Abstract

This study investigates treating polyethylene terephthalate (PET) waste water bottles with different mass of ethylene glycol (EG) using reactive extrusion technique at a temperature of 260°C. The study puts emphases on evaluating the thermal, mechanical, and chemical characteristics of the treated polyethylene terephthalate. The properties of the treated PET from the extruder were analyzed using FT-IR, TGA, DSC, and nanoindentation. The melt flow indexes (MFI) of both treated and untreated PET were also measured and compared. Thermal properties such as melting temperature () for treating PET showed an inversely proportional behavior with the EG concentrations. The FT-IR analysis was used to investigate the formation of new linkages like hydrogen bonds between PET and EG due to the hydroxyl and carbonyl groups. Nanoindentation results revealed that both the mechanical characteristics, elastic modulus and hardness, decrease with increasing EG concentration. On the other hand, the melt flow index of treated PET exhibited an increase with increasing EG concentration in the PET matrix.

1. Introduction

Synthetic polymers have undergone remarkable growth in terms of diversity, quality, and production volume in recent years [1]. The main difference between the two classes of polymers, namely, natural and synthetic polymers, is that the former are biologically or environmentally degradable, which makes them less durable and have high production cost, whereas the latter last considerably longer in all applications, being almost nonbiodegradable under normal circumstances. The nonbiodegradability of synthetic polymers has triggered a major unease for environmentalists in terms of polymer waste management [2]. In recent years, recycling of synthetic polymers has caught the attention of many research groups, for two major motives: to minimize the ever growing volume of polymer waste and to create value-added items from low cost resources by transforming synthetic polymeric waste into beneficial and useful items having similar properties to virgin materials [36].

PET is considered as a multipurpose polymer used for the manufacture of products which differ extensively in their properties and thus differ in their use. Owing to its extensive use over the years, PET is considered as one of the most important polymers in the present world [7, 8]. PET is semicrystalline, transparent, thermoplastic polyester. It has good tensile strength, chemical resistance, and suitable thermal stability. Huge quantities of PET are used in the production of food packaging materials and water bottles [9, 10]. With the enormous development and usage of PET, a large fraction of PET gets added to the waste system on a yearly basis. The demand for nonbiodegradable PET in various applications has been increasing at an alarming rate [11, 12]. Although PET is not hazardous, many factors contribute to the accumulation of PET in the environment and this necessitates serious attention to recycling as the accumulation has become a global environmental issue [2, 13, 14]. The recycling of PET through chemical methods [10, 1518], especially depolymerization or lysis of PET using solvents and ionic liquids, has gained considerable interest as it can help in the synthesis of different kinds of end products. Depolymerization of PET can be achieved by hydrolysis using water [19] or lysis using alcohol [20] (methanolysis using methanol) [21, 22] or amines [23] or acids [24]. The most established or commercialized processes for the depolymerization of PET are glycolysis, hydrolysis, and methanolysis [5]. The depolymerization of PET can also be classified based on the type of catalyst or ionic liquids or supercritical conditions used in the process [25].

Glycolysis is the process where glycols like ethylene glycol (EG) are used in the lysis of PET [26] and glycolysis also has applications in the formulation of resins comprising unsaturated polyesters. Ethylene glycol is used in the reduction of metal salts to metals [27, 28] and is a precursor to polyesters, in addition to its various other applications [27]. The rate of PET glycolysis is found to be of second order in terms of EG concentration [29]. From the glycolysis reaction, the monomer bis(2-hydroxyethyl) terephthalate (BHET) is the main product and the rate of reaction is dependent on various factors which include temperature, pressure, ethylene glycol concentration, and the catalyst involved. For a recycling process to be desirable, it should be effective in terms of energy consumption and expenses related to processing. Glycolysis is usually carried out in boiling ethylene glycol [30] in the presence of catalysts like zinc acetate [31] or lead acetate [16]. The use of such catalysts in large scale may cause pollution due to their toxic nature [5]. The properties of PET can be modulated by treating it with suitable reagents or dry processes for use in various applications [32, 33]. The wettability or hydrophilic property of PET was enhanced using two dry processes, namely, atmospheric pressure plasma and ultraviolet excimer light [32]. Reactive extrusion was used to modify the rheological and mechanical properties of PET by treating with acrylic epoxy resin as the chain extender [33]. Composites prepared from melt blending of PET and nanoclay were found to have enhanced Young’s modulus compared to PET and also prevented the migration of terephthalic acid into yoghurt drinks which were maintained in PET-nanoclay composites [34]. Antimicrobial PET fabric was synthesized from PET-MgO composites that were produced by the melting, mixing, and extrusion of PET and magnesium oxide nanoparticles [35]. Composites of PET with microencapsulated carbon microspheres (MCMSs) were prepared by melt blending and these composites were found to have good flame retarding and mechanical properties [36, 37]. Hence, the properties of PET can be enhanced by melting blending or extrusion with certain characteristic materials.

