Memetic Algorithm with Local Search as Modified Swine Influenza Model-Based Optimization and Its Use in ECG Filtering

Table 4

Comparison of the experimental results of algorithms used for dimension 30.

30D

F

Fsph

Fs2.22

Fs1.2

Fs2.21

Fros

Fste

Fqua

Fs2.26

Fras

Fack

Fgri

Fpen1

Fpen2

GA-BLX

Mean

4.06𝑒−02

9.10𝑒−02

1.29𝑒+02

3.97𝑒−01

4.72𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

6.95𝑒−02

−1.60𝑒−04

2.94𝑒+00

5.47𝑒+00

2.54𝑒−02

3.24𝑒−04

2.96𝑒−03

STD

1.72𝑒−02

1.11𝑒−01

3.89𝑒+01

5.91𝑒−02

3.56𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

4.29𝑒−02

7.78𝑒−04

3.42𝑒+00

6.03𝑒−01

1.68𝑒−02

4.74𝑒−04

3.70𝑒−03

GA-SBX

Mean

5.98𝑒−02

1.64𝑒−02

3.12𝑒+01

4.52𝑒−01

5.78𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

1.29𝑒−01

1.81𝑒−09

8.86𝑒−01

1.05𝑒+01

1.96𝑒−02

2.31𝑒−04

3.38𝑒−03

STD

2.99𝑒−02

5.16𝑒−03

1.32𝑒+01

6.06𝑒−02

3.40𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

5.48𝑒−02

6.21𝑒−09

2.67𝑒+00

1.68𝑒+00

2.14𝑒−02

4.53𝑒−04

4.17𝑒−03

SIMBO-T

Mean

1.82𝑒−09

4.71𝑒−09

2.05𝑒−09

3.24𝑒−09

2.90𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

4.29𝑒−14

1.25𝑒+04

2.72𝑒−09

4.42𝑒−09

2.89𝑒−09

1.67𝑒+00

3.00𝑒+00

STD

2.02𝑒−09

3.2𝑒−09

2.48𝑒−09

3.00𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

2.14𝑒−13

0.00𝑒+00

2.56𝑒−09

2.73𝑒−09

2.90𝑒−09

2.27𝑒−16

9.06𝑒−16

SIMBO-V

Mean

2.13𝑒−09

4.81𝑒−09

2.07𝑒−09

4.00𝑒−09

2.90𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

9.62𝑒−20

1.26𝑒+04

3.18𝑒−09

5.01𝑒−09

1.92𝑒−09

1.67𝑒+00

3.00𝑒+00

STD

2.38𝑒−09

3.05𝑒−09

2.65𝑒−09

2.84𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

3.58𝑒−19

0.00𝑒+00

3.33𝑒−09

3.42𝑒−09

2.92𝑒−09

2.27𝑒−16

9.06𝑒−16

SIMBO-Q

Mean

1.29𝑒−09

2.14𝑒−09

1.57𝑒−09

2.09𝑒−09

2.90𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

6.36𝑒−27

1.26𝑒+04

1.51𝑒−09

1.63𝑒−09

9.21𝑒−10

1.67𝑒+00

3.00𝑒+00

STD

1.73𝑒−09

2.58𝑒−09

2.64𝑒−09

2.01𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

3.18𝑒−26

0.00𝑒+00

2.70𝑒−09

1.55𝑒−09

1.47𝑒−09

2.27𝑒−16

9.06𝑒−16

mSIMBO-T

Mean

3.10𝑒−09

4.96𝑒−09

1.30𝑒−09

4.65𝑒−09

2.90𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

1.73𝑒−12

1.25𝑒+04

1.98𝑒−09

4.52𝑒−09

2.00𝑒−09

1.66𝑒+00

3.00𝑒+00

STD

3.14𝑒−09

2.51𝑒−09

1.52𝑒−09

3.09𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

8.64𝑒−12

0.00𝑒+00

2.57𝑒−09

3.22𝑒−09

2.51𝑒−09

2.27𝑒−16

9.06𝑒−16

mSIMBO-V

Mean

2.16𝑒−09

4.44𝑒−09

2.61𝑒−09

5.59𝑒−09

2.90𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

3.46𝑒−21

