On the Heterogeneity of Existing Repositories of Movements Intended for the Evaluation of Fall Detection Systems

<div>Multiple comparison test of the means of the statistical characteristics of the movements labelled as “walking” in the seven datasets that contain this type of ADL (sensor located on the waist): (a) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.39034pt" id="M139" style="vertical-align:-3.42943pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -5.96091 26.7317 9.39034" width="26.7317pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M538 96L524 119C492 88 454 63 446 63C439 63 434 70 440 101C463 223 491 341 518 448H508L433 422L401 276C355 192 240 56 188 56C163 56 154 89 163 133C184 233 207 338 235 443L230 448L152 424L58 17C40 -60 23 -143 23 -185C23 -241 42 -261 63 -261C92 -261 117 -241 125 -227L124 -221C109 -209 89 -165 89 -103C89 -55 96 -13 105 26H107C121 -3 134 -12 151 -12C172 -12 194 -5 221 16C279 61 330 124 384 194H386C381 159 377 141 368 105C343 3 363 -12 383 -12C416 -12 486 35 538 96Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,6.89,3.132)"><path d="M442 495C434 557 427 602 423 639C405 645 348 665 284 665C142 665 55 579 55 469C55 373 127 319 229 267C304 227 348 190 348 131C348 67 309 25 248 25C152 25 93 138 73 202L38 190C45 130 58 46 68 21C81 15 100 7 128 -1C158 -10 193 -15 229 -15C375 -15 472 74 472 188C472 287 400 343 295 394C207 439 171 470 171 525C171 583 212 624 268 624C349 624 387 550 407 487L442 495Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,11.503,3.132)"><path d="M860 0V35C782 43 777 50 775 142L766 516C764 599 768 607 848 615V650H646L450 212L258 650H51V615C137 607 144 593 136 480L120 282C112 177 105 124 99 93C92 57 74 40 17 35V0H258V35C191 41 172 50 168 95C164 126 163 173 168 256L180 517H184L388 7H416L637 527H642L644 142C644 50 639 43 564 35V0H860Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,19.614,3.132)"><path d="M702 650H468V614C550 604 550 590 527 521C500 434 457 318 402 172H399C363 266 284 469 255 549C240 592 240 603 313 614V650H15V614C77 608 93 594 124 517C165 413 259 172 327 -11H377C455 195 546 422 579 500C619 595 637 607 702 614V650Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (b) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.45753pt" id="M140" style="vertical-align:-3.31394pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -6.14359 26.6012 9.45753" width="26.6012pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M548 455L523 469C505 448 490 439 461 439C416 439 374 447 316 447C144 447 23 310 23 161C23 47 89 -12 179 -12C312 -12 429 106 429 244C429 303 419 344 368 386L371 388C404 383 440 378 474 378C507 378 530 411 548 455ZM350 274C350 191 308 25 198 25C144 25 108 75 108 157C108 264 170 395 276 395C296 395 320 384 333 360C347 334 350 316 350 274Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,6.76,3.132)"><path d="M442 495C434 557 427 602 423 639C405 645 348 665 284 665C142 665 55 579 55 469C55 373 127 319 229 267C304 227 348 190 348 131C348 67 309 25 248 25C152 25 93 138 73 202L38 190C45 130 58 46 68 21C81 15 100 7 128 -1C158 -10 193 -15 229 -15C375 -15 472 74 472 188C472 287 400 343 295 394C207 439 171 470 171 525C171 583 212 624 268 624C349 624 387 550 407 487L442 495Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,11.373,3.132)"><path d="M860 0V35C782 43 777 50 775 142L766 516C764 599 768 607 848 615V650H646L450 212L258 650H51V615C137 607 144 593 136 480L120 282C112 177 105 124 99 93C92 57 74 40 17 35V0H258V35C191 41 172 50 168 95C164 126 163 173 168 256L180 517H184L388 7H416L637 527H642L644 142C644 50 639 43 564 35V0H860Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,19.484,3.132)"><path d="M702 650H468V614C550 604 550 590 527 521C500 434 457 318 402 172H399C363 266 284 469 255 549C240 592 240 603 313 614V650H15V614C77 