Research Article  Open Access
Xiang He, Cun Zhang, Penghua Han, "Overburden Damage DegreeBased Optimization of HighIntensity Mining Parameters and Engineering Practices in China’s Western Mining Area", Geofluids, vol. 2020, Article ID 8889663, 21 pages, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8889663
Overburden Damage DegreeBased Optimization of HighIntensity Mining Parameters and Engineering Practices in China’s Western Mining Area
Abstract
China’s western mining area is an arid and semiarid area with a fragile ecological environment, and the highintensity mining activities aggravate ecological damage. Reasonable choice of the mining parameters (i.e., mining height, panel width, and advancing speed) can not only improve the mining efficiency but also weaken the mininginduced deformation and failures of the overburden and surface. The statistical analysis of the relationship between the mining parameters and periodic weighting interval (PWI) proves that mining parameters have significant influence on overburden failure. In this study, the damage constitutive equation was derived, and the overburden damage degree was defined to quantitatively characterize mininginduced stratum damage in a threedimensional space. FLAC3D numerical models embedded with a damage constitutive equation were built to compare the panel width effect and advancing speed effect between the overburden damage degree and the waterconducted fracture zone (WCFZ). The reasonable range for mining parameters of the panel 12401 was provided based on the fitting function of the overburden damage degree versus mining parameters. The field measurements were carried out on panel 12401 of the Shangwan coal mine, including the advancing speed, PWI, and ground crack development. The results show that, under constant engineering and geological conditions, the damage degree of overburden will be weakened by increasing the advancing speed, reducing the mining height, or shortening the panel width. The overburden damage degree is more accurate than the height of the waterconducted fractured zone. The reasonable mining parameters of the panel 12401 are 8.8 m in mining height, 300 m in panel width, and 13.47 to 20.58 m/d in advancing speed, respectively. The field measurement results of the PWI and ground cracks have verified the validity using the overburden damage degree to determine highintensity mining parameters.
1. Introduction
Coal is the dominant energy source in China. In 2018, the total consumption was 4.64 billion tons of standard coal, accounting for 59% of the nation’s total energy consumption [1]. China’s western mining area is an important energy base for the country, which is typically characterized by large reserves, shallow buried coal seams, simple geological structure, excellent coal quality, and fragile ecological environment [2]. Guo et al. [3] defined highintensity mining as a highyield and highefficiency coal mining method in thick coal seams (more than 3.5 m) with large panel width (more than 200 m), fast advancing speed (more than 5 m/d), high output (usually 5–10 million t/y), a small coal seam depth/thickness ratio (less than 100), and severe overburden and surface failures. For example, the mining height of panel 22307 in the Bulianta coal mine is 7.0 m with a panel width of 450 m and an advancing speed of 21.6 m/d. However, highintensity longwall mining usually results in a drop of the groundwater table [4], death of vegetation [5], desertification of land [6], and further deterioration of the fragile ecological environment in these arid and semiarid areas [7]. Therefore, it is one of the research hotspots for both ensuring the safety of highintensity production and reducing surface ecological damage by optimizing mining parameters.
In general, based on the overburden movement and fracture development, an overburden can be divided into, from bottom to top, a caved zone, a fractured zone, and a continuous zone [8–11]. The waterconducted fracture zone (WCFZ) consists of the caved zone and fractured zone and can be considered plasticized [12]. Hence, its height is important for the safety of underground production and the surface ecological environment (Guo et al. 2018; [13–16]). The height of WCFZ depends on the mining method, mining height, advancing speed, panel width, overburden strength, stratum structure, and geological structure [2, 17–20]. The empirical formula method has been widely used to predict the height of WCFZ. Empirical formulas were usually established on a large number of field measurements with consideration of the rock mechanical strength and mining height; however, most of the field data from the eastern mining areas in China [21]. Guo et al. [3] presented a theoretical study to predict the height of the WCFZ based on the rock failure criteria to determine the maximum suspension length and maximum overhanging length during longwall mining. Liu et al. [22] and Hu et al. [23] obtained the empirical formulas of the height of WCFZ and the weights of variables using multivariate regression analysis. Majdi et al. [12] presented five mathematical approaches to estimate the height of a destressed zone and argued that the height of the destressed zone ranged from 6.5 to 24 times the mining height in the short term and from 11.5 to 46.5 times the mining height in the long term. Some scholars believe that the position and structure of the main key stratum are the determinants of the height of WCFZ. Therefore, key stratum theory is also a common method to predict the height of WCFZ [24–27].
The morphology of the WCFZ is also a main factor to characterize the damage of the overburden. The WCFZ is in a saddle shape after critical mining scale (i.e., length and width) which has been verified by numerous studies [21, 28–30]. Qian et al. [31] found Oshaped mininginduced fracture zone after the gob was compacted, which is the main storage place for gas. Lin et al. [32] established a mathematical model to depict the dynamic evolution of mininginduced fracture elliptic parabolic zone considering the mining height and distance from the first subkey stratum to the coal seam roof. Wang et al. [33] described the spatial shape of mininginduced fracture as an arch shape through physical modeling. Using FLAC3D modeling, Zhang et al. [34] found that the spatial shape of the WCFZ was a “hat” in the conditions with thick alluvium and thin bedrock. Based on equivalent continuum methods, Zhou et al. [35] developed a new 3D numerical model to simulate the archshaped induced fractures in the roof.
