Research Article

Genetic Algorithm for Biobjective Urban Transit Routing Problem

Table 7

Comparison of biobjective results of Mandl's Swiss road network.

Case Number of routes Parameters Fan et al. [3] Mumford [18] Proposed GA
The best results for passenger The best results for operator The best results for passenger The best results for operator The best results for passenger The best results for operator

I 4 90.88 61.08 90.43 61.0891.8461.08
8.35 36.61 9.57 36.618.1636.61
0.77 2.310.002.310.002.31
0.000.000.000.000.000.00
ATT 10.65 13.88 10.57 13.8810.5013.88
12663 149 63 150 63

II 6 93.13 65.18 95.38 70.9196.7970.91
6.29 30.38 4.56 25.503.2125.50
0.58 3.53 0.06 2.950.002.95
0.00 0.90 0.000.640.000.64
ATT 10.49 13.82 10.27 13.4810.2113.48
14863 221 63 224 63

III 7 92.55 64.42 96.47 65.13 98.0170.65
6.68 26.20 3.34 22.93 1.9921.13
0.77 8.16 0.19 10.34 0.007.13
0.00 1.22 0.00 1.61 0.001.09
ATT 10.44 14.13 10.22 14.25 10.1613.76
16663 264 63 239 63

IV 8 91.33 55.17 97.56 57.93 99.0461.91
8.67 21.97 2.31 31.92 0.9629.67
0.00 18.11 0.13 9.70 0.006.87
0.00 4.75 0.000.450.00 1.54
ATT 10.45 15.45 10.17 14.45 10.1114.22
24563 291 63 256 63