Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine / 2014 / Article

Research Article | Open Access

Volume 2014 |Article ID 120486 | 7 pages | https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/120486

Treating Postlaparoscopic Surgery Shoulder Pain with Acupuncture

Academic Editor: Vitaly Napadow
Received05 Dec 2013
Revised14 Mar 2014
Accepted30 Mar 2014
Published23 Apr 2014

Abstract

Objective. The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of acupuncture on postlaparoscopic shoulder pain (PLSP) which is a common side effect in patients undergoing abdominal laparoscopic surgery. Methods. Patients with moderate to severe PLSP in spite of analgesic treatment, which were referred by the medical staff to the Complementary-Integrative Surgery Service (CISS) at our institution, were provided with acupuncture treatment. The severity of PLSP and of general pain was assessed using a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) from 0 to 10. Pain assessment was conducted prior to and two hours following acupuncture treatment. Acupuncture treatment was individualized based on traditional Chinese medicine diagnosis. Results. A total of 25 patients were evaluated during a 14-month period, from March 2011 to May 2012. A significant reduction in PLSP (mean reduction of ) and general pain (mean reduction ) were observed, and no significant side effects were reported. Conclusion. Individualized acupuncture treatments according to traditional Chinese medicine principles may improve postlaparoscopic shoulder pain and general pain when used in conjunction with conventional therapy. The primary findings of this study warrant verification in controlled studies.

1. Introduction

Laparoscopic surgery, also called minimally invasive surgery, is a modern surgical technique in which operations in the abdomen are performed through small incisions so that a miniature video camera can be inserted and allow the surgeon to examine the surgical area [1]. In order to enhance the surgeon’s ability to clearly view the operating area, the abdomen is inflated using carbon dioxide (CO2) [1, 2]. The inflation of CO2 is believed to cause shoulder pain, which is often associated with laparoscopic procedures, due to irritation of the diaphragm. The incidence of shoulder pain varies from 35% to 80%, ranges from mild to severe, and usually lasts up to 72 hours after surgery [1, 2]. 38% of patients report constant pain in the 48–72 hrs following surgery, while 28% experience it intermittently. Most patients will require analgesics or nonpharmacologic (heat packs, etc.) treatment for pain relief [3].

Current treatment of postlaparoscopic shoulder pain (PLSP) is not standardized and may include preventive measures such as removing CO2 by means of Trendelenburg position (the body is laid flat on the back, with the feet higher than the head by 15–30 degrees) and a pulmonary recruitment maneuver [2, 4], intraperitoneal gas drain [4], use of warmed and humidified insufflations of carbon dioxide [5, 6], and pain control after surgery with analgesic medications [79]. However, these treatments are often unsatisfactory or carry side effects [10].

Integration of complementary medicine (CM) is being used increasingly in medical settings [11, 12], especially for various pain syndromes [13]. In 2010 a unique service integrating CM in the Surgery Department at the Bnai-Zion Medical Center in Israel was established (Complementary and Integrative Surgery Service (CISS)). Practitioners at the CISS provide various CM treatments to palliate common perioperative symptoms. Treatment outcomes are documented and analyzed via a rigorous registry protocol [14, 15]. Acupuncture was reported in several studies as an effective treatment for reducing postoperative pain [16], and therefore we considered it as potentially appropriate for PLSP. During the first months of the CISS’s activity, practitioners developed a traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) based approach for treating patients with PLSP. The treatment approach was developed through a process which included conducting a literature review of conventional medicine and classical TCM texts relevant to PLSP; observation of multiple laparoscopic surgeries; acupuncturists’ group discussions on the topic; and extensive clinical exploration of the various approaches that were suggested [17]. When a consensus among the practitioners was reached regarding the treatment approach, we began gathering data on the outcomes systematically. In this paper we report the outcomes of patients experiencing PLSP that were referred to our service by the medical staff (physicians and nurses) between March 2011 and May 2012. This is the first paper in the English literature reporting on acupuncture treatment for PLSP.

2. Methods

The study was conducted at the Bnai-Zion Medical Center in the General Surgery Department from March 2011 to May 2012. The study was approved by the institution’s IRB and was registered with ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT01733771).