Current studies on overburden damage mainly focused on the height and morphology of the WCFZ and provided an important reference for engineering design. However, due to severe surface subsidence and ground cracks are inevitably accompanied with highintensity mining in the western mining area, the height and shape of the WCFZ cannot quantitatively reflect the damage state of the overburden in threedimensional space. In addition, when the WCFZ exceeds the surface during shallow coal seams mining and the WCFZ is incomplete in the overburden, the current predictive equations and shape models of the WCFZ become poor to describe the overburden damage. Therefore, this study reports a new method to describe overburden damage based on FLAC3D numerical simulations embedded with a damage constitutive equation. Reasonable mining parameters were determined through the method, and its reliability was verified by the field measurements.
2. Relationship between Mining Parameters and PWI
Highintensity mining usually results in enhanced deformation, overburden damage, and environmental impacts than those in general geological and mining conditions. Rock strata above the gob can be assumed to be the beam (or plates) structure. When the subsidence deformation of the rock stratum exceeds the threshold, it will fracture, leading to the upward development of fractures. Based on Equation (1); the subsidence deformation of the rock stratum is negatively correlated with the comprehensive expansion coefficient [31]. The more fragmentized the roof is, the greater the comprehensive expansion coefficient is. Thus, as the caving interval of the basic roof decreases, the comprehensive expansion coefficient of the rock stratum will increase. Then, the upper rock stratum will be more difficult to fracture because of the decrease of its subsidence space, resulting in the height of the waterconducting fracture zone of the overburden to decrease. where is the subsidence deformation of the th rock stratum, is the mining height, is the height difference between the th rock stratum and the coal seam, and is the comprehensive expansion coefficient below the th rock stratum.
Periodic weighting intervals (PWI) and the associated mining parameters were collected from 19 longwall faces in the western mining area (Table 1 and Figure 1).

(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
The PWI is related to many factors, such as rock structure, mining parameters of the working face, coal mining methods, and in situ stress. However, the geological conditions of mines differ greatly from each other. Thus, the same mine adjacent working faces were selected as a case to ensure that the geological and coal seam occurrence conditions are as close as possible and that the influence law of mining parameters on rock fracture is analyzed accurately. (1)Four adjacent working faces of the Huojitu coal mine and Daliuta coal mine were selected as samples. As shown in Figure 1(a), the panel widths of one mine are same and the mining heights are very close. As shown in Figure 1(b), the PWI has a positive linear correlation with the advancing speed. However, due to the different occurrence conditions of the coal seams, the PWI of the Daliuta coal mine is much longer than that of the Huojitu coal mine(2)Five adjacent working faces of the Shangwan coal mine were selected as samples, which have approximately equal panel widths and advancing speeds (Figure 1(a)). The influence law of the mining height on the PWI of the main roof was analyzed. As illustrated in Figure 1(c), with a negative exponential relationship between the mining height and PWI and the increase of the mining height, the basic roof is prone to fracture(3)Similarly, five adjacent working faces in the Yujialiang coal mine were selected as samples to analyze the effect of the panel width on the PWI. As illustrated in Figure 1(d), with the panel width increasing from 240 m to 400 m, the PWI of the basic roof is shortened from 15 m to 9.9 m
From the analysis above, under constant engineering geological conditions, the PWI of the basic roof increases as the advancing speed increases, the mining height reduces, or the panel width shortens. In other words, the degree of overburden damage degree will be weakened for one panel by increasing the advancing speed, reducing the mining height, or shortening the panel width.
3. The Study Site
The Bulianta coal mine and the Shangwan coal mine are located at southwest Ordos City, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, as shown in Figure 2(a). Coal 12 is the main coal seam of the two coal mines, with a thickness of 7.56–10.79 m and a dip angle of 1–5°. The thickness of the overlying strata is 199–271 m, and thickness of the aeolian layer is 0–34 m in the study site. As demonstrated in Figure 2(b), panel 12511 is the second working face in the 5^{th} district of the Bulianta coal mine, and panel 12401 is the first working face in the 4^{th} district of the Shangwan mine. Panel 12511 was exploited with an average mining height of 7.4 m, a panel width of 319.1 m, and a panel length of 3139.3 m. The BLT1 drillhole is located 75 m in front of the setup entry and 164 m away from the headgate, and the BLT2 drillhole is located 909 m in front of the setup entry and 47 m away from the headgate. To maximize the recovery rate of coal resources, the panel 12401 was designed with a panel length of 3139.3 m and a fullseam mining height of 8.8 m which has been the largest mining height in China. Since there were no similar engineering geological conditions before, the mining parameters, especially the panel width and advancing speed, are required to be optimized to ensure the safety and efficiency of mine production and minimize the ecological damage caused by coal exploitation.
(a)
(b)
4. Damage Constitutive Model
4.1. Basic Hypotheses
Rock mass engineering practice and related experiments show that the deformation and strength characteristics of rock mass belong to the category of brittle failure [36, 37]. Thus, the following hypotheses were made: (a) rock mass is composed of two parts: matrix (noncrack part) and damaged body (microcrack part); (b) the matrix is isotropic elastic medium, and elastic deformation does not cause rock mass damage; (c) the damaged body is rigid perfectly plastic body without yield strength; (d) hydrostatic pressure does not cause rock mass damage; and (e) the matrix and damaged body conform to the deformation compatibility, that is, the strain is equal. The damage variable of the unit body in the rock mass was defined as follows: where is the damage variable, is the volume of the unit body, is the volume of the matrix, and is the volume of the damaged body, as shown in Figure 3.
