Detection of Intermittent Fault for Discrete-Time Systems with Output Dead-Zone: A Variant Tobit Kalman Filtering Approach

Huang, Jie; He, Xiao

doi:https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/7849841

Journal of Control Science and Engineering

On this page

Abstract Introduction Preliminaries Conclusion Acknowledgments References Copyright Related Articles

Special Issue

Fault Diagnosis and Application to Modern Systems

View this Special Issue

Research Article | Open Access

Volume 2017 | Article ID 7849841 | https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/7849841

Detection of Intermittent Fault for Discrete-Time Systems with Output Dead-Zone: A Variant Tobit Kalman Filtering Approach

Jie Huang¹and Xiao He¹

Academic Editor: William MacKunis

Received10 Sept 2016

Accepted09 Jan 2017

Published07 Feb 2017

Abstract

This paper is concerned with the intermittent fault detection problem for a class of discrete-time linear systems with output dead-zone. Dead-zone phenomenon exists in many real practical systems due to the employment of low-cost commercial off-the-shelf sensors. Two Bernoulli random variables are utilized to model the dead-zone effect and a variant formation of Tobit Kalman filter is brought forward to generate a residual that can indicate the occurrence of an intermittent fault. A numerical example is presented to demonstrate the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed technique. The statistical performance of the technique is illustrated as well.

1. Introduction

Due to the uncertainties in the external environment or the abrupt changes in signals, there may exist different kinds of faults yielding unacceptable or intolerable behaviors for the whole system. Since a fault can lead to bad influences or even disastrous consequences on the performance of systems, an accurate fault detection plays a significant role in designing a safe and reliable system. For the past years, many researchers have been investigating this problem and they have established numerous methods, including the model-free fault detection approaches [1–7] and model-based fault detection approaches [8]. Since system mathematical mode indicating evaluation of the system state can be acquired, model-based fault detection approaches occupy an important place in the practical application of diagnosis technology. The mode-based fault detection approaches can be further classified as observer-based approaches [9–13], parity equations approaches [14, 15], and parameter estimation methods [16, 17]. For the model-based approaches, a fault detection observer or filter is designed to detect the fault signal through generating a residual signal and then comparing the residual signal with a threshold [18–20]. The Kalman filter [21] is frequently used for residual signal generation by estimating the states to study the differences between predicted measurements and actual measurements.

At present, most researchers focus on detection of permanent faults and transient faults. Nevertheless, as the electronic technology and computer science have been rapidly developing, a special kind of faults, intermittent faults, comes into sight. Compared with permanent faults, the occurrence of intermittent faults is periodic, intermittent, and recurrent. Differed from transient faults, the intermittent faults can recur in the same component and disappear after changing component. With the cumulative effect, intermittent faults will turn to permanent faults, which are menaces for system performance and equipment safety [22]. There are a few literatures using quantitative analysis methods to investigate the detection problem of intermittent faults. Reference [23] considered the detection of scalar intermittent faults in continuous linear stochastic dynamic systems. Reference [24] looked into the intermittent fault detection problem for networked systems with unknown input and multiple state delays. In [25], a robust fault detection method was proposed to detect intermittent faults for linear stochastic systems in the presence of time-varying parametric perturbations and noises.

In real control systems, especially those making use of low-cost commercial sensors with poor calibration, dead-zone is one of the common sources of measurement nonlinearity. It can seriously limit the performance of systems and bring challenges to engineers. The model of dead-zone with input and output can be described bywhere and are the left and right slopes with and ; and are the left and right break points with and . The researches on the approaches to control the dead-zone can be traced back to Tao and Kokotovic [26] who constructed a continuous-time adaptive dead-zone inverse. Then, they extended it to a discrete-time formulation for linear systems with measurable dead-zone output [27]. After that, [28] presented an asymptotically adaptive elimination of an unknown dead-zone whose input and output are available. Around the beginning of the 21st century, a fuzzy dead-zone precompensator was established in [29] and neural network was applied to the construction of a precompensator in [30].

The Tobit model was first coming forward in [31] as a hybrid of probit analysis and multiple regression for household expenditure with censoring data. Although this model has been widely used in the fields of economics and medicine, it has not been well concerned in control engineering. Reference [32] presented a formulation of Kalman filter, named Tobit Kalman filter, which provided an efficient method to tackle the system with censoring data. In [32], a new definition of innovation was introduced by employing the Tobit regression.

