Abstract

Introduction. Undernutrition continues to be a major public health problem throughout the developing world, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa and Asia including India. Limited studies suggest associations between maternal body mass index (BMI) and child nutritional status. The present study aims to determine the relationship between maternal BMI and children nutritional status. Methods. The study was conducted among 246 mothers who had given birth to single children () and belonged to the Proto-Australoid population of North Bengal, India. The anthropometric measurements of height and weight were recorded following standard procedures. Overall body composition was evaluated using BMI. Result. The results showed that overall mean BMI among mothers was  kg/m2, while those among boys and girls were  kg/m2 and  kg/m2 (), respectively. The BMI of mothers were significantly and highly correlated with HAZ (0.709) and BMIZ (0.748) () of children. These are indicative of a strong genetic component between maternal and child anthropometry. Conclusion. The results indicate significant associations between mothers’ and children’s nutritional status. Assessments of body composition and nutritional status using BMI, especially among mothers and their children, are recommended.

1. Introduction

The nutritional status of any individual is his/her health as dictated by the quality of nutrients consumed and the body’s ability to utilize them for its metabolic needs. The World Health Organization (WHO) believes that the ultimate objective of nutritional assessments is overall improvement in the quality of human health [1]. Undernutrition is considered to be a major public health issue in many of the developing countries such as India. Among children, it is a principal cause of increased ill-health, premature mortalities and morbidities, and long-lasting physiological effects [2, 3]. Undernutrition has also been observed to have significant adverse health effects among those children who survive to adulthood and it is the largest contributor to global burden of disease [4]. The underlying causes of undernutrition vary from poverty and low levels of education to poor access to health services [3, 58]. India has the highest occurrence of child undernutrition in the world and it has been estimated that more than half of the Indian children remain undernourished [3]. It has also been reported that the country has more than 47 million stunted children and that nearly 20% of children are born with low birth weight [9, 10]. Therefore, nutritional assessments of children are a priority area in the country and have potential roles to play in formulating developmental strategies and intervention programmes in the same.

Undernutrition among children has been routinely assessed using the technique of anthropometry. This technique is usually preferred because it is noninvasive and relatively simple and it can be easily recorded and interpreted. Usually, researchers have utilized the indices of body mass index (BMI), stunting, wasting, and underweight to assess child nutritional status. A prolific number of studies are present in the existing literature in this aspect. Recent studies include those of Gashu et al. [11], Murakami and Livingstone [12], Sinharoy et al. [13], and Zhang et al. [14].

Maternal malnutrition is a major predisposing factor for morbidity and mortality among women of the developing countries. The causes include inadequate food intake, poor nutritional quality of diets, frequent infections, and short interpregnancy intervals. The consequences of poor maternal nutritional status are reflected in low pregnancy weight gain and high infant and maternal morbidity and mortality. It was observed by Goudet et al. [15] that maternal nutritional status remains an important determinant of child health and nutritional status. As a result, one of the major aims of nutritional research is to understand the relationship between maternal and child nutritional status using anthropometry [16]. Recent studies have shown that maternal nutritional status was related to several adverse outcomes in the offspring that also included nutritional outcomes among the latter [1721]. Studies have shown maternal BMI to be closely associated with child nutritional status [22, 23]. Maternal underweight was another significant factor involved [24]. Maternal nutritional status has also an important role to play in birth weight of infants [25, 26].

