Teaching-Learning-Based Optimization with Learning Enthusiasm Mechanism and Its Application in Chemical Engineering

Table 9

Simulation results on the oil shale pyrolysis problem.

Algorithm	Best	Mean	Worst	SD	+/=/−	Rank
RCBBOG	0.35356	0.35297	0.35201		+	10
IHS	0.35370	0.35352	0.35330	9.90E − 05	+	8
CMAES	0.35247	0.35121	0.34860		+	11
CLPSO	0.35186	0.35113	0.35028		+	12
JADE	0.35375	0.35363	0.35334		+	3
TLBO	0.35375	0.35355	0.35268		=	6
mTLBO	0.35375	0.35366	0.35334		=	1
DLTLBO	0.35372	0.35354	0.35265		+	7
NIWTLBO	0.35375	0.35341	0.35268		=	9
LETLBO	0.35375	0.35358	0.35268		=	4
GOTLBO	0.35375	0.35357	0.35266		=	5
LebTLBO	0.35375	0.35366	0.35333	9.24E − 05	/	1

The best and the second best results are highlighted with boldface and italic, respectively.