Inclusion criteria consisted of patients who experienced clinically significant PLSP (reporting pain of more than 3 on a Visual Analogue Scale of 0–10) which appeared within 24 hrs following laparoscopic surgery (mainly cholecystectomy, hernias in the anterior abdominal wall, and bariatric surgery) and did not respond satisfactorily to analgesic use. Analgesics were provided according to the departments’ pain management protocol. If within two hours of analgesic provision pain persisted with a VAS score of four and above, patients were referred to acupuncture. Exclusion criteria included age under 16 and first trimester of pregnancy.

Patients were categorized according to classical TCM clinical patterns/syndromes [1820]. The TCM diagnosis was based on a thorough physical examination including traditional tongue and pulse diagnosis as well as facial and voice diagnosis [21]. TCM diagnosis of patients with PLSP was validated by two TCM practitioners (each with a minimum of seven years in practice). Whenever there were disagreements regarding the TCM pattern categorization, a third TCM practitioner was involved until resolution was achieved. Based on the individualized TCM diagnosis, a customized acupuncture treatment plan was formulated.

Acupuncture treatments were documented according to STRICTA guidelines [22]. Disposable soft spring handle needles (Dongbang Acupuncture Inc.) 20 × 30 mm were utilized. After insertion of the needles and achieving a “De Qi” sensation (warmth, numbness around the needle), needles were stimulated according to the TCM syndrome [23]. The needles were left in place according to the particular needle technique employed: dispersing for 30 minutes, balancing for 20 minutes, and strengthening for 15–18 minutes. The number of points chosen in each treatment ranged between four and eight. Some points were placed bilaterally and others on one side. For a detailed description of the acupuncture points that were used according to each syndrome, see Table 5.

Shoulder pain was evaluated using Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) with a scale of “no symptom whatsoever” to “unbearable symptom severity” (100 mm length line). There were no numbers on the scale. The questionnaires were presented on a touch screen, utilizing iPAD application technology. Patients reported symptom severity on the VAS scale prior to treatment and within 2 hours following it. Each patient was provided with the first acupuncture treatment within 24 hours of surgery. The degree of shoulder pain relief was considered clinically significant if a reduction of more than 15 mm was reported on VAS.

3. Statistical Analysis

Data was entered and managed using the Microsoft Excel 2003 Program and later analyzed using the SPSS Program, version 18 (IBM SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA). The normality of the data was tested by Kolmogorov-Smirnov . As the pain variables were normally distributed, paired -test was conducted for differences between before and after acupuncture treatments. Pearson’s correlation was conducted for determining the strength and direction of the association between general pain and shoulder pain and also to measure the linear association between those two variables. was considered significant.

4. Results

4.1. Patient Referral and Characteristics

Twenty-six patients were referred to acupuncture treatment for PLSP by the surgery departments’ physicians and nurses. One patient was not willing to participate in the study due to fear from needles. Twenty-five patients provided consent for acupuncture treatment and received individualized acupuncture treatment for PLSP. Two patients received an additional treatment for PLSP on the consecutive day. Patient characteristics are presented in Table 1.


PatientsAge (y)Gender Type of laparoscopic surgery

139F Hernia repair
240F Sleeve gastrectomy
350F Cholecystectomy
457F Sleeve gastrectomy
520M Sleeve gastrectomy
625F Cholecystectomy
753F Left hemicolectomy
858F Appendectomy
963F Hernia repair
1037F Left hemicolectomy
1122F Peritoneal lavage
1252F Right hemicolectomy
1371M Fundoplication
1445F Cholecystectomy
1557F Cholecystectomy
1625F Sleeve gastrectomy
1718F Sleeve gastrectomy
1823F Sleeve gastrectomy
1939F Cholecystectomy
2045F Sleeve gastrectomy
2120M Sleeve gastrectomy
2261M Appendectomy + cholecystectomy
2341F Gall bladder inflammation
2427F Sleeve gastrectomy
2522F Sleeve gastrectomy

4.2. Pain Measurement

Changes in PLSP are presented in Tables 2 and 4. The mean pain for PLSP before treatment was on the VAS. PLSP severity before intervention ranged from 3.6 to 9.9. Two hours following treatment mean pain for PLSP decreased to () with a mean reduction of . PLSP severity 2 hours following intervention ranged from 0.2 to 6.6.


Number of patientsMeanStandard deviationMinimumMaximum50th median

PLSP before258.371.823.69.98.90
PLSP after251.891.800.26.61.10

Note: .

