Review Article

Carbohydrate Elimination or Adaptation Diet for Symptoms of Intestinal Discomfort in IBD: Rationales for “Gibsons’ Conundrum”

Box 1

IBD pathogenesis.
Classically, IBD (especially in CD) is associated with a hyperactive innate immune response
producing unrestrained levels of proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines (e.g., IL-12, IFN-
γ, and TNF-α), resulting in a marked expansion of lamina propria. This propagates further
inflammation by recruiting T-helper 1 (CD4+ Th1) cells. Alternatively, the opposite scenario can
occur in which resident tissue macrophages fail in their attempt to initiate an innate immune
response against foreign antigens and are defective in the secretion of proinflammatory
cytokines [42, 43]. Reduced concentrations of these mediators mean neutrophil recruitment
cannot be adequately enforced at the lamina propria, resulting in impaired clearance of antigenic
contents [44]. The following overcompensatory immune responses lead to either a polarization
toward an atypical humoral phenotype driven by T-helper 2 (CD4+ Th2) cells along with
mediators such as IL-4 and IL-13 (especially in UC [45]) or recruitment of CD4+ Th1 cells
[36]. The amplification of inflammatory response as an attempt to remove foreign material only
incites further epithelial injury which coincides with a decreased production of defensins [46, 47].
It is quite possible that both paradigms may be true given the genetic heterogeneity among
IBD populations. A newly discovered subset of inflammatory T cells, known as T-helper 17
(Th17) cells, produces the proinflammatory cytokine IL-17 and requires IL-23 for proper
maintenance and function. Indirectly, Th17 cells relate CD and UC etiologies due to IL-23
sharing similar subunits with another major cytokine found in the Th1 phenotype, namely, IL-12
[48, 49]. Also, responsiveness to anti-TNF-α treatment suggests common pathogenic pathways
are shared by both IBD subtypes [50, 51].