A Modified Artificial Bee Colony Algorithm with Firefly Algorithm Strategy for Continuous Optimization Problems

Table 4

Performance comparison of ABC and MABC algorithms using NS, NF, and %SD values and .

Functions	D		ABC			MABC		Significant
		NS	NF	%SD	NS	NF	%SD
	2		4051	7.60		1878	5.38	+
	5		12010	3.83		6079	3.54	+
	10		26356	4.15		13608	2.49	+
	30		87678	2.65		43695	2.75	+
	60		188597	1.98		124882	1.66	+
	2		3427	4.64		1588	0.06	+
	5		10611	4.79		5203	11.02	+
	10		23874	3.22		12340	6.26	+
	30		83755	6.78		40377	4.89	+
	60		180206	5.94		125596	17.04	+
	2		-	-		31723	7.22	++
	5		-	-		31487	46.42	++
	10		-	-		65308	51.11	++
	30		-	-		310197	50.90	++
	60		-	-		1897652	21.86	++
	2		6938	0.02		3197	0.05	+
	5		19854	9.64		9716	5.47	+
	10		43100	4.23		22187	4.12	+
	30		140991	4.52		69473	3.92	+
	60		293036	1.41		188176	4.09	+
	2		5962	9.46		2234	8.10	+
	5		18047	4.26		7310	5.95	+
	10		40131	4.73		17175	7.47	+
	30		140089	4.68		59496	19.55	+
	60		323945	6.17		177682	20.57	+
	2		6173	9.65		2129	6.58	+
	5		17836	6.30		6969	3.66	+
	10		40015	4.54		15611	2.63	+
	30		132011	3.91		49996	3.05	+
	60		290327	5.64		139990	4.85	+
	2		8292	4.99		3551	2.56	+
	5		22948	2.99		10611	2.70	+
	10		48612	1.86		23381	1.89	+
	30		154908	1.35		72955	2.47	+
	60		318003	1.34		217442	4.05	+
	2		8033	11.14		5985	37.89	+
	5		47947	52.66		41999	73.14	0
	10		95032	67.34		63610	39.31	+
	30		111795	14.40		76601	20.79	+
	60		207006	4.27		201120	15.46	0