Inflammatory Mediators in Periodontal PathogenesisView this Special Issue
Research Article | Open Access
Susanne Schulz, Natalie Pütz, Elisa Jurianz, Hans-Günter Schaller, Stefan Reichert, "Are There Any Common Genetic Risk Markers for Rheumatoid Arthritis and Periodontal Diseases? A Case-Control Study", Mediators of Inflammation, vol. 2019, Article ID 2907062, 11 pages, 2019. https://doi.org/10.1155/2019/2907062
Are There Any Common Genetic Risk Markers for Rheumatoid Arthritis and Periodontal Diseases? A Case-Control Study
Background. Several studies suggest that there is a biologically plausible connection between rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and periodontal diseases (PD). Both disorders are characterized as multifactorial diseases potentially sharing common risk factors. Based on the inflammatory nature of RA and PD, the impact of genetic variations of genes of the immune system on both diseases was studied in this study. Materials and Methods. We conducted a case-control study () comparing 101 RA patients suffering from periodontal disease of different severities (no/mild PD vs. severe PD) with 100 systemically healthy controls without RA and severe PD. The genotype, allele, and haplotype distributions of 22 SNPs of 13 pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines were assessed applying sequence-specific PCR. Results. Evaluating the impact of cytokine SNPs in RA, we identified the G allele of rs1801275 in IL4Rα () and the G allele of rs361525 in TNFα () as disease-associated risk factors in bivariate analyses. In multivariate analyses, these significant associations could not be proven. The A allele of rs2430561 in IFNγ was indicative for severe periodontitis among the patients with rheumatoid arthritis (). Investigating the impact of rs2430561 in IFNγ on comorbidity using binary logistic regression analyses, the A allele was confirmed as an independent risk factor for severe periodontal disease and RA (). Conclusions. These results emphasize the association of genetic variations in proinflammatory cytokines (TNFα and IFNγ) and cytokine receptor (IL4Rα) and RA and periodontal diseases. In multivariate analyses, the A allele of IFNγ was proven to be a significant marker of RA and PD comorbidities. The study broadens the knowledge about disease-specific differences in genetic composition and provides an improved understanding of a possible association of both diseases.
A relationship between periodontal disease (PD) and rheumatoid arthritis (RA) has been emphasized in several clinical studies [1–4]. Both diseases are described as chronic destructive inflammatory diseases sharing remarkable pathological and clinical similarities at cellular and molecular levels [5–7]. Patients suffering from rheumatoid arthritis are more likely to exhibit severe periodontitis or missing teeth than healthy controls [8–10]. On the other hand, patients with periodontal disease were shown to be more susceptible to RA compared with healthy persons . There is a dose-dependent association pattern between severity of periodontitis and RA disease activity . Moreover, the nonsurgical treatment of periodontal disease was shown to have a positive effect on rheumatic complaints [12, 13], and vice versa, the therapy of RA was proven to have a beneficial impact on periodontitis . However, the possible underlying link between both diseases is not completely understood.
An important early clinical sign specific for RA is the occurrence of anti-citrullinated protein antibodies (ACPAs) . It was demonstrated that the periodontopathogen Porphyromonas gingivalis (P.g.) has the unique capacity of expression of peptidylarginine deiminases, responsible for protein citrullination . This fact corroborated the assumption of the involvement of periodontal infection in the aetiology of RA . Genetic constellation (HLA-DRB04) was supposed to be associated with a higher odds ratio for the occurrence for borderline significance for ACPA (anti-CCP) [S. Reichert, personal communication]. However, no conclusive scientific evidence regarding the role of periodontal pathogens in RA was provided so far. Furthermore, it is recognised that increased inflammatory burden accompanied by PD and RA can mutually influence each other and affect further inflammatory diseases . Of particular importance in this context are common features of regulation and dysregulation of inflammatory response [9, 18]. Periodontal disease and rheumatoid arthritis are characterized by excessive chronic inflammatory reactions leading to infiltration of T and B lymphocytes, neutrophils, and monocytes . Both diseases are characterised by an imbalance between proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory cytokines [7, 20–22]. This complex interplay is a determining fact for PD and RA, respectively, and leads to the maintenance of inflammation and induction of bone resorption, joint destruction, and erosion [7, 23].
In recent years, a lot of clinical association studies were conducted in order to confirm the impact of genetic variants on RA [24, 25] and PD [26, 27]. Genetic studies reveal that both diseases are characterized by shared genetic risk factors such as a MHC class II HLA-DRB1 allele  or cytokine SNPs, including the KCNQ1 gene .
These considerations lead to the hypothesis of a shared genetic profile associated with a higher susceptibility to RA and periodontal disease. In order to support this hypothesis, we evaluated a panel of pro- and anti-inflammatory genes (IL1α, IL1β, IL1R, IL2, IL4, IL1RA, IL-4Rα, IL6, IL10, IL12, IFNγ, TGFβ, and TNFα) possibly involved in the aetiology of both inflammatory diseases. We assessed allele, genotype, and haplotype frequencies of these genes in RA patients suffering from PD of different severities and systemically healthy controls without RA and severe PD.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Study Population
In the case-control study, 201 unrelated subjects of Caucasian origin were included. In general, patients and controls were only included if they had a minimum age of 18 years (patients) or 30 years (controls), were not pregnant, and had not taken antibiotics in the past 3 months or undergone subgingival scaling and root planning procedures 6 months prior to the examination. The patients and controls had no known medical or general health conditions that might profoundly contribute to development of periodontitis (except RA in RA patients). In accordance with this, subjects were not included if they were suffering from diabetes mellitus type I or II, Morbus Crohn, coronary heart disease, lupus erythematosus, Behçet disease, or oral pemphigus or pemphigoid or if they developed gingival overgrowth due to specific drugs such as antiepileptics, calcium-channel blockers, or cyclosporine. The controls were excluded if they took anti-inflammatory drugs regularly. The medication of RA patients with nonsteroidal or anti-inflammatory drugs was recorded. During the course of anamnesis age, current or past diseases as well as medication and smoking status were assessed. The medication included nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs: 50%), disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs: 70%), and biologicals (42%). The periodontal examination comprised the assessment of approximal plaque index (API) , the percentage of sites with bleeding upon probing (BOP), pocket depth (PD: distance between the gingival margin and apical stop of the pocket), and the number of missing teeth. To determine the mean clinical attachment loss (CAL: distance between the cement-enamel junction and apical stop of the probe) in cases and controls, six sites around each tooth were measured, and the maximum values were recorded.