A lot of methods have been proposed for estimation of nonlinear systems with censoring measurements. The extended Kalman filter (EKF) is a commonly used substitution of the Kalman filter when the nonlinear systems are encountered. However, when EKF is not convergent, its performance will deteriorate and become unstable [33]. The unscented Kalman filter (UKF) was devised to be an alternative of the EKF by improving convergence and linearization. Nevertheless, while data are censored, discontinuities will locate between the sigma points resulting in the biased measurement noise covariance [33]. Among those approaches, the particle filter in [34] is accurate but also most computationally expensive. It can cause difficulty in implement of the systems with limitations on computational power, like embedded systems [32]. Another defect is that the posterior weights will go to “collapse” as the particle filter is employed in some very large scale systems [35]. Some methods on fault-tolerant control of systems with dead-zone have been proposed recently [36, 37]. Compared with the aforementioned methods, the Tobit Kalman filter not only has less computational burden, but also has good performance while operating in the nonlinear system, which makes it more practical. This paper considers the fault detection for the discrete-time systems with output dead-zone. Since the dead-zone model does not fall under the category of Tobit model types, the Tobit Kalman filter here is a variant formulation which still maintains the performance of the original one. This variant Tobit Kalman filter will be used for designing the fault detection filter.

So far, there exist fairly rare researches on fault detection, especially the intermittent fault detection, for systems with output dead-zone. This paper has first proposed an intermittent fault detection method for a class of discrete-time systems with output dead-zone via the Tobit Kalman filtering approach, which has less computational expense and higher practicability. Also, the statistical performance will be illustrated in this paper. The remainder of this paper will be divided into five sections. Section 2 states the problem under consideration and the preliminaries of Tobit regression for the data with dead-zone. In Section 3, the variant Tobit Kalman filter will be derived. Section 4 is the part of designing the fault detection filter. Section 5 presents the simulation results and statistical performance. Finally, the conclusion is drawn in Section 6.

2. Problem Formulation and Preliminaries

2.1. Problem Formulation

The discrete-time system with faults to be detected is described aswhere is the state vector; is the latent measurement vector; is the observed measurement vector with a dead-zone; is the fault vector; and represent the Gaussian random vectors with zero mean and covariance and , respectively. The system matrices , , and are constant and deterministic with proper dimensions.

The measurement with dead-zone is to be defined aswhere is a negative vector with elements s, representing the left breakpoint; is a positive vector with elements s, representing the right breakpoint; and are positive constants, representing the left and right slopes, separately. As the statement in [26], the above dead-zone model is a static simplification of different physical phenomena with ignorable fast dynamics.

In order to model the occurrence of dead-zone, two Bernoulli random variables are introduced.

At any time step, the measurement can be expressed as a combination of with probability or . When or , the latent measurements can be observed. When and , the data become latent values. Here, is the index of elements in the measurement vector, where .

It should be noticed that the Bernoulli random matrices should be diagonal; that is, .

Consequently, the measurements can be rewritten as

2.2. Preliminaries

The fault detection filter in this paper is designed by using a variant Tobit Kalman filter. One of the significant points of the Tobit Kalman filter is introducing the innovation through the Tobit regression. As the Tobit regression is used for reference in the design of the fault detection filter with output dead-zone, some preliminaries will be introduced in this section. Notice that all the equations and values are scalars in this section.

Let represent the value of cumulative probability density function of unit-normal distribution at .

Suppose that the values of and the limits , are known, and follows the normal distribution with zero mean and standard deviation, ; then

The cumulative density function of can be obtained according to (6):

The corresponding probability density function iswhere is the value of probability density function at .

The expected value of with a dead-zone is

The variance of with a dead-zone iswhere

3. Variant Tobit Kalman Filter

3.1. Time Update

With the updating of the time indices, the estimation of state before taken into account is expressed aswhere is the estimate of state at time with all the measurements up to time being given.

The state error covariance matrix can be written as where is corresponding state error covariance matrix of and is the true value of the state at time .

3.2. Measurement Update

The stage of measurement update is to rectify the estimate of state using the new information. As all measurements up to time are given, the equation of the state is written as

The state error covariance matrix iswhere is the expectation of measurement at time , whose scalar value can be calculated by (8). In the rest of this paper, will be denoted as for convenience.

The state error covariance matrix can be written by substituting (5) into (15).where

Take the trace of the state error covariance matrix described in (16) and then set the deviation of the trace equal to zero. Then, the optimal Kalman gain can be found so as to minimize the state error covariance.

Substituting (17) into (18) leads to

Since the expected value of a Bernoulli random variable equals success probability, then

In principle, the value of true state should be applied in the calculation. The assumptions in [32] will be used to reduce the constraints.

