A Comparison of Selected Modifications of the Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm

Table 4

Estimation of the best and poorest modifications.

𝑓1	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	AdaptW, ChaoticRandW, ChaoticW, NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW
SCE-PSO	AdaptW	ConstantW
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW, NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW
𝑓2	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	AdaptW, LinTimeVaryingW	ConstrFactor
SCE-PSO	AdaptW	ConstrFactor
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW	ConstrFactor
𝑓3	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	LinTimeVaryingW	ConstantW
SCE-PSO	AdaptW, NonlinTimeW	ConstantW
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW, NonlinTimeW	ConstantW, RandomW
𝑓4	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	ChaoticRandW, LinTimeVaryingW	ConstrFactor
SCE-PSO	NonlinTimeConstW	ConstrFactor
SCERand-PSO	NonlinTimeConstW	ConstrFactor
𝑓5	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	ChaoticRandW, NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW
SCE-PSO	ChaoticRandW, ChaoticW, NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW
SCERand-PSO	ChaoticRandW, ChaoticW, LinTimeVaryingW, NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW
𝑓6	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	ChaoticRandW, NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW
SCE-PSO	AdaptW	ConstantW
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW	ConstantW
𝑓7	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW, RandomW
SCE-PSO	NonlinTimeConstW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW, NonlinTimeW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor, LinTimeVarying
𝑓8	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	AdaptW	ConstrFactor
SCE-PSO	AdaptW	LinTimeVarying
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor, LinTimeVaryingW, NonlinTimeConstW
𝑓9	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	ChaoticW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor, RandomW
SCE-PSO	ChaoticW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor
SCERand-PSO	ChaoticW	ConstantW
𝑓10	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	ChaoticRandW	ConstantW
SCE-PSO	ChaoticW	ConstantW
SCERand-PSO	ChaoticRandW, ChaoticW, LinTimeVaryingW	ConstantW
𝑓11	Best	Poorest
OC-PSO	AdaptW, LinTimevaryingW, NonlinTimeConstW, NonlinTimeW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor
SCE-PSO	LinTimevaryingW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor, RandomW
SCERand-PSO	AdaptW	ConstantW, ConstrFactor, RandomW