4.2. Derivation of Constitutive Equation
The damaged body of rock mass is the stress release zone, and its deviatoric stress is zero. Under the condition of hydrostatic pressure, the cracks in the rock mass tend to close without any damage. Therefore, it can be considered that the damage of the rock mass is mainly caused by the deviatoric stress, and the rock mass stress and the matrix stress lie in the identical plane of deviatoric stresses. Thus,
Thereinto, where and are the second invariants of the deviatoric stress tensor of the rock mass and its matrix, respectively, is the deviatoric stress tensor of the rock mass, is the hydrostatic pressure, and is the Kronecker symbol.
Similarly,
Substituting Equations (4) to (7) into Equation (3),
Based on the hypothesis that hydrostatic pressure does not cause damage to the rock mass, that is, , Equation (8) can be rewritten as
Based on the hypothesis that the matrix is isotropic elastic medium, where is the elastic constant tensor of the matrix and is the strain tensor of the matrix.
Based on the hypothesis that the matrix and damaged body conform to the deformation compatibility, where is the strain tensor of the damaged body.
Substituting Equations (10) and (11) into Equation (9),
Equation (12) is the damage constitutive equation of rock mass. However, the volume of the damaged body in rock mass is virtual, which cannot be measured, resulting in Equation (12) is unavailable to practical application. Based on Equations (3) and (11), where is the shear modulus of the rock mass and varies with the degree of damage, variable, and is the shear modulus of the matrix, constant.
The relationship between equivalent stress and equivalent strain in elastoplastic mechanics is as follows:
Based on Equation (14), the change curve of shear modulus of the rock mass can be obtained by mechanical tests. Substituting Equation (13) into Equation (12),
Equation (15) is the ultimate damage constitutive equation of the rock mass, which is more convenient for practical application than Equation (12).
4.3. Model Verification
During the mining process of panel 12511, the WCFZ was observed using the combination method of washing fluid leakage and drillhole color TV. At the drillhole depth of 24.80–130.71 m, the trend of washing fluid leakage is relatively gentle (Figure 4). Beyond the drilling depth of 130.71 m, the leakage of the washing fluid increased significantly. At 134.74 m, the washing fluid circulation was interrupted, indicating that all the liquid was lost. After the drilling was completed, a drillhole color TV was used for the borehole imaging of the wall. The images obtained showed that the integrity of the strata was good above the drilling depth of 130.2 m, with few original fractures. An inclined fracture with 2 to 3 cm aperture began to appear below the drillhole depth at 130.2 m that was considered to be the top of the WCFZ. The irregular cross fractures began to appear at the drillhole depth of 201.1 m, causing serious damage to the drillhole, which was considered to be the top of the caved zone.
Based on the measured results from the BLT1, the top of the WCFZ is at a drillhole depth of 130.2 m. The ground elevation of the BLT1 drillhole is +1287 m, the floor elevation of coal 1–2 is +1044.9 m, and the mining height is 7.1 m. The equation for calculating the height of WCFZ [38] is as follows: where is the maximum height of WCFZ, is the mining depth, is the drillhole depth at the top of the WCFZ, and is the compression value of rock strata in the fractured zone during drilling observation, generally set as . From the calculation, the measured height of the WCFZ is 106.22 m.
The damage constitutive equation of the rock mass was embedded into the FLAC3D model to simulate the overburden failure. FlAC3D allows operators to use C++ language for custom constitutive model secondary development. The custom constitutive model should be compiled into dynamic Link Library (DLL) and stored in the “exe64\plugins\cModel” folder under the FLAC3D installation directory. After configuration by the “Model Configure Plugin” command, the custom constitutive model can be called. The cycle of FLAC3D is mainly divided into five steps: (1) solving the equilibrium equation according to Newton’s second law to get the acceleration of grid node, (2) adopting time integration to calculate node velocity and displacement, (3) the strain rate of the element solved by spatial derivative, (4) updating element stress and state variables based on constitutive model, and (5) calculating the internal forces of grid nodes by element integration. The constitutive model of step (4) in the above steps is realized by secondary development in this paper, and the other steps are automatically calculated by FLAC3D.
The simulation model took the panel of the Bulianta coal mine as the prototype with dimensions of . A fixed boundary, roller boundary, and free boundary were set at the bottom, around, and at the top of the model, respectively. In the numerical simulation models, the excavation area was 50 m from the model boundary to eliminate the boundary effect. The MohrCoulomb criterion was adopted in the excavation simulation, and the doubleyield constitutive model was applied in the gob elements [39–41]. Based on the lab tests and literature researches, the specific parameters are listed in Tables 2 and 3.


FLAC3D is a finite difference method software, which cannot simulate the height of waterconducting fracture zone. However, the height of plastic zone has been used to indirectly describe the height of waterconducting fracture zone for a long time [42, 43]. After the excavation of the model, the profile of plastic zone was made in the middle of the model, as shown in Figure 5. The shape of WCFZ is similar to saddle shape, and the height of WCFZ is 108.6 m. There is merely a difference of 2.38 m from the measured value of 106.22 m, and the relative error is 2.24%. The simulation result is close to the measured value, indicating that the model embedded with a damage constitutive equation is highly reliable.
