% hydroalcoholic solution by a pharmacy certified by the regulatory Brazilian National Agency for Sanitary Vigilance (ANVISA), Farmácia Sensitiva, São Paulo. The techniques used in the preparation were according to the Brazilian Homeopathic Pharmacopea, 2nd Edition, 1997.
2.4. Data Analysis
After the first plotting of the oedema intensity obtained during the pretreatment period (from zero to 30 minutes), data were classified in crescent ordering using an Excel 2003 software, in a way that it would be possible to divide, for each group, the 10 rats (50%) that presented spontaneously lower oedema intensity and the 10 rats (50%) that presented higher oedema intensity. Thus, two subgroups of 10 animals were formed for each experimental group, characterizing two different rat subpopulations according to inflammatory kinetic pattern (Table 2). The whole experimental design is explained in a flowchart (Figure 7).
Since the classic curve of carrageenan-induced oedema is over up to 6 hours after inoculation, the choice of both times (30 and 180 minutes) was based on its known plateau [23, 24]. Moreover, previous studies about the effects of Arnica 6cH upon carrageenan-induced oedema show no more effects after this period [10, 11]. The kinetics of inflammatory process evaluation after the injection of carrageenan are a classical experimental model developed during the 70 s [23, 24]. Thus, it is a trustful criterion to be used in this case.
After plotting data (Figures 1(a) and 1(b)), both kinetic patterns became easy to identify: (a) animals that presented less intense oedema during the first pretreatment 30 minutes had the peak between 30 and 180 minutes (named late oedema) and (b) those that presented more intense oedema in the first 30 minutes decreased after this period (named early oedema).
All results were compared among the six subgroups. This a posteriori selection was made in order to check the role of individual idiosyncrasy in the Arnica effect according to the similia principle, since the speed of oedema remission is one of the most known Arnica montana symptoms described in materia medica [10, 11, 13, 14].
2.5. Immunohistochemical Analysis
All slides were washed with 1 : 1 alcohol-ether solution during five minutes and then dried with a soft sheet of paper and treated with 1 : 10 poly-L-lysin (SIGMA). Then, 5 microns paraffin-embedded tissue slices were transferred to their surface using a 40°C histological bath. Next, slices were deparaffined through two baths in absolute xylol for 2 minutes and two baths in absolute alcohol for 3 minutes. Slides were, then, washed in current tap water.
For the immunohistochemistry procedures, a first step for antigen retrieving was made using heat treatment of samples. Slides were put inside a citrate buffer bath (SIGMA), pH = 6.0, containing 0.5% tween 20 (DAKO), and heated in an electric pot at 80°C (PANASONIC) during 20 minutes. After that, slides were washed in PBS, pH = 7.2 (SIGMA), for 6 minutes and dried with a soft absorbent paper, and the tissue sample was delimited using an appropriate pen (Pap-pen, AbCam).
The endogenous peroxidase activity was blocked by incubation of tissues in a 3% H2O2 solution diluted in methanol (ISOFAR), for 15 minutes at room temperature. Then, they were washed in PBS (SIGMA) for 6 minutes and treated with 2.5% horse normal serum (VECTOR) during 20 minutes at 25°C, for blocking unspecific protein-binding sites. Immediately after this step, the tissues were treated with the primary antibody (see dilutions and specifications in Table 3) and left standing overnight at 4°C in a humid chamber. All dilutions of primary antibodies were made in 1% bovine serum albumin (BSA).
In the next day, cuts were washed in PBS (sigma) for 6 minutes and treated with the polymer-peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody (IMPRESS UNIVERSAL, VECTOR), at 25°C during 30 minutes. After a new washing in PBS (6 minutes), they were exposed to DAB (DAKO) for 3 seconds, washed once again in tap water, stained with Harris hematoxylin (01 minute), and mounted.
For the evaluation of mast cell degranulation percentage, two hundred cells per slide stained by Toluidine blue method were counted, using contiguous fields, differentiating the degranulated from the nondegranulated ones. To evaluate the lymphatic vessels diameter, five fields chosen by chance were evaluated using a 200 x objective. Photomicrographs of each field were made (CANNON), and the percentage of lymphatic vessels area per field was determined by a digital image analysis system (Image Tool 3.0). The diameter of lymphatic vessels can be considered as a good parameter to evaluate lymphatic oedema absorption, according to previous observations . As the protocol was about acute events, the hypothesis of lymphangiogenesis was not considered.