The control group is comprised of 100 subjects not suffering from rheumatoid arthritis. This group was recruited consecutively at the Department of Operative Dentistry and Periodontology of the Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg from 2005 until 2009. The periodontal examination was carried out by an experienced periodontist using a non-pressure-sensitive periodontal probe (PCPUNC156, Hu-Friedy, Rotterdam, Netherlands). All controls exhibit no or mild periodontitis according to the consensus report for “definition of a periodontitis case and disease progression in risk factor research” . A “mild periodontitis” was defined as the presence of clinical attachment loss of ≥3 mm in ≥2 nonadjacent teeth. Controls with vestibular values of clinical attachment caused by traumatic tooth brushing or orthodontic therapy, CAL according overhanging subgingival restorations, or primary endodontic lesions were not considered as cases of periodontitis. Furthermore, pseudo pockets on the last molars with a depth of >3.5 mm were not considered as a periodontitis case .
The patient group includes 101 subjects with diagnosed rheumatoid arthritis according to current criteria for classifying rheumatoid arthritis . RA was diagnosed and treated at the Clinic of Internal Medicine II, Department of Rheumatology, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg (Prof. G. Keyßer and Dr. C. Schäfer), at the Department of Rheumatology “Rheumahaus Potsdam” (Dr. M. Bohl-Bühler and Dr. S. Reckert) and at three private practices in Magdeburg and Halle (Saale). From 2012 until 2016, the RA patients were included consecutively without consideration of periodontal status. For periodontal assessment, pressure-sensitive periodontal probes (TPS-probe Vivicare, Vivadent, Schaan, Liechtenstein, or DB764R Aesculap AG & Co. KG, Tuttlingen, Germany) were used. The dental examiners were instructed and trained in the implementation of both periodontal probes. The examiners were educated on a phantom model A-PB (frasaco GmbH, Tettnang, Germany) and under clinical conditions. According to the consensus report, a severe periodontitis case was defined as proximal attachment loss of ≥5 mm in >30% of the teeth . Mild periodontitis was defined as mentioned above.
2.2. Genetic Investigations
For genetic investigations, fresh venous blood was obtained from the subjects in ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid- (EDTA-) treated tubes. Preparation of genomic DNA was carried out using a QIAamp blood extraction kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) in accordance with the manufacturer’s manual.
The analysis of SNPs was carried out using the Cytokine Genotyping array CTS-PCR-SSP Tray Kit (Collaborative Transplant Study, Department of Transplantation Immunology of the University Clinic of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany). PCRs were performed with sequence-specific primers for the detection of genotypes and haplotypes. A fragment of 440 bp of the human C-reactive protein and 90 bp fragment of the human β-globin gene was coamplified as positive controls, respectively.
For every PCR, 10 ml of a Mastermix containing 1UTaq-Polymerase (Thermo Scientific, Waltham, USA), 100 ng genomic DNA, and PCR reaction buffer were added. PCR was performed in an Eppendorf Mastercycler Gradient (Eppendorf, Wesseling-Berzdorf, Germany) (2 min. 94°C; 10 cycles: 15 s 94°C, 1 min. 64°C, 30 s 72°C; 20 cycles: 15 s 94°C, 50 s 61°C, 30 s 72°C). After agarose gel electrophoresis, the resulting pattern was evaluated visually. In Table 1, the detected SNPs are displayed.
2.3. Molecular Biological Assessment of Porphyromonas gingivalis
Subgingival plaque samples were taken before subgingival scaling was carried out. The microbial samples were collected from the deepest pocket of each quadrant (insertion of a sterile paper point for 20 s) and pooled in one tube. Bacterial DNA was isolated applying the QIAamp® DNA Mini Kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) according to the manufacturer’s manual. The subgingival occurrence of P.g. was detected using the micro-Ident® test of HAIN-Diagnostik (Nehren, Germany) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. The method was described in detail in .
2.4. Statistical Analyses
Statistical analyses were carried out using commercially available software (SPSS v.25.0 package, IBM, Chicago, IL). Values of were considered significant. Continuous data were assessed for normal distribution using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. These data were reported as deviation (normal distributed values) or median, 25th/75th interquartiles (values not normally distributed). For the statistical evaluation of continuous variables, Student’s -test (normal distributed values), Mann–Whitney test, or Kruskal-Wallis test (values not normally distributed) was used. Categorical variables were plotted in contingency tables and evaluated using the chi-square test and Yates continuity correction. If the expected cell frequency was <5, Fisher’s exact test was applied.
Binary logistic regression analysis was used for investigating the impact of polymorphic variants on the occurrence of PD or RA considering established confounders.
3.1. Clinical Evaluation
We performed a case-control study in order to evaluate the impact of genetic variants in selected pro- and anti-inflammatory genes (Table 1) in association with RA. We involved a control group of systemically healthy controls without RA and severe PD () and a group of patients with RA () suffering from periodontitis of different severities (severe periodontitis: ; no/mild periodontitis: ) in our study. The demographical and periodontal characteristics are displayed in Table 2. In general, patients suffering from RA were significantly older, were more often of female gender, and were more often smokers than probands without RA. Corresponding to the inclusion criteria, RA patients exhibited the more severe dental parameters including probing depth and clinical attachment loss. Subdividing the group of RA patients according to their periodontal status, it was obvious that patients suffering from severe periodontitis were more often males. In terms of age and smoking status, no significant differences were shown, although RA patients with severe periodontitis were older () and more frequently smokers () than RA patients with no or mild periodontitis. As expected, all RA patients suffering from severe periodontitis showed the more severe periodontal characteristics.
Proximal attachment loss of ≥5 mm in ≥30% of teeth present. Statistical comparisons were made by the chi-square test including Yates correction for categorical variables. Continuous variables were analyzed by the Mann–Whitney test and presented as median (25th/75th interquartiles (IQR); values not normally distributed) or Student’s -test and mean (standard deviation (SD); normal distribution).
