Table of Contents Author Guidelines Submit a Manuscript
Science and Technology of Nuclear Installations
Volume 2012, Article ID 735719, 13 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2012/735719
Research Article

An Evaluation Methodology Development and Application Process for Severe Accident Safety Issue Resolution

Safety Analysis & Methods Development, Babcock and Wilcox Nuclear Energy, 109 Ramsey Place, Lynchburg, VA 24501, USA

Received 2 November 2011; Accepted 8 February 2012

Academic Editor: Gilberto Espinosa-Paredes

Copyright © 2012 Robert P. Martin. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Linked References

  1. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission and Regulatory Guide 1.203, “Transient and Accident Analysis Methods,” Revision 0, December 2005.
  2. R. P. Martin, M. W. Bingham, C. A. Bonilla et al., “AREVA NP's severe accident safety issue resolution methodology for the U.S. EPR,” in Proceedings of the International Conference on Advances in Nuclear Power Plants (ICAPP'08), pp. 1122–1131, Anaheim, Calif, USA, June 2008. View at Scopus
  3. USNRC and NUREG-0800, “Standard Review Plan for the Review of Safety Analysis Reports for Nuclear Power Plants,” most recent revision.
  4. USNRC and Regulatory Guide 1.206, “Combined License Applications for Nuclear Power Plants,” most recent revision.
  5. US NRC and SECY-93-087, “Policy, Technical, and Licensing Issues Pertaining to Evolutionary and Advanced Light-Water (ALWR) Designs,” issued April, 1993 and the corresponding SRM, issued July, 1993.
  6. US NRC, “Reactor Safety Study-An Assessment of Accident Risks in U.S. Commercial Nuclear Power Plants,” WASH-1400 (NUREG-75/014), 1975. View at Google Scholar
  7. M. Firnhaber, K. Trambauer, S. Hagen et al., “CORA-13 Experiment on Severe Fuel Damage,” NEA/CSNI-(93) 17, GRS-106, KfK 5287, July, 1993.
  8. Z. R. Martinson, Idaho National Engineering Laboratory et al., PBF Severe Accident Fuel Damage Test 1–3 Test Results Report, 1989, NUREG/CR-5354.
  9. M. Firnhaber, “ISP 28: Phebus-SFD B9+ Experiment on the Degradation of a PWR Type Core,” NEA/CSNI/R(92)17, Volumes 1 and 2, 1992.
  10. B. Clément, N. Hanniet-Girault et al., “The first international PHEBUS fission product program for investigation of phenomena of severe water reactor accidents,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 226, no. 1, pp. 5–28, 2003. View at Google Scholar
  11. W. Hering, Ch. Homann, and J. S. Lamy, “Comparison report on the blind phase of the OECD International Standard Problem no.45, exercise (QUENCH-06),” OECD Document ISP45-OECD, 2002, Report FZKA-6677. View at Google Scholar
  12. W. Hering, Ch. Homann, J. S. Lamy et al., “Comparison and interpretation report of OECD International Standard Problem no.45 exercise (QUENCH-06),” ISP45-OECD, 2002, Report FZKA-6722. View at Google Scholar
  13. E. W. Coryell, Summary of Important Results and SCDAP/RELAP5 Analysis for OECD LOFT Experiment LP-FP-2, 1994, NUREG/CR-6160, NEA/CSNI-(94) 3.
  14. J. L. Rempe, S. A. Chavez, G. L. Thinnes et al., Light Water Reactor Lower Head Failure Analysis, 1993, NUREG/CR-5642, EGG-2618.
  15. J. L. Rempe, “MASCA and RASPLAV test program—description, status, and implications,” INEEL/EXT- 03-00224, 2003. View at Google Scholar
  16. J. L. Rempe, K. G. Condie, and D. L. Knudson, “Thermal properties for candidate SCWR materials,” INL/EXT- 05-01030, 2005. View at Google Scholar
  17. L. A. Stickler, J. L. Rempe et al., “Calculations to estimate the margin-to-failure in the TMI-2 vessel,” NUREG/CR-6196, EGG-2733, 1994.
  18. T. Y. Chu, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission et al., Lower Head Failure Experiments and Analyses, 1999, NUREG/CR-5582 (SAND98-2047).
  19. J. R. Wolf, J. L. Rempe et al., “TMI-2 vessel investigation project integration report,” NUREG/CR -6197, 1994, EGG-2734. View at Google Scholar