We also evaluated postoperative pain (general pain) around the operated area, as presented in Tables 3 and 4; patients were requested to report their general pain (not associated with PLSP) on VAS scales at the same time they were evaluated for PLSP. The acupuncture treatments were provided with the goal of relieving general pain as well as PLSP. In 24 patients the mean reduction of pain was ().


Number of patientsMeanStandard deviationMinimumMaximum50th median

General pain before246.442.530.08.97.40
General pain after241.951.880.05.401.15

.
One patient did not report general level of pain.

PatientMain TCM syndromePLSP beforePLSP afterGeneral pain before General pain after

1Heat in the heart + phlegm9.81.18.93.5
2Sp Qi def. + phlegm9.91.68.62.6
3Phlegm80.96.90.7
4Phlegm9.81.26.80.4
5Lung Qi def.9.93.87.82.1
6Qi def. + phlegm9.84.27.95.2
7Phlegm heat in the stomach and intestine + kidney Yin def. + heat7.90.95.72.8
8Phlegm heat 3.60.65.40
9Spleen Qi def., blood def. in the heart9.91.91.20
10 Kidney Yin and Yang def.5.21.100
11 Lung heat/fire + liver Yang rising8.30.47.40.7
12Spleen Qi def. + liver Qi stg.9.70.36.61.2
13Gall bladder heat and phlegm7.11.80.80.3
14Phlegm in upper burner9.96.67.34.8
15Liver Qi stg. + heat in upper burner73.58.67.1
16Lung heat/fire + gall bladder heat and phlegm stg.8.916.60.4
17Liver Qi and blood stg.815.51.4
18Kidney Yin and Yang def.9.91.700
19Stomach Qi stg. + spleen Qi def.8.90.28.70.6
20Spleen Qi def. + dampness + liver blood stg.4.83.666.1
21Spleen dampness + liver Qi stg.9.76.56.84.8
22Phlegm heat9.70.88.81.2
23Phlegm heat in the stomach + liver Qi stg.6.30.64.70.8
24Phlegm heat in the stomach + phlegm could in the triple burner9.80.27.41.1
25Spleen Qi def. and dampness, liver blood def.7.61.851.6


SyndromeKey point

PhlegmPc5—a key point that was used every time that phlegm was diagnosed.
St 40, Tw10, Liv 2, Gb 40—one or two points where combined depending on the TCM syndrome
HeatLi 11, St 40, Liv 2, Gb 40, Sp 6, Kid 2.
Blood and Qi stagnationLi4, Liv 3, Pc 6, Pc 7, Sp 10.
DampnessLu 5, Sp 9, Sp 6, Sp 3.
Blood and Qi deficiencySt 36, St 37, St 38, St 39, Sp 6, Liv 3, Liv 4, Sp, Sp 10.

The number of points chosen in each treatment ranged from four to eight.

In addition, we found a linear correlation between mean difference in general pain and mean difference in shoulder pain (Pearson , ), meaning that patients who had a greater reduction in PLSP had a similar reduction in general pain and vice versa.

4.3. Adverse Events

We asked patients to report adverse effects associated with the treatment such as hematomas, needle pain, nausea, and weakness. We assessed fainting and forgotten needles. No adverse events were reported during this trial by patients and practitioners.

4.4. PLSP Categorization into TCM Syndromes

We identified five main TCM syndromes in patients with PLSP and acupuncture points relevant to the treatment of each syndrome (Tables 4 and 5).

4.4.1. Phlegm

People undergoing a surgical process are subjected to a world full of emotions. Threat of death, familial relations, and personal emotional and spiritual resources are at an extreme.

Excess of any of the five emotions in TCM, that is, anger, fear/fright, happiness, worry/doubt, and sadness, leads to an abundance of Qi. Excess Qi then transforms into “fire,” which condenses the body fluids and forms phlegm [24].

Anxiety and fright are the most common emotions during presurgical preparations. Gong Ju Zhong, a famous TCM scholar, said that “Phlegm is produced by fright. The Shen (spirit) leaves its residence, and when the residence is empty, the fluids will form phlegm” [24]. In turn, phlegm blocks Qi, consequently causing pain as a result of Qi blockage. The treatment protocol we chose for treating phlegm had two objectives: (i) to dispel and disperse the phlegm that was produced and (ii) to stop the present formation and prevent the future formation of phlegm.