Assumption 1 (see [32]). For small estimation errors, the prediction of state can be used to obtain a sufficiently accurate estimate of the success probability; that is,

Remark 2. As Assumption 1 holds true, the state can be considered as independent of the Bernoulli variables and .

Assumption 3 (see [32]). In most applications, the matrices are diagonal, which means that the measurement noise is independent in the measurements.
According to the assumptions above, can be written in terms of Assumption 1:Compute by Assumptions 1 and 3.whereSubstituting (27), (28), and (21) into (16) yields

The full view of the variant Tobit Kalman filter iswhere , , , and are defined as (27), (28), (25), and (26), respectively.

4. Fault Detection

In the fault detection, it is expected that the reconstructed process variables derived by the filter will follow the corresponding real values of the fault-free operating states. To get information on whether a fault occurs, the measured variables will be compared with their estimates delivered by the filter. The difference between the measurements and their estimates is defined as a residual. Therefore, a residual generation is the most significant procedure for a successful fault detection [8].

After the estimation of the states, the estimates of outputs are created as shown in

Then, the residual vector is built as the difference between the measurements and their estimates:

The residual evaluation function is used for differentiating the fault from disturbance and uncertainties. This procedure of postprocessing the residuals takes out the information about the fault of interest from the residual signals. After calculating the residual vector, substitute it into the specified evaluation function and compare the evaluation value with the preset threshold. If the residual evaluation value is larger than the threshold, an alarm of fault will be built.

Consider the time-windowed root-mean-square (RMS) norm as the evaluation function:

Then, choose a threshold of the following form:

Remark 4. In the practical applications, the threshold is considered as the maximum value of the residual evaluation function in the fault-free case through the Monte Carlo method.

Remark 5. Making choice of the threshold should be compromised based on the actual situation. As the value of threshold is increasing, the false alarm rate will reduce whereas the missing alarm rate will rise up. With the decrease of the threshold value, the false alarm rate will go up but the missing alarm rate will be lower. Hence, to choose a threshold needs to consider overall interests.

The relationship between the value of residual evaluation function and the threshold should be satisfied as

The algorithm of the fault detection filter is summarized as follows.

Algorithm 6 (fault detection using a variant Kalman filter). The initial conditions and are given.

Step 1. Compute and using (12) and (13).

Step 2. Compute , , , and using (25), (26), (9), and (10).

Step 3. Compute and using (27) and (28).

Step 4. Compute using (21).

Step 5. Compute and using (14) and (30).

Step 6. Compute using (32) and then obtain through (33).

Step 7. Evaluate using (34) and then compare it with the threshold using the rule (36).

Step 8. Return to Step 1.

5. Simulation Results

In this section, the simulation result will illustrate the applicability of the fault detection filter using the variant Tobit Kalman filtering.

Consider the tracking system of ballistic roll rates explored in [32], which has the dynamic model of (2) with the state-space matrices:

In this example, ; the frequency ; the standard deviation of process noise is ; the variance of measurement noise is .

The dead-zone of measurement is given asthat is, , , , and .

The initial conditions are set as

Then, an intermittent fault is added to the system, which is described as follows:with coefficient matrix

The simulation results are shown in Figures 1, 2, and 3.

Figure 1 is the figure of the measurements with the dead-zone. It can be seen that some parts of measurements have distortion or cannot be observed because of the dead-zone. Figure 2 presents the estimates of the processing states. The blue curve represents the true states and the red dash curve represents the estimates of states using the variant Kalman filter. Even though the data are absent or distorted, the estimation values of states using the variant Tobit Kalman filter can closely track the true states in fault-free case. When the faults occur, the difference between the true states and their estimates is obvious. Accordingly, the outputs of the variant Tobit Kalman filter provide accurate estimation of the measurements to generate the residual signal.

Figure 3 illustrates , residual response, and residual evaluation function response varying with time . The faults occur in the time intervals , , and with the magnitude and coefficient matrix defined as (40) and (41). In the figure of residual evaluation, the blue curve is the response of faulty systems and the red dash line represents the preset threshold. Figure 3 indicates that the response raises an alarm opportunely when the faults happen at time , , and . When the faults disappear at times , , and , the alarms go down rapidly. These simulation results demonstrate that the residual can detect the intermittent faults accurately.

The Monte Carlo method is applied to obtain the statistical performance of the fault detection method proposed in this paper. The statistical performance is shown in Table 1. Fault detection time (FDT) represents the time when the occurrence of fault is detected and the alarm raises. False alarm rate (FAR) is the probability of false detection and missing alarm rate (MAR) is the probability of missing detection. It can be seen that the value of threshold can influence a lot the FDT, FAR, and MAR. As the value of threshold is becoming larger, it takes more time to detect the fault and raise alarm. The smaller threshold can reduce the MAR. However, the FAR is increasing at the same time. When threshold is chosen as a large value, although there will be less or even no false alarms, more faults will be failed to detect. Therefore, it is significant to choose a proper value of threshold and make a tradeoff among the FDT, FAR, and MAR.