5. Optimization of Mining Parameters Based on Overburden Damage Degree
5.1. Definition of the Overburden Damage Degree
With the purpose of overcoming the shortcomings of existing methods for describing overburden damage, the concept of the overburden damage degree was proposed. As shown in Equation (17), the overburden damage degree is defined as the ratio of the total volume of plastic zones to the observation space volume vertically above the excavation range of the coal seam. The greater the overburden damage degree is, the more severe the strata damage is. The overburden damage degree is no longer confined to the spatial form and the threezone distribution of the overburden and instead quantitatively describes the overburden failure. For numerical simulations, the calculation of the overburden damage degree is relatively convenient and practical. where is the overburden damage degree, is the volume of a plastic zone, and is the observed space volume.
5.2. Numerical Modeling
In practice, in order to maximize the recovery rate of coal resource, the working face is usually designed with a fullseam mining technology. Thus, the influence of different panel widths and advancing speeds on overburden damage is more significant to production. The FLAC3D numerical models of different panel widths and advancing speeds were established by taking panel 12401 of the Shangwan coal mine as a prototype. As shown in Figure 6, the model height is m, and the length is m in the advancing direction, and the model width is determined by the different panel widths. The settings of the boundary conditions and pillar width of the model were the same as those in Section 4.3. The MohrCoulomb criterion was adopted in the excavation simulation, and the doubleyield constitutive model was applied in the gob elements. Since panel 12401 is adjacent to the panel 12511 and has the same stratigraphic structure, the selection of physical and mechanical parameters is the same as in Tables 2 and 3.
5.3. Effect of the Panel Width on Overburden Damage
The number of working faces in a mining district will be reduced by increasing the panel width; then, the number of coal pillars will be reduced correspondingly, which is conducive to improving the coal recovery. However, the increase of the panel width leads to a more intensive overburden movement, which is not conducive to the protection of aquifers and surface ecological environment. Nine numerical models with different panel widths (Table 4) were constructed to investigate the influence of the panel width on the overburden damage degree. Base on the current situation of highintensity mining, the designed panel widths were ranging from 100 to 500 m with a gradient of 50 m. To improve the calculation efficiency, the model width increased with the panel width on the premise of not affecting the calculation results. The headgate and tailgate were excavated with dimensions high when the initial stress balanced. After the roadways were excavated, the panel 12401 was mined with 8.8 m mining height. The advancing speed was selected as 10 m/d, considering the previous mining experience of the Shangwan coal mine in Section 2.

As shown in Figure 7, cross profiles were made through the center of the models, and the distribution characteristics of the plastic zone with different panel widths were obtained. The plastic zone of the overburden is archshaped, and the boundary of the plastic zone is mainly shear failure. As increases in the panel width, the width of the plastic zone increases synchronously and the height of plastic zone increases from 51.72 m to the surface. When the panel width is 250 m, the aeolian sand appears to undergo shear failure, namely, when cracks occur on the surface. When the panel width is 300 m, the height of WCFZ and the depth of the surface failure further increase, but they are not connected. As depicted in Figure 7(e), the height of WCFZ reaches 162.9 m, but the burial depth of the panel 12401 ranges from 124 m to 244 m. Therefore, the coal exploitation of the panel 12401 has potential hazards such as air leakage, water, and sand inrush.
(a) 150 m
(b) 200 m
(c) 250 m
(d) 300 m
(e) 350 m
The overburden damage degree of the different panel widths was obtained by writing Fish language. As shown in Figure 8, as the panel width increases, the height of WCFZ and the overburden damage degree increase synchronously, verifying the reliability of the overburden damage degree to describe the overburden failure. The overburden damage degree versus the different panel widths was fitted as follows:
The fitting curve is monotonically increasing, and the inflection point is (319.84, 55.85). Specifically, when the panel width is 319.84 m, the overburden damage degree increases fastest. As illustrated in Figure 6, the overburden of panel 12401 is mainly thick and hard sandstone stratum. The thick and hard strata not only bear the weight of the overlying strata, but also hinder the upward development of fractures below [27, 44]. As the panel width increases from 300 m to 350 m, the overburden damage degree and the height of WCFZ have relatively large increase. The result indicates that the thick and hard strata are broken, which hinder the upward development of fractures. Combined with Figures 6, 7(d) and 7(e), we concluded that the thick and hard stratum mentioned above were the medium sandstone, and the inflection point of the fitting curve was the critical point of the stratum break. Therefore, under the engineering geological conditions of panel 12401 of the Shangwan coal mine, the maximum panel width determined by the overburden damage degree should be less than 319.84 m, which promotes safe and efficient mining. Meanwhile, the panel width is restricted by the available coal mining technology and mechanical equipment. Yi [45] investigated that the reasonable panel width of the Shangwan coal mine determined by the working resistance of hydraulic support should not exceed 300 m.
5.4. Effect of Advancing Speed on Overburden Damage
The tensile strength of the overburden will be improved by speeding up the panel advancing [46]. Nine Numerical models with different advancing speeds were constructed to investigate the influence law of advancing speed on the overburden damage degree. Based on the current situation of highintensity mining, the designed advancing speed range was 5 to 21 m/d with a gradient of 2 m/d. The dimensions of the models were . The headgate and tailgate were excavated with dimensions when the initial stress balanced. After the roadways were excavated, panel 12401 was mined with 8.8 m mining height and 300 m panel width. Different advancing speeds were simulated through stepwise excavation. The excavated step was equal to the advancing speed value, and the calculation time was 500 steps.