For the anti-CD45RA, CD3, CD18, CD163, and MAC 387 markers, ten microscopic fields chosen by chance were observed per slide, using immersion objective (magnitude 1000 x). They included almost all the subcutaneous vascular connective tissues of the pad, and the number of positive cells per field was recorded. In the case of Anti-MAC 387, only mononuclear positive cells were considered. The hematoxylin-eosin-stained slides were used to count the number of PMN cells per field. In this case, the recognition of cells was made only by morphological criteria. The expression of CD163 is proportional to the macrophage maturation, because of that, these results were expressed as the ratio between CD163/MAC 387 mononuclear positive cells per field.
For the Anti-CD54, the intensity of positivity on the endothelial cells surface was evaluated by a score system, varying from 1 to 4. Five fields chosen by chance were evaluated by slide, using immersion objective (magnitude 1000 x), and the scores were done by two independent observers, in a blind manner, to avoid subjective interpretation in the analysis. The final score for each slide was equal to the sum of the partial scores. The criteria of score grading are represented in Table 4.
2.7. Statistical Analysis
The Bartlett test was firstly employed to determine the Gaussian distribution of the majority of data points. Then, ANOVA/Tuckey-Krammer or Kruskall-Wallis/Dunn was performed, according to the Bartlett results. The evaluation of mast cell degranulation, instead, was evaluated by test. The values of were considered significant. All statistical analysis was performed using the INSTAT 3 software.
In relation to oedema, an additional intragroup statistical analysis was also performed, and the comparison of oedema intensity among subgroups at 30 minutes (spontaneous oedema) revealed significant differences (Tuckey-Krammer, ), validating the proposed experimental design.
2.8. Bioethical Criteria
The protocol was approved by the Bioethics Committee of Universidade Paulista (protocol 011/07), according to the São Paulo State law no. 11.977/05 (Animal protection code of São Paulo State, Brazil). This procedure is in accordance with the European Convention for the Protection of Vertebrate Animals used for Experimental and Other Scientific Purposes and its appendix.
The histopathological aspect of inflamed footpads revealed the classic framework of a typical early acute inflammation: oedema and cell infiltrate corresponding to 2/3 of PMN cells and 1/3 mononuclear cells. However, considering the intragroup statistical treatment, the existence of different patterns of inflammatory process development in function of time could be identified (Tables 5 and 6). Thus, there was the necessity to systematize and classify these patterns before analyzing the effects of Arnica montana 6cH.
According to that, a significant antioedematous effect of Arnica montana 6cH could be seen (ANOVA, ) only in the subgroup of rats that presented the peak of oedema between 30 and 180 minutes after the injection of carrageenan into the footpad (called late subgroup) (Figure 1). Also, the histomorphometric analysis of slides stained by Toluidine blue revealed that the late subgroup also presented less intense mast cell degranulation (, ) and greater diameter average of lymphatic vessels (Kruskal-Wallis, ). Instead, in the early subgroup (oedema peak before 30 minutes), only a discrete but significant increase in mast cell degranulation was observed (, ), as well as increase in scores of CD54 expression by endothelial cells (Kruskal-Wallis, ) (Tables 5 and 6, Figures 2 and 5).
No difference among groups and subgroups was observed regarding cell migration, considering PMN cells and all markers used in the immunohistochemical analysis, including the CD 163+/MAC 387+ cells ratio (Tables 5 and 6, Figures 3, 4, and 5).
Taking all data together, it is possible to illustrate the main conclusion by a scattering graph of oedema intensity, in which the different trends among groups and subgroups can be seen, after the treatment with Arnica montana 6cH (Figure 6). Note that animals treated with Arnica and exhibiting late oedema (late subgroup) are displaced to the baseline in relation to the other groups.
Among the homeopathic medicines that have special interest in inflammation control [3, 25, 26], Arnica montana is one of most studied [16–20]. Nevertheless, in the recent scientific literature about homeopathy, there are many studies searching to demonstrate the efficacy of its effect, but few works are devoted to the comprehension of physiopathological changes in tissues after the exposition of animals to these medicines [6, 27, 28]. Is from this point of view that the present work was built; through a detailed study of the inflamed connective tissue, considering the subsets of cells that migrate to it, the vessels behavior, and time-dependent dynamic of this process under the action of Arnica montana 6cH. Interestingly, some effects observed are in accordance with previous observed results, such as the overture of lymphatic vessels and the consequent reduction of oedema .