The WHO has estimated that, in the year 2012, a total of 6.60 million deaths occurred among children aged under 5 years (usually referred to as preschool children) and that undernutrition was identified to be the principal underlying cause of mortality in an estimated 45.00% of all deaths among children [27]. Preschool children have been specifically studied because their health status is a sensitive indicator of overall community health, particularly among disadvantaged groups in populations [28, 29]. This group is also nutritionally vulnerable due to their easy susceptibility to undernutrition and infection [30, 31]. They require a high supply of nutrients since they are usually very active and their growth rate is rapid. Moreover, during this period, nutritional diseases in the form of kwashiorkor, marasmus, anaemia, and xerophthalmia are not uncommon [3234]. Preschool children call for focused attention in India as because the country has the world’s highest percentage of undernourished children [35]. In the year 2015, it was reported that globally there were 5.90 million deaths of children under the age of 5 years, of which 1.20 million (20%) occurred in India alone [36]. Currently, the country has an under 5 mortality rate of 48 per 1000 live births [36]. A large number of published literatures are available on the nutritional status of children aged less than 5 years using anthropometry. Here, the studies of Biswas and Bose [37], Mandal et al. [38], Mathad et al. [39], Sen and Mondal [40], Patel et al. [41], Anuradha et al. [42], and Chatterjee et al. [43] are mentionable.

Contemporary India is composed of a sizable number of ethnic and indigenous elements having enormous amounts of ethnic and genetic diversity. With a population of more than 84 million individuals, India has the largest number of indigenous people in the world and the country now includes diverse tribal, nontribal, and caste populations [44, 45]. Studies have focused on assessments of nutritional status among preschool children belonging to different indigenous and tribal populations of the country. Here, the studies among the Lodha [46], Sahariya [47], Proto-Australoid tribals [4850], Chenchu [51], and tribals from Assam and other parts of north-east India [52, 53] are mentionable. Other notable studies among preschool children belonging to the tribal populations of the country include those of Rao et al. [54], Bhattacharyya and Sarkar [55], and Meshram et al. [56].

However, Indian studies on the association between maternal nutritional status parameters and child nutritional status using anthropometry appear to be scarce in the existing literature. There are some studies on the relation between such maternal nutritional parameters and birth weight [5760]. Given the above, the present study was undertaken to determine the association between maternal BMI and nutritional status of children belonging to a tribal population of the country.

2. Material and Method

2.1. Nature of Subjects and Area

The present study was carried out among preschool children aged 2–5 years who frequented 16 centers of the Integrated Child Development Scheme (ICDS) located in the rural areas of Sukna, Mohargaon, Matigara, and Nishchintapur under Siliguri subdivision of the district of Darjeeling. The children covered in the present study belonged to the Proto-Australoid Tribal Population. Initially, it was the British who were instrumental in bringing individuals belonging to the Proto-Australoid tribal communities (e.g., Santal, Oraon, and Munda) from the Chotanagpur plateau of Bihar to North Bengal in the mid-19th century to be employed as workers in the tea gardens. They are now found in a conglomerate ethnic group collectively referred to as “Tea-labourer” in North Bengal [61].

The ICDS was launched by the Government of India on 2nd of October 1975 as an experimental project in 29 rural and tribal blocks and 4 urban slums. It now includes preschool children, pregnant and lactating mothers, and women in the age group of 15 years to 44 years and is the largest national program for promotion and development of health of mother and child [48, 62]. It provides nonformal preschool education, supplementary nutrition, immunization, health check-up, referral services, nutrition, and health education to the beneficiaries. The children are also served a daily food supplementation in the form of porridge, consisting approximately of 50 grams of rice and 25 grams of lentil in the centers.

Prior to data collection, necessary permissions were taken from the ICDS centers and local Panchayets (a village level governing authority). Approval for the study was obtained from the University of North Bengal and the study has been conducted in accordance with the ethical guidelines for human experiments as laid down in the Helsinki Declaration of 2000 [63]. The participants were selected using a stratified random sampling method. Initially, mothers and children belonging to the Proto-Australoid tribal population were identified. Subsequently, those mothers having a single child were identified. Once this was accomplished, mothers having single children aged 2–5 years were selected. A total of 300 mothers and their 300 children (boys: 155; girls: 145) were approached to participate in the study. The age and ethnicity of the children were verified from both ICDS center records and birth certificates. However, 54 of them (boys: 30; girls: 24) were excluded, as their ages could not be verified or their mothers refused to participate in the study. So the final sample comprised 246 mothers who had a single child and 246 children aged 2–5 years (boys: 124; girls: 122). All the children were free from physical deformities and were not suffering from any illness and/or diseases at the time of data collection. The objectives of the study were explained to either parent of the children and an informed consent was obtained from them. The data was collected during the period from June 2014 to November 2014.