3.2. Genetic Variants in Rheumatoid Arthritis
Furthermore, we evaluated the impact of genetic variants in selected pro- and anti-inflammatory genes in association with occurrence of RA. Significantly, more G allele carriers of rs1801275 in IL4Rα and of rs361525 in TNFα were in the group of patients suffering from RA compared to the group of probands without RA (Table 3).
Statistical comparisons were made by the chi-square test including Yates correction. RA patients: patients with rheumatoid arthritis.
In binary logistic regression analyses, including age, gender, smoking status, and the occurrence of P.g. as confounding factors, the G allele of IL4Rα () and the G allele of TNFα SNPs () could not be proven as independently associated with RA. Increasing age, female gender, smoking, and the occurrence of P.g., however, could be shown as significant risk factors for RA in these complex risk models (Table 4).
Age, gender, smoking status, and the occurrence of Porphyromonas gingivalis (P.g.) were considered as confounding factors.
All other investigated genotypes, alleles, and haplotypes of pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines were not found to be in association with rheumatoid arthritis in our study.
3.3. Cytokine Allele, Genotype, and Haplotype Frequencies in Association with Periodontitis
In a second evaluation, we tested possible associations between genetic variants and the severity of periodontal disease in the group of RA patients. No significant associations could be proven for all allele, genotype, and haplotype distributions investigated, except for IFNγ SNP rs240561. Patients suffering from more severe periodontitis were more frequently A allele carriers of this genetic variant than patients with no or mild periodontitis (, Table 5). In a multivariate risk model, higher age, male gender, smoking, and the higher incidence of P.g. but not the A allele of IFNγ SNP rs240561 had predictive value for severe periodontal disease. However, comparing patients with comorbidity of RA and PD with probands without RA, the A allele was significantly associated with both diseases in bivariate (Table 5, ) and multivariate analyses (Table 6, ).
Statistical comparisons were made by the chi-square test including Yates correction. PD: periodontal disease.
(a) RA patients with severe PD vs. RA patients who do not have severe PD
(b) Patients with comorbidity of RA and severe PD vs. controls without both, RA and severe PD
Age, gender, smoking status, and the occurrence of Porphyromonas gingivalis (P.g.) were considered as confounding factors.
Over the last years, the involvement of genetic variants of cytokines as potential markers for disease susceptibility, progression, therapeutic success, and prognosis of PD and RA received particular attention [35, 36]. Based on the multifactorial pathogenesis of both diseases, it can be expected that genetic variants have rather a modulating than a determinant influence in this context. However, epidemiological studies showed that the genetic contribution to rheumatoid arthritis and periodontitis is substantial and may account for 50% of the RA  and PD risk profile, respectively [38, 39].
Therefore, we investigated possible associations between a panel of genetic variants of pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokine genes, including allele, genotype, and haplotype distributions, and RA or PD in bivariate and multivariate models considering further established risk markers for both diseases.
4.1. Clinical Evaluation
In the present association study, we included a group of controls without RA and severe periodontitis and a group of RA patients suffering from periodontitis of different severities (no/mild or sever periodontitis). As shown in Table 2, RA patients were significantly older than controls (). It is well established, that the incidence of rheumatoid arthritis increases with age . Especially, women in their fourth and fifth decades are more affected by RA . Also in our study, women were shown to be more susceptible to RA than men (Table 2, ). Another major risk factor of RA is cigarette smoking. Smoking increases the RA risk especially in patients with genetic predisposition . This fact was confirmed by our study, since RA patients were significantly more often smokers than controls without RA (Table 2, ). As it was demonstrated by different studies, patients suffering from rheumatoid arthritis exhibit the more severe periodontal symptoms including probing depth and clinical attachment loss [6, 8].
Within the RA group, the patients were subdivided according their periodontal status. Patients suffering from severe periodontitis were older (n.s.), more often smokers (n.s.), and males () compared to patients without or with mild periodontitis (Table 2). Since age, smoking, and the male gender are major risk factors of severe periodontitis, these tendencies were in accordance with established risk profile of periodontal disease .
4.2. Genetic Variants in Rheumatoid Arthritis
A lot of genetic variants have been reported to be implicated in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis [43, 44]. In this study, the G allele of SNP rs1801275 in the IL4Rα gene and the G allele of SNP rs361525 in the TNFα gene were shown to be associated with RA out of 22 polymorphic variants in 13 cytokine genes (Table 3). However, considering further risk markers of RA, these associations of SNPs in IL4Rα as well as in the TNFα gene and RA did not remain significant. This might indicate that factors like increasing age, the female gender, smoking, and the occurrence of P.g. were more strongly associated with RA implying a minor role of these genetic variants in our study.
Studies investigating the impact of rs1801275 in the IL4Rα gene in RA revealed contradictory results [45–49]. In accordance with our results, Moreno et al. could confirm the G allele of rs1801275 as a risk factor for rheumatoid arthritis in RF positive patients . On the other hand, other studies showed an impact of AG and AA genotypes  and A allele , respectively, on the development of RA. Furthermore, in a meta-analysis, no association of this genetic variant was demonstrated for rheumatoid arthritis  and for patients with juvenile idiopathic arthritis . Since the inclusion criteria varied considerably, no consistent risk pattern regarding rs1801275 could be generated. It could be conceivable that genetic markers of IL4Rα could influence its gene expression. This could be of great importance since IL4Rα mediates the intracellular signalling cascades elicited by the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL4, a major regulator of the TH1/TH2 balance. However, functional studies could not prove a genetic influence of this polymorphism on gene expression in patients suffering from allergic asthma  or systemic sclerosis . Further studies are needed in order to investigate the potential functional role of this polymorphism in rheumatoid arthritis.