The first results obtained here point toward an interesting fact: the individual analysis of each subgroup shows the importance of temporality in the effect of Arnica montana 6cH; animals that presented spontaneous late peak of oedema (after 30 minutes from irritant injection) were more sensible to Arnica than the animals that presented an early peak of oedema (before 30 minutes). In this case, the oedema was even less intense than the control and dexamethasone treated groups, and this fact was concomitant with the significant reduction of mast cell degranulation and increase of lymphatic vessels diameter. Both phenomena could contribute to the reduction of macroscopic oedema and differ from dexamethasone pattern, in which lymphatic vessels area reduces passively together with the oedema reduction, as shown in Figure 2. This effect corroborates the results observed previously in .
Carrageenan is a polysaccharide obtained from the seaweed Chondrus crispus that has the ability to induce local inflammation, without systemic effects . It is classically known that prostaglandins are generated during the oedema formation after subcutaneous carrageenan injection by migrated neutrophils . The observation of antioedema effect of Arnica montana 6cH exclusively in animals that presented the late pattern of acute inflammation points toward the participation of different chemical mediators in controlling pathways, as demonstrated before in [10, 11]. In this sense, histamine and prostaglandin, mediators whose peak of action occurs toward 15–30 minutes, probably modulate this process in the late oedema subgroup, instead of mediators with a very precocious action, such as bradykinin, whose peak is about 10 minutes after releasing [24, 30].
Experimental models designed specially to demonstrate the importance of individual variation in the effect of homeopathic medicine were already described before [5, 31, 32], but never in an inflammation protocol. Individuality means specificity in homeopathic medicine; in Rocha 2008 , only the naturally hyperactive rats were responsible to Rhus toxicodendron 200cH treatment, regarding their behavior in an open-field device. On the other hand, Soares 2007  observed that only hypoactive rats were responsible to Bryonia alba 200cH. These complementary studies show results compatible to the respective materia medica. The systematic comparison of both studies and others is seen in .
Regarding to PMN and mononuclear leukocyte sub-types cell migration, no difference among groups and subgroups was seen, nor the CD163+/MAC387+ ratio revealed any change in the dynamic of macrophage maturation in the inflammatory site. The CD 163 is a transmembrane glycoprotein type I, of 175 kD, also known as ED2 protein. Its presence has been described in the mature macrophage surface, but also in a less intense manner in immature monocytes and other mononuclear cells in humans. The expression of ED 2 is associated to the iron metabolism and increases during the later phases of inflammation, because positive cells have a modulator role, releasing autocrine IL10 [33–35]. The presence of T and B lymphocytes into the inflammatory site could be related to a certain modulator action [23, 24], which has been suggested in previous studies about Arnica montana 6cH , but not confirmed herein.
The expression of adhesion molecules CD 54 (ICAM-1) was greater in animals treated with Arnica montana 6cH that presented early pattern of inflammation and was associated to a greater percentage of degranulated mast cells in the inflamed tissue, but not to a greater leukocyte migration. Although no mechanistic explanation could be done in this step of the study, it seems that the global results are split in two main patterns: those of regulating vascular dynamics, evident in the late oedema subgroup, and those of regulating cell events, evident in the early oedema subgroup, suggesting an individual-dependent qualitative adjustment of vascular and cellular inflammation events by Arnica montana 6cH, as seen in Figure 6. These different patterns of variability, oscillating according to the previous state of the tested biological system, have been experimentally described in other experimental contexts with different homeopathic preparations [26, 36–38].
In conclusion, the two proposed hypotheses could be highlighted: (a) there is no selective modulation of leukocyte subsets migration by Arnica montana 6cH treatment, but only vascular regulations, regarding lymphatic absorption, CD54 expression, and histamine degranulation and (b) there is a clear interference of the individual kinetic variation in vascular events after treatment with Arnica montana 6cH.
Conflict of Interests
There is no conflict of interests related to this work.
The authors thank CAPES-PROSUP Program and FAPESP Proc. no. 2007/59661-5 for the financial support; Marcia Gutierrez from Farmacia Sensitiva for supplying medicines; Fernanda Ferrari, Paulo Ailton Valdovato, and Lika Osugui for technical support.
- E. Davenas, B. Poitevin, and J. Benveniste, “Effect on mouse peritoneal macrophages of orally administered very high dilutions of Silica,” European Journal of Pharmacology, vol. 135, no. 3, pp. 313–319, 1987.
- M. Oberbaum, Z. Weisman, A. Kalinkovich, and Z. Bentwich, “Healing chronic wounds performed on mouse ears using silica (SiO2) as a homeopathic remedy,” in Signals and Images, M. Bastide, Ed., pp. 191–200, Kluwer Academic, Dodrecht, The Netherlands, 1997.
