|
| First author (year) | Region | Journal | Study design | Classification of AP | Groups | Interventions | Duration of treatment (days) |
|
| Li (2020) | Shanxi | Guangming Journal of Chinese Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 time/day | 14 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zhan (2019) | Beijing | Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 10 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Yuan (2019) | Hubei | Chinese and Foreign Medical Research | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Hu (2019) | Zhejiang | Chinese Journal of Surgery of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 1 time/day | 10 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zhang (2018) | Henan | Chinese Journal of New Clinical Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zhang (a) (2018) | Shaanxi | Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zhang (b) (2018) | Shaanxi | Medical Journal of West China | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Fan (2018) | Chongqing | Journal of Clinical Medical | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zha (2018) | Henan | Chongqing Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Ji (2017) | Qinghai | Shaanxi Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2–3 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Chen (2017) | Henan | Modern Diagnosis and Treatment | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Liu (2017) | Hubei | World Chinese Journal of Digestology | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Gao (2016) | Liaoning | Chinese Traditional Patent Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Chen (2015) | Hubei | World Chinese Journal of Digestology | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Chen (2015) | Hebei | International Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zhang (2015) | Liaoning | Medical Information | RCT | AP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | NA |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Zhu (2015) | Jiangsu | The World Clinical Medicine | RCT | AP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | NA |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Liu (2015) | Zhejiang | Journal of Emergency in Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | AP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Bai (2015) | Nei Mongol | China Foreign Medical Treatment | RCT | AP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Yang (2014) | Fujian | Fujian Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | AP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | 5–7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Liu (2014) | Henan | Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 50 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Lin (2012) | Xinjiang | Nei Mongol Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | SAP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
| Hong (2012) | Zhejiang | Journal of Emergency in Traditional Chinese Medicine | RCT | AP | XBJ group | Conventional treatment; Xuebijing injection 100 ml, 2 times/day | 7 |
| Control group | Conventional treatment |
|
