Research Article
Stability Analysis of Two-Segment Stepped Columns with Different End Conditions and Internal Axial Loads
Table 2
Comparison of VIM results for
β values (
) with exact results [
11].
| | | | BC | | 0.1 | 0.3 | 0.5 | 0.7 | 0.9 | | | Exact | VIM | Exact | VIM | Exact | VIM | Exact | VIM | Exact | VIM |
| C-F | 4 | 1.56686 | 1.56685 | 1.46680 | 1.46680 | 1.23095 | 1.23096 | 1.01112 | 1.01111 | 0.84904 | 0.84904 | 2 | 1.56950 | 1.56950 | 1.53686 | 1.53686 | 1.43779 | 1.43779 | 1.30081 | 1.30082 | 1.16904 | 1.16904 | 1.33 | 1.57036 | 1.57037 | 1.55961 | 1.55961 | 1.52425 | 1.52425 | 1.46498 | 1.46497 | 1.39505 | 1.39506 |
| P-P | 4 | 2.42298 | 2.42298 | 2.00448 | 2.00448 | 1.96601 | 1.96601 | 1.89495 | 1.89495 | 1.68817 | 1.68816 | 2 | 2.85769 | 2.85769 | 2.59029 | 2.59029 | 2.55657 | 2.55656 | 2.50864 | 2.50864 | 2.33135 | 2.33135 | 1.33 | 3.04226 | 3.04226 | 2.92536 | 2.92536 | 2.90675 | 2.90676 | 2.88509 | 2.88509 | 2.78735 | 2.78735 |
| C-P | 4 | 4.39908 | 4.39907 | 3.37502 | 3.37502 | 3.01150 | 3.01149 | 2.94442 | 2.94442 | 2.50798 | 2.50798 | 2 | 4.46510 | 4.46509 | 4.06141 | 4.06141 | 3.80247 | 3.80247 | 3.76424 | 3.76424 | 3.42116 | 3.42116 | 1.33 | 4.48429 | 4.48429 | 4.34651 | 4.34652 | 4.22846 | 4.22847 | 4.21207 | 4.21207 | 4.03808 | 4.03808 |
| P-C | 4 | 3.15057 | 3.15057 | 2.66544 | 2.66544 | 2.62683 | 2.62682 | 2.40572 | 2.40571 | 2.25642 | 2.25641 | 2 | 3.91057 | 3.91057 | 3.54573 | 3.54573 | 3.51694 | 3.51694 | 3.32992 | 3.32992 | 3.18659 | 3.18659 | 1.33 | 4.28124 | 4.28124 | 4.10249 | 4.10249 | 4.08788 | 4.08789 | 3.98602 | 3.98602 | 3.89716 | 3.89716 |
| C-C | 4 | 5.97573 | 5.97573 | 4.16581 | 4.16580 | 3.93102 | 3.93102 | 3.54153 | 3.54153 | 3.16821 | 3.16821 | 2 | 6.19875 | 6.19876 | 5.32574 | 5.32574 | 5.11300 | 5.11300 | 4.82979 | 4.82978 | 4.46859 | 4.46859 | 1.33 | 6.25686 | 6.25686 | 5.93175 | 5.93175 | 5.81351 | 5.81351 | 5.67979 | 5.67980 | 5.45754 | 5.45753 |
|
|