- J. de Araújo Prado Neto, F. F. Perazz, L. G. V. Cardoso, L. V. Bonamin, and J. C. Tavares Carvalho, “Action of Causticum in inflammatory models,” Homeopathy, vol. 93, no. 1, pp. 12–16, 2004.
- C. de Paula Coelho, V. D'Almeida, M. Pedrazzolli-Neto et al., “Therapeutic and pathogenetic animal models for Dolichos pruriens,” Homeopathy, vol. 95, no. 3, pp. 136–143, 2006.
- M. P. S. Rocha, F. M. Soares, L. C. Martini, and L. V. Bonamin, “Behavior of rats treated with Rhus toxicodendron 200cH,” International Journal of High Dilution Research, vol. 7, pp. 3–6, 2008.
- L. V. Bonamin and P. C. Endler, “Animal models for studying homeopathy and high dilutions: conceptual critical review,” Homeopathy, vol. 99, no. 1, pp. 37–50, 2010.
- A. Shang, K. Huwiler-Müntener, L. Nartey et al., “Are the clinical effects of homoeopathy placebo effects? Comparative study of placebo-controlled trials of homoeopathy and allopathy,” Lancet, vol. 366, no. 9487, pp. 726–732, 2005.
- R. Lüdtke and A. L. B. Rutten, “The conclusions on the effectiveness of homeopathy highly depend on the set of analyzed trials,” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, vol. 61, no. 12, pp. 1197–1204, 2008.
- M. Frenkel, B. M. Mishra, S. Sen et al., “Cytotoxic effects of ultra-diluted remedies on breast cancer cells,” International Journal of Oncology, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 395–403, 2010.
- A. C. Carvalho, Efeitos da administração de Arnica montana (tintura-mãe e UHD) na atividade de diferentes agentes flogísticos em ratos, Master of Science Dissertation, Instituto de Ciências da Saúde, Universidade Paulista—UNIP, 2000.
- A. C. Carvalho and L. V. Bonamin, “Efeitos da Arnica montana (tintura-mãe e preparações dinamizadas 6CH) na atividade de diferentes agentes flogísticos em ratos,” Pesquisa Homeopática, vol. 16, pp. 31–43, 2001.
- F. S. Ferrari and L. V. Bonamin, “Efeitos da Arnica montana (6CH, 12CH e Tintura-mãe) na reabsorção linfática de ratos submetidos a modelo de inflamação aguda,” in Proceedings of the Annals of the 20th Symposium of Groupe International de Recherche sur l'Infinitésimal (GIRI '06), 2006.
- L. V. Bonamin, “Arnica montana and behavior of connective tissue,” in Signals and Images: Contributions and Contradictions of High Dilution Research, L. V. Bonamin, Ed., pp. 113–125, Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008.
- S. B. Macêdo, L. R. Ferreira, F. F. Perazzo, and J. C. Tavares Carvalho, “Anti-inflammatory activity of Arnica montana 6cH: preclinical study in animals,” Homeopathy, vol. 93, no. 2, pp. 84–87, 2004.
- C. A. Klaas, G. Wagner, S. Laufer et al., “Studies on the anti-inflammatory activity of phytopharmaceuticals prepared from Arnica flowers,” Planta Medica, vol. 68, no. 5, pp. 385–391, 2002.
- P. Bellavite, A. Conforti, F. Pontarollo, and R. Ortolani, “Immunology and homeopathy. 2. Cells of the immune system and inflammation,” Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 13–24, 2006.
- P. Bellavite, R. Ortolani, and A. Conforti, “Immunology and homeopathy. 3. Experimental studies on animal models,” Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 171–186, 2006.
- J.-H. Karow, H.-P. Abt, M. Fröhling, and H. Ackermann, “Efficacy of Arnica montana D4 for healing of wounds after Hallux valgus surgery compared to diclofenac,” Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 17–25, 2008.
- A. Conforti, P. Bellavite, S. Bertani, F. Chiarotti, F. Menniti-Ippolito, and R. Raschetti, “Rat models of acute inflammation: a randomized controlled study on the effects of homeopathic remedies,” BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 7, article 1, 2007.
- E. A. Palombo, “Traditional medicinal plant extracts and natural products with activity against oral bacteria: potential application in the prevention and treatment of oral diseases,” Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. In press.
- F. P. G. Bonfim, E. R. Martins, R. G. R. Dores, C. K. R. Barbosa, V. W. D. Casali, and I. C. G. Honório, “Use of homeopathic Arnica montana for the issuance of roots of Rosmarinus officinalis L. and Lippia alba (Mill) N.E,” International Journal of High Dilution Research, vol. 7, pp. 72–76, 2008.
