|
| Reference | No. | Medicine | Population (age range) | Autonomic stimulus | Duration and HRV measures | Other measures |
|
| [33] | 1 | ECM | 42 patients (14–73) | Eight-constitution acupuncture | 5 min, frequency domain | BMI |
| [34] | 2 | SCM | 32 healthy students (20–30) | Paced breathing in specific respiration rate | 5 min, time and frequency domain | Respiration rate |
| [35] | 3 | SCM | 60 healthy students (20–30) | Ratio of inhalation and exhalation, posture (sitting, standing) | Time and frequency domain | Self-evaluation for physical condition (scale 10 cm) |
| [36] | 4 | SCM | 78 healthy students (20–30) | Breath-counting meditation | 5 min, time and frequency domain | Skin conductance, temperature, abdominal amplitude, thoracic amplitude |
| [37] | 5 | SCM | 78 students | Meditation program (α version) | Time and frequency domain | BDI (depression), STAXI (anger), STAI (anxiety) questionnaires |
| [38] | 6 | SCM | 16 healthy TE constitution (20–60) | Taegeuk acupuncture | 5 min, frequency domain | None |
| [39] | 7 | SCM | 6 healthy SE constitution men (20–30) | Taegeuk acupuncture | 5 min, frequency domain | None |
| [40] | 8 | SCM | 63 fatigue and nonfatigue subjects (40–60) | None | 5 min, time and frequency domain | BMI, biochemistry analysis, pulse wave analysis, nail fold capillary microscopy, questionnaires (FSS, GSRS, SF-MPQ, PSQI, SF-12) |
| [41] | 9 | SCM | 8 healthy SY constitution women (20–30) | Taegeuk acupuncture | 5 min, frequency domain | None |
| [42] | 10 | SCM | 47 healthy subjects (29–66) | Forrest healing program (aroma, foods, tea by constitution + trekking) | 5 min, time and frequency domain | BMI, body temperature, vital sign (BP, SpO2), electroencephalography, biochemistry analysis, blood cell count, stress hormone test |
| [43] | 11 | SCM | 665 subjects (39–72) | None | 5 min, time and frequency domain | BMI, BP, fasting blood sugar, cholesterol, abdominal obesity |
| [44] | 12 | SCM | 20 healthy subjects (18–30) | Bee venom acupuncture | 5 min, time and frequency domain | Pulse wave analysis, cerebral blood flow |
| [45] | 13 | SCM | 103 idiopathic facial palsy patients (10–79) | None | 5 min, time and frequency domain | Facial electromyography |
| [46] | 14 | SCM | 10 TE constitution patients | Herbal formula for TE constitution (Jowisengcheong-tang) | 5 min, time and frequency domain | None |
| [47] | 15 | SCM | 30 healthy men (20–26) | Acupuncture at LI4 | 5 min, time and frequency domain | None |
| [48] | 16 | SCM | 39 patients (20–59) | Autogenic training | 5 min, time and frequency domain | MBTI questionnaire (extraversion, introversion) |
| [49] | 17 | SCM | 8498 workers | None | 5 min, time and frequency domain | None |
| [50] | 18 | SCM | 44 healthy subjects (20–30) | Emotional stimulus (horror film) | 120 sec, 197 sec, 120 sec, time and frequency domain | None |
| [51] | 19 | SCM | 86 subjects (22–25) | Electroacupuncture | 30 sec, time domain (SDNN) | None |
| [52] | 20 | SCM | 19 healthy subjects | Acupuncture at LI4 and LR3 | 5 min, time and frequency domain | BP, BMI |
|