608 93 594 124 517C165 413 259 172 327 -11H377C455 195 546 422 579 500C619 595 637 607 702 614V650Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (c) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.39034pt" id="M141" style="vertical-align:-3.42943pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -5.96091 12.1354 9.39034" width="12.1354pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M538 96L524 119C492 88 454 63 446 63C439 63 434 70 440 101C463 223 491 341 518 448H508L433 422L401 276C355 192 240 56 188 56C163 56 154 89 163 133C184 233 207 338 235 443L230 448L152 424L58 17C40 -60 23 -143 23 -185C23 -241 42 -261 63 -261C92 -261 117 -241 125 -227L124 -221C109 -209 89 -165 89 -103C89 -55 96 -13 105 26H107C121 -3 134 -12 151 -12C172 -12 194 -5 221 16C279 61 330 124 384 194H386C381 159 377 141 368 105C343 3 363 -12 383 -12C416 -12 486 35 538 96Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,6.89,3.132)"><path d="M482 498C482 606 448 710 328 710C138 710 24 416 24 218C24 99 58 -12 184 -12C373 -12 482 294 482 498ZM395 521C395 483 391 449 383 395H128C158 537 226 671 312 671C388 671 395 566 395 521ZM375 342C348 190 284 25 192 25C128 25 109 116 109 199C109 243 112 292 121 342H375Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (d) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="12.3132pt" id="M142" style="vertical-align:-6.35229pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -5.96091 41.8705 12.3132" width="41.8705pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M538 96L524 119C492 88 454 63 446 63C439 63 434 70 440 101C463 223 491 341 518 448H508L433 422L401 276C355 192 240 56 188 56C163 56 154 89 163 133C184 233 207 338 235 443L230 448L152 424L58 17C40 -60 23 -143 23 -185C23 -241 42 -261 63 -261C92 -261 117 -241 125 -227L124 -221C109 -209 89 -165 89 -103C89 -55 96 -13 105 26H107C121 -3 134 -12 151 -12C172 -12 194 -5 221 16C279 61 330 124 384 194H386C381 159 377 141 368 105C343 3 363 -12 383 -12C416 -12 486 35 538 96Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,6.89,3.132)"><path d="M442 495C434 557 427 602 423 639C405 645 348 665 284 665C142 665 55 579 55 469C55 373 127 319 229 267C304 227 348 190 348 131C348 67 309 25 248 25C152 25 93 138 73 202L38 190C45 130 58 46 68 21C81 15 100 7 128 -1C158 -10 193 -15 229 -15C375 -15 472 74 472 188C472 287 400 343 295 394C207 439 171 470 171 525C171 583 212 624 268 624C349 624 387 550 407 487L442 495Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,11.503,3.132)"><path d="M860 0V35C782 43 777 50 775 142L766 516C764 599 768 607 848 615V650H646L450 212L258 650H51V615C137 607 144 593 136 480L120 282C112 177 105 124 99 93C92 57 74 40 17 35V0H258V35C191 41 172 50 168 95C164 126 163 173 168 256L180 517H184L388 7H416L637 527H642L644 142C644 50 639 43 564 35V0H860Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,19.614,3.132)"><path d="M702 650H468V614C550 604 550 590 527 521C500 434 457 318 402 172H399C363 266 284 469 255 549C240 592 240 603 313 614V650H15V614C77 608 93 594 124 517C165 413 259 172 327 -11H377C455 195 546 422 579 500C619 595 637 607 702 614V650Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,26.108,5.233)"><path d="M318 -137C221 -59 159 100 159 272S220 600 318 680L294 710C146 612 80 452 80 273V272C80 91 146 -72 294 -168L318 -137Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,28.513,5.233)"><path d="M541 58L519 60C477 65 472 69 472 126V703C421 688 341 674 277 667V636C338 628 344 624 344 570V449C322 452 311 454 303 454C147 454 29 343 29 207C29 58 147 -12 233 -12C244 -12 259 -9 283 6L344 45V-13C423 10 517 22 541 26V58ZM344 80C322 66 307 64 289 64C243 64 171 111 171 234C171 386 248 412 271 412C301 412 328 395 344 360V80Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,32.082,5.233)"><path d="M148 517C189 517 220 549 220 