A Hybrid Short-Term Forecasting Model of Passenger Flow on High-Speed Rail considering the Impact of Train Service Frequency

Table 1

MAPE values (%) of different models for 25 testing experiments.

Testing experiment	Hybrid	Holt-Winters	Linear
1	18.1	18.1	20.4
2	17.3	17.0	20.5
3	12.2	12.5	20.4
4	15.7	21.9	21.4
5	12.6	16.8	22.3
6	12.1	13.6	23.5
7	12.3	15.9	23.3
8	20.4	32.9	23.1
9	15.0	23.0	22.4
10	14.7	19.4	15.5
11	19.4	27.2	15.6
12	16.2	22.7	15.0
13	11.2	13.6	14.8
14	11.0	12.6	14.7
15	11.7	11.9	14.5
16	10.6	12.2	14.6
17	10.1	12.7	14.8
18	15.3	23.8	15.2
19	22.8	34.6	15.8
20	12.5	17.1	17.0
21	10.3	12.7	17.4
22	9.7	12.1	17.3
23	16.2	24.3	17.2
24	21.1	42.3	37.9
25	12.2	22.4	39.0
Average	14.4	19.7	19.7