Besides rs1801275 in the IL4Rα gene, a genetic variant in the TNFα (G allele of rs361525) gene was shown to be associated with RA in our study. In a meta-analysis by Lee and Bae, the impact of A allele of rs361525 on RA was demonstrated evaluating 10 case-control studies including patients of different ethnicities . However, taking only 6 studies conducted in Europe into consideration, the G allele was more frequent among RA patients () . These results obviously imply that the disease-related genetic characteristic of rs361525 is dependent on ethnicity. A possible genetic influence of rs361525 on TNFα expression was studied intensively leading to controversial outcomes [53–55]. However, in patients with rheumatoid arthritis  or osteoarthritis , the GG genotype and G allele of rs361525 were associated with increased TNFα expression, respectively. Therefore, in our RA group, the higher frequency of G allele carriers of rs361525 could be accompanied with higher TNFα expression indicative for RA . Of particular importance for the RA therapy is the treatment with TNFα antagonists . Indeed, it could be demonstrated that genetic variants in TNFα, including rs361525, were associated with responsiveness to TNFα treatment [60, 61].
Our results support the thesis of an association of genetic variants in cytokine genes (IL4Rα and TNFα) with RA. However, in multivariate analysis, a corresponding genetic influence could not be proven (Table 4). This might imply that other risk factors are stronger disease-determining markers and that these genetic variants play a minor role in the aetiology of RA. And indeed, higher age, the female gender, smoking, and the subgingival occurrence of Porphyromonas gingivalis were significant predictors in binary logistic regression analysis. These results are in accordance with the established risk model of RA [19, 40, 41].
4.3. Cytokine Allele, Genotype, and Haplotype Frequencies in Association with Periodontitis within the Test Group
A lot of case-control studies, meta-analyses, and GWAS were conducted in order to evaluate the impact of genetic variants on the aetiology of aggressive and chronic periodontites with variable results [62–64].
A shared genetic background was assumed to be the basis among others for the biological plausible link between periodontitis and further inflammatory diseases, including RA. Therefore, studies were performed in order to identify common genetic risk factors for both diseases [14, 29, 65]. Applying the candidate gene approach, SNPs in IL1β (rs1143634)  and KCNQ1 (rs2237892)  were shown to be associated with comorbidity of rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease.
Also in this study, possible associations of genetic characteristics in cytokine genes and the severity of periodontal disease in RA patients were assessed. Out of the panel of 22 SNPs in 13 cytokine genes, we identified the A allele of SNP rs240561 in IFNγ as a risk indicator for severe periodontitis in RA patients (Table 5). Furthermore, evaluating patients suffering from RA and severe PD, the A allele was a significant predictor for comorbidity also considering further confounders (Table 6).
The scientific knowledge about possible association of rs2430561 to PD [66, 67] and/or RA [68–70] is highly inconsistent. Regarding possible association of this SNP and the susceptibility to PD, a meta-analysis was performed . However, this study failed to prove a genetic association. The IFNγ SNP rs2430561 was demonstrated to be in complete linkage disequilibrium with a polymorphic microsatellite located in the first intron of the IFNγ gene with susceptibility to RA [68; 72]. In contrast, other studies failed to confirm this genetic association to RA susceptibility or severity [69, 70].
In the electrophoretic mobility shift assay, this SNP was demonstrated to be located in a putative nuclear transcription factor NF-κB binding site influencing IFNγ expression . Therefore, studies were conducted in order to assess the influence of this SNP on IFNγ expression resulting in different outcomes [72–75]. However, the inclusion and exclusion criteria of patients as well as the chosen methodological design varied widely. Several studies showed a lower expression associated with the A allele of IFNγ SNP rs2430561 . In contrast, Prabhu Anand et al. could prove a higher IFNγ expression in peripheral blood mononuclear cells accompanied with AA genotype in healthy subjects . Clinical studies investigating the impact of the IFNγ level on periodontitis showed an increased expression in saliva  and gingival biopsies in chronic periodontitis as well as in gingival crevicular fluid  in periodontal active sites . Also, patients with rheumatoid arthritis were shown to exhibit higher levels of IFNγ in mononuclear cells and tissues from affected organs . IFNγ and its associated signalling pathways were demonstrated to promote the breakdown of soft and hard tissues of the periodontium and induce bone loss [80, 81]. IFNγ is involved in the adaptive immune response due to the activation of macrophages and differentiation of T helper cells  including the induction of Th1 cytokines via the JAK/STAT signalling pathway . These IFNγ-associated pathways are important characteristics in the aetiology of inflammatory diseases including PD  and RA , respectively. And indeed, the T cell-mediated increased IFNγ expression induced by periodontal infections with P.g. or Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans was shown to be promoting rheumatoid arthritis . Therefore, IFNγ and its functional important genetic variant rs2430561 could provide a biological plausible link between both inflammatory diseases.
4.4. Study Limitations
The present study was performed as a case-control study. It was conducted to establish assumptions of possible associations between genetic variants and periodontitis and rheumatoid arthritis, respectively. However, considering the study design, the verification of these assumptions is not realizable.
Due to one of the strengths of the present study, the homogeneous ethnicity, and due to the strict inclusion and exclusion criteria of the study participants, the sample size was relatively small. This may result in potential bias because of increasing the likelihood of a type II error skewing the outcomes. Therefore, the present investigation could only be considered as a pilot case-control study, and the drawn conclusions should be confirmed and extended in a large-scale cohort. Furthermore, the persons involved in the study are not necessarily representatives of the population as a whole.
In our study, 22 SNPs were tested. In chi2 tests, significant associations between genetic variants and PD/RA were assessed (Tables 3 and 5). However, if multiple hypotheses are evaluated, the likelihood of incorrectly rejecting the null hypothesis increases, which potentially leads to type I errors. Therefore, a statistical correction for multiple testing should be applied. After Bonferroni correction, the results of Tables 3 and 5 did not remain significant. Therefore, the drawn conclusion should be interpreted with caution.
Because of the integration of subjects from two settings, different methods of the determination of BOP, PD, and CAL were applied and were subject to possible biases. For RA patients, two different pressure-sensitive periodontal probes were used. The overall reproducibility of both probes has been already confirmed in previous studies [85, 86].
Control subjects were dental assessed using a non-pressure-sensitive periodontal probe. It has already been highlighted in earlier studies that both, non-pressure-sensitive periodontal probes and pressure-sensitive probes, are reliable tools for reproducible pocket depth measurements receiving a comparable error rate [87–89].