587C220 627 189 657 149 657C111 657 78 627 78 587C78 549 111 517 148 517ZM285 0V32C225 39 220 45 220 114V454C164 438 98 425 37 418V389C85 381 92 378 92 312V114C92 43 86 39 28 32V0H285Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,34.007,5.233)"><path d="M52 442L22 406L27 394H92V108C92 45 88 39 30 32V0H302V32C227 39 220 45 220 108V394H321C335 401 339 431 335 442H220L218 477C214 562 214 597 220 616C224 631 233 642 251 642C279 642 311 617 335 593C345 583 355 583 369 593C384 605 395 618 399 629C406 644 405 659 391 673C374 689 349 701 309 703C261 697 226 679 190 649C133 601 112 553 105 531C97 507 92 486 92 464V442H52Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,36.166,5.233)"><path d="M52 442L22 406L27 394H92V108C92 45 88 39 30 32V0H302V32C227 39 220 45 220 108V394H321C335 401 339 431 335 442H220L218 477C214 562 214 597 220 616C224 631 233 642 251 642C279 642 311 617 335 593C345 583 355 583 369 593C384 605 395 618 399 629C406 644 405 659 391 673C374 689 349 701 309 703C261 697 226 679 190 649C133 601 112 553 105 531C97 507 92 486 92 464V442H52Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,38.326,5.233)"><path d="M291 272C291 452 228 611 76 710L51 680C147 602 211 444 211 272S151 -55 51 -137L76 -168C227 -66 291 91 291 272Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (e) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="11.2432pt" id="M143" style="vertical-align:-5.28229pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -5.96091 18.9586 11.2432" width="18.9586pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M538 96L524 119C492 88 454 63 446 63C439 63 434 70 440 101C463 223 491 341 518 448H508L433 422L401 276C355 192 240 56 188 56C163 56 154 89 163 133C184 233 207 338 235 443L230 448L152 424L58 17C40 -60 23 -143 23 -185C23 -241 42 -261 63 -261C92 -261 117 -241 125 -227L124 -221C109 -209 89 -165 89 -103C89 -55 96 -13 105 26H107C121 -3 134 -12 151 -12C172 -12 194 -5 221 16C279 61 330 124 384 194H386C381 159 377 141 368 105C343 3 363 -12 383 -12C416 -12 486 35 538 96Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,6.89,3.132)"><path d="M687 0V35C623 43 611 56 577 144C512 316 450 490 386 665L335 652L130 138C97 54 84 43 18 35V0H242V35C169 44 166 58 181 106C193 146 206 182 217 213H409C424 173 439 130 449 100C465 56 460 44 401 35V0H687ZM390 266H234C260 337 285 410 313 483H316L390 266Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,13.339,3.132)"><path d="M212 391V464C146 445 80 427 26 418V388C75 381 84 376 84 321V-128C84 -184 80 -192 16 -198V-230H294V-198C216 -191 212 -184 212 -127V0C227 -6 249 -12 274 -12C402 17 517 114 517 261C517 357 454 454 336 454C319 454 301 447 281 435L212 391ZM212 354C229 369 250 378 275 378C324 378 385 333 385 210C385 106 347 38 293 38C268 38 231 59 212 77V354Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (f) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="14.9947pt" id="M144" style="vertical-align:-6.35227pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -8.64243 42.3247 14.9947" width="42.3247pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M687 0V35C623 43 611 56 577 144C512 316 450 490 386 665L335 652L130 138C97 54 84 43 18 35V0H242V35C169 44 166 58 181 106C193 146 206 182 217 213H409C424 173 439 130 449 100C465 56 460 44 401 35V0H687ZM390 266H234C260 337 285 410 313 483H316L390 266Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0091,0,0,-0.0091,9.212,3.132)"><path d="M624 292C624 400 569 451 537 451C520 451 497 442 490 436L489 427C521 404 550 351 550 280C550 170 513 51 423 51C383 51 361 87 361 150C361 197 384 301 397 339L391 343L310 328C307 297 301 249 293 212C270 102 223 56 182 56C144 56 114 93 114 172C114 278 161 369 243 430L223 457C99 392 24 290 24 156C24 43 81 -12 141 -12C187 -12 247 32 286 88C295 31 325 -12 380 -12C431 -12 475 16 511 49C581 