Review Article

Traditional Chinese Mind and Body Exercises for Promoting Balance Ability of Old Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Characteristics of eligible studies in current meta-analysis.

Author and yearSubjectsDurationDesignInterventionOutcomeKey findings
ControlExperiment

Li et al. 2005  
Age: 70–92  
Gender: 77M, 179F
24 wRCTStretching
60 minutes, 3 times per week
Tai Chi
60 minutes, 3 times per week
BBS
TUG
The score of BBS and TUG was improved in the Tai Chi group compared to the stretching group

Zhang et al. 2006  
Age: ≥60  
Gender: 25M, 24F
8 wRCTContinue their current level of physical activityTai Chi
60 minutes, 7 times per week
One-leg balanceTCC training group significantly improved in one-leg balance compared to daily activities

Pereira et al. 2008  
Age: 60–82  
Gender: 77F
12 wRCTDoing their daily activitiesTai Chi
50 minutes, 3 times per week
Unipodal position testTC had an increase in unipodal position compared to control group

Kim et al. 2009  
Age: 65–87  
Gender: 20M, 20F
12 wRCTWellness education
60 minutes, per week
Tai Chi
60 minutes, 3 times per week
Center of pressureTC had a greater COP compared to wellness education

Logghe et al. 2009  
Age: ≥70  
Gender: 78M, 191F
13 wRCTUsual careTai Chi + Chi Kung
60 minutes, twice per week
BBSNo difference

Taylor-Piliae et al. 2010 Trial 1  
Age: 60–84  
Gender: 40M, 92F
24 wRCTAttend-control
90 minutes, once per week
Tai Chi
45 minutes, twice per week
Single-leg stanceTai Chi had greater improvements compared to control group

Taylor-Piliae et al. 2010 Trial 2  
Age: 60–84  
Gender: 40M, 92F
24 wRCTWestern exercise
45 minutes, 3 times per week
Tai Chi
45 minutes, twice per week
Single-leg stanceTai Chi had greater improvements compared to WE

Nguyen and Kruse 2012  
Age: 60–79  
Gender: 48M, 48F
24 wRCTDaily activitiesTai Chi
60 minutes, twice per week
TUGTUG in TC group is significantly improved compared to daily activities

Taylor et al. 2012 Trial 1  
Age: ≥65  
Gender: 182M, 502F
20 wRCTLow-level exercise
60 minutes, once per week
Tai Chi
60 minutes, once per week
TUGNo difference

Taylor et al. 2012 Trial 2  
Age: ≥65  
Gender: 182M, 502F
20 wRCTLow-level exercise
60 minutes, once per week
Tai Chi
60 minutes, twice per week
TUGNo difference

Tousignant et al. 2012  
Age: ≥65  
Gender: 41M, 111F
15 wRCTPhysiotherapy interventionBaduanjin
60 minutes, twice per week
BBS
TUG
No difference

Son et al. 2016  
Age: 65–83  
Gender: 50F
12 wRCTOtago exercise
60 minutes, twice per week
Tai Chi
60 minutes, twice per week
TUG
OLS
Otago group exhibited a greater improvement in TUG compared to TC group; TC group showed greater improvement in OLS compared to Otago group

Note: TC: Tai Chi; TUG: Timed Up and Go Test; BBS: Berg Balance Score; OLS: One-leg-standing.