1.25𝑒+04

2.63𝑒−09

3.21𝑒−09

2.68𝑒−09

1.67𝑒+00

3.00𝑒+00

STD

2.53𝑒−09

2.51𝑒−09

2.48𝑒−09

2.98𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

1.73𝑒−20

0.00𝑒+00

2.72𝑒−09

2.21𝑒−09

2.75𝑒−09

2.27𝑒−16

9.06𝑒−16

mSIMBO-Q

Mean

1.24𝑒−09

2.40𝑒−09

4.80𝑒−10

2.03𝑒−09

2.90𝑒+01

0.00𝑒+00

7.48𝑒−26

1.25𝑒+04

1.53𝑒−09

1.70𝑒−09

4.62𝑒−10

1.67𝑒+00

3.00𝑒+00

STD

1.90𝑒−09

2.45𝑒−09

8.02𝑒−10

2.37𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

3.74𝑒−25

0.00𝑒+00

2.26𝑒−09

2.26𝑒−09

5.80𝑒−10

2.27𝑒−16

9.06𝑒−16

MA-BLX-T

Mean

3.05𝑒−09

6.19𝑒−09

3.30𝑒−09

4.79𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

5.19𝑒−02

4.76𝑒+02

3.25𝑒−09

5.10𝑒−09

3.76𝑒−09

1.40𝑒−04

1.36𝑒−01

STD

2.67𝑒−09

2.85𝑒−09

3.03𝑒−09

3.17𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

4.17𝑒−02

1.51𝑒+02

3.20𝑒−09

2.77𝑒−09

3.43𝑒−09

1.14𝑒−04

4.90𝑒−02

MA-BLX-V

Mean

3.56𝑒−09

4.86𝑒−09

3.95𝑒−09

5.51𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

5.97𝑒−02

4.15𝑒+02

2.93𝑒−09

3.63𝑒−09

2.20𝑒−09

7.05𝑒−04

1.25𝑒−01

STD

3.22𝑒−09

2.59𝑒−09

3.18𝑒−09

2.86𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

4.32𝑒−02

1.06𝑒+02

2.59𝑒−09

2.81𝑒−09

2.77𝑒−09

1.76𝑒−03

3.87𝑒−02

MA-BLX-Q

Mean

2.78𝑒−09

4.83𝑒−09

3.42𝑒−09

5.19𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

6.09𝑒−02

4.31𝑒+02

4.72𝑒−09

5.42𝑒−09

2.99𝑒−09

5.28𝑒−04

1.13𝑒−01

STD

2.87𝑒−09

2.86𝑒−09

3.28𝑒−09

3.03𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

4.54𝑒−02

8.73𝑒+01

3.45𝑒−09

3.12𝑒−09

2.81𝑒−09

2.14𝑒−03

4.54𝑒−02

MA-SBX-T

Mean

3.35𝑒−09

4.38𝑒−09

2.16𝑒−09

3.56𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

7.20𝑒−02

−8.5𝑒−10

2.70𝑒−09

3.95𝑒−09

2.68𝑒−09

4.43𝑒−01

1.00𝑒−01

STD

3.36𝑒−09

2.85𝑒−09

2.63𝑒−09

2.95𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

4.06𝑒−02

6.98𝑒−09

2.85𝑒−09

2.60𝑒−09

2.67𝑒−09

1.16𝑒−01

1.83𝑒−03

MA-SBX-V

Mean

1.98𝑒−09

3.83𝑒−09

2.27𝑒−09

4.54𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

4.22𝑒−02

−3.00𝑒−10

2.73𝑒−09

3.46𝑒−09

2.32𝑒−09

4.41𝑒−01

1.00𝑒−01

STD

2.16𝑒−09

2.56𝑒−09

2.61𝑒−09

3.42𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

3.06𝑒−02

6.30𝑒−09

2.64𝑒−09

2.76𝑒−09

2.97𝑒−09

1.78𝑒−01

9.08𝑒−05

MA-SBX-Q

Mean

2.32𝑒−09

5.05𝑒−09

2.38𝑒−09

4.92𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

6.60𝑒−02

−4.90𝑒−10

2.86𝑒−09

3.59𝑒−09

2.37𝑒−09

3.96𝑒−01

1.01𝑒−01

STD

3.45𝑒−09

2.84𝑒−09

2.77𝑒−09

3.18𝑒−09

0.00𝑒+00

0.00𝑒+00

6.33𝑒−02

6.97𝑒−09

3.29𝑒−09

2.58𝑒−09

2.47𝑒−09

1.73𝑒−01

4.20𝑒−03