As shown in Figure 9, cross profiles were made through the center of models, and the distribution characteristics of the plastic zone with different advancing speeds were obtained. The plastic zone of the overburden is not connected with the surface, which indicates that the mining height and panel width are reasonably selected. As the advancing speed increases from 5 to 19 m/d, the height of WCFZ decreases from 132.7 to 114.35 m and the dimension of the surface plastic zone decreases in the advancing direction of the working face. The results above indicate that the mininginduced failure on the overburden and surface is weakened as the advancing speed increases.
(a) 5 m/d
(b) 13 m/d
(c) 15 m/d
(d) 17 m/d
(e) 19 m/d
As shown in Figure 10, both the overburden damage degree and the height of WCFZ show a decreasing trend as the advancing speed increasing. When the advancing speed is 5 to 13 m/d, the height of WCFZ remains at 132.7 m, but different advancing speeds correspond to different overburden damage degree values, thereby indicating that the overburden damage degree is more accurate than the height of WCFZ in describing the overburden damage. The variation range of the overburden damage degree influenced by the advancing speed and panel width is 41% to 49.37% and 19.98% to 88.02%, respectively. Therefore, the damage degree is more sensitive to the variation in panel width. The damage degree with different advancing speeds was fitted as follows:
The fitting curve is monotonically decreasing, and the inflection point is (13.47, 45.08). Specifically, when the advancing speed is 13.47 m/d, the overburden damage degree decreases fastest. The overburden damage degree and the height of WCFZ change slightly after the inflection point; thus, the reasonable advancing speed of panel 12401 should not be less than 13.47 m/d.
Due to the limited speed of the shearer, the advancing speed of the working face has to simultaneously meet the following equation: where is the advancing speed of the working face, is the cutting time of the shearer, is the cutting speed of the shearer, is the cutting depth, and is the panel width.
Based on the operation regulations of panel 12401, the shearer cuts coal for 17 hours a day with a running speed of 7 m/min and a cutting depth of 0.865 m. The maximum advancing speed of the working face under ideal conditions is 20.58 m/d through Equation (20). Therefore, the reasonable advancing speed of the working face is 13.47 to 20.58 m/d.
6. Field Practice
Based on the analysis above in this study, the mining parameters of panel 12401 of the Shangwan coal mine were designed as 8.8 m in mining height, 300 m in panel width, and 13.47 to 20.58 m/d in advancing speed. There were no air leakages, water inrushes, surface river interruptions, or other hazards during the entire mining process, indicating that the mining parameters determined by the overburden damage degree were valid.
6.1. Effects of the Advancing Speed on the Periodic Weighting
In the realworld production process, the advancing speed is easier to control than the mining height and panel width without affecting recovery rate of coal resources. During the new equipment debugging period from March 25, 2018, to May 27, 2018 (stage I), mining equipment failed frequently, and the continuity of the coal seam excavation was poor. As shown in Figure 11, the advancing distance of panel 12401 was 246.35 m in stage I, and the distribution of the advancing speed was discrete. The average advancing speed was merely 3.91 m/d, which was much less than the critical advancing speed of 13.47 m/d. During the normal mining period from May 28, 2018, to June 5, 2018 (stage II), the advancing distance reached 369.6 m, and the advancing speed was maintained at the critical value with an average advancing speed of 13.69 m/d.
The sum of the mean value and standard deviation of the endcirculation resistance of supports was taken as the criterion to judge the first roof weighting (periodic roof weighting). The expressions are as follows: where is the mean value of the endcirculation resistance of supports, is the number of monitoring cycles, is the endcirculation resistance of the support, is the standard deviation of the endcirculation resistance of the supports, and is the first roof weighting (periodic roof weighting) criterion. Statistics for the endcirculation resistance of the supports were within 360 m of the advancing distance, and the results show that =310.73 bar, =56.11 bar, and =366.84 bar.
The distribution characteristics of the support working resistance of the panel 12401 are shown in Figure 12. In stage I, the first weighting interval was 38 m, and the periodic weighting happened 14 times with an average periodic weighting interval of 15.12 m. In stage II, the periodic weighting happened 6 times with an average periodic weighting interval of 18.33 m. As the acceleration of the advancing speed, the periodic weighting interval increased, which was consistent with the statistical results in Section 2. Compared with stage II, stage I has an uneven distribution of the working resistance and a more durable weighting, which was resulting in frequent crushing accidents.
Due to the cumulative effect of overburden damage, accelerating the advancing speed shortens the accumulation time of overburden damage, and the periodic weighting interval of the basic roof increases accordingly. Meanwhile, accelerating the advancing speed shortens the duration of the periodic weighting, which promotes rapidly forming stable structure for the basic roof, and the overburden damage reduces accordingly. Therefore, the reliability of numerical simulation results for the overburden damage degree is verified by the distribution characteristics of the support working resistance in two stages.
6.2. Effects of Advancing Speed on Ground Cracks
Ground cracks are the external manifestation of the overburden damage caused by the highintensity mining of the shallow coal seams. The surface of panel 12401 is a 0 to 27 m aeolian sand with weak shear and tensile resistance, which is prone to forming ground cracks [16]. As shown in Figure 13, dynamic ground cracks of the two stages in the middle of the panel 12401 were selected for comparison. In stage I, due to the low advancing speed, the overlying strata were in states of tension or shear for a long period, resulting in forming the stepped type ground cracks. In stage II, within a reasonable range of the advancing speed, the tension and shear time of the overlying strata is shortened. Thus, the surface failure is relatively weak, and only the tension cracks with small openings appear. The field engineering practice shows that the acceleration of the advancing speed weakens the damage degree of the overburden and surface. This conclusion is consistent with the numerical simulation results, which verifies the reliability of the numerical simulation and the validity of the overburden damage degree in describing overburden failure.
