Review Article

Treatment of Community-Acquired Pneumonia: Are All Countries Treating Children in the Same Way? A Literature Review

Table 1

Papers on CAP antibiotic treatment in children from 2010 to 2016.

Authors year of publication ref.CountryStudy designTreated infections (% of pneumonia)Population: age in/outpatientMost prescribed antibiotics (%)

(1)Amadeo et al. (2010) [48]EuropeMulticenter, 2-day PPS on abx prescriptionsVarious (respiratory tract infection: 30%)<18 y inpatientsThird-generation cephalosporins (18%)

(2)Ceyhan et al. (2010) [49]TurkeyMulticenter, cross-sectional, 1-day PPSVarious (29.4%)<18 y inpatientsCephalosporins (22.1%),
penicillin (20.5%) 
% inappropriate prescriptions

(3)Younis (2010) [50]Iraq6-month, multicenter, prospective, observational studyVarious (20%)6 m–16 y inpatientsAmpicloxacillin (50%)

(4)Mohajer et al. (2011) [51]Saudi Arabia1-month, retrospective, cross-sectional study on pharmacy prescriptionsVarious (16.2%)<12 y inpatientsCephalosporin <1 yr (44.6%),
coamoxiclav 1–5 years (35.4%), and 5–12 years (35.8%)

(5)Bergicho et al. (2012) [52]Ethiopia1-month, single-center observational retrospective study on abx prescriptionsVarious (9.27%)<18 y inpatientsCotrimoxazole (18.87%)
Amoxicillin (14.5%)

(6)Borrás Novell et al. (2013) [53]SpainA 1-year, prospective multicenter study including patients seen in PED on day 14 of each month who required hospitalization with systemic abxVarious (29.4%)<18 y inpatientsCefotaxime (27.8%),
coamoxiclav (23.4%)

(7)Brogan et al. (2012) [54]USA5-year, multicenter, retrospective cohort study from the Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS)100%1–18 y inpatientsCephalosporins (40.4%)

(8)Fossum et al. (2013) [55]Norway1-year, observational study primary care recordsAll respiratory tract infection (2.4%)<6 y outpatientsMacrolides (44%)

(9)Gwimile et al. (2012) [56]Tanzania7-month, single-center, cross-sectional descriptive hospital based studyVarious (41%)1 m–5 y inpatientsPenicillin (47.9%)

(10)Moinuddin et al. (2012) [57]India9-month, prospective treatment charts review100%<18 y inpatientsThird-generation cephalosporins (57.2%)

(11)Choudry and Bezbaruah (2013) [58]India1-month, single-center observational prospective study on abx prescriptionsVarious (17%)<12 y inpatientsCoamoxiclav (35%)
Ceftriaxone (29%)

(12)De Sá Del Fiol et al. (2013) [59]Brazil12-month, cross-sectional study on questionnaire on abx prescriptions in two Primary Health CentresVarious (3.13%)<9 y outpatientsPenicillin (73.13%)

(13)Dorj et al. (2013) [6]Mongolia10-week observational prospective study on written abx prescriptions of community pharmacies in rural and urban areas100%Adults and children outpatientsAminopenicillins (16%)

(14)Feleke et al. (2013) [60]Ethiopia6-month, prospective, cross-sectional study on patients chartsVarious (56.3%)<10 y inpatientsCeftriaxone (43.50%)

(15)Neuman et al. (2013) [61]USAData were obtained from the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NHAMCS) for ED visits from 2001 through 2009 for children with CAP100%Adults and children outpatientsCephalosporin (35%)
Macrolides (36%)

(16)Alakhali and Shaik_Mohammad (2014) [62]Saudi Arabia2-month, observational, retrospective study on abx prescriptionsVarious (9.7%)<12 y inpatientsCephalosporin (52%)

(17)Dubos et al. (2014) [63]FranceA phone survey with a standardized questionnaire submitted randomly to GPs, pediatricians, and pediatric fellows100%<18 y outpatientsCoamoxiclav 54%
Amoxicillin 29%

(18)Maltezou et al. (2014) [64]GreeceA standardized questionnaire distributed to 520 private-practice pediatricians100%<18 y outpatientsCompliance with the first-line recommended antibiotic was 30.6% for CAP

(19)Mishra et al. (2014) [65]IndiaSingle-center, prospective, interventional studyVarious (LRTI: 17.9%)1 m–16 y outpatientAmoxicillin (44%)

(20)Osowicki et al. (2015) [66]AustraliaMulticentre, single-day, hospital-wide PPSVarious (LRTI: 22%)<18 y inpatientsNarrow-spectrum penicillin (18%)
β-lactam–β-lactamase
inhibitor combinations (15%)