2.2. Anthropometric Measurements Recorded

The anthropometric measurements of height and weight were recorded following standard procedures of Weiner and Lourie [64]. Height of mothers and their children was recorded with the help of an anthropometric rod to the nearest 0.10 cm. Their weights were recorded in minimum clothing and weight with bare feet was taken using a portable weighing scale to the nearest 0.50 kg. Intraobserver and interobserver technical errors of the measurement (TEM) were calculated for testing reliability of the data following the method of Ulijaszek and Kerr [65]. For calculating TEM, height and weight were recorded from 50 children other than those selected for the study by both authors (PT and JS).

The TEM was calculated using the following equation:

where is difference between the measurements and is number of individuals.

The coefficient of reliability () was subsequently calculated from TEM using the following equation: where is standard deviation of the measurements.

Very high values of (>0.975) were obtained for both intra- and interobserver TEM and these values were observed to be higher than the cutoff value of 0.95 as recommended by Ulijaszek and Kerr [65]. Hence, the measurements recorded by both PT and JS were considered to be reliable and reproducible. Subsequently, height and weight in the course of the present study were recorded by one of the authors (PT).

2.3. Prevalence of Undernutrition among Children

Undernutrition among children was documented by calculating -score values using the available age and sex-specific WHO child growth reference values [66]. -scores were calculated using the WHO Anthro Plus calculator. The values of height-for-age -score (HAZ), weight-for-age -score (WAZ), weight-for-height -score (WHZ), and body mass index for -score (BMIZ) between “−2 to −3” and “<−3” were considered as moderately and severely undernourished, respectively. The BMI was calculated following the internationally accepted standard equation of WHO [67]:

2.4. Prevalence of Undernutrition among Mothers

The prevalence of undernutrition among mothers was assessed following the international BMI cutoff points for CED as proposed by WHO [67].

2.5. Statistical Analysis

The data was statistically analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS version 17.0). One way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was done to assess age and sex-specific mean differences in anthropometric variables. Correlation analysis was utilized to assess correlation among mother’s BMI and child nutritional parameters. Stepwise regression analysis was utilized to assess the association of mother’s BMI (independent) on children’s -scores (dependent). The predictor variable of mother’s BMI was used in this model. The values of and were considered to be statistically significant.

3. Results

3.1. Descriptive Statistics of the Data

Overall mean and standard deviation (SD) of mothers and their children was depicted in Table 1. Among children, mean ± SD of age, height, weight, and BMI were years,  cm,  kg, and  kg/m2, respectively. Among mothers, the respective values were years,  cm,  kg, and  kg/m2.

3.2. Prevalence of Different Grades of Undernutrition (CED) among Mothers Based on BMI

Prevalence of CED among mothers was very high (Table 2). Majorities of them were suffering from CED Grade II (68.70%), followed by those affected by CED Grade III (29.03%) and finally by those affected by CED Grade I (2.01%). Less than 0.50% of them exhibited normal BMI values.

3.3. Age and Sex-Specific Prevalence of Undernutrition among the Children

The age and sex-specific prevalence of undernutrition among boys and girls are shown in Table 3. Among boys, overall mean ± SD of height, weight, and BMI were  cm,  kg and  kg/m2, while, among girls, the respective values were  cm,  kg, and  kg/m2. Among girls, mean height and weight exhibited an increasing trend except in case of BMI which was lower than that shown by boys. Using, ANOVA statistically significant differences ( and ) were observed between sexes with respect to height, weight, BMI, HAZ, WAZ, WHZ, and BMIZ.