(a) Tension ground cracks
(b) Stepped type ground cracks
7. Discussion
The statistical analysis of the relationship between the mining parameters and periodic weighting interval in the western mining area was carried out, which indicated that mining parameters have significant influence on overburden failure. The overburden damage degree index was defined to quantitatively characterize the damage degree of the miningdisturbed overburden in a threedimensional space. The reasonable mining parameters of panel 12401 are 8.8 m in mining height, 300 m in panel width, and 13.47 to 20.58 m/d in advancing speed, which were determined by the FLAC3D simulation of the overburden damage degree. The measured results of the PWI and the ground cracks of the two stages verified the validity of the determination of the highintensity mining parameters through the overburden damage degree method.
Previous studies on overburden failure mainly focused on the height and morphology of the WCFZ considering the profile of the overburden ([10–12, 22, 47]), while the overburden damage degree, defined in this study, is a variable in a threedimensional space to describe the damage volume ratio of the overburden. Based on the relationship between the overburden damage degree and the mining parameters, the reasonable mining parameters can be obtained. In addition, the mining parameters are closely related to the PWI and the crack development. Therefore, the overburden damage degree promotes ground pressure control and the surface crack management.
The concept of the overburden damage degree proposed in this study has been effectively applied in the production practices of the Shangwan coal mine in China’s western mining area. The validity of the overburden damage degree method will be further verified with different panel conditions in the future. The extraction of the overburden damage degree can be easily realized in the numerical models. However, methods for extracting the overburden damage degree from physical simulations and field engineering practices require a further study.
8. Conclusions
Taking the highintensity mining working faces in the western mining area as the background, the effects of mining parameters on the PWI, the height of WCFZ, the damage degree, and the ground cracks were investigated in this study by employing a combined method of statistical analysis, FLAC3D numerical simulation, and field measurement. The reasonable range for mining parameters of the panel 12401 was provided based on the fitting function of the overburden damage degree versus mining parameters. The main conclusions are as follows: (1)The PWI of the basic roof increases as the advancing speed increases, the mining height reduces, or the panel width shortens under constant engineering geological conditions. In other words, the degree of overburden damage degree will be weakened for one panel by increasing the advancing speed, reducing the mining height, or shortening the panel width(2)The overburden damage degree quantitatively describes the overburden failure in a threedimensional space, but the height and morphology of the WCFZ merely consider the profile of the overburden. The numerical simulation results show that the overburden damage degree is more accurate than the height of WCFZ in describing the overburden failure(3)The variation range of the overburden damage degree influenced by the advancing speed and panel width is 41% to 49.37% and 19.98% to 88.02%, respectively, which means the overburden damage degree is more sensitive to the variation in panel width(4)The reasonable mining parameters of the panel 12401 are 8.8 m in mining height, 300 m in panel width, and 13.47 to 20.58 m/d in advancing speed, respectively. The field measurement results of the PWI and ground cracks have verified the validity using the overburden damage degree to determine highintensity mining parameters
Abbreviations
:  Damage variable 
:  Volume of the unit body 
:  Volume of the matrix 
:  Volume of the damaged body 
:  Rock mass stress 
:  Matrix stress 
:  Second invariants of the deviatoric stress tensor of the rock mass 
:  Second invariants of the deviatoric stress tensor of the matrix 
:  Deviatoric stress tensor of the rock mass 
:  Hydrostatic pressure 
:  Hydrostatic pressure of the matrix 
:  Kronecker symbol 
:  Elastic constant tensor of the matrix 
:  Strain tensor of the matrix 
:  Strain tensor of the damaged body 
:  Shear modulus of the rock mass 
:  Shear modulus of the matrix 
:  Equivalent stress 
:  Equivalent strain 
:  Drillhole depth at the top of the WCFZ 
:  Compression value of rock strata 
:  Mining height 
:  Overburden damage degree 
:  Volume of a plastic zone 
:  Observed space volume 
:  Mean value of the endcirculation resistance of supports 
:  Number of monitoring cycles 
:  Endcirculation resistance of the support 
:  Standard deviation of the endcirculation resistance of the supports 
:  Threshold value of the roof weighting. 
Data Availability
The data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declared that they have no conflicts of interest to this work.
Acknowledgments
The financial support for this work was provided by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 51874281, 51704274, and 51404272), the State Key Laboratory Cultivation Base for Gas Geology and Gas Control (Henan Polytechnic University) (WS2019A05), the Yue Qi Distinguished Scholar Project, China University of Mining & Technology, Beijing (2017JCB02), and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (2020YQNY04).
References
 National Bureau of Statistics of China, 2018 national economic and social development statistical bulletin [EB/OL], 2018, http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/zxfb/201902/t20190228_1651265.html.
