Review Article

Antioxidants as Adjuvants in Periodontitis Treatment: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 4

Summary of the included studies.

Author (year)Study designSample descriptionPeriodontitis diagnostic methodPeriodontal treatmentTreatment antioxidantStatistical analysisOutcome
Sample size and source, age (years), gender, and groupsClinicalLaboratory

Alkadasi et al. (2017)RCT, Cairo, Egypt
Age: 35-58
Males: 14
Females:16
Control: 10
Intervention: 10
PI
GI
PPD
CAL
sRANKL levels in GCFScaling and root planning and modified Widman flap procedureN-Acetylcysteine (NAC) capsules (600 mg; Swanson Health Products Co., Fargo, ND, USA)One-way ANOVA with post Dunnett testsThe use of adjunctive NAC resulted in a significant reduction in probing depths in the S-NAC group when compared to the S-nonNAC group at 3 months, but no statistically significant differences in GCF sRANKL levels were observed in the sites that underwent surgical treatment with or without NAC at different time intervals.

Alkadasi et al. (2017)RCT, Andhra Pradesh, India
Age: 25-52
Males: 21
Females:21
Control: 21
Intervention: 21
PI
MGI
PPD
CAL
BOP
Salivary interleukin 1 beta (IL-1β) and uric acid; serum tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α)Scaling and root planningLycopene (8 mg/day, LycoRed, JAGSONPAL Pharmaceuticals)Paired -test for intragroup and Student’s independent -test for intergroup; ANCOVAThere was a significant improvement in the parameters of MGI, PI, BOP, IL-1β, and salivary uric acid, but the improvement in PPD and CAL parameters was not statistically significant.

Arora et al. (2013)RCT, Ahvaz, Iran
Males: 21
Females: 19
Age: 25-57
Control: 20
Intervention: 20
PPDAntioxidant capacity (TAC), malondialdehyde (MDA), total cholesterol (TC), triglycerides (TG), and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C)Scaling and root planningChicory leaf extract (2 g/day)-test independentChicory leaf extract with nonsurgical periodontal therapy may be helpful in controlling the periodontal status.

Babaei et al. (2018)RCT, source: UI
Age: >10
Gender: UI
Control: 5
Intervention: 5
PPD
CAL
BOP
Scaling and root planningLycopene (4 mg/day; Lycotas Pharma. Co.)Paired -test and independent Student’s -testResults show that lycopene is a promising treatment modality as an adjunct to full-mouth SRP of the oral cavity in patients with moderate periodontal disease.

Belludi et al. (2013)RCT, Manipal, Karnataka, India
Age: 20-50
Males: 61
Females: 54
Control: 59
Intervention: 56
GI
PI
PPD
CAL
BI
Total antioxidant capacity in GCF and plasmaScaling and root planningSachets containing green tea (240 ml of water)Repeated measures ANOVA with post hoc Bonferroni test; independent sample -testGreen tea intake as a component of nonsurgical periodontal therapy is promising for superior and rapid resolution of the disease process. Green tea increases the total antioxidant capacity of GCF and plasma along with potent anti-inflammatory, astringent, and antiplaque effects.

Chopra et al. (2016)RCT, Tanta, Egypt
Age: 30-60
Males: 21
Females:19
Control: 20
Intervention: 20
PI
GI
PPD
CAL
Pentraxin-3 (PXT3) levels in GCFScaling and root planningGel formulation was prepared from tea tree oil (TTO) (5%, Melaleuca alternifolia, Sigma®, Steinheim, Germany)Paired -test and independent Student’s -testThe local delivery of TTO gel in case of chronic periodontitis may have some beneficial effects to augment the results of the conventional periodontal therapy.

Elgendy et al. (2013)RCT, Tehran, Iran
Males:10
Females: 20
Control: 15
Intervention: 15
PPD
BI
PI
Scaling and root planning (SRP)Green tea (Lahijan green tea)Wilcoxon test; Mann–Whitney testThe results show that PD and BI reduced significantly in both groups before and after SRP; this reduction in the intervention group was higher than the control group.