  20. D. Magallon and I. Huhtiniemi, “Corium melt quenching tests at low pressure and subcooled water in FARO,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 204, no. 1–3, pp. 369–376, 2001. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  21. I. Huhtiniemi and D. Magallon, “Insight into steam explosions with corium melts in KROTOS,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 204, no. 1–3, pp. 391–400, 2001. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  22. J. H. Kim, I. K. Park, Y. S. Shin et al., “A study on intermediate scale steam explosion experiments with zirconia and corium melts,” in Proceedings of the Transactions of the International Congress on Advanced Nuclear Power Plants (ICAPP'02), Hollywood, Fla, USA, June 2002.
  23. W. W. Tarbell, Sandia National Laboratories et al., Results from the DCH-1 Experiment, Sandia National Laboratory, 1987, SAND86-2483, NUREG/CR-4871.
  24. M. D. Allen, R. T. Nichols, J. E. Brockmann et al., DCH-2: Results from the Second Experiment Performed in the Surtsey Direct Heating Test Facility, Sandia National Laboratory, 1988, SAND87-0976, NUREG/CR-4917.
  25. M. D. Allen, M. M. Pilch, R. O. Griffith, and R. T. Nichols, Experiments to Investigate the Effects of Water in the Cavity on Direct Containment Heating in Surtsey Test Facility- the WC-1 and WC-2 Tests, Sandia National Laboratories, 1992, SAND91-1173.
  26. M. D. Allen, M. M. Pilch, T. K. Blanchat et al., Experiments to Investigate to Direct Containment Heating Phenomena With Scaled Models of the Zion Nuclear Power Plant in the Surtsey Test Facility, 1994, NUREG/CR-6044.
  27. T. K. Blanchat, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission et al., Experiments to Investigate Direct Containment Heating Phenomena With Scaled Models of a Surry Nuclear Power Plant, 1994, NUREG/CR- 6152.
  28. M. Pilch, M. D. Allen, E. W. Klamerus et al., Resolution of the Direct Containment Heating Issue for All Westinghouse Plants With Large Dry Containments or Subatmospheric Containments, 1996, NUREG/CR-6338, SAND95-2381.
  29. M. M. Pilch and U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, The Probability of Containment Failure by Direct Containment Heating in Surry, 1995, NUREG/CR-6109, SAND93-2078.
  30. J. L. Binder, L. M. McUmber, and B. W. Spencer, Direct Containment Heating Integral Effects Tests at 1/40 Scale in Zion Nuclear Power Plant Geometry, Argonne National Laboratory, 1994, NUREG/CR-6168, ANL-94/18.
  31. B. W. Spencer, J. J. Sienicki, L. M. McUmber et al., Hydrodynamics and Heat Transfer Aspects of Corium-water Interactions, Argonne National Laboratory, 1987, EPRI NP-5127.
  32. R. E. Henry, R. J. Hammersley, and G. T. Klopp, “Direct containment heating experiments in a zion-like geometry,” AIChE Symposium Series, vol. 87, no. 283, pp. 86–98, 1991. View at Google Scholar
  33. H. Karwat, “SOAR on Containment Thermalhydraulics and Hydrogen Distribution,” NEA/CSNI (99), 1999. View at Google Scholar
  34. J. Royen, “Final Comparison Report on ISP-35: NUPEC Hydrogen Mixing and Distribution Test (Test M-7-1),” NEA/CSNI (94), 1994. View at Google Scholar
  35. M. Firnhaber, T. F. Kanzleiter, S. Schwarz et al., “ISP37: VANAM M3—a multi compartment aerosol depletion test with hygroscopic aerosol material,” NEA/CSNI (96), 1996. View at Google Scholar
  36. G. W. Koroll, W. A. Dewit, J. L. Sitar et al., “Hydrogen recombiner development at AECL,” in Proceedings of the OECD/NEA/CSNI Workshop on the Implementation of Hydrogen Mitigation Techniques, Winnipeg, 1996, AECL-11762, NEA/CSNI/R(96)8.
  37. K. Fischer, “Qualification of a passive catalytic module for hydrogen mitigation,” Nuclear Technology, vol. 112, no. 1, pp. 58–62, 1995. View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  38. J. Hosler and G. Sliter, “PARs for combustible gas control in advanced light water reactors,” in Proceedings of the OECD/NEA/CSNI Workshop on the Implementation of Hydrogen Mitigation Techniques, Winnipeg, 1996, AECL-11762, NEA/CSNI/R(96)8.
