Mathematical Problems in Engineering

Research Article

Memetic Computing Applied to the Design of Composite Materials and Structures

Table 7

Statistics corresponding to the series of simulations. Biaxial loading .


Loads	Algorithm		NL

: :	VNS	6	500	6	2.8594·10⁸	2.7272·10⁸
	MA	6	500	6	2.8594·10⁸	2.8594·10⁸
	AG	6	89	8.28	2.8594·10⁸	6.969·10⁷
	SA	8	76	12.456	8.978·10⁶	1.1579·10⁵
	TS	6	32	8.7120	2.7920·10⁸	7.4150·10⁶

: :	VNS	8	500	8	1.4029·10⁷	1.2698·10⁷
	MA	8	500	8	1.4029·10⁷	1.3822·10⁷
	AG	8	35	11.8	1.3145·10⁷	1.2643·10⁶
	SA	8	10	16.544	5.6258·10⁶	2.0485·10⁴
	TS	8	13	10.5680	1.0056·10⁷	1.5439·10⁵

: :	VNS	8	498	8.008	6.6161·10⁶	6.3187·10⁶
	MA	8	500	8	6.6161·10⁶	6.6044·10⁶
	AG	8	3	14.4733	6.5042·10⁶	1.9654·10⁵
	SA	10	26	19.532	4.3045·10⁵	3.4465·10³
	TS	8	3	11.5360	5.2699·10⁶	3.5922·10⁴

: :	VNS	8	471	8.116	8.2968·10⁶	5.4898·10⁶
	MA	8	500	8	8.2968·10⁶	8.2815·10⁶
	AG	10	18	17.1267	7.6349·10⁵	6.3974·10⁴
	SA	10	24	21.12	6.7663·10⁵	2.5123·10³
	TS	10	3	12.4680	5.0663·10⁵	5.1883·10³

: :	VNS	8	118	9.528	6.6895·10⁶	1.866·10⁶
	MA	8	500	8	6.6895·10⁶	6.0696·10⁶
	AG	10	2	20.52	1.0673·10⁶	1.9896·10⁴
	SA	12	3	23.672	4.5062·10⁴	3.2251·10²
	TS	10	1	13.6400	5.9026·10⁵	3.0134·10³

: :	VNS	10	496	10.016	9.0479·10⁵	6.8493·10⁵
	MA	10	500	10	9.0479·10⁵	8.9861·10⁵
	AG	12	14	24.26	2.8056·10⁵	9.3622·10³
	SA	10	22	26.24	5.6722·10⁵	2.4689·10³
	TS	12	4	14.7000	8.7860·10⁴	1.0494·10³

: :	VNS	10	400	10.4	6.37·10⁵	5.0705·10⁵
	MA	10	481	10.08	6.37·10⁵	6.1494·10⁵
	AG	10	3	15.6467	5.6117·10⁵	6.2101·10⁴
	SA	12	4	21.292	1.5327·10⁵	1.1971·10³
	TS	10	3	13.9240	5.6117·10⁵	1.0223·10⁴

: :	VNS	12	260	12.27	8.9005·10⁴	7.3328·10⁴
	MA	12	496	12.02	9.0984·10⁴	8.7607·10⁴
	AG	12	4	18.9467	8.5403·10⁴	8.4764·10³
	SA	16	3	26.456	4.0543·10³	30.7819
	TS	12	1	15.9200	1.7488·10⁴	6.1199·10²

: :	VNS	12	15	13.96	3.6897·10⁴	1.3575·10⁴
	MA	12	98	13.61	3.6897·10⁴	1.8147·10⁴
	AG	14	1	23.1267	1.1361·10⁴	1.146·10³
	SA	16	3	31.672	5.6763·10³	22.3771
	TS	14	3	17.5640	5.2902·10³	81.8767

: :	VNS	12	72	14.28	2.9117·10⁴	8.6122·10³
	MA	12	339	12.81	2.9117·10⁴	2.173·10⁴
	AG	16	2	27.4133	2.6399·10³	2.2388·10²
	SA	18	2	35.388	1.23·10³	4.4746
	TS	16	1	19.2560	9.2541·10²	23.4648

: :	VNS	14	363	14.636	1.1324·10⁴	5.3271·10³
	MA	14	494	14.02	1.1324·10⁴	1.0644·10⁴
	AG	18	10	30.1067	8.7844·10²	85.4087
	SA	16	2	38.476	9.3088·10²	4.1987
	TS	16	1	20.3560	8.7751·10²	18.3449

: :	VNS	16	500	16	3.522·10³	3.3743·10³
	MA	16	500	16	3.522·10³	3.522·10³
	AG	16	15	22.7667	3.522·10³	7.5575·10²
	SA	16	2	29.65	3.1351·10³	18.3958
	TS	16	16	18.9880	3.5220·10³	1.4030·10²

: :	VNS	18	500	18	1.0035·10³	9.2486·10²
	MA	18	500	18	1.0073·10³	9.8167·10²
	AG	18	16	27.4133	9.7849·10²	1.8292·10²
	SA	20	4	35.736	3.3870·10²	2.003
	TS	18	9	21.4320	8.8434·10²	24.9275

: :	VNS	18	38	19.848	5.2267·10²	3.1132·10²
	MA	16	7	18.49	5.2345·10²	4.3804·10²
	AG	20	10	30.52	3.2510·10²	54.4953
	SA	20	2	40.38	1.8789·10²	1.3868
	TS	20	2	23.7400	1.9273·10²	2.8100

: :	VNS	18	11	20.708	3.3956·10²	1.4176·10²
	MA	18	63	19.776	3.3956·10²	1.9003·10²
	AG	22	16	34.3	1.0962·10²	16.2374
	SA	26	1	45.928	5.8144	0.032
	TS	22	3	25.8480	43.3493	0.7962

: :	VNS	20	500	20	3.2888·10²	3.1014·10²
	MA	20	500	20	3.2888·10²	3.2887·10²
	AG	20	5	30.44	2.9623·10²	44.4987
	SA	20	2	38.96	2.2611·10²	1.8568
	TS	20	1	24.3960	1.9686·10²	5.8882

: :	VNS	22	500	22	1.1748·10²	1.0838·10²
	MA	22	500	22	1.1785·10²	1.1536·10²
	AG	22	9	34.2467	1.1539·10²	12.4818
	SA	26	3	44.54	22.4217	0.1669
	TS	22	3	26.7880	1.0333·10²	1.7983

: :	VNS	24	500	24	46.2995	42.4606
	MA	24	500	24	46.4240	45.1922
	AG	24	8	37.9467	44.3415	4.5575
	SA	28	7	49.4	13.0737	0.165
	TS	24	1	29.6360	19.4564	0.2810

: :	VNS	24	469	24.124	46.643	41.4749
	MA	24	500	24	46.643	46.6245
	AG	24	3	37.0533	42.1974	4.8935
	SA	26	1	46.908	13.6039	0.0983
	TS	26	10	29.3760	15.1788	0.7773

: :	VNS	26	130	27.496	9.8711	7.8726
	MA	26	231	27.144	10.1457	8.3843
	AG	28	16	40.2333	7.8922	1.6101
	SA	30	2	52.46	4.6966	0.0335
	TS	28	7	32.5520	7.0430	0.2389

: :	VNS	30	500	30	3.8763	3.5545
	MA	30	500	30	3.8763	3.8245
	AG	30	10	42.86	3.7687	0.6741
	SA	30	1	54.748	3.1197	0.015
	TS	38	8	35.3000	2.3280	0.1268