|
| Study | Length of stay in days, mean (SD) | Post-operative mortality, number (%) | Follow-up, months, mean | Recurrence, number (%) | Long term mortality, number (%) |
|
| Dulucq et al. [10] | Open: 24.6 (9.61)
LC: 16.3 (4.73) | Open: 1 (3.6%)
LC: 0 | Open: 43 (25)
LC: 29.4 (20.2) | Open: 8 (28.5%)
LC: 1 (4.1%) | 1 year
Open: 8 (28.5%)
LC: 1 (4.1%) |
|
| Huscher et al. [11] | Open: 14.5 (4.6)
LC: 10.3 (3.6) | Open: 2 (6.9%)
LC: 1 (3.3%) | Open: 49.7 (5.2)
LC: 52.2 (26.5) | Open: 10 (34.5%)
LC: 11 (36.6%) | 5 years
Open: 21 (72.4%)
LC: 21 (70%) |
|
| Pugliese et al. [12] | Open: 18 (5)
LC: 10 (3) | Open: 3 (3%)
LC: 2 (4.2%) | N/E | N/E | N/E |
|
| Topal et al. [13] | N/E | Open: 1 (4.5%)
LC: 1 (2.6%) | N/E | N/E | N/E |
|
| Sarela et al. [14] | Open: 31.75 (22.95)
LC: 22.5 (15.98) | Open: 1 (9%)
LC: 1 (5.5%) | N/E | N/E | N/E |
|
| Chouillard et al. [15] | Open: 11.5 (6.5)
LC: 8 (4.5) | Open: 3 (3.8%)
LC: 0 | Open: 33 (10.8)
LC: 29 (10.3) | N/E | 3 years
Open: 45 (57%)
LC: 31 (60.7%) |
|
| Orsenigo et al. [16] | Open: 15 (12)
LC: 13 (9) | Open: 4 (1.4%)
LC: 3 (2%) | 33 both groups | N/E | N/E |
|
| Bouras et al. [17] | N/E | Open: 0
LC: 1 (0.4%) | Open: 44.1 (27.9)
LC: 43.3 (30.2) | Open: 2 (0.8%)
LC: 1 (1.1%) | 3 years
Open: 1 (1.1%)
LC: 2 (0.8%) |
|
| Scatizzi et al. [18] | Open: 9 (4.25)
LC: 7 (11) | Open: 0
LC: 0 | Open: 18 (8.7)
LC: 18 (8.7) | N/E | 1 year
Open: 13 (43.3%)
LC: 9 (30%) |
|
| Sica et al. [19] | N/E | Open: 1 (4%)
LC: 0 | N/E | Open: 13 (52%)
LC: 11 (50%) | 3 years
Open: 14 (56%)
LC: 12 (54.5%) |
|
| Siani et al. [20] | Open: 14.5 (3.1)
LC:10.5 (1.5) | N/E | Open: 32.6
LC: 31.9 | N/E | Open: 12 (48%)
LC: 11 (44%) |
|
| Cianchi et al. [21] | Open: 11.5 (0.8)
LC: 8.1 (0.5) | Open: 2 (4.9%)
LC: 1 (2.4%) | N/E | N/E | N/E |
|
| Mamidanna et al. [22] | Open: 14 (1.33)
LC: 11 (1.5) | Open: 594 (5.5%)
LC: 23 (4.8%) | N/E | N/E | N/E |
|
| Brenkman et al. [23] | N/E | Open: 128 (8%)
LC: 17 (6%) | N/E | N/E | 1 year
Open: 365 (22%)
LC: 61 (22%) |
|