Finally, the data presented can be considered applicable for Caucasian individuals of central Germany only and must therefore be interpreted with caution. Extrapolation to the general population is not rationally supported.
Our results strengthen the thesis that SNP rs2430561 of the proinflammatory cytokine IFNγ may constitute a shared genetic risk factor for PD and RA. This might provide new arguments for the hypothesis of shared inflammatory processes underlying PD and RA. Further studies have to be conducted in order to replicate these findings in larger cohorts.
|API:||Approximal plaque index|
|BOP:||Bleeding upon probing|
|CAL:||Clinical attachment loss|
|DMARD:||Disease-modifying antirheumatic drug|
|GWAS:||Genome-wide association study|
|IL4Rα:||Interleukin 4 receptor alpha|
|NSAID:||Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug|
|SNP:||Single nuclear polymorphism|
|TNFα:||Tumor necrosis factor alpha|
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
The ethics committee of the Medical School of Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg approved the study. The investigations were carried out in accordance with the ethical guidelines of the “Declaration of Helsinki” and its amendment in “Tokyo and Venice.”
All participants signed their written consent to participate in this study. All authors have given their consent for publication.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
SS, HGS, and SR participated in study design and evaluation. EJ and NP examined the patients and controls regarding their periodontal status and were responsible for the collection of subgingival plaque and venous blood samples. SS and NP analyzed subgingival plaque samples. The cytokine genotyping was carried out by SS and NP.
The authors thank all individuals for their cooperation in the present study. Furthermore, we greatly appreciate the efforts of the rheumatologists Dr. C. Weimann (Magdeburg) and Dr. Th. Linde, Dr. A. Liebhaber, and Dr. R. Schobeß (Halle) in the recruitment and diagnosis of RA patients in their private practices. Dr. M. Haffner was thanked for the periodontological examination of these RA patients. We acknowledge the financial support within the funding programme Open Access Publishing by the German Research Foundation (DFG). The study was supported by the Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg.
- V. M. A. Araújo, I. M. Melo, and V. Lima, “Relationship between periodontitis and rheumatoid arthritis: review of the literature,” Mediators of Inflammation, vol. 2015, Article ID 259074, 15 pages, 2015.
- D. Ziebolz, A. Rupprecht, J. Schmickler et al., “Association of different immunosuppressive medications with periodontal condition in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: results from a cross-sectional study,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 89, no. 11, pp. 1310–1317, 2018.
- M. J. de Smit, J. Westra, E. Brouwer, K. M. J. Janssen, A. Vissink, and A. J. van Winkelhoff, “Commentary: periodontitis and rheumatoid arthritis: what do we know?” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 86, no. 9, pp. 1013–1019, 2015.
- J. Schmickler, A. Rupprecht, S. Patschan et al., “Cross-sectional evaluation of periodontal status and microbiologic and rheumatoid parameters in a large cohort of patients with rheumatoid arthritis,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 88, no. 4, pp. 368–379, 2017.
- S. Culshaw, I. B. McInnes, and F. Y. Liew, “What can the periodontal community learn from the pathophysiology of rheumatoid arthritis?” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 38, pp. 106–113, 2011.
- R. Joseph, S. Rajappan, S. G. Nath, and B. J. Paul, “Association between chronic periodontitis and rheumatoid arthritis: a hospital-based case–control study,” Rheumatology International, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 103–109, 2013.
- H. Marotte, P. Farge, P. Gaudin, C. Alexandre, B. Mougin, and P. Miossec, “The association between periodontal disease and joint destruction in rheumatoid arthritis extends the link between the HLA-DR shared epitope and severity of bone destruction,” Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, vol. 65, no. 7, pp. 905–909, 2006.
- F. B. Mercado, R. I. Marshall, A. C. Klestov, and P. M. Bartold, “Relationship between rheumatoid arthritis and periodontitis,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 72, no. 6, pp. 779–787, 2001.
- P. de Pablo, I. L. C. Chapple, C. D. Buckley, and T. Dietrich, “Periodontitis in systemic rheumatic diseases,” Nature Reviews Rheumatology, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 218–224, 2009.
- S. Reichert, M. Haffner, G. Keyßer et al., “Detection of oral bacterial DNA in synovial fluid,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 591–598, 2013.
- F. Mercado, R. I. Marshall, A. C. Klestov, and P. M. Bartold, “Is there a relationship between rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease?” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 267–272, 2000.
- R. Cosgarea, R. Tristiu, R. B. Dumitru et al., “Effects of non-surgical periodontal therapy on periodontal laboratory and clinical data as well as on disease activity in patients with rheumatoid arthritis,” Clinical Oral Investigations, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 141–151, 2019.
- F. J. Silvestre, J. Silvestre-Rangil, L. Bagan, and J. V. Bagan, “Effect of nonsurgical periodontal treatment in patients with periodontitis and rheumatoid arthritis: a systematic review,” Medicina Oral Patología Oral y Cirugia Bucal, vol. 21, pp. e349–e354, 2016.
- T. Kobayashi, M. Okada, S. Ito et al., “Assessment of interleukin-6 receptor inhibition therapy on periodontal condition in patients with rheumatoid arthritis and chronic periodontitis,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 85, no. 1, pp. 57–67, 2014.
- L. I. Sakkas, D. Daoussis, S. N. Liossis, and D. P. Bogdanos, “The infectious basis of ACPA-positive rheumatoid arthritis,” Frontiers in Microbiology, vol. 8, p. 1853, 2017.
- W. T. McGraw, J. Potempa, D. Farley, and J. Travis, “Purification, characterization, and sequence analysis of a potential virulence factor from Porphyromonas gingivalis, peptidylarginine deiminase,” Infection and Immunity, vol. 67, no. 7, pp. 3248–3256, 1999.
- K. Lundberg, N. Wegner, T. Yucel-Lindberg, and P. J. Venables, “Periodontitis in RA—the citrullinated enolase connection,” Nature Reviews Rheumatology, vol. 6, no. 12, pp. 727–730, 2010.
- F. B. Mercado, R. I. Marshall, and P. M. Bartold, “Inter-relationships between rheumatoid arthritis and periodontal disease. A review,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 30, no. 9, pp. 761–772, 2003.