Coprocessing is another method of using plastic wastes as raw material or as a source of energy or to replace both natural mineral resources and fossil fuels such as petroleum, coal, and gas in energy intensive industries such as cement, steel, and power generation [3840].

In this work, PET was treated with 0, 0.4, 0.6, 1, 1.4, and 2 grams of EG using a single screw extruder at the temperature of 260°C. The effect of different mass of EG on PET degradation was investigated. The chemical, thermal, and mechanical properties of the treated PET were investigated.

2. Experimental

2.1. Materials and Methods

The collected PET waste bottles were cleaned, dried, and shredded into small pieces. Ethylene glycol (99.5% (G.C) minimum assay, Panreac, Spain) was used for the treatment of PET. A single screw extruder (HAAKE POLYLAB QC, Thermo Scientific, Germany) was used for the reactive processing of PET with different mass of EG. Electrical Grinder (Geepas Industrial Co. Ltd., China) was used to mill the extruded PET and convert it into powder for further analysis and melt flow index measurements.

2.2. Treated PET Sample Preparation

The preparation procedure was divided into two parts. In the first part, 20 g sample of the shredded PET waste was weighed. Then it was placed in the hopper of the extruder, after the extruder barrel was heated to the temperature of 260°C. The PET was maintained in the barrel at 260°C with very low screw speed for 15 minutes to achieve a complete melting of the PET. The screw speed of the extruder was adjusted to 10 rpm in order to obtain a homogenous spread of melted PET in the extruder barrel. Then the speed of the screw was increased to 50 rpm to extrude the entire PET from the extruder. In the second part of the experiment, a mixture of PET and EG was prepared. A 20 g sample of PET was placed in a flask, and then 0.4 g of EG was added. The mixture was placed inside the extruder at 260°C for 15 min at 10 rpm in order to obtain a homogenous mixture. The speed of the screw was increased to 50 rpm to extrude the treated PET from the extruder. The same procedure was repeated to analyze the effect of 0.6 g, 1 g, 1.4 g, and 2 g of EG on the PET. Each treated PET sample was kept at room temperature in sealed plastic bags.

2.3. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR)

Fourier transform infrared spectrometer (MAGNA-IR 560 Spectrometer, Thermo Nicolet Corporation) was used to identify the functional groups of the extruded PET treated with different mass of EG. The extruded PET was grinded to a fine powder and a few milligrams of the sample was grinded with dry KBr to a very fine powder. This powder was then compressed into a thin disc. First, the FT-IR instrument was calibrated by scanning the background. Then, the KBr disc was placed in the sample holder which was inserted into the FT-IR spectrometer for analysis. The infrared transmission spectral results of the samples were attained at room temperature in the wavenumber range 4000–400 cm−1 using 32 scans with a resolution of 2 cm−1.

2.4. Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA)

The TGA analysis of the treated PET was carried out utilizing a Thermogravimetric Analyzer (Q50, TA Instruments). Samples of ~15 mg weight were taken in the sample pan. Then loaded sample pan was placed in the balance suspended inside the furnace tube, which was then heated from room temperature to 600°C at the rate of 10°Cmin−1 in atmosphere. The obtained TGA measurements were evaluated with the software, TA Universal Analysis 2000 (TA Instruments).

