Emergency Medicine International

Research Article

Summary and Analysis of Relevant Evidence for Nondrug Nursing Programs in Neonatal Operational Pain Management

Table 3

Quality evaluation of systematic reviews.
AMSTARHarrison et al. [17]Stevens et al. [18]Johnston et al. [19]
Whether to formulate the preliminary design plan?1 point1 point1 point
Whether the research selection and data selection are repeatable?1 point1 point1 point
Whether to carry out a comprehensive retrieval strategy?1 point1 point1 point
Whether the grey literature is considered in the inclusion criteria?0 points0 points0 points
Whether to describe the characteristics of the included study?1 point1 point1 point
Whether to provide a list of the included and excluded literature?1 point1 point1 point
Whether to evaluate the scientificity of the included study?1 point1 point1 point
Whether the scientificity of the included study was properly applied in the derivation of the conclusions?1 point1 point1 point
Whether the methods used to synthesize the results were appropriate?1 point1 point1 point
Whether to fully assess the possibility of publication bias?0 points1 point1 point
Whether to indicate a conflict of interest?1 point1 point1 point
Total points9 points10 points10 points