 C. L. Wang, C. S. Zhang, X. D. Zhao, L. Liao, and S. L. Zhang, “Dynamic structural evolution of overlying strata during shallow coal seam longwall mining,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 103, pp. 20–32, 2018. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 W. B. Guo, G. B. Zhao, G. Lou, and S. Wang, “A new method of predicting the height of the fractured waterconducting zone due to highintensity longwall coal mining in China,” Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 2789–2802, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 L. Sun, C. H. Li, Y. P. Cai, and X. Wang, “Interval optimization model considering terrestrial ecological impacts for water rights transfer from agriculture to industry in Ningxia, China,” Scientific Reports, vol. 7, no. 1, p. 3465, 2017. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 X. Y. Liu, W. Zhou, and Z. K. Bai, “Vegetation coverage change and stability in large openpit coal mine dumps in China during 1990–2015,” Ecological Engineering, vol. 95, pp. 447–451, 2016. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 N. Li, C. Z. Yan, and J. L. Xie, “Remote sensing monitoring recent rapid increase of coal mining activity of an important energy base in northern China, a case study of Mu Us Sandy Land,” Resources, Conservation and Recycling, vol. 94, pp. 129–135, 2015. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Y. L. Bi, L. L. Xie, J. Wang, Y. X. Zhang, and K. Wang, “Impact of host plants, slope position and subsidence on arbuscular mycorrhizal fungal communities in the coal mining area of northcentral China,” Journal of Arid Environments, vol. 163, pp. 68–76, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 D. P. Adhikary and H. Guo, “Measurement of longwall mining induced strata permeability,” Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, vol. 32, no. 3, pp. 617–626, 2014. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Q. S. Bai and S. H. Tu, “A General Review on Longwall MiningInduced Fractures in NearFace Regions,” Geofluids, vol. 2019, 22 pages, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 X. X. Miao, X. M. Cui, J. A. Wang, and J. L. Xu, “The height of fractured waterconducting zone in undermined rock strata,” Engineering Geology, vol. 120, no. 14, pp. 32–39, 2011. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 V. Palchik, “Formation of fractured zones in overburden due to longwall mining,” Environmental Geology, vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 28–38, 2003. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 A. Majdi, F. P. Hassani, and M. Y. Nasiri, “Prediction of the height of destressed zone above the mined panel roof in longwall coal mining,” International Journal of Coal Geology, vol. 98, no. 1, pp. 62–72, 2012. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Z. Y. Song, H. Konietzky, and M. Herbst, “Drawing mechanism of fractured top coal in longwall top coal caving,” International journal of rock mechanics and mining sciences, vol. 130, article 104329, p. 130, 2020. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 J. X. Tang, Z. Y. Dai, Y. L. Wang, and L. Zhang, “Fracture Failure of Consequent Bedding Rock Slopes After Undergroundmining in Area,” Rock mechanics and rock engineering, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 2853–2870, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 C. Xu, Q. Fu, X. Y. Cui, K. Wang, Y. X. Zhao, and Y. B. Cai, “ApparentDepth Effects of the Dynamic Failure of Thick Hard Rock Strata on the Underlying Coal Mass During Underground Mining,” Rock mechanics and rock engineering, vol. 52, no. 5, pp. 1565–1576, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 X. L. Yang, G. C. Wen, L. C. Dai, H. T. Sun, and X. L. Li, “Ground Subsidence and Surface Cracks Evolution from ShallowBuried CloseDistance Multiseam Mining: A Case Study in Bulianta Coal Mine,” Rock mechanics and rock engineering, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 2835–2852, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 L. Q. Ma, Z. Y. Jin, J. M. Liang, H. Sun, D. S. Zhang, and P. Li, “Simulation of water resource loss in shortdistance coal seams disturbed by repeated mining,” Environmental earth sciences, vol. 74, no. 7, pp. 5653–5662, 2015. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 G. Wang, M. M. Wu, R. Wang, H. Xu, and X. Song, “Height of the mininginduced fractured zone above a coal face,” Engineering Geology, vol. 216, pp. 140–152, 2017. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 J. C. Zhang, “Investigations of water inrushes from aquifers under coal seams,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 350–360, 2005. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 C. Zhang, S. Tu, L. Zhang, Q. Bai, Y. Yuan, and F. Wang, “A methodology for determining the evolution law of gob permeability and its distributions in longwall coal mines,” Journal of Geophysics and Engineering, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 181–193, 2016. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 B. N. Hu, H. X. Zhang, and B. H. Shen, Regulations of Coal Mining and Protective Coal Pillar Design under Buildings, Water Bodies, Railways, Coal Mines and Roadways, Coal Industry Press, Beijing, Beijing, 2017.
