| Method | Result |
CPU time (S) | Best | Average | Worst |
| PSO-ACO-K | 16,295.31 | 16,295.31 | 16,295.31 | ~30 | PSO-ACO | 16,295.34 | 16,295.92 | 16,297.93 | ~33 | PSO | 16,345.96 | 16,417.47 | 16,562.31 | ~123 | SA | 16,473.48 | 17,521.09 | 18,083.25 | ~129 | TS | 16,666.22 | 16,785.45 | 16,837.53 | ~140 | GA | 16,530.53 | 16,530.53 | 16,530.53 | ~170 | ACO | 16,530.53 | 16,530.53 | 16,530.53 | ~121 | HBMO | 16,357.28 | 16,357.28 | 16,357.28 | ~40 | PSO_SA | 16,295.86 | 16,296.00 | 16,296.10 | ~38 | ACO-SA | 16,298.62 | 16,310.28 | 16,322.43 | ~84 | -Means | 16,555.68 | 18,061.01 | 18,563.12 | 0.7 | MY proposed ALG. | 16,292.25 | 16,293.76 | 16,294.98 | ~30 |
|
|