In 15 of the cases phlegm was part of the syndrome. We found that, by choosing points that disperse phlegm, patients first described a sense of emotional relief, followed by reduction of pain.

4.4.2. Qi and Blood Stagnation

The formation of pain in the shoulder after laparoscopic surgery was referred to as Qi and/or blood stagnation. This was diagnosed based on the combination of two criteria—the presence and intensity of the purple color on the patient’s tongue and the characteristics of sharp and severe pain [1821]. This form of stagnation may be generated by the emotional stress of undergoing a surgical procedure, as well as the mechanics of the surgical procedure itself.

4.4.3. Heat

In 14 patients heat was observed. Two parameters were used to diagnose heat: tongue and pulse diagnosis. Tongue diagnosis of heat was based on findings such as the appearance of red dots on the tongue, with their position indicating in which burner (upper, middle, or lower burner) the heat is accumulating [1820]. Another important finding was the appearance of yellow coating on the tongue [18].

The second parameter used to determine heat was the pulse. An indication of heat would be a rapid pulse [19, 25]. A secondary tool used to assess heat was facial diagnosis. Rosy cheeks or any form of redness on the face would indicate heat [1921]. We found that heat would appear in patients who often reported emotional frustration, had a harder time dealing with change, or were lonely for long periods of time. Following acupuncture, patients reported being calmer and the medical staff noticed that they were more compliant and easier to deal with.

4.4.4. Dampness

Dampness was diagnosed in 4 patients according to three major characteristics: having a slippery/wavy pulse [19, 25]; being obese or having a subjective feeling of “heaviness” in the body; having a swollen tongue with white or yellow coating, where the thickness of the coating would indicate the severity of the dampness [1821]. These patients were less willing to “get up and move around”; this may have hampered their rehabilitation. The aim of the treatment was to mobilize them and resolve dampness, thereby reducing pain and facilitating movement.

4.4.5. Deficiency Syndromes

The deficiency is manifested in the tongue and pulse, which generally look less vital [18, 19, 25]. Patients often exhibit a white or yellowish complexion. Their voice may be very weak and it is hard for them to conduct a lengthy conversation. Some patients even found it hard to fill out the questionnaires. The detailed diagnostics of deficiency syndromes are well known in the classical TCM literature [1821, 2325].

In our case series, we found that patients often suffered from Qi deficiency. Nine patients suffered from spleen Qi deficiency. This could be due to the lifestyle they conducted before the surgery. It may also have been caused by the prolonged fasting before and after surgery.

One patient suffered from lung Qi deficiency; this was attributed to heavy smoking and lack of exercise or diet.

Five patients suffered from Yin deficiency involving the kidney and the stomach. These patients were already weak prior to surgery. All five patients required a second treatment, which was provided within 24 hours of the first one. A third treatment was provided only to one patient with prolonged hospitalization due to surgery complications. This patient received a third treatment mainly for general pain, although mild shoulder pain was addressed too.

5. Discussion

In the present study, individualized acupuncture was found to be safe and a potentially efficacious adjuvant treatment to relieve pain in patients with PLSP. The employment of an individualized classical traditional Chinese medicine approach is unique in conventional care settings in which a disease oriented approach employing fixed formulas of acupuncture points is often utilized. The task of applying TCM syndromal diagnosis to patients with PLSP was indeed challenging in light of the relatively modern nature of this diagnosis. The acute changes induced by surgery and medications were not observed by TCM scholars at the time of canonization of TCM theory and practice. Consequently, the presentations of the syndromes were atypical and complex. In our study, we identified five major TCM syndromes (see Table 4) based on patient history and classical TCM physical examination. The rationalization of this process may serve researchers of other traditional therapies to construct treatment and research strategies in conventional care settings.

Although causality cannot be inferred in our observational study, we assume that the immediate outcomes, within 2 hours following treatment, were probably related to the acupuncture treatment. This assumption is derived from the natural history of PLSP, which usually takes a longer time to resolve [1, 2]. Moreover, patients were referred by physicians and the nursing staff to acupuncture treatment only if standard analgesics did not reduce pain sufficiently. This may reflect the severity and persistency of such pain, as well as the judgment of the medical staff regarding acupuncture’s effectiveness for this indication. The effect attributed to acupuncture may be exerted by both the specific and nonspecific effects of an acupuncture session, and in this study we did not aim to differentiate between these components [26].