2.5. Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC)

The DSC analysis of the treated PET was performed with a Differential Scanning Calorimeter (Q200, TA Instruments). The treated PET sample (~5 mg) was placed in an aluminum sample pan. Then the sample was sealed with aluminum lid using a pressing machine. The sealed pan was placed in the DSC device, where the reference cell was an empty sealed aluminum pan. All samples were subjected to heating from ambient conditions to 400°C at a rate of 10°Cmin−1 in nitrogen atmosphere. The DSC graphs obtained were evaluated with the software, TA Universal Analysis 2000 (TA Instruments). The melting temperature () was determined from the DSC thermogram as the pinnacle temperature value of the endothermic outcome.

2.6. Nanoindentation

The mechanical properties of the treated PET were obtained using nanoindentation, (NanoTest, Micro Materials, UK), using a Berkovich diamond indenter. The indentations were made by applying a maximum load of 10 mN at a constant rate of displacement of 0.05 mNs−1. On attaining the maximum load, the indenter was removed from the surface of the sample at the same rate of 0.05 mNs−1 till the indenter was totally withdrawn from the sample. The purpose of maintaining a uniform displacement rate for indentation of the samples is to prevent hardening effects due to strain on the measurements. A total of five indents were made on each sample with a distance of 50 μm between the indentations to prevent interactions.

The load-depth data from the indentations was used to determine the hardness () and reduced moduli () of the samples.

The deformation associated with both elastic and plastic behavior occurs during the indentation of the specimen, but as a result of unloading of the indenter only the elastic portion is recovered.

The hardness () value as a result of indentation can be defined as in The load value determined at the maximum level or depth of penetration () during an indentation cycle is represented by , whereas “” represents the projected contact area and denotes the depth of contact during the indentation. The value of can be calculated by means of is derived from the early or initial region of the unloading curve and denotes the slope () when . The value 0.75 in (2) is a constant and is mainly dependent on the geometry of the indenter.

The initial unloading contact stiffness () can be used to determine the elastic modulus of the sample. The equation for the relationship between contact stiffness, reduced modulus, and contact area is represented by The constant is dependent on the indenter geometry. For a Berkovich indenter, has a value of 1.034. The reduced elastic modulus is represented by . The reduced modulus takes into consideration the elastic deformation of not only the specimen but also the indenter. The reduced modulus, , is evaluated by determining the contact stiffness () and contact area () from the load-displacement graph obtained by the indentation process. The elastic modulus () of the sample is calculated as shown in Poisson’s ratios of the specimen and indenter are represented by and , respectively. Poisson’s ratio for the indenter has the value of 0.07. represents the modulus of the Berkovich diamond indenter which has a value of 1141 GPa. Poisson’s ratio for the specimen was estimated to be 0.35 which is the value for semicrystalline polymeric materials. This value was used for all calculations.

2.7. Melt Flow Index (MFI)

The melt flow index for the treated PET was performed using XRL-400A/B/C series, Material Flow Velocity Machine (Chengde Jingmi Testing Machine Co., Ltd., China). The melt flow index apparatus consists of two testing modes: displacement testing mode and time testing mode. The displacement testing mode measures the flow index as the distance covered by a certain tested sample, expressed as grams/centimeter. Alternatively, the time testing mode measures the time needed to cut a certain amount from the tested sample, expressed as gram/10 minutes. The latter mode was selected for measuring the melt flow index. The treated and untreated PET samples were grinded and converted into powder using a grinder. Then the samples were weighed and place into the MFI instrument for testing. The parameters (cutting time, temperature, and load) were adjusted by performing several tests on the samples in order to optimize the testing parameters. The samples were heated to 256°C and kept at this temperature for 10 minutes. Then the load of 2160 grams was applied to samples to force the melted samples out of the nozzle to measure the MFI in terms of g/10 min. To determine the temperature at which the treated and untreated PET samples start flowing through the nozzle of the MFI instrument, the samples were heated to 220°C and maintained at this temperature for 10 minutes with the nozzle closed. After 10 minutes, the load was applied, the nozzle was opened with the temperature increasing at a constant rate, and the temperature at which the sample started flowing out of the nozzle was noted for each sample.

