Journal of Control Science and Engineering / 2020 / Article / Tab 9

Research Article

An Enhanced Grasshopper Optimization Algorithm to the Bin Packing Problem

Table 9

Results for CEC2019 functions.

FunctionTypeEGOAGOADAALOPSOOBLGOA

f1avg1.5212E + 051.9571E + 064.6646E+041.1544E + 071.8749E + 061.2357E + 05
std1.8946E + 051.8015E + 061.4480E + 051.4062E + 071.4164E + 061.4289E+05
best1.00003.2527E + 051.00008.0545E + 052.1036E + 038.3500E + 02
worst5.2933E + 054.9750E + 064.5874E + 053.9307E + 074.4657E + 064.4661E+05

f2avg271.2334719.7666116.65102664.53013490.0571217.4122
std361.7063645.6242148.63812243.36731450.532792.5807
best4.3805311.43805.0277432.72581432.2960103.6213
worst996.96882384.2235372.95328234.19645455.4163438.8886

f3avg2.86699.29293.13988.51253.43872.1356
std1.00382.23911.11731.41371.94441.7195
best1.77074.60821.42666.43141.40911.4091
worst4.393711.71115.214111.71167.15636.7118

f4avg27.366327.641733.749138.030727.397231.8436
std9.683411.431014.895614.049413.415411.2370
best8.959713.93458.973822.75599.954617.9143
worst40.798247.094759.703967.514552.041158.7070

f5avg1.21611.28971.30121.59971.22001.1464
std0.07700.11190.11210.24680.09060.0386
best1.06641.08131.10221.12761.06881.0787
worst1.31751.43041.45041.79231.34691.1968

f6avg4.37974.06306.24247.24726.15412.6168
std1.67492.12781.76311.86831.63171.1671
best1.68091.77613.09294.01923.65291.0000
worst6.56119.33128.55859.53168.61614.7035

f7avg920.21881183.37341254.71911195.19841318.86191058.0542
std325.6570419.8797254.7967350.7395555.2455295.0898
best272.5803479.3381884.4280815.0716423.4350641.5707
worst1307.06501834.66421561.12091877.95512318.16171532.6045

f8avg4.05814.15284.47054.63174.50154.0682
std0.42090.45810.30540.45360.33320.4385
best3.12663.51963.93653.45303.82553.1707
worst4.51455.00394.99945.01395.04444.5417

f9avg1.18031.23491.34491.32851.29191.2322
std0.07320.15090.13490.10520.09570.1046
best1.11621.12291.14851.21401.16491.0843
worst1.31331.58991.57671.56361.45801.4399

f10avg21.009221.014921.083921.377621.022121.1974
std0.02930.04210.08940.13050.05950.1520
best20.999820.999921.017021.125520.999921.0000
worst21.092721.133921.314921.609121.190021.4238

Article of the Year Award: Outstanding research contributions of 2020, as selected by our Chief Editors. Read the winning articles.