International Journal of Forestry Research

Research Article

Evaluating Sensitivity of the Ranking of Forest Fuel Treatments to Manager’s Risk Attitudes and the Importance of Treatment Objectives, Montana, USA

Table 3

Results of Mann-Whitney U tests of equality of median certainty equivalents for three pairs of fuel treatment strategies for two risk attitudes and three managers.
WeightAlmost Risk Neutral (ARAC  ϵ  -.005, .005])Highly risk averse (ARAC  ϵ  .02, .04])
scenarioCWPP vs. NPCWPP & WUI vs. NPCWPP vs. CWPP & WUICWPP vs. NPCWPP & WUI vs. NPCWPP vs. CWPP & WUI
 U.S. Forest Service (FS)
BFSRejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS1RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS2RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS3RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS4RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS5RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS6RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS7RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS8RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS9RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS10RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
FS11RejecRejecRejecRejecDo not rejecDo not rejec
FS12RejecRejecRejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejec
FS13RejecRejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejec
FS14RejecRejecDo not rejecRejecRejecRejec
FS15RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
 Department of Natural Resources and Conservation (DR)
BDRRejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejecRejec
DR1RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
DR2RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
DR3RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
DR4RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
DR5RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
DR6RejecRejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejec
DR7RejecRejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejec
DR8RejecRejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejec
DR9RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
DR10RejecRejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
 Plum Creek Timber Company (PC)
BPCDo not rejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejecRejec
PC1Do not rejecDo not rejecRejecDo not rejecRejecRejec
PC2Do not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecRejecRejec
PC3Do not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecRejecDo not rejec
PC4RejecDo not rejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejec
PC5Do not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecRejecDo not rejec
PC6RejecDo not rejecRejecRejecRejecRejec
PC7Do not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecRejecRejec
PC8Do not rejecRejecRejecDo not rejecRejecRejec
PC9Do not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecRejec
PC10Do not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejecDo not rejec