3. Results and Discussion

FT-IR defines the existence of specific chemical or functional groups in the polymeric material. The combined FT-IR spectra for EG, PET, and treated PET with different mass (grams) of EG are shown in Figure 1.

The treated PET with different EG mass demonstrated the presence of new hydroxyl groups (O–H) that appeared at wavenumber between 3500 cm−1 and 3400 cm−1 as shown in the FT-IR spectra which may contribute to the formation of inter- and intramolecular hydrogen bonds in the EG treated PET polymer. The hydroxyl groups in the treated PET polymer are contributed by EG during the interaction between the two components in the extruder. On the other hand, the nontreated PET polymer does show the presence of hydroxyl groups but with reduced intensity than the treated PET. Moreover, at wavenumber 2950 cm−1, an alkyl group (C–H stretch) appeared in the PET polymer, whereas this group was reflected with less intensity in the FT-IR spectra for the treated PET with EG, and its intensity decreases gradually with increasing EG concentration and was found to be the least for the PET treated with 2 g of EG. Furthermore, a carbonyl group (C=O stretch) appeared in the treated PET with EG at a wavenumber of 1715 cm−1, while this group is also reflected in the FT-IR spectra for the untreated PET polymer but with a lesser intensity as shown in Figure 1. Besides, an ether group (C–O–C stretch (diaryl)) is obvious for the treated PET with different EG concentrations at an approximate wavenumber of 1250 cm−1, whereas it is demonstrated at a very low intensity for the untreated PET polymer. Another band that is clearly shown in the FT-IR spectra for the treated PET with EG is reflected at a wavenumber of about 1100 cm−1, while it is not shown for the untreated PET polymer. This wavenumber indicates the availability of C–C stretch in the treated PET with different EG concentrations but not in PET polymer. In addition, the FT-IR clearly shows a band at the wavenumber of about 720 cm−1 for the treated PET with various EG concentrations, whereas it is demonstrated at a lesser intensity for the PET polymer. This peak indicates the existence of bending in treated PET with EG to a higher extent than in the untreated PET polymer. The variation in the intensity of the peaks or the presence of new peaks for the FT-IR spectra of the EG treated PET when compared to untreated PET could be due to the presence of EG in the polymeric matrix or due to the transesterification or condensation reactions of PET with EG or the formation of monomers like BHET.

Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was carried out to assess the thermal stability, the stages of degradation, and the moisture percentage in the sample. The TGA for the untreated PET and treated PET with 0.4, 0.6, 1, 1.4, and 2 grams of EG was carried out. The combined results of the TGA analysis for all the samples are shown in Figure 2(a). TGA readings, including initial decomposition temperature (), percent weight loss (), and percentage of moisture are summarized in Table 1.

The thermal degradation of polymers is a complex process and consists of initiation, propagation, and termination stages [40]. Initial decomposition temperature of the PET treated with EG as well as neat PET polymer was found to be at about 374°C. The weight loss at 100°C which corresponds to the moisture content was found to be very low for all the PET samples. From the TGA test, the moisture content in the PET polymer was shown to be 0.1%. On the other hand, the moisture content in the treated PET with 0.4 g of EG was 0%. This value increased gradually with the increase in the EG concentration as shown in Table 1. The weight loss percent at the decomposition temperature was investigated for all the samples. The weight loss for the EG treated PET increased with increase in the EG mass; that is, the PET treated with 0.4 g of EG showed 2.59% weight loss, whereas this value rose to 5.24% for PET with 2 g of EG. On the contrary, the value of the weight loss percent for the neat PET polymer was found to be 0.73, which is less compared to the PET samples treated with EG. From Figure 2(b), in the derivative thermogravimetric (DTG) analysis, the peak temperature values were found to be 437, 434, 436, 444, 448, and 450°C for the PET treated with 0, 0.4, 0.6, 1, 1.4, and 2 grams of EG, respectively.