A possible limitation of this study is that the questionnaires were filled out by patients in their practitioners’ presence. This may have inadvertently caused patients to “please” the practitioners by reporting better outcomes. Our study also lacks longer periods of follow-up. Repeated pain recordings on the days following treatment could provide such information.

Additional potential limitations are a carry-on or add-on effect of analgesics to that of acupuncture. It is truly difficult to differentiate between these effects; however, we do not find it necessary to do so. The concept of integrative medicine emphasizes making appropriate use of both conventional and complementary medicine; therefore, combining both for a patient with inadequate pain control fulfills this concept [27]. We are less interested in whether complementary medicine can, or should, replace other forms of conventional pain management but rather whether it can be used safely and effectively to complement current conventional pain management approaches. Differentiating between acupuncture and other cointerventions effect can be assessed using pragmatic trial methodology, that is, comparing between patients on analgesic use and acupuncture only. In addition, various treatment protocols can be established for various syndromes, and treatment outcomes per treatment protocols can be compared. The issue of appropriateness of individualized versus protocolized approaches in busy, high volume departments deserves attention. Based on our experience in such settings, we favor the former approach as long as detailed rationalization of treatment selection and documentation is provided. However, only future controlled trials comparing patient outcomes as well as economic analysis could possibly resolve this debate from both patient and administrative perspectives.

The novelty of our study is in the application of classical TCM approaches to modern acute hospital care. The TCM presentation of our patients was complex due to the physiological and biochemical effects of surgery and medications. Often, it was difficult to differentiate the underlying (presurgery) disharmony in TCM pattern diagnosis from the acute manifestations that were a consequence of the surgery. We therefore often selected to address both [25].

In summary, providing individualized acupuncture according to TCM principles seems to have potential in relieving PLSP. Randomized controlled trials should be conducted in order to validate our preliminary findings and differentiate between the effects of acupuncture and other cointerventions.

Conflict of Interests

The authors state that there is neither actual nor potential conflict of interests, including any financial or personal relationships with other people or organizations.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank Ilana Merhav and Tanya Kligerman, librarians at the Bnai-Zion Medical Center, and Shlomit Grimberg and Sarah Ben-Shlush for assisting in data collection, as well as Marianne Steinmetz for editing this paper.