(21)Salih et al. (2014) [67]Sudan12-month, cross-sectional study on abx prescriptions100% (severe)2 m–5 y inpatientsCoamoxiclav (22.1%)
Cephalosporins:
(i) Ceftriaxone (20.2%)
(ii) Cefuroxime (19.7%)

(22)Sviestina et al. (2014) [68]France, Latvia, and UKMulticenter, 1-day PPS on abx prescriptions Various: LRTI Latvia (26.2%), France (11.8%), UK (9.3%)<18 y inpatientsUK: piperacillin/tazobactam (32%), coamoxiclav (26%)
Latvia: amoxicillin (30%), ceftriaxone (21%)
France: coamoxiclav (21%), amoxicillin (17%)

(23)Awor et al. (2015) [69]UgandaAll drug shops in the intervention area were included and all child visits in 8 months were analyzedVarious (45%)<7 y outpatientsAmoxicillin (91%)

(24)Fadare et al. (2015) [70]Nigeria7- month, cross-sectional study using medical recordsVarious (respiratory tract infections: 53.7%)<5 y outpatientsAmoxicillin (52.4%)
Coamoxiclav (19%)

(25)Iroh Tam et al. (2015) [71]USAMulticenter, retrospective study (six hospitals) on medical records with pneumonia100%2 m–18 y inpatientsThird-generation cephalosporins (72%)

(26)Milner et al. (2015) [72]USA2-year multicenter retrospective cohort study100%3 m–18 yEmergency department providers prescribed narrow-spectrum therapy 27% of the time

(27)Thapaliya et al. (2013) [73]Nepal6-month, single center, retrospective study on medical chartsVarious (22.5%)<13 y inpatientsCephalosporins (ceftriaxone 49.3%, cefotaxime 26.2%)

(28)Williams et al. (2015) [74]USA6-month multicenter, prospective, population-based, active surveillance of CAP hospitalizations among children pre: 1–9%, post: 15.2%100%3 m–18 y inpatientsCephalosporins pre (52.8%)

(29)Fonseca Lima et al. (2016) [75]Brazil3-year, single-center, cross-sectional study100%1 m–5 y inpatientsAmpicillin 62.17%

(30)De Luca et al. (2016) [76]Italy1-day PPS on abx prescriptions ##Various (LRTI: 22.1% of children, 2.3% of neonates)<18 y inpatientsCephalosporins (43.3%)

(31)Ivanovska et al. (2016) [77]Netherlands3-year, retrospective, observational study, deriving data on diagnoses and prescriptions from the electronic health records-based NIVEL Primary Care DatabaseRespiratory tract infection (pneumonia 5.8–7.1%)<18 y outpatientsAmoxicillin: 2010 (60.4%), 2011 (66.9%), and 2012 (63%)

(32)Launay et al. (2016) [78]FranceMulticenter, prospective two-period study using data from the French pneumonia network100%1 m–15 y inpatientsFirst period: amoxicillin 58.1%
Second period: amoxicillin 71.0%

(33)Sharma et al. (2016) [79]Guyana1-year, retrospective chart review of pediatric patients seen in the emergency departmentVarious (RTI: 19.5%)1 m–13 y outpatientsAmoxicillin 33.6%

(34)Thomson et al. (2015) [80]USA15-month, single-center, retrospective cohort study100%3 m–18 y inpatientsAminopenicillins (63.6%)
Third-generation cephalosporins (16.8%)

(35)Usonis et al. (2016) [81]EuropeSnapshot prospective study based on a questionnaire developed and distributed by the CAP Paediatric Research Initiative (CAP-PRI) working group and distributed across Europe100%<18 y inpatients and outpatientsInpatients: amoxicillin (32%), ampicillin (37%)
Outpatients: amoxicillin (84%)

(36)Vesporten et al. (2016) [82]Africa, Asia, Oceania, Latina America, North America and Europe1-day PPS on abx prescriptions ##Various (LRTI 18.7%)<18 y inpatientsThird-generation cephalosporins: Eastern Europe (37.5%) and Asia (28.6%), fourth-generation cephalosporins in North America (13.3%). Narrow-spectrum (b- lactamase sensitive penicillin 11% in Africa and 4.3% in Northern Europe)

(37)Zec et al. (2016) [83]SerbiaSingle-center, 6-month, retrospective study on medical charts100%1 m–6 y inpatientsCephalosporins (cefazolin 40.4%, third-generation cephalosporins 31.7%)

from Antibiotic Resistance and Prescribing in European Children (ARPEC) project.