Research Article

Self-Regulation and Rubrics Assessment in Structural Engineering Subjects

Table 6


Evaluation criteriaExcellentVery good GoodVery poorUnacceptable

Explain the different types of foundation elements used in construction.In accordance with the proposed problem, the student explains the different foundation elements used in building work through different problem-solving procedures.In accordance with the proposed problem, the student explains the different foundation elements used in building work through a single problem-solving procedure.In accordance with the proposed problem, the student explains the different foundation elements in building work through a single procedure. However, the student makes some nonsignificant mistakes (75–60% accuracy).The student gives an imprecise definition of the different elements of the foundation used in building work. The solution of the problem therefore contains significant mistakes (50% error rate).The student does not describe the different elements of the foundation used in building work. No solution is given to the building problem that is proposed
36%54321
Test the foundation elements in accordance with current building regulations.The student tests and completes simplifications in accordance with current regulations, which are on the conservative side, that help with the calculation.The student tests the safety of a foundation with reference to current regulations.The student tests the safety of a foundation on the basis of current safety regulations. However, the student makes some nonsignificant mistakes (75–60% accuracy).The student tests some aspects of the safety of a foundation in relation to current regulations, but the work presents significant mistakes (50% error rate).The student does not test the safety of a foundation in relation to current legislation.
32%54321
Describe the reason for the different tests specified in the regulations on foundation elements.The student describes all the reasons for performing the different tests in the regulations on foundation elements (with no errors, 100% accuracy).The student describes almost all the reasons for performing the different tests in the regulations on foundation elements (with no significant errors, 90–80% accuracy).The student describes the most basic reasons for performing the different tests in the regulations on foundation elements (75–60% accuracy).The student describes very few reasons for performing the tests in the regulations on foundation elements (50% error rate).The student describes no reasons for performing the different tests indicated in the regulations on foundation elements.
32%54321