Ferial et al. (2018)RCT pilot, Manipal, India
Age: 18-60
Males: 13
Females: 17
Control: 15
Intervention: 15
GI
PI
BOP
PPD
CAL
Parameters of total antioxidant capacity (TOAC) and glutathione-S-transferase (GST) in GCFScaling and root planningGreen tea dentifrice (1,4%)Paired -test and independent Student’s -test, Wilcoxon test, and Mann–Whitney testGreen tea dentifrice use showed statistically significant improvements in GI, BOP, CAL, TAOC, and GST levels on intra- and intergroup comparisons at 4 weeks. The results of the present study assert the use of green tea dentifrice as an adjunct to SRP during the active and healing phases following periodontal therapy, thereby enhancing the clinical outcomes.

Hrishi et al. (2016)Open RCT, Nalchik, Russia
Age: 38-62
Males: 39
Females: 45
Control: 45
Intervention: 39
GI
PI
BOP
PMA
Nitrite/nitrate levels, interleukin-1β; (IL-1β), interleukin-6 (IL-6), interleukin-10 (IL-10) in GCFScaling and root planning. In addition, application of chlorhexidine 0.06%Standardized fermented papaya gel (SFPG, 7 g)Mann–Whitney testAll parameters showed a significant improvement in the comparison of the test group with the control group.

Kharaeva et al. (2016)RCT, Chinoutpalli, India
Age: 18-35
Male: 16
Female: 14
Control: 15
Intervention: 15
PI
GI
PPD
Scaling and root planningCoQ10 (Qute 120 mg by Yash Pharma International)Paired -test and independent Student’s -testThe use of coenzyme Q10 oral supplements as an adjunct to scaling and root planning showed significant reduction in gingival inflammation when compared to scaling and root planning alone.

Manthena et al. (2015)RCT, Loni, Ahmednagar
Age: 35-58
Gender: UI
Control: UI
Intervention: UI
GI
PDI
CPI
Scaling and root planningTablet melatonin 3 mg daily at night-testThere was significant improvement in all the indices in the group test as compared to the control group. Melatonin is a potential antioxidant, and the clinical improvement it showed was significantly superior to that of the standard control group.

Marawar et al. (2014)Clinical trial, Udaipur, Rajasthan
Age: 30-60
Gender: UI
Control: 10
Intervention: 10
Community periodontal index of treatment needsUric acid determination in saliva sampleScaling and root planningLycopene softgel (6 mg/dose)One-way ANOVAThere was a reduction in periodontal inflammation with an increase in the salivary uric acid levels seen in subgroups treated by antioxidants in both gingivitis and periodontitis groups.

Mathur et al. (2013)RCT, Bangkok, Thailand
Age: 37-74
Males: 22
Females:20
Control: 23
Intervention: 19
PPD
CAL
GI
BOP
Scaling and root planningGreen tea gel (12% of green tea—C. sinensis extract)Regression test; Mann–Whitney test; Friedman’s testGreen tea gel could provide a superior benefit in reducing BOP and gingival inflammation when used as an adjunct to nonsurgical periodontal treatment.

Rattanasu et al. (2016)RCT, Haryana, India
Age: >18
Control: 22 (male : female: 3 : 8)
Intervention: 38 (male : female: 4 : 1)
PI
GI
BOP
PPD
CAL
Levels of superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity (%)Scaling and root planningVitamin E softgel (200 mg/day)Mann–Whitney testSystemic and local SOD levels are lowered in periodontitis. Adjunctive vitamin E supplementation improves periodontal healing as well as antioxidant defense.

Singh et al. (2014)RCT, Damascus, Syria
Age: 23-65
Male: 18
Female: 42
Control:15
Intervention: 15
PPD
CAL
BOP
PI
GI
Parameters of/total antioxidant capacity (TOAC) in plasmaScaling and root planningVitamin CPaired -test and independent Student’s -test; Mann–Whitney testThe nonsurgical periodontal therapy seems to reduce the oxidative stress during the periodontal inflammation.

RCT: randomized controlled trial; PI: plaque index; GI: gingival index; PD: probing depth; CAL: clinical attachment loss; GCF: gingival crevicular fluid; MGI: modified gingival index; BOP: bleeding on probing; UI: unreported information; BI: percentage of sites with bleeding on probing; PMA: Parma’s papillae-gum margin-alveolar; CPI: community periodontal index.