- L. V. Bonamin, K. S. Martinho, A. L. Nina, F. Caviglia, and R. G.W. Do Rio, “Very high dilutions of dexamethasone inhibit its pharmacological effects in vivo,” Homeopathy, vol. 90, no. 4, pp. 198–203, 2001.
- J. G. Leme, G. H. Bechara, and R. R. Dos Santos, “A proinflammatory factor in lymphocytes. Its role in the development of acute, non immunological inflammatory reactions,” British Journal of Experimental Pathology, vol. 57, no. 4, pp. 377–386, 1976.
- G. H. Bechara, L. Sudo, R. Ribeiro Dos Santos, and J. Garcia Leme, “Modulation by lymphocytes of the vascular effects caused by inflammatory mediators and carrageenin in the rat,” British Journal of Experimental Pathology, vol. 57, no. 5, pp. 497–504, 1976.
- C. M.V. Pedalino, F. F. Perazzo, J. C.T. Carvalho, K. S. Martinho, C. de O Massoco, and L. V. Bonamin, “Effect of Atropa belladonna and Echinacea angustifólia in homeopathic dilution on experimental peritonitis,” Homeopathy, vol. 93, no. 4, pp. 193–198, 2004.
- A. L. dos Santos, F. F. Perazzo, L. G. V. Cardoso, and J. C. T. Carvalho, “In vivo study of the anti-inflammatory effect of Rhus toxicodendron,” Homeopathy, vol. 96, no. 2, pp. 95–101, 2007.
- P. Bellavite, A. Conforti, F. Pontarollo, and R. Ortolani, “Immunology and homeopathy. 2. Cells of the immune system and inflammation,” Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 13–24, 2006.
- L. V. Bonamin, A. Lagache, and M. Bastide, “Research on ultra-dilutions and the Theory of Corporeal Signifiers: the follow up,” in Signals and Images: Contributions and Contradictions of High Dilution Research, L. V. Bonamin, Ed., pp. 9–43, Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008.
- R. Vinegar, W. Schreiber, and R. Hugo, “Biphasic development of carrageenan oedema in rats,” Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental, vol. 166, pp. 96–103, 1976.
- T. N. Lo, A. P. Almeida, and M. A. Beaven, “Dextran and carrageenan evoke different inflammatory responses in rat with respect to composition of infiltrates and effect of indomethacin,” Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics, vol. 221, no. 1, pp. 261–267, 1982.
- A. Cristea, S. Teodorescu-Negres, and V. Darie, “Chamomilla homeopatic dhiluition effect on central nervous system,” in Signals and Images, M. Bastide, Ed., pp. 171–178, Kluwer Academic, Dodrecht, The Netherlands, 1997.
- F. M. Soares, “tividade geral de ratos tratados com Bryonia alba 200CH,” Scientific Report, Universidade de Santo Amaro, Brasil, 2007.
- M. M. Van Den Heuvel, C. P. Tensen, J. H. Van As et al., “Regulation of CD163 on human macrophages: cross-linking of CD163 induces signaling and activation,” Journal of Leukocyte Biology, vol. 66, no. 5, pp. 858–866, 1999.
- D. J. Schaer, G. Schoedon, and A. Schaffner, “Assignment of the CD163 antigen (CD163) to mouse chromosome 6 band F2 by radiation hybrid mapping,” Cytogenetic and Genome Research, vol. 98, no. 2-3, pp. 231–B1, 2002.
- P. Philippidis, J. C. Mason, B. J. Evans et al., “Hemoglobin scavenger receptor CD163 mediates interleukin-10 release and heme oxygenase-1 synthesis. Anti-inflammatory monocyte-macrophage responses in vitro, in resolving skin blisters in vivo, and after cardiopulmonary bypass surgery,” Circulation Research, vol. 94, no. 1, pp. 119–126, 2004.
- M. Bastide, V. Daurat, M. Doucet-Jaboeuf, A. Pelegrin, and P. Dorfman, “Immunomodulator activity of very low doses of thymulin in mice,” International Journal of Immunotherapy, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 191–200, 1987.
- V. Daurat, P. Dorfman, and M. Bastide, “Immunomodulatory activity of low doses of interferon α,β in mice,” Biomedicine and Pharmacotherapy, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 197–206, 1988.
- K. S. Martinho, V. D. B. Bento, G. U. Benvenga, V. A. Marcondes, and L. V. Bonamin, “Hepatic cell growth models for the study of ultra high dilutions,” in Signals and Images: Contributions and Contradictions of High Dilution Research, L. V. Bonamin, Ed., pp. 119–136, Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008.