The organic macromolecules or the low-molecular weight organic molecules that constitute the polymer matrix can withstand a particular temperature range and this forms the basis for the thermal degradation of polymers. The thermal stability of the polymers relies on the intrinsic features of the specimen and also the particular interface or interactions among the different macromolecular or molecular components of the polymeric matrix [41]. When certain low-molecular weight materials called plasticizers are added to the polymer matrix, it results in the modification of the 3-dimensional organization of the polymeric structure. Plasticizers also reduce the intermolecular forces of attraction, thereby increasing the mobility and volume of the polymeric matrix. This phenomenon is achieved by the formation of linkages in the form of hydrogen (H) bonds between the hydroxyl groups and the polar functional groups present in the polymer and plasticizer [42].

From the TGA curves for the untreated PET and PET treated with different EG mass, it is observed that all the specimens are relatively stable in the temperature range of 25–350°C. In addition, the percentage of moisture content in all the samples measured at about 100°C is almost negligible. Besides, it is clear from the graph that the TGA curves for all the samples indicate one-step degradation, where the degradation temperature () is within the range of 370–410°C. The weight loss for all the samples at 374°C is shown in Table 1. The onset thermal degradation point for all treated PET starts at 374°C. Beyond the temperature of 374°C, the PET/EG polymer becomes significantly degraded. Moreover, as the mass of EG increases in the PET sample, the weight loss increases at the temperature of 374°C, where the weight loss percentage increased from 2.59 for PET treated with 0.4 g of EG to 5.42 for PET treated with 2 g of EG. This could be due to the volatile nature of the plasticizer at higher temperature.

Differential scanning calorimetry analysis (DSC) was carried out for all the samples to determine the melting points () of untreated PET and the treated PET with 0.4 g, 0.6 g, 1 g, 1.4 g, and 2 g of EG. From the TGA curves, the degradation of the PET samples begins at 374°C, beyond which there is enhanced weight loss and degradation and hence the DSC thermograms were concluded at 400°C. The combined DSC thermograms of the PET/EG for various EG masses are shown in Figure 3. In addition, a summary of the DSC analysis results, mainly the melting point (), is shown in Table 2.

The main physical property investigated by using DSC test was the melting point of all the samples. As shown in Table 2, the melting point of PET polymer was found to be 243.49°C. It is clear that the melting point of the treated PET with EG decreased with increase in the EG mass.

From the DSC curve, it can be seen that the relaxation in the thermal region of 230–260°C is triggered by the softening of the PET crystalline domains due to melting. With increase in the content of EG in the PET matrix, a shifting trend in the DSC curve was observed as shown in Figure 3(a). This shift noticeably shows a decrease in the melting point of the treated PET with increase in EG mass, where the melting point of the treated PET decreased from 250.08°C to 242.33°C with the increase in EG mass from 0.4 g to 2 g, as shown in Table 2. The DSC thermograms for the entire temperature range used in the experiment are shown in Figure 3(b). This decrease in the melting temperature might signify that the systematic compact organization of the PET molecules was reduced with the introduction of EG into the polymeric matrix. Also, it can be inferred that EG enhances the mobility of PET segments and reduces PET crystalline regions.

The mechanical properties of PET as well as the PET treated with different EG mass were investigated by nanoindentation. The maximum load applied for each nanoindentation on a sample was 10.03 mN. A total of five indentations were made on each sample. Figures 4(a)4(f) show the loading-depth curves of PET treated with 0 g, 0.4 g, 0.6 g, 1 g, 1.4 g, and 2 g of EG, respectively. The main mechanical properties examined using the nanoindentation test were the maximum depth covered by the indenter through the sample, the hardness, and the reduced modulus of the tested samples. These results are listed in Table 3 for all samples.