Lower values of HAZ, WAZ, WHZ, and BMIZ indicated whether the children were stunted, underweight, and wasted. Among boys, HAZ -score was −, −, −, and − in the individuals ages, respectively. Among girls, the corresponding values were −, −, −, and − which were lower than boys. -values were observed to be statistically significant () among them. In case of WAZ -scores, the values for boys were −, −, −, and − for the corresponding ages, which were higher than the corresponding values for girls. -values were also statistically significant (). The BMIZ among boys were for 2 years, − for 3 years, − for 4 years, and − for 5 years. Among girls, the corresponding values were −, −, −, and , respectively. The age specific differences in prevalence of different categories of undernutrition were observed to be statistically significant () among boys and girls, except WAZ and WHZ among boys.

3.4. Pearson’s Correlation Coefficients between Mother’s BMI and Child -Score Indices

The Pearson’s correlation coefficients between maternal BMI and child -score indices (HAZ, WAZ, WHZ, and BMIZ) were positive and are shown in Table 4. The correlation coefficients were 0.608, 0.152, 0.195, and 0.772, respectively.

3.5. Stepwise Logistic Regression among Maternal Anthropometric Characters (Independent Variables) with Children -Score Indices

Using a stepwise logistic regression, dependent variables (HAZ, WAZ, WHZ, and BMIZ of children) were fitted for mother’s BMI and the results are depicted in Table 5. The results reveal that BMI was an important predictor variable of HAZ, WAZ, and BMIZ. Maternal BMI (Model 1) explained for 70.90%, 5.10%, and 74.80% of variations in these three dependent variables except for WHZ (28.60%). There were significant associations between maternal BMI and children HAZ, WAZ, and BMIZ except WHZ. The associations of sex-specific mean anthropometric variable of mother’s BMI and children -score are shown in Figure 1. Moreover, mean -scores of HAZ, WAZ, WHZ, and BMIZ of children had increasing trends with increased maternal BMI.

4. Discussion

It is evident from Table 1 that most of the mothers included in the present study suffered from different grades of CED. Studies have consistently reported that prevalence of CED was very high among women from India. Using data from the Indian National Family Health Survey [68], Bharati et al. [69] reported an overall prevalence of CED of 31.20% among women aged 15–49 years. The prevalence of CED was high (20–39%) among Bengalee women as observed by Bose et al. [70]. Arlappa et al. [71] observed a very high prevalence of CED (52%) among women from Rajasthan. In a recent study, Bandyopadhyay and Sen [72] reported very high levels of CED among women working in brickfields of West Bengal. High levels of CED were reported from women belonging to different tribal populations by Bisai and Bose [73], Chakrabarty and Bharati [74], Banik [75], and Ghosh [76]. However, very recent studies from the country have reported that prevalence of CED is decreasing among women in the country. Rai [77], while utilizing data from the National Family Health Survey (NFHS) 1998-1999 and NFHS 2005-2006, documented high levels of CED among Indian women but also indicated an almost 3% reduction in CED and a 6% increase in overweight/obesity during 1998–2006. In another very recent study, Meshram et al. [78] observed that prevalence of CED had declined from 52% during 1975–79 to 34% during 2011-12.

The present study enabled direct evaluation of association between mother’s anthropometrics characteristic and child nutritional status. Significant associations between maternal BMI and children nutritional status were observed. India is currently in the midst socioeconomic, demographic, nutritional, and epidemiological transition and still undernutrition continues to affect large segments of the population. The early detection and effective management of current energy deficit as assessed by mother’s BMI may reduce increased susceptibility to undernutrition among children. It was also observed that mean -scores for WAZ, HAZ, WHZ, and BMIZ of children had increasing trends associated with an increase in maternal BMI status (Figure 1). The stepwise regression model revealed that maternal BMI was most predictive variable of HAZ, WAZ, and BMIZ (model 1) and this explained the significant variations in these three dependent variables.

