Differences in Median Ultraviolet Light Transmissions of Serial Homeopathic Dilutions of Copper Sulfate, Hypericum perforatum, and Sulfur
Table 1
Comparisona between light transmissions of controlsb and potencies (6c–30c)c of CuSO4, hypericum, and S8.
CuSO4
Hypericum
S8
190 nm–340 nm
220 nm–340 nm
190 nm–340 nm
220 nm–340 nm
190 nm–340 nm
220 nm–340 nm
Measurement 1
Mean controls
0.999990
1.000002
0.999995
0.999999
0.999998
1.000001
SD controls
0.000573
0.000539
0.000279
0.000258
0.000260
0.000246
Mean hp
1.000037
1.000058
0.999826
0.999851
1.000093
1.000075
SD hp
0.000637
0.000601
0.000349
0.000331
0.000279
0.000266
0.910
0.955
0.160
0.171
0.299
0.363
−0.019
−0.010
−0.238
−0.232
−0.171
−0.149
Measurement 2
Mean controls
0.999996
0.999998
1.000004
1.000001
1.000010
1.000006
SD controls
0.000311
0.000311
0.000393
0.000371
0.000594
0.000578
Mean hp
1.000062
1.000058
1.000005
1.000053
1.000648
1.000583
SD hp
0.000500
0.000465
0.000460
0.000431
0.000676
0.000639
0.791
0.806
0.596
0.488
0.012
0.013
−0.045
−0.042
−0.090
−0.117
−0.411
−0.408
Measurement 3
Mean controls
0.999997
1.000007
1.000003
1.000020
1.000014
1.000010
SD controls
0.000383
0.000338
0.001094
0.000984
0.000493
0.000478
Mean hp
0.999810
0.999817
0.999663
0.999662
1.000684
1.000602
SD hp
0.000492
0.000422
0.000955
0.000893
0.000610
0.000576
0.449
0.241
0.454
0.476
0.004
0.005
−0.130
−0.201
−0.127
−0.120
−0.475
−0.464
Measurement 4
Mean controls
0.999992
1.000000
0.999999
0.999997
0.999997
0.999991
SD controls
0.001013
0.000905
0.000549
0.000484
0.000365
0.000366
Mean hp
0.999624
0.999670
0.999660
0.999721
1.000506
1.000478
SD hp
0.000896
0.000791
0.000780
0.000682
0.000844
0.000782
0.450
0.364
0.154
0.177
0.071
0.068
−0.130
−0.156
−0.241
−0.228
−0.297
−0.300
Measurement 5
Mean controls
1.000002
1.000009
1.000008
1.000008
0.999992
0.999994
SD controls
0.000860
0.000792
0.001375
0.001247
0.000712
0.000659
Mean hp
0.999926
0.999916
0.999673
0.999736
1.000170
1.000122
SD hp
0.000800
0.000718
0.001312
0.001205
0.000793
0.000735
0.985
0.821
0.701
0.688
0.973
0.864
−0.003
−0.039
−0.065
−0.068
−0.006
−0.028
Autoclave
Mean controls
0.999994
0.999997
0.999993
0.999997
1.000002
1.000002
SD controls
0.000629
0.000536
0.000557
0.000465
0.000519
0.000470
Mean hp
0.999915
0.999943
0.999801
0.999802
1.000557
1.000497
SD hp
0.000567
0.000517
0.000673
0.000587
0.000563
0.000520
0.610
0.664
0.391
0.298
0.011
0.014
−0.087
−0.075
−0.145
−0.176
−0.416
−0.403
EMF
Mean controls
1.000001
0.999998
1.000002
0.999996
1.000008
1.000002
SD controls
0.000409
0.000376
0.000333
0.000302
0.000567
0.000527
Mean hp
0.999765
0.999779
0.999845
0.999866
1.000661
1.000594
SD hp
0.000475
0.000423
0.000588
0.000519
0.000715
0.000677
0.198
0.219
0.913
0.942
0.013
0.013
−0.221
−0.211
−0.019
−0.012
−0.408
−0.408
Incubation
Mean controls
0.999998
1.000003
1.000009
0.999997
0.999986
0.999997
SD controls
0.000406
0.000371
0.000677
0.000632
0.001174
0.001122
Mean hp
0.999629
0.999649
0.999999
1.000009
1.000649
1.000571
SD hp
0.000431
0.000409
0.000383
0.000334
0.000623
0.000587
0.020
0.026
0.289
0.298
0.041
0.115
−0.399
−0.382
−0.179
−0.176
−0.336
−0.259
UV
Mean controls
1.000003
1.000005
1.000000
1.000000
1.000001
1.000009
SD controls
0.000629
0.000612
0.000580
0.000569
0.000439
0.000413
Mean hp
0.999610
0.999637
0.999558
0.999586
1.000676
1.000599
SD hp
0.000342
0.000319
0.000536
0.000517
0.000545
0.000498
0.212
0.281
0.015
0.024
0.002
0.002
−0.214
−0.185
−0.411
−0.383
−0.520
−0.512
aby Mann-Whitney- test, mean normalised transmission with standard deviation (SD) is shown, statistically significant results () are displayed in bold, = effect size
b for CuSO4 and hypericum, for S8
c for CuSO4 and for hypericum and S8.