Journal of Engineering

Review Article

Alignment between Business Requirement, Business Process, and Software System: A Systematic Literature Review

Table 4

Synthesis of models used in each study.
IDYearReferenceBusiness requirementBusiness processSoftware system
S12017[17] UMLUML
S22016[13] UMLUML
S32016[18] 
S42015[19]UMLUML 
S52015[20] BPMNVarSOAML
S62015[21]GRLBPMN 
S72015[22]   
S82015[23] BPMNUML
S92015[24]CA 
S102014[25] BPMNUML and ERD
S112014[26]BPMN 
S122014[27]Business goal graphXBMCSMC
S132014[28]MAPBPMN 
S142014[29]BPMN 
S152013[30]BPMN 
S162013[31] BPMNSCA
S172013[32] BPMNBPMN
S182013[33] BPMN/tartarus metamodelTartarus metamodel
S192013[34]UMLUML
S202012[35] BPMNBPMN
S212012[36] BPMNSoaML
S222012[37]UML 
S232012[38] BPMN 
S242011[39] BPMN and e3 valueUML
S252011[40]TroposBPEL 
S262011[41]UMLBPMNUML
S272011[42]  UML
S282010[43] BPMN 
S292010[44]UMLUMLUML
S302010[45] BPMNSoaML
S312010[46] BPMN 
S322010[47]BPMNSoaML 
S332010[48]  UML
S342010[49]VMOSTBMM 
S352009[50]UMLUMLUML
S362009[51]BMM SoaML
S372009[52]UMLUML
S382009[53]   
S392009[54] BPMNSOA
S402008[55] BPMNUML
S412008[56]Use case (textual template)UML 
S422008[57]   
S432008[58]Tropos Tropos
S442008[59] BPEL 
S452008[60] OWL 
S462008[61] BPMNUML
S472008[62]   
S482008[63] e3 valueUML
S492008[64]Use case (tabular form)BPMN 
S502007[65]UMLUMLUML
S512007[66]   
S522007[67] BPEL 
S532007[68]GRLUML 
S542007[69]  UML
S552006[70]UMLUML 
S562006[71]RAD 
S572006[72] UML and EPCUML
S582006[73]Use case (tabular form)EPC 
S592005[74] MAPUML
S602004[75]TroposBPEL 
S612004[76] UMLUML
S622004[77]UMLUMLUML
S632003[78]UMLUMLUML