Results indicated that correlations between mother’s and child’s anthropometry were significant. The present study also observed existence of high correlations between mother’s BMI and -scores of height of child. Both these points are indicative of a strong genetic component between maternal and child anthropometry. Thus, mother’s anthropometry strongly influences child’s anthropometry. Studies on the association between the nutritional statuses of mothers with that of their offsprings are scarce in the exiting literature. Some studies are available in the domain of BMI between mothers and their children. There were significant associations between maternal BMI with children weight and height -score and it was observed by many researchers (e.g., [79]) that an increase in BMI status was associated with a lower rate of childhood undernutrition. It was noted more than twenty years ago by Rahman et al. [80] that a child’s nutritional status, as indicated by weight-for-age (as a percentage of NCHS median), was associated with BMI of mother (). Islam et al. [81] in a study from Bangladesh showed that mothers who were underweight were 2.5 times more likely to have underweight children. Santos et al. [82] in a Chilean study observed direct correlation () between children’s BMI -score and their mothers’ BMI, both among boys (Spearman rho = 0.26) and girls (rho = 0.30). In a recent study, Kulasekaran [83] reported that women with poorer nutritional status, as indicated by BMI, had registered higher risk of severe thinness (height-for-age) and severe underweight (weight-for-age) (27.10% and 23.30%, resp.) among their children. The study also reported that severe wasting (weight-for-height) in children was also associated with mothers’ BMI. In yet another recent publication, Negash et al. [21] observed that HAZ was positively associated with maternal height. In another very recent study, Fleten et al. [84] reported that maternal BMI (; ) was correlated with WHZ of children while maternal height (; ) was correlated with HAZ of children. Significant positive association between maternal BMI and children BMI was also noted by Ajslev et al. [85] and Ray [86].

The present study has confirmed the earlier suggestion that anthropometric measurements were useful in identifying mothers at high risk of delivering low birth weight newborns [58]. Anthropometric measurements recorded on children aged 2 years showed that boys have higher metric values in case of height, HAZ -score, and BMIAZ -score than girls. But mean weight, BMI, WAZ -score, and WHZ -score of girls increased. Net increase in BMI, HAZ, WAZ, and BMIZ in case of boys aged 4 years in case of except height and weight over that of girls was noted by Rolland-Cachera et al. [87].

Possibly, it is important to note that, during infancy, the relationship between mother and child malnutrition is affected by biological consequences of maternal malnutrition during lactation. Thus, interventions by improving maternal nutritional status could have a significant role in the prevention of childhood malnutrition. One additional issue that needs to be highlighted is “adiposity rebound,” which refers to the second increase in BMI during early childhood [87]. It is of concern that between-population differences in the patterns of adiposity rebound may exist, in particular, between populations in industrialized and developing countries. This may affect the estimate of obesity prevalence for children at around the age of adiposity rebound when the international BMI references based upon data collected in a particular wealthy society are used. This pattern of change in BMI means that the age of adiposity rebound inevitably predicts later BMI, as was first shown by Rolland-Cachera et al. [87]. This association between changes in BMI applies at all ages, not just at around 5 years, so the adiposity rebound should not be viewed as a critical period for obesity development. The NCHS/WHO growth references have played an important role in the past for international use in assessing child and adolescent growth and nutritional status. WHO has recently developed and recommended the use of a new international reference for infants and preschool children.

5. Conclusions

The results of the present study indicate a high prevalence of undernutrition among mothers and their children aged 2–5 years. Initiatives should be taken to improve nutritional status of such children. The results showed that moderate undernutrition is more prevalent than severe undernutrition. The intervention programmes should focus on improving the nutritional status and environmental and personal hygiene of the children along with regular monitoring of their health so as to achieve their optimal growth potentials. The present study has observed the prevalence of undernutrition among children to be associated with maternal nutritional status.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Acknowledgments

The authors acknowledge the help and cooperation of the ICDS centers, participants of the study, and their parents. Financial assistance of the University Grants Commission, Government of India, in the form of a Rajiv Gandhi National Fellowship (F1-17.1/17.1/2012-13/RGNF-2012-2013-ST-WES-24896) is also acknowledged.