- R. Agnihotri and S. Gaur, “Rheumatoid arthritis in the elderly and its relationship with periodontitis: a review,” Geriatrics & Gerontology International, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 8–22, 2014.
- T. Yucel-Lindberg and T. Båge, “Inflammatory mediators in the pathogenesis of periodontitis,” Expert Reviews in Molecular Medicine, vol. 15, 2013.
- D. E. Furst and P. Emery, “Rheumatoid arthritis pathophysiology: update on emerging cytokine and cytokine-associated cell targets,” Rheumatology, vol. 53, no. 9, pp. 1560–1569, 2014.
- M. Soory, “Periodontal diseases and rheumatoid arthritis: a coincident model for therapeutic intervention?” Current Drug Metabolism, vol. 8, no. 8, pp. 750–757, 2007.
- B. Cetinkaya, E. Guzeldemir, E. Ogus, and S. Bulut, “Proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory cytokines in gingival crevicular fluid and serum of patients with rheumatoid arthritis and patients with chronic periodontitis,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 84, no. 1, pp. 84–93, 2013.
- V. Konda Mohan, N. Ganesan, and R. Gopalakrishnan, “Association of susceptible genetic markers and autoantibodies in rheumatoid arthritis,” Journal of Genetics, vol. 93, no. 2, pp. 597–605, 2014.
- S. Viatte, D. Plant, and S. Raychaudhuri, “Genetics and epigenetics of rheumatoid arthritis,” Nature Reviews Rheumatology, vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 141–153, 2013.
- M. K. da Silva, A. C. G. de Carvalho, E. H. P. Alves, F. R. P. da Silva, L. d. S. Pessoa, and D. F. P. Vasconcelos, “Genetic factors and the risk of periodontitis development: findings from a systematic review composed of 13 studies of meta-analysis with 71,531 participants,” International Journal of Dentistry, vol. 2017, Article ID 1914073, 9 pages, 2017.
- M. L. Laine, W. Crielaard, and B. G. Loos, “Genetic susceptibility to periodontitis,” Periodontology 2000, vol. 58, no. 1, pp. 37–68, 2012.
- J. Koziel, P. Mydel, and J. Potempa, “The link between periodontal disease and rheumatoid arthritis: an updated review,” Current Rheumatology Reports, vol. 16, no. 3, p. 408, 2014.
- T. Kobayashi, J.-i. Kido, Y. Ishihara et al., “The KCNQ1 gene polymorphism as a shared genetic risk for rheumatoid arthritis and chronic periodontitis in Japanese adults: a pilot case-control study,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 89, no. 3, pp. 315–324, 2018.
- D. E. Lange, H. C. Plagmann, A. Eenboom, and A. Promesberger, “Clinical methods for the objective evaluation of oral hygiene,” Deutsche zahnärztliche Zeitschrift, vol. 32, no. 1, pp. 44–47, 1977.
- M. S. Tonetti, N. Claffey, and on behalf of the European Workshop in Periodontology group C, “Advances in the progression of periodontitis and proposal of definitions of a periodontitis case and disease progression for use in risk factor research. Group C Consensus report of the 5th European workshop in periodontology,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 32, pp. 210–213, 2005.
- S. Reichert, W. Schlumberger, C. Dähnrich et al., “Association of levels of antibodies against citrullinated cyclic peptides and citrullinated α-enolase in chronic and aggressive periodontitis as a risk factor of rheumatoid arthritis: a case control study,” Journal of Translational Medicine, vol. 13, no. 1, p. 283, 2015.
- D. Aletaha, T. Neogi, A. J. Silman et al., “2010 rheumatoid arthritis classification criteria: an American College of Rheumatology/European League Against Rheumatism collaborative initiative,” Arthritis & Rheumatism, vol. 62, no. 9, pp. 2569–2581, 2010.
- S. Schulz, N. Zissler, W. Altermann et al., “Impact of genetic variants of CD14 and TLR4 on subgingival periodontopathogens,” International Journal of Immunogenetics, vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 457–464, 2008.
- S. Mateen, A. Zafar, S. Moin, A. Q. Khan, and S. Zubair, “Understanding the role of cytokines in the pathogenesis of rheumatoid arthritis,” Clinica Chimica Acta, vol. 455, pp. 161–171, 2016.
- S. Razzouk, “Regulatory elements and genetic variations in periodontal diseases,” Archives of Oral Biology, vol. 72, pp. 106–115, 2016.
- D. L. Scott, F. Wolfe, and T. W. J. Huizinga, “Rheumatoid arthritis,” The Lancet, vol. 376, no. 9746, pp. 1094–1108, 2010.
- B. S. Michalowicz, D. Aeppli, J. G. Virag et al., “Periodontal findings in adult twins,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 62, no. 5, pp. 293–299, 1991.
- M. L. Laine, B. G. Loos, and W. Crielaard, “Gene polymorphisms in chronic periodontitis,” International Journal of Dentistry, vol. 2010, Article ID 324719, 22 pages, 2010.
- C. Austad, T. K. Kvien, I. C. Olsen, and T. Uhlig, “Health status has improved more in women than in men with rheumatoid arthritis from 1994 to 2009: results from the Oslo rheumatoid arthritis register,” Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, vol. 74, no. 1, pp. 148–155, 2015.
- H. Kallberg, B. Ding, L. Padyukov et al., “Smoking is a major preventable risk factor for rheumatoid arthritis: estimations of risks after various exposures to cigarette smoke,” Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, vol. 70, no. 3, pp. 508–511, 2011.
- R. J. Genco and W. S. Borgnakke, “Risk factors for periodontal disease,” Periodontology 2000, vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 59–94, 2013.
- D. Trajkov, S. Mishevska-Perchinkova, A. Karadzova-Stojanoska, A. Petlichkovski, A. Strezova, and M. Spiroski, “Association of 22 cytokine gene polymorphisms with rheumatoid arthritis in population of ethnic Macedonians,” Clinical Rheumatology, vol. 28, no. 11, pp. 1291–1300, 2009.
- K. Yamamoto, Y. Okada, A. Suzuki, and Y. Kochi, “Genetic studies of rheumatoid arthritis,” Proceedings of the Japan Academy, Series B, vol. 91, no. 8, pp. 410–422, 2015.
