Minimizing Metro Transfer Waiting Time with AFCS Data Using Simulated Annealing with Parallel Computing

Table 5

Comparison of station-based TWT.

Transfer station	Transfer volume; (pass)		Total TWT; (min)		Average TWT (min/pass)		Difference (min)	Percentage; change
ID	EO	OO	EO	OO	EO	OO
AM peak
	6,432	6,440	10,852.2	9,737.8	1.69	1.51	-1,114.4	-10.3%
	10,619	10,611	21,509.3	21,461.3	2.03	2.02	-48.0	-0.2%
	23,724	23,821	43,244.5	28,801.8	1.82	1.21	-14,442.7	-33.4%
	13,454	13,357	24,206.6	21,443.3	1.80	1.61	-2,763.3	-11.4%
	8,833	8,833	15,655.4	14,805.4	1.77	1.68	-850.0	-5.4%
	537	507	1,877.2	1,951.4	3.50	3.85	74.2	+4.0%
	12,126	12,156	31,194.6	27,383.0	2.57	2.25	-3,811.6	-12.2%
	3,350	3,339	10,062.2	11,165.9	3.00	3.34	1,103.7	+11.0%
	7,163	7,163	21,913.5	20,286.9	3.06	2.83	-1,626.6	-7.4%
	10,381	10,381	27,064.7	13,294.9	2.61	1.28	-13,769.8	-50.9%
	17,579	17,590	56,087.6	51,749.4	3.19	2.94	-4,338.2	-7.7%
	10,327	10,327	25,926.3	24,517.6	2.51	2.37	-1,408.7	-5.4%
	14,177	14,177	28,451.9	29,595.4	2.01	2.09	1,143.5	+4.0%
Total	138,702	138,702	318,046.0	276,194.1	2.29	1.99	-41,851.9	-13.2%
Off-peak
	1,240	1,247	4,095.7	3,987.4	3.30	3.20	-108.3	-2.6%
	1,425	1,452	4,744.4	4,717.0	3.33	3.25	-27.4	-0.6%
	3,632	3,655	11,915.3	10,400.0	3.28	2.85	-1,515.3	-12.7%
	1,331	1,229	4,010.4	3,770.0	3.01	3.07	-240.4	-6.0%
	2,595	2,466	9,256.5	5,325.8	3.57	2.16	-3,930.7	-42.5%
	50	51	173.8	200.0	3.48	3.92	26.2	+15.1%
	1,718	1,726	6,000.5	5,270.3	3.49	3.05	-730.2	-12.2%
	610	603	2,318.5	2,091.2	3.80	3.47	-227.3	-9.8%
	1,464	1,528	5,441.7	5,260.4	3.72	3.44	-181.3	-3.3%
	1,022	1,065	2,853.1	1,629.9	2.79	1.53	-1,223.2	-42.9%
	2,199	2,210	7,709.3	7,099.0	3.51	3.21	-610.3	-7.9%
	2,100	2,052	7,731.3	6,372.1	3.68	3.11	-1,359.2	-17.6%
	2,721	2,823	9,037.0	9,341.6	3.32	3.31	304.6	+3.4%
Total	22,107	22,107	75,287.5	65,464.7	3.41	2.96	-9,822.8	-13.0%