6. Conclusion

In this paper, we have investigated the problem of fault detection for the discrete-time systems with output dead-zone. Two Bernoulli random variables are introduced to describe the dead-zone of measurements. The variant Tobit Kalman filter is utilized for designing a recursive fault detection filter under the situation of dead-zone measurements. A simulation example of the occurrence of intermittent faults is provided. The simulation results have illustrated that the performance of fault detection filter is satisfied, where the fault can be recognized quickly and accurately. Also, the statistical performance of the fault detection method illustrated the relationship of threshold, FDT, FAR, and MAR. The dead-zone is a common issue arising in the engineering applications. The fault detection filter using the variant Tobit Kalman filter shows its practical value, with the good performance and lower computational expense. Furthermore, it can be extended to the fault detection for two-dimension systems like vision-based systems with occlusion region.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grants 61473163, 61522309, and 61490701 and Tsinghua University Initiative Scientific Research Program.

References

X. Sun, H. J. Marquez, T. Chen, and M. Riaz, “An improved PCA method with application to boiler leak detection,” ISA Transactions, vol. 44, no. 3, pp. 379–397, 2005.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
D. Diallo, M. E. H. Benbouzid, D. Hamad, and X. Pierre, “Fault detection and diagnosis in an induction machine drive: a pattern recognition approach based on concordia stator mean current vector,” IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 512–519, 2005.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
J. Liu, “Shannon wavelet spectrum analysis on truncated vibration signals for machine incipient fault detection,” Measurement Science and Technology, vol. 23, no. 5, Article ID 055604, 2012.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. M. El-Shal and A. S. Morris, “A fuzzy expert system for fault detection in statistical process control of industrial processes,” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics Part C: Applications and Reviews, vol. 30, no. 2, pp. 281–289, 2000.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
B. Samanta, “Gear fault detection using artificial neural networks and support vector machines with genetic algorithms,” Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 18, no. 3, pp. 625–644, 2004.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. B. Jack and A. K. Nandi, “Fault detection using support vector machines and artificial neural networks, augmented by genetic algorithms,” Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 16, no. 2-3, pp. 373–390, 2002.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
P. V. J. Rodríguez, M. Negrea, and A. Arkkio, “A simplified scheme for induction motor condition monitoring,” Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 22, no. 5, pp. 1216–1236, 2008.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. X. Ding, Model-based Fault Diagnosis Techniques: Design Schemes, Algorithms, and Tools, Springer, London, UK, 2nd edition, 2013.
Z. Gao, X. Liu, and M. Z. Q. Chen, “Unknown input observer-based robust fault estimation for systems corrupted by partially decoupled disturbances,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 63, no. 4, pp. 2537–2547, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. Wu, X. Yao, and W. X. Zheng, “Generalized $H_{2}$ fault detection for two-dimensional Markovian jump systems,” Automatica, vol. 48, no. 8, pp. 1741–1750, 2012.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
S. Tong, B. Huo, and Y. Li, “Observer-based adaptive decentralized fuzzy fault-tolerant control of nonlinear large-scale systems with actuator failures,” IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 1–15, 2014.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. Tong, T. Wang, and Y. Li, “Fuzzy adaptive actuator failure compensation control of uncertain stochastic nonlinear systems with unmodeled dynamics,” IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems, vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 563–574, 2014.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
H. J. Yang, Y. Q. Xia, and B. Liu, “Fault detection for T-S fuzzy discrete systems in finite-frequency domain,” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B: Cybernetics, vol. 41, no. 4, pp. 911–920, 2011.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
J. Blesa, P. Jiménez, D. Rotondo, F. Nejjari, and V. Puig, “An interval NLPV parity equations approach for fault detection and isolation of a wind farm,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 62, no. 6, pp. 3794–3805, 2015.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. Tornil-Sin, C. Ocampo-Martinez, V. Puig, and T. Escobet, “Robust fault diagnosis of nonlinear systems using interval constraint satisfaction and analytical redundancy relations,” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics: Systems, vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 18–29, 2014.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
R. Isermann, “Fault diagnosis of machines via parameter estimation and knowledge processing—tutorial paper,” Automatica. A Journal of IFAC, the International Federation of Automatic Control, vol. 29, no. 4, pp. 815–835, 1993.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