It is clear from the table that the maximum depth reached by the indenter in the PET polymer without EG was found to be 1043.03 nm. On the other hand, the PET treated with EG exhibited an increase in the maximum depth attained by the indenter with increase in the EG concentration used for treatment. The maximum depth attained was found to be 1169.08 nm for PET treated with 0.4 g of ethylene glycol and 1546.05 nm for PET treated with 2 g of EG. Moreover, the hardness and reduced modulus of the PET treated with ethylene glycol showed lower values when compared to the untreated PET polymer. Furthermore, the hardness of the treated polymer showed a decreasing trend with increase in the mass of EG when compared to untreated PET polymer. The nanoindentation test showed that the hardness of PET with 0.4 g EG was 0.41722 GPa, while this value decreased to 0.23520 GPa for PET treated with 2 g of EG. Similar to the hardness trend, the reduced modulus also showed a decreasing trend with increase in the concentration of EG. The maximum value for the reduced modulus () was recorded to be 8.13187 GPa for the PET without EG treatment. On the contrary, the lowest value was found to be 5.23870 GPa for the PET treated with 2 g of EG. Similarly, the elastic modulus for PET without EG treatment was found to be 7.185 GPa and the lowest elastic modulus was obtained for the PET treated with 2 g of EG, which was found to be 4.618 GPa.

Plasticizers are also known to influence the mechanical properties of polymers. With increase in the plasticizer content in the polymeric matrix, the tensile strength of the polymer decreases whereas the elongation period to break is increased [39]. As the EG mass in the PET was increased, the hardness as well as the reduced modulus decreased. On the other hand, the maximum depth attained by the indenter in the sample increased with the increase in EG concentration in PET. The intramolecular forces in PET were decreased by the presence of EG. Subsequently, the presence of plasticizer will also result in the reduction in the melting point of the treated PET as indicated by DSC. Low-molecular weight small molecules of EG may get implanted between the PET chains or matrix, thereby increasing the free volume and spacing, allowing the polymeric chains to slide past each other at lower temperatures.

The melt flow index of PET and PET treated with EG was measured. The results are summarized in Table 4. From the results, it can be seen that the flow index for PET increases with increase in the mass of EG added during treatment. The flow index was 0.891 g/10 min for untreated PET, whereas the flow index was 13.627 and 12.17 g/10 min for PET treated with 1.4 and 2 grams of EG, respectively.

To determine the temperature at which the samples start flowing out of nozzle of the MFI instrument, the samples were heated to 220°C with nozzles closed followed by opening the nozzle, applying the load, and increasing the temperature at a constant rate. With increase in the mass of EG used for treating PET, the temperature at which the samples start flowing through the nozzle was decreased. The results of the flow start temperature for the treated and untreated PET samples with EG are given in Table 5.

The flow index of the treated PET has clearly shown the effect of EG concentration in the PET polymer. The melt flow index increases with increase in the EG mass but the flow start temperature decreases with increase in EG concentration. Consequently, the presence of EG resulted in less viscosity of the PET samples at lower temperatures and hence ethylene glycol plays the role of a plasticizer in the PET samples.

4. Conclusion

In this work, PET was placed inside an extruder at 260°C with different EG mass, allowed to react, followed by extruding the samples. The chemical, thermal, and mechanical properties as well as the flow index of the treated PET were tested using FT-IR, TGA, DSC, nanoindentation, and melt flow index. The FT-IR spectra showed that addition of EG resulted in the occurrence of new hydroxyl groups in the treated PET. The intensities of specific peaks were intensified indicating that EG had interacted with PET polymeric matrix. Furthermore, the percent weight loss at the onset of thermal degradation increased with increase in EG mass used for PET treatment as indicated by the thermogravimetric analysis. Moreover, from the DSC thermograms, it can be observed that the melting point of the treated PET decreased with increase in the mass of EG. Also, the mechanical properties were affected by the presence of EG in the PET matrix. The results of the melt flow index analysis indicated that, with increase in the concentration of EG in the PET polymer, the flow index increased and consequently caused the sample to become less viscous. It can be inferred that EG interacts with PET and plays the role of a plasticizer filling the gaps between the polymer chains. This also explains the decrease in hardness and reduced modulus with increase in EG concentration in the PET polymeric matrix. The reactive extrusion of polymers can be utilized to modulate their mechanical and thermal properties. Also, further research can be conducted by the utilization of suitable catalysts or ionic liquids to modify the properties of extruded PET.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.