Review Article

Therapeutic Efficacy of Kangfuxin Liquid Combined with PPIs in Gastric Ulcer

Table 2

Intervention characteristics of included studies.

Study ID (name,  year)InterventionDuration/follow-upAdverse eventsOutcome measures
Trial groupControl group (essential treatment)

Li, 2012 [20]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentEsomeprazole, 40 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Xiang, 2013 [21]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentEsomeprazole, 40 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Zhang, 2009 [22]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentEsomeprazole, 40 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRT: 2 cases nausea, 1 case diarrhea; C: 2 cases nauseaTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Zhang, 2013 [23]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentEsomeprazole, 20 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Huang, 2014 [24]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentOmeprazole, 20 mg, BID, Po4 weeks/1 yearNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy, recurrence rate
Huang, 2016 [25]KFX, 10 mL, TID + omeprazole, 20 mg, QD, PoOmeprazole, 20 mg, BID, PoT: 28 days/NR C: 14 days/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, clearance rate of HP
McGrady, 2016 [26]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentOmeprazole, 20 mg, BID, Po4 weeks/NRT: 1 case headache, 1 case nausea; C: 3 cases headache, 2 cases nausea, 2 cases constipationTotal efficacy rate
Xuan, 2008 [27]KFX, 10 mL, TID + omeprazole, 20 mg, QD, PoOmeprazole, 20 mg, BID, Po4 weeks/NRT: 1 case rash over axillae; C: 1 case insomniaTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Zhu, 2016 [28]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentLansoprazole, 30 mg, QD, Po2 weeks/NRNOTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Zhou, 2016 [29]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentLansoprazole, 30 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRT: 2 cases dizziness and diarrhea; C: 11 cases nausea and diarrheaTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy, inflammatory cytokines, T-lymphocyte subsets
He, 2014 [30]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentLansoprazole, 30 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRNOTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Chen, 2012 [31]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentRabeprazole, 10 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Ou, 2014 [32]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentRabeprazole, 10 mg, QD, Po5 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Yu, 2016 [33]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentRabeprazole, 20 mg, QD, Po3 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate
Chen, 2017 [15]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, BID, Po2 weeks/NRT: 1 case rash; C: 2 cases nausea, 1 case rashTotal efficacy rate
Fan, 2015 [34]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRT: NO; C: 5 cases diarrheaTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy, inflammatory cytokines, T-lymphocyte subsets, clearance rate of HP
Liang, 2011 [35]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, BID, intravenous drip2 weeks/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Peng, 2010 [36]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, BID, Po10 days/NRT: 1 case diarrhea; C: 2 cases diarrheoa, 1 case bellyacheTotal efficacy rate
Tian, 2015 [37]KFX, 10 mL, QD + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, QD, Po1 month/NRNRTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Ye, 2007 [38]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, QD, Po4 weeks/NRT: 4 cases digestive symptoms; C: 3 cases digestive symptomsTotal efficacy rate, efficacy rate of gastroscopy
Zhang, 2015 [39]KFX, 10 mL, TID + essential treatmentPantoprazole, 40 mg, BID, intravenous drip1 week/half a yearT: 1 case diarrhea; C: 2 cases diarrhea, 1 case headache, 1 case rashTotal efficacy rate, recurrence rate
Zhang, 2015 [40]KFX, 10 mL, TID + omeprazole, 20 mg, QD, PoOmeprazole, 20 mg, BID, PoT: 4 weeks/NR C: 2 weeks/NRT: 2 case diarrhea; C: NOTotal efficacy rate, clearance rate of HP

QD, once a day; BID, twice a day; TID, three times a day; KFX, Kangfuxin Solution; Po, oral administration; HP, Helicobacter pylori; NR, no report.