- O. Moreno, C. I. González, D. L. Saaibi et al., “Polymorphisms in the IL4 and IL4RA genes in Colombian patients with rheumatoid arthritis,” The Journal of Rheumatology, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 36–42, 2007.
- G. G. Song, S. C. Bae, J. H. Kim, and Y. H. Lee, “Interleukin-4, interleukin-4 receptor, and interleukin-18 polymorphisms and rheumatoid arthritis: a meta-analysis,” Immunological Investigations, vol. 42, no. 6, pp. 455–469, 2013.
- V. Ziaee, A. Rezaei, S. Harsini et al., “Polymorphisms of genes encoding interleukin-4 and its receptor in Iranian patients with juvenile idiopathic arthritis,” Clinical Rheumatology, vol. 35, no. 8, pp. 1943–1948, 2016.
- P. I. Burgos, Z. L. Causey, A. Tamhane et al., “Association of IL4R single-nucleotide polymorphisms with rheumatoid nodules in African Americans with rheumatoid arthritis,” Arthritis Research & Therapy, vol. 12, no. 3, p. R75, 2010.
- Y. Hussein, S. El-Tarhouny, R. Mohamed, H. Pasha, and A. Abul-Saoud, “Association of interleukin-4 receptor gene polymorphisms with rheumatoid arthritis in Egyptian female patients,” Joint Bone Spine, vol. 79, no. 1, pp. 38–42, 2012.
- M. Pascual, S. Roa, A. García-Sánchez et al., “Genome-wide expression profiling of B lymphocytes reveals IL4R increase in allergic asthma,” The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, vol. 134, no. 4, pp. 972–975, 2014.
- J. C. A. Broen, P. Dieude, M. C. Vonk et al., “Polymorphisms in the interleukin 4, interleukin 13, and corresponding receptor genes are not associated with systemic sclerosis and do not influence gene expression,” The Journal of Rheumatology, vol. 39, no. 1, pp. 112–118, 2012.
- Y. H. Lee and S. C. Bae, “Associations between TNF-α polymorphisms and susceptibility to rheumatoid arthritis and vitiligo: a meta-analysis,” Genetics and Molecular Research, vol. 14, no. 2, pp. 5548–5559, 2015.
- A. Mekinian, R. Tamouza, S. Pavy et al., “Functional study of TNF-α promoter polymorphisms: literature review and meta-analysis,” European Cytokine Network, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 88–102, 2011.
- G. Cui, H. Wang, R. Li et al., “Polymorphism of tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) gene promoter, circulating TNF-alpha level, and cardiovascular risk factor for ischemic stroke,” Journal of Neuroinflammation, vol. 9, no. 1, 2012.
- J. M. Gane, R. A. Stockley, and E. Sapey, “The rs361525 polymorphism does not increase production of tumor necrosis factor alpha by monocytes from alpha-1 antitrypsin deficient subjects with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease - a pilot study,” Journal of Negative Results in Biomedicine, vol. 14, no. 1, p. 20, 2015.
- E. Oregón-Romero, M. Vázquez-del Mercado, S. L. Ruiz-Quezada et al., “Tumor necrosis factor α-308 and -238 polymorphisms in rheumatoid arthritis. Association with messenger RNA expression and sTNF-α,” Journal of Investigative Medicine, vol. 56, no. 7, pp. 937–943, 2008.
- J. F. Muñoz-Valle, E. Oregón-Romero, H. Rangel-Villalobos et al., “High expression of TNF alpha is associated with −308 and −238 TNF alpha polymorphisms in knee osteoarthritis,” Clinical and Experimental Medicine, vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 61–67, 2014.
- E. A. V. Moelants, A. Mortier, J. van Damme, and P. Proost, “Regulation of TNF-α with a focus on rheumatoid arthritis,” Immunology and Cell Biology, vol. 91, no. 6, pp. 393–401, 2013.
- S. Bek, A. B. Bojesen, J. V. Nielsen et al., “Systematic review and meta-analysis: pharmacogenetics of anti-TNF treatment response in rheumatoid arthritis,” The Pharmacogenomics Journal, vol. 17, no. 5, pp. 403–411, 2017.
- J. Swierkot, K. Bogunia-Kubik, B. Nowak et al., “Analysis of associations between polymorphisms within genes coding for tumour necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha and TNF receptors and responsiveness to TNF-alpha blockers in patients with rheumatoid arthritis,” Joint Bone Spine, vol. 82, no. 2, pp. 94–99, 2015.
- Y. H. Lee, J. D. Ji, S. C. Bae, and G. G. Song, “Associations between tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) −308 and −238 G/A polymorphisms and shared epitope status and responsiveness to TNF-α blockers in rheumatoid arthritis: a metaanalysis update,” The Journal of Rheumatology, vol. 37, no. 4, pp. 740–746, 2010.
- M. Munz, C. Willenborg, G. M. Richter et al., “A genome-wide association study identifies nucleotide variants at SIGLEC5 and DEFA1A3 as risk loci for periodontitis,” Human Molecular Genetics, vol. 26, no. 13, pp. 2577–2588, 2017.
- A. Teumer, B. Holtfreter, U. Völker et al., “Genome-wide association study of chronic periodontitis in a general German population,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 40, no. 11, pp. 977–985, 2013.
- A. S. Schaefer, G. Bochenek, T. Manke et al., “Validation of reported genetic risk factors for periodontitis in a large-scale replication study,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 40, no. 6, pp. 563–572, 2013.
- A. Havemose-Poulsen, L. K. Sørensen, K. Bendtzen, and P. Holmstrup, “Polymorphisms within the IL-1 gene cluster: effects on cytokine profiles in peripheral blood and whole blood cell cultures of patients with aggressive periodontitis, juvenile idiopathic arthritis, and rheumatoid arthritis,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 78, no. 3, pp. 475–492, 2007.
- Z. Heidari, H. Mahmoudzadeh-Sagheb, M. Hashemi, S. Ansarimoghaddam, B. Moudi, and N. Sheibak, “Association between IFN-γ +874A/T and IFN-γR1 (-611A/G, +189T/G, and +95C/T) gene polymorphisms and chronic periodontitis in a sample of Iranian population,” International Journal of Dentistry, vol. 2015, Article ID 375359, 8 pages, 2015.