References

  1. F. Brunicardi, D. Andersen, T. Billiar et al., Schwartz's Principles of Surgery, McGraw-Hill Professional, New York, NY, USA, 9th edition, 2009.
  2. P. Phelps, O. S. Cakmakkaya, C. C. Apfel, and O. C. Radke, “A simple clinical maneuver to reduce laparoscopy-induced shoulder pain: a randomized controlled trial,” Obstetrics and Gynecology, vol. 111, no. 5, pp. 1155–1160, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  3. J. B. Dixon, Y. Reuben, C. Halket, and P. E. O'Brien, “Shoulder pain is a common problem following laparoscopic adjustable gastric band surgery,” Obesity Surgery, vol. 15, no. 8, pp. 1111–1117, 2005. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  4. S. H. Sharami, M. B. Sharami, M. Abdollahzadeh, and A. Keyvan, “Randomised clinical trial of the influence of pulmonary recruitment manoeuvre on reducing shoulder pain after laparoscopy,” Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 505–510, 2010. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  5. T. Sammour, A. Kahokehr, and A. G. Hill, “Meta-analysis of the effect of warm humidified insufflation on pain after laparoscopy,” British Journal of Surgery, vol. 95, no. 8, pp. 950–956, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  6. M. S. Sajid, A. S. Mallick, J. Rimpel, S. A. Bokari, E. Cheek, and M. K. Baig, “Effect of heated and humidified carbon dioxide on patients after laparoscopic procedures: a meta-analysis,” Surgical Laparoscopy, Endoscopy and Percutaneous Techniques, vol. 18, no. 6, pp. 539–546, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  7. E. Engelman and F. Cateloy, “Efficacy and safety of perioperative pregabalin for post-operative pain: a meta-analysis of randomized-controlled trials,” Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, vol. 55, no. 8, pp. 927–943, 2011. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  8. P. F. White and H. Kehlet, “Improving postoperative pain management: what are the unresolved issues?” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, vol. 16, no. 2, Article ID CD007556, 2011. View at: Google Scholar
  9. M. X. Traa, S. Derry, and R. A. Moore, “Single dose oral fenoprofen for acute postoperative pain in adults,” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, vol. 16, no. 2, p. CD007556, 2011. View at: Google Scholar
  10. E. J. Lavonas, J. F. Fries, D. E. Furst et al., “Comparative risks of non-prescription analgesics: a structured topic review and research priorities,” Expert Opinion on Drug Safety, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 33–44, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  11. R. L. Nahin, P. M. Barnes, B. J. Stussman, and B. Bloom, “Costs of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and frequency of visits to CAM practitioners: United States, 2007,” National Health Statistics Reports, no. 18, pp. 1–14, 2009. View at: Google Scholar
  12. S. A. Shorofi and P. Arbon, “Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) among hospitalised patients: an Australian study,” Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 86–91, 2010. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  13. Y. Sun, T. J. Gan, J. W. Dubose, and A. S. Habib, “Acupuncture and related techniques for postoperative pain: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials,” British Journal of Anaesthesia, vol. 101, no. 2, pp. 151–160, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  14. E. Schiff, S. Attias, H. Hen et al., “Integrating a complementary medicine service within a general surgery department: from contemplation to practice,” Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 300–305, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  15. E. Schiff, E. Ben-Arye, S. Attias, G. Sroka, I. Matter, and Y. Keshet, “Perceiving integration of a complementary medicine service within a general surgery department through documentation of consultations: a thematic analysis,” Patient Education and Counseling, vol. 89, no. 3, pp. 430–433, 2012. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  16. Y. Sun, T. J. Gan, J. W. Dubose, and A. S. Habib, “Acupuncture and related techniques for postoperative pain: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials,” British Journal of Anaesthesia, vol. 101, no. 2, pp. 151–160, 2008. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  17. M. A. Frenkel and J. M. Borkan, “An approach for integrating complementary-alternative medicine into primary care,” Family Practice, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 324–332, 2003. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  18. G. Maciocia, Tongue Diagnostic in Chinese Medicine, Eastland Press, Seattle, Wash, USA, 5th edition, 2000.
  19. G. Maciocia, Forwarded by Dr. Ming S. X. the Foundation of Chinese Medicine, Churchill Levingstone, New York, NY, USA, 1989.
  20. W. Bing and T. Dynasty, Yellow Emperor’s Canon Internal Medicine, Chinese Science & Technology Press, 1997.
  21. N. Bilello, Understanding the Difficult Patient, Blue Poppy Press, Costa Mesa, Calif, USA, 2005.
  22. STRICTA, “Standards for reporting interventions in clinical trials of acupuncture,” 2010. View at: Google Scholar
  23. J. Kong, R. Gollub, T. Huang et al., “Acupuncture De Qi, from qualitative history to quantitative measurement,” Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 13, no. 10, pp. 1059–1070, 2007. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  24. M. Al-Khafaji, P. Deadman, and T. Martin, “Some acupuncture points which treat phlegm disorders,” Journal of Chinese Medicine, vol. 39, pp. 1–4, 1992. View at: Google Scholar
  25. B. Flaws, The Secret of Chinese Pulse Diagnosis, Blue Poppy Press, Costa Mesa, Calif, USA, 2nd edition, 1997.
  26. K. Linde, K. Niemann, A. Schneider, and K. Meissner, “How large are the nonspecific effects of acupuncture? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials,” BMC Medicine, vol. 8, article 75, 2010. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
  27. J. A. Dusek, M. Finch, G. Plotnikoff, and L. Knutson, “The impact of integrative medicine on pain management in a tertiary care hospital,” Journal of Patient Safety, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 48–51, 2010. View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar

Copyright © 2014 Gur Kreindler et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

2585 Views | 607 Downloads | 4 Citations
 PDF  Download Citation  Citation
 Download other formatsMore
 Order printed copiesOrder

We are committed to sharing findings related to COVID-19 as quickly and safely as possible. Any author submitting a COVID-19 paper should notify us at help@hindawi.com to ensure their research is fast-tracked and made available on a preprint server as soon as possible. We will be providing unlimited waivers of publication charges for accepted articles related to COVID-19. Sign up here as a reviewer to help fast-track new submissions.