Efficiency Evaluation of Bus Transport Operations Given Exogenous Environmental Factors

Table 5

Comparison between the results of the first stage and the third stage.

City	Average TE		Average PTE		Average SE
	First stage	Third stage	First stage	Third stage	First stage	Third stage
Eastern region average	0.797	0.823	0.883	0.887	0.902	0.931
Beijing	0.777	0.920	1.000	1.000	0.777	0.920
Tianjin	0.820	0.865	0.888	0.878	0.923	0.987
Shenyang	0.939	0.944	0.968	0.948	0.970	0.996
Shanghai	0.651	0.758	0.824	0.827	0.790	0.917
Nanjing	0.577	0.631	0.616	0.640	0.939	0.986
Hangzhou	0.749	0.802	0.801	0.816	0.934	0.983
Jinan	0.887	0.855	0.911	0.898	0.974	0.955
Guangzhou	0.861	0.894	0.976	0.975	0.882	0.916
Haikou	0.837	0.672	1.000	1.000	0.837	0.672
Dalian	0.959	0.985	0.993	1.000	0.966	0.985
Qingdao	0.757	0.802	0.807	0.856	0.938	0.941
Xiamen	1.000	0.952	1.000	1.000	1.000	0.952
Shenzhen	0.554	0.620	0.694	0.696	0.799	0.891
Central region average	0.841	0.817	0.870	0.875	0.968	0.936
Taiyuan	0.939	0.837	0.953	0.928	0.986	0.901
Changchun	0.837	0.802	0.854	0.860	0.982	0.936
Harbin	0.890	0.927	0.940	0.927	0.946	1.000
Hefei	0.792	0.764	0.804	0.814	0.985	0.939
Nanchang	0.897	0.770	0.942	0.970	0.950	0.790
Zhengzhou	0.898	0.855	0.909	0.872	0.988	0.983
Wuhan	0.755	0.823	0.819	0.845	0.922	0.974
Changsha	0.724	0.757	0.736	0.783	0.983	0.966
Western region average	0.912	0.872	0.968	0.954	0.943	0.917
Huhhot	0.877	0.817	1.000	1.000	0.877	0.817
Nanning	0.920	0.812	0.950	0.922	0.970	0.880
Chongqing	0.957	1.000	1.000	1.000	0.957	1.000
Chengdu	0.969	0.978	1.000	0.988	0.969	0.990
Guiyang	0.988	0.932	0.989	0.972	0.999	0.958
Kunming	0.823	0.786	0.841	0.792	0.978	0.992
Xi’an	0.926	0.977	0.982	0.978	0.944	0.999
Yinchuan	0.808	0.671	1.000	1.000	0.808	0.671
Urumqi	0.942	0.881	0.954	0.930	0.988	0.950
National average	0.844	0.836	0.905	0.904	0.932	0.928