113 624 195 624 292Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,14.882,5.233)"><path d="M541 58L519 60C477 65 472 69 472 126V703C421 688 341 674 277 667V636C338 628 344 624 344 570V449C322 452 311 454 303 454C147 454 29 343 29 207C29 58 147 -12 233 -12C244 -12 259 -9 283 6L344 45V-13C423 10 517 22 541 26V58ZM344 80C322 66 307 64 289 64C243 64 171 111 171 234C171 386 248 412 271 412C301 412 328 395 344 360V80Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,18.45,5.233)"><path d="M148 517C189 517 220 549 220 587C220 627 189 657 149 657C111 657 78 627 78 587C78 549 111 517 148 517ZM285 0V32C225 39 220 45 220 114V454C164 438 98 425 37 418V389C85 381 92 378 92 312V114C92 43 86 39 28 32V0H285Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,20.375,5.233)"><path d="M52 442L22 406L27 394H92V108C92 45 88 39 30 32V0H302V32C227 39 220 45 220 108V394H321C335 401 339 431 335 442H220L218 477C214 562 214 597 220 616C224 631 233 642 251 642C279 642 311 617 335 593C345 583 355 583 369 593C384 605 395 618 399 629C406 644 405 659 391 673C374 689 349 701 309 703C261 697 226 679 190 649C133 601 112 553 105 531C97 507 92 486 92 464V442H52Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,22.535,5.233)"><path d="M52 442L22 406L27 394H92V108C92 45 88 39 30 32V0H302V32C227 39 220 45 220 108V394H321C335 401 339 431 335 442H220L218 477C214 562 214 597 220 616C224 631 233 642 251 642C279 642 311 617 335 593C345 583 355 583 369 593C384 605 395 618 399 629C406 644 405 659 391 673C374 689 349 701 309 703C261 697 226 679 190 649C133 601 112 553 105 531C97 507 92 486 92 464V442H52Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,24.694,5.233)"><path d="M318 -137C221 -59 159 100 159 272S220 600 318 680L294 710C146 612 80 452 80 273V272C80 91 146 -72 294 -168L318 -137Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,27.099,5.233)"><path d="M823 0V32C771 40 767 43 767 100V293C767 395 719 454 632 454C603 454 576 441 554 426C530 409 507 394 482 376C464 421 424 454 368 454C339 454 312 442 281 422C259 409 240 395 218 379V456C157 439 89 425 42 418V389C89 382 93 373 93 315V105C93 42 88 39 30 32V0H265V32C227 38 220 43 220 100V344C248 366 273 376 297 376C334 376 366 354 366 282V100C366 41 362 38 315 32V0H546V32C501 38 494 43 494 100V302C494 317 493 331 492 342C524 369 549 376 569 376C601 376 639 359 639 277V105C639 42 632 38 588 32V0H823Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,32.599,5.233)"><path d="M465 45L455 77C444 72 433 69 421 69C404 69 389 81 389 128V293C389 349 380 392 337 425C310 445 280 454 239 454C182 443 111 409 73 383C51 366 38 353 38 335C38 309 74 285 101 285C121 285 136 293 143 319C151 350 160 374 171 388C180 400 191 406 205 406C241 406 265 371 265 308V278C242 258 165 234 106 212C54 192 30 168 30 116C30 54 81 -12 165 -12C185 -12 232 21 270 46C274 34 281 21 295 9C308 -3 329 -12 356 -12L465 45ZM265 79C249 67 238 63 223 63C200 63 163 84 163 139C163 174 179 192 210 208C231 219 247 229 265 239V79Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,35.64,5.233)"><path d="M494 0V32C450 38 426 53 393 105L296 260C330 305 354 338 375 361C411 396 421 401 476 410V442H293V410C332 402 337 394 323 371C311 351 295 324 274 293L227 371C213 393 218 402 252 410V442H16V410C70 402 80 391 108 344L196 199C166 159 140 123 115 95C81 54 61 43 7 32V0H196V32C156 41 150 53 167 81C182 105 199 138 219 166L269 79C287 49 283 38 245 32V0H494Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.0065,0,0,-0.0065,38.784,5.233)"><path d="M291 272C291 452 228 611 76 710L51 680C147 602 211 444 211 272S151 -55 51 -137L76 -168C227 -66 291 91 291 272Z"></path></g></svg>.</span></div>

Journal of Healthcare Engineering

fig25

Figure 25

Figure 25: On the Heterogeneity of Existing Repositories of Movements Intended for the Evaluation of Fall Detection Systems 