- M. Ianni, G. Bruzzesi, D. Pugliese et al., “Variations in inflammatory genes are associated with periodontitis,” Immunity & Ageing, vol. 10, no. 1, p. 39, 2013.
- A. Khani-Hanjani, D. Lacaille, D. Hoar et al., “Association between dinucleotide repeat in non-coding region of interferon-gamma gene and susceptibility to, and severity of, rheumatoid arthritis,” The Lancet, vol. 356, no. 9232, pp. 820–825, 2000.
- V. Pokorny, L. McLean, F. McQueen, M. Abu-Maree, and S. Yeoman, “Interferon-gamma microsatellite and rheumatoid arthritis,” The Lancet, vol. 358, no. 9276, pp. 122-123, 2001.
- A. Constantin, F. Navaux, V. Lauwers-Cancès et al., “Interferon gamma gene polymorphism and susceptibility to, and severity of, rheumatoid arthritis,” The Lancet, vol. 358, no. 9298, pp. 2051-2052, 2001.
- Q. Shi, C. Cai, J. Xu, J. Liu, H. Liu, and N. Huo, “Is there an association between IFN-γ +874A/T polymorphism and periodontitis susceptibility?: a meta-analysis,” Medicine, vol. 96, no. 25, article e7288, 2017.
- V. Pravica, C. Perrey, A. Stevens, J. H. Lee, and I. V. Hutchinson, “A single nucleotide polymorphism in the first intron of the human IFN-γ gene: Absolute correlation with a polymorphic CA microsatellite marker of high IFN-γ production,” Human Immunology, vol. 61, no. 9, pp. 863–866, 2000.
- F. P. Schena, G. Cerullo, D. D. Torres et al., “Role of interferon-γ gene polymorphisms in susceptibility to IgA nephropathy: a family-based association study,” European Journal of Human Genetics, vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 488–496, 2006.
- S. Prabhu Anand, M. Harishankar, and P. Selvaraj, “Interferon gamma gene +874A/T polymorphism and intracellular interferon gamma expression in pulmonary tuberculosis,” Cytokine, vol. 49, no. 2, pp. 130–133, 2010.
- M. C. Warlé, A. Farhan, H. J. Metselaar et al., “Are cytokine gene polymorphisms related to in vitro cytokine production profiles?” Liver Transplantation, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 170–181, 2003.
- D. M. Isaza-Guzmán, N. Cardona-Vélez, D. E. Gaviria-Correa, M. C. Martínez-Pabón, M. C. Castaño-Granada, and S. I. Tobón-Arroyave, “Association study between salivary levels of interferon (IFN)-gamma, interleukin (IL)-17, IL-21, and IL-22 with chronic periodontitis,” Archives of Oral Biology, vol. 60, no. 1, pp. 91–99, 2015.
- S. Zhang, A. Crivello, S. Offenbacher, A. Moretti, D. W. Paquette, and S. P. Barros, “Interferon-gamma promoter hypomethylation and increased expression in chronic periodontitis,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 37, no. 11, pp. 953–961, 2010.
- E. Papathanasiou, F. Teles, T. Griffin et al., “Gingival crevicular fluid levels of interferon-γ, but not interleukin-4 or -33 or thymic stromal lymphopoietin, are increased in inflamed sites in patients with periodontal disease,” Journal of Periodontal Research, vol. 49, no. 1, pp. 55–61, 2014.
- L. Rönnblom and M. L. Eloranta, “The interferon signature in autoimmune diseases,” Current Opinion in Rheumatology, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 248–253, 2013.
- G. Mizraji, M. Nassar, H. Segev et al., “Porphyromonas gingivalis promotes unrestrained type I interferon production by dysregulating TAM signaling via MYD88 degradation,” Cell Reports, vol. 18, no. 2, pp. 419–431, 2017.
- M. H. Tanaka, E. M. A. Giro, L. B. Cavalcante et al., “Expression of interferon-γ, interferon-α and related genes in individuals with Down syndrome and periodontitis,” Cytokine, vol. 60, no. 3, pp. 875–881, 2012.
- M. Navarrete, J. García, N. Dutzan et al., “Interferon-γ, interleukins-6 and -4, and factor XIII-A as indirect markers of the classical and alternative macrophage activation pathways in chronic periodontitis,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 85, no. 5, pp. 751–760, 2014.
- W. M. Schneider, M. D. Chevillotte, and C. M. Rice, “Interferon-stimulated genes: a complex web of host defenses,” Annual Review of Immunology, vol. 32, no. 1, pp. 513–545, 2014.
- L. Fiorillo, G. Cervino, A. Herford et al., “Interferon crevicular fluid profile and correlation with periodontal disease and wound healing: a systemic review of recent data,” International Journal of Molecular Sciences, vol. 19, no. 7, 2018.
- L. Tupta-Veselicky, P. Famili, F. J. Ceravolo, and T. Zullo, “A clinical study of an electronic constant force periodontal probe,” Journal of Periodontology, vol. 65, no. 6, pp. 616–622, 1994.
- A. Bergenholtz, N. al-Harbi, F. M. al-Hummayani, P. Anton, and S. al-Kahtani, “The accuracy of the Vivacare true pressure-sensitive periodontal probe system in terms of probing force,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 27, no. 2, pp. 93–98, 2000.
- M. S. Reddy, K. G. Palcanis, and N. C. Geurs, “A comparison of manual and controlled-force attachment-level measurements,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 24, no. 12, pp. 920–926, 1997.
- D. S. Barendregt, U. Van der Velden, M. F. Timmerman, and G. A. van der Weijden, “Comparison of two automated periodontal probes and two probes with a conventional readout in periodontal maintenance patients,” Journal of Clinical Periodontology, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 276–282, 2006.
- A. Renatus, L. Trentzsch, A. Schönfelder, F. Schwarzenberger, and H. Jentsch, “Evaluation of an electronic periodontal probe versus a manual probe,” Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research, vol. 10, pp. ZH03–ZH07, 2016.
Copyright © 2019 Susanne Schulz et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.