 Y. Liu, Q. M. Liu, W. P. Li, T. Li, and J. H. He, “Height of waterconducting fractured zone in coal mining in the soil–rock composite structure overburdens,” Environmental Earth Sciences, vol. 78, no. 7, p. 242, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 X. J. Hu, W. P. Li, D. T. Cao, and M. C. Liu, “Index of multiple factors and expected height of fully mechanized water flowing fractured zone,” Journal of China Coal Society, vol. 37, no. 4, pp. 613–620, 2012. View at: Google Scholar
 E. Jiránková, “Utilisation of surface subsidence measurements in assessing failures of rigid strata overlying extracted coal seams,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 53, pp. 111–119, 2012. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 J. F. Ju and J. L. Xu, “Structural characteristics of key strata and strata behaviour of a fully mechanized longwall face with 7.0m height chocks,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 58, pp. 46–54, 2013. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Q. D. Qu, J. L. Xu, R. L. Wu, W. Qin, and G. Z. Hu, “Threezone characterisation of coupled strata and gas behaviour in multiseam mining,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 78, pp. 91–98, 2015. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 J. L. Xu, W. B. Zhu, and X. Z. Wang, “(2012). New method to predict the height of fractured waterconducting zone by location of key strata,” Journal of China Coal Society, vol. 37, no. 5, pp. 762–769, 2012. View at: Google Scholar
 Z. Y. Song, W. J. Wei, and J. W. Zhang, “Numerical investigation of effect of particle shape on isolated extracted zone (IEZ) in block caving,” Arabian Journal of Geosciences, vol. 11, no. 12, p. 310, 2018. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Z. B. Yu, S. Y. Zhu, Y. Z. Guan, and D. X. Hu, “Feasibility of Modifying Coal Pillars to Prevent Sand Flow Under a Thick Loose Layer of Sediment and Thin Bedrock,” Mine water and the environment, vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 817–826, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 D. Y. Zhang, W. H. Sui, and J. W. Liu, “Overburden Failure Associated with Mining Coal Seams in Close Proximity in Ascending and Descending Sequences Under a Large Water Body,” Mine water and the environment, vol. 37, no. 2, pp. 322–335, 2018. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 M. G. Qian, P. W. Shi, and J. L. Xu, Ground pressure and strata control, China University of Mining and technology Press, Xuzhou, 2010.
 H. F. Lin, R. F. Ma, S. G. Li, L. H. Cheng, H. Y. Pan, and L. Li, “Coupling model of evolution of mining fissure elliptic paraboloid zone and methane delivery,” Advanced Materials Research, vol. 734737, pp. 546–550, 2013. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 F. Wang, J. L. Xu, and J. L. Xie, “Effects of arch structure in unconsolidated layers on fracture and failure of overlying strata,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 114, pp. 141–152, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 C. Zhang, S. Tu, and Y. Zhao, “Compaction characteristics of the caving zone in a longwall goaf: a review,” Environmental Earth Sciences, vol. 78, no. 1, pp. 27–46, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 L. Zhou, X. P. Su, Y. Y. Lu, Z. L. Ge, Z. Y. Zhang, and Z. H. Shen, “A New ThreeDimensional Numerical Model Based on the Equivalent Continuum Method to Simulate Hydraulic Fracture Propagation in an Underground Coal Mine,” Rock mechanics and rock engineering, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 2871–2887, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 M. Kachanov, “Effective properties of Solids: review of Concepts,” Applied Mechanics Reviews, vol. 45, no. 8, pp. 304–335, 1992. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 S. Murakami, “Mechanical representation of damage and damage variables,” in Continuum Damage Mechanics: A Continuum Mechanics Approach to the Analysis of Damage and Fracture, pp. 15–55, Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht, 2012. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Z. Wang, L. Zhao, J. Kang, and L. Jia, “Technological study on height observation of water flowing fractured zone caused by repeated mining in multiple coal seam,” Coal engineering, vol. 50, no. 12, pp. 82–85, 2018. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Q. S. Bai, S. H. Tu, F. T. Wang, and C. Zhang, “Field and numerical investigations of gateroad system failure induced by hard roofs in a longwall top coal caving face,” International Journal of Coal Geology, vol. 173, pp. 176–199, 2017. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 G. B. Zhang, W. Q. Zhang, C. H. Wang, G. L. Zhu, and B. Li, “Mining seams Bedrock–Deformation andfailure of strata and Alluvium,” Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, vol. 34, no. 5, pp. 1553–1563, 2016. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 T. Zhang, Y. X. Zhao, Q. Gan, X. D. Nie, G. P. Zhu, and Y. Hu, “Investigations into MiningInduced Stress–Fracture–Seepage Field Coupling in a Complex Hydrogeology Environment: A Case Study in the Bulianta Colliery,” Mine water and the environment, vol. 38, no. 3, pp. 632–642, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 C. Zhang and L. Zhang, “Permeability Characteristics of Broken Coal and Rock Under Cyclic Loading and Unloading,” Natural Resources Research, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 1055–1069, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 Y. C. Luan, J. T. Li, X. H. Ban, C. Y. Sang, C. Q. Zhang, and D. P. Ma, “Observational research on the height of water flowing fractured zone in repeated mining of shortdistance coal seams,” Journal of Mining and Safety Engineering, vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 139–142, 2010. View at: Google Scholar
 Y. Y. Lu, T. Gong, B. W. Xia, B. Yu, and F. Huang, “Target Stratum Determination of Surface Hydraulic Fracturing for FarField Hard Roof Control in Underground ExtraThick Coal Extraction: A Case Study,” Rock mechanics and rock engineering, vol. 52, no. 8, pp. 2725–2740, 2019. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
 M. S. Yi, “Selection of echanzied working face length by great height mining under shallow coal seam in Shendong coal district,” Journal of China Coal Society, vol. 2007, no. 12, pp. 1253–1257, 2007. View at: Google Scholar
 J. H. Yang, S. L. Kong, and D. Z. Kong, “Effect of working face length and advancing speed on strata behaviors in highintensity mining,” Rock and soil mechanics, vol. S2, pp. 333–399+350, 2015. View at: Google Scholar
 J. A. Wang and H. D. Park, “Coal mining above a confined aquifer,” International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, vol. 40, no. 4, pp. 537–551, 2003. View at: Publisher Site  Google Scholar
Copyright
Copyright © 2020 Xiang He et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.