J.-A. Jiang, J.-Z. Yang, Y.-H. Lin, C.-W. Liu, and J.-C. Ma, “An adaptive PMU based fault detection/location technique for transmission lines part I: theory and algorithms,” IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 486–493, 2000.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. He, Z. Wang, Y. Liu, and D. H. Zhou, “Least-squares fault detection and diagnosis for networked sensing systems using a direct state estimation approach,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 1670–1679, 2013.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. He, Z. Wang, X. Wang, and D. H. Zhou, “Networked strong tracking filtering with multiple packet dropouts: algorithms and applications,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 61, no. 3, pp. 1454–1463, 2014.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. He, Z. Wang, L. Qin, and D. Zhou, “Active fault-tolerant control for an internet-based networked three-tank system,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. 24, no. 6, pp. 2150–2157, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
R. E. Kalman, “A new approach to linear filtering and prediction problems,” Journal of Basic Engineering, vol. 82, no. 1, pp. 35–45, 1960.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
D.-H. Zhou, J.-T. Shi, and X. He, “Review of intermittent fault diagnosis techniques for dynamic systems,” Acta Automatica Sinica, vol. 40, no. 2, pp. 161–171, 2014.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
M. Chen, G. Xu, R. Yan, S. X. Ding, and D. Zhou, “Detecting scalar intermittent faults in linear stochastic dynamic systems,” International Journal of Systems Science, vol. 46, no. 8, pp. 1337–1348, 2015.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | Zentralblatt MATH
X. He, Y. Hu, and K. Peng, “Intermittent fault detection for uncertain networked systems,” Mathematical Problems in Engineering, vol. 2013, Article ID 282168, 10 pages, 2013.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
R. Yan, X. He, and D. Zhou, “Detection of intermittent faults for linear stochastic systems subject to time-varying parametric perturbations,” IET Control Theory & Applications, vol. 10, no. 8, pp. 903–910, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
G. Tao and P. V. Kokotovic, “Adaptive control of plants with unknown dead-zones,” Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers. Transactions on Automatic Control, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 59–68, 1994.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
G. Tao and P. V. Kokotović, “Discrete-time adaptive control of systems with unknown deadzones,” International Journal of Control, vol. 61, no. 1, pp. 1–17, 1995.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
H. Cho and E.-W. Bai, “Convergence results for an adaptive dead zone inverse,” International Journal of Adaptive Control and Signal Processing, vol. 12, no. 5, pp. 451–466, 1998.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
F. L. Lewis, W. K. Tim, L.-Z. Wang, and Z. X. Li, “Deadzone compensation in motion control systems using adaptive fuzzy logic control,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 731–742, 1999.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
R. R. Selmic and F. L. Lewis, “Deadzone compensation in motion control systems using neural networks,” Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers. Transactions on Automatic Control, vol. 45, no. 4, pp. 602–613, 2000.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
J. Tobin, “Estimation of relationships for limited dependent variables,” Econometrica, vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 24–36, 1958.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
B. Allik, C. Miller, M. J. Piovoso, and R. Zurakowski, “The Tobit Kalman filter: an estimator for censored measurements,” IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 365–371, 2016.
View at: Google Scholar
B. Allik, C. Miller, M. J. Piovoso, and R. Zurakowski, “Nonlinear estimators for censored data: a comparison of the EKF, the UKF and the Tobit Kalman filter,” in Proceedings of the 2015 American Control Conference (ACC '15), pp. 5146–5151, Chicago, Ill, USA, July 2015.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
C. Andrieu and A. Doucet, “Particle filtering for partially observed Gaussian state space models,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B. Statistical Methodology, vol. 64, no. 4, pp. 827–836, 2002.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | Zentralblatt MATH | MathSciNet
C. Snyder, T. Bengtsson, P. Bickel, and J. Anderson, “Obstacles to high-dimensional particle filtering,” Monthly Weather Review, vol. 136, no. 12, pp. 4629–4640, 2008.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
M. Chen, B. Jiang, and W. W. Guo, “Fault-tolerant control for a class of non-linear systems with dead-zone,” International Journal of Systems Science, vol. 47, no. 7, pp. 1689–1699, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar | MathSciNet
M. Chen and G. Tao, “Adaptive fault-tolerant control of uncertain nonlinear large-scale systems with unknown dead zone,” IEEE Transactions on Cybernetics, vol. 46, no. 8, pp. 1851–1862, 2016.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar

Copyright

Copyright © 2017 Jie Huang and Xiao He. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

PDF Download Citation

Download other formats

Order printed copies

Views

1817

Downloads

923

Citations