Mathematical Problems in Engineering / 2019 / Article / Tab 6

Research Article

Dynamic Multiobjective Software Project Scheduling Optimization Method Based on Firework Algorithm

Table 6

Comparison of HV, IGD, and SP among IFA, FA, NSGA-II, and MPSO.

InstanceHVIGDSP
IFAFANSGA-IIMPSOIFAFANSGA-IIMPSOIFAFANSGA-IIMPSO

T10_10.0544 0.00970.02480.01630.0997 0.67620.32540.46570.06140.13750.09280.1244
T10_20.0455 0.00550.02570.01620.0898 0.75350.40560.70530.06140.13370.12630.0979
T10_30.0454 0.01560.02200.01810.1125 0.59410.36680.34090.08270.15030.12630.1412
T10_40.02590.01490.0289 0.01910.27210.46810.2616 0.38190.10950.18310.1006 0.1133
T10_50.0550 0.00730.03360.01970.2034 0.67990.28200.32280.06140.15390.12360.0951
T10_60.0534 0.00660.02040.01650.1846 0.75120.42670.31800.02950.08260.15150.1539
T10_70.0550 0.01410.02410.01830.1493 0.56520.32540.68470.02950.13750.16860.1476
T10_80.0536 0.00770.04400.01790.14310.72990.1286 0.53990.10890.15200.12270.1150
T10_90.0541 0.01270.04320.01610.1286 0.57060.14440.52490.03180.16480.06940.1222
T10_100.0540 0.00970.01870.01740.1272 0.64310.48530.32250.03180.14430.13640.1187

T20_10.1909 0.01830.11370.08650.0528 0.71290.22820.67650.04250.06140.04810.0847
T20_20.1586 0.01290.08360.11180.0910 0.75340.35020.56100.05260.06150.06580.0681
T20_30.1667 0.01820.11480.09250.0851 0.70940.22980.42550.05590.07130.06730.0851
T20_40.1511 0.04030.09710.10110.1333 0.57970.31680.50660.02710.08790.04030.0906
T20_50.1762 0.03000.11200.08660.0743 0.61840.26580.45090.02880.07000.05670.0661
T20_60.1681 0.02400.11520.10410.0605 0.59640.32940.28800.04750.06830.0425 0.0609
T20_70.2022 0.03120.10080.09050.0951 0.62160.24810.37000.04520.08790.06370.0698
T20_80.1734 0.03460.09080.10620.1016 0.57130.32330.31170.03820.07530.06300.0709
T20_90.1460 0.02840.11700.10760.1406 0.58190.24390.34200.03950.05000.04290.0762
T20_100.1877 0.03720.10720.10990.0197 0.59300.23610.37000.03980.06400.04820.0804

T30_10.1819 0.03280.09720.07800.0714 0.60370.22950.36740.04160.06750.06000.0593
T30_20.1526 0.03590.07870.06340.0709 0.58170.31250.42660.04470.07040.06650.0681
T30_30.1529 0.03770.09150.06920.0444 0.54440.23910.66060.04840.07230.06720.0951
T30_40.1457 0.03890.12650.09650.1605 0.54850.17850.25770.04300.06130.05520.0565
T30_50.1429 0.03310.10160.06610.1100 0.57830.22240.27150.04310.07310.05100.1014
T30_60.1558 0.03260.10680.09300.0662 0.63980.23300.33450.04990.06350.0416 0.0915
T30_70.1778 0.02000.13090.08150.0118 0.63230.21510.57460.05250.06520.06290.0794
T30_80.1690 0.03180.09760.09990.0467 0.61400.29720.61590.04560.08710.06150.0839
T30_90.1522 0.01880.08140.06310.0431 0.69420.28280.57390.04330.07310.04950.0669
T30_100.1634 0.03600.12740.07770.0336 0.60640.15130.47550.05230.07610.06030.0779

Real_10.1058 0.02060.07060.04600.1078 0.61060.24870.43420.04457 0.10980.06660.0748
Real_20.1583 0.03080.09920.04040.1204 0.66940.27090.56280.04062 0.10270.06040.0734
Real_30.1656 0.03360.11070.06200.0981 0.68710.26900.64010.04668 0.09970.06870.1044

We are committed to sharing findings related to COVID-19 as quickly and safely as possible. Any author submitting a COVID-19 paper should notify us at help@hindawi.com to ensure their research is fast-tracked and made available on a preprint server as soon as possible. We will be providing unlimited waivers of publication charges for accepted articles related to COVID-19. Sign up here as a reviewer to help fast-track new submissions.