  39. P. Rongier and E. Studer, “H2PAR facility,” in Proceedings of the OECD/NEA/CSNI Workshop on the Implementation of Hydrogen Mitigation Techniques, Winnipeg, 1996, AECL-11762, NEA/CSNI/R(96)8.
  40. W. Breitung, C. Chan, S. B. Dorofeev et al., “Flame acceleration and deflagration-to-detonation transition in nuclear safety,” NEA/CSNI (2000), 2000. View at Google Scholar
  41. M. Firnhaber, “ISP 30: BETA V5.1 experiment on melt-concrete interaction,” NEA/CSNI/R (92)9, 1992. View at Google Scholar
  42. D. G. Thompson et al., “Compilation, analysis and interpretation of ACE phase C and MACE experimental data—MCCI thermohydraulic results,” ACEX TR-C 14, Argonne National Laboratory, 1997. View at Google Scholar
  43. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, and S. Basu, “Mace test M3b data report volume 1,” EPRI TR-108806, 1997, MACE-TR-D13. View at Google Scholar
  44. Farmer M. T. et al., “Mace test M4 data report,” MACE-TR-D 16, 1999. View at Google Scholar
  45. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, D. J. Kilsdonk, and R. W. Aeschlimann, “OECD MCCI project 2-D core concrete interaction (CCI) tests: CCI-1 test data report-thermalhydraulic results,” OECD/MCCI 2004-TR01, 2004. View at Google Scholar
  46. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, D. J. Kilsdonk, and R. W. Aeschlimann, “OECD MCCI project 2-D core concrete interaction (CCI) tests: CCI-2 test data report-thermalhydraulic results,” OECD/MCCI 2004-TR05, 2004. View at Google Scholar
  47. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, D. J. Kilsdonk, and R. W. Aeschlimann, “OECD MCCI project 2-D core concrete interaction (CCI) tests: CCI-3 test data report-thermalhydraulic results,” OECD/MCCI 2005-TR04, 2005. View at Google Scholar
  48. B. W. Spencer, M. Fischer, M. T. Farmer et al., “MACE scoping test,” MACE-TR-D 03, Argonne National Laboratory, 1999. View at Google Scholar
  49. J.-M. Bonnet, “Thermal hydraulic phenomena in corium pools for ex-vessel situations: the BALI experiment,” in Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Nuclear Engineering (ICONE 8), Baltimore, Md, USA, April 2000.
  50. B. Tourniaire and J.-M. Bonnet, “Study of the mixing of immiscible liquids by sparging gas results of the BALISE experiments,” in Proceedings of the 10th International Topical Meeting on Nuclear Reactor Thermal Hydraulics (NURETH-10), Seoul, Korea, October 2003.
  51. M. Nie, M. Fischer, and W. Koller, “Status of interpretation of selected transient MCCI experiments conducted in the frame of the CORESA R&D project,” in Proceedings of the Jahrestagung Kerntechnik, Stuttgart, Germany, May 2002.
  52. S. Hellmann, V. Lansmann, B. Friedrich et al., “Physico-chemical and material aspects of the core melt retention concept of the EPR,” in Proceedings of the OECD Workshop on Ex-Vessel Debris Coolability, Karlsruhe, Germany, November 1999.
  53. B. Adroguer, P. Chatelard, J. P. van Dorsselaere et al., “Corium interactions and thermochemistry (CIT project),” INV-CIT (99)-P040, European Commission, 1999. View at Google Scholar
  54. B. Eppinger, T. Cron, G. Stern et al., “KAPOOL experiments on melt-through of a metal plate by an overlying melt pool,” FZKA 7024, Forschungszentrum Karlsruhe, August 2004.
  55. M. T. Farmer, “Melt eruption test (MET-1) results,” in Proceedings of the 6th Program Review Meeting of the MCCI-OECD Project, Madrid, Spain, April 2005.
  56. J. M. Veteau and R. Wittmaack, “CORINE experiments and theoretical modelling,” FISA-95-EU Research on Severe Accidents, EUR 16896 EN, 1996.
  57. B. Eppinger, F. Fellmoser, G. Fieg et al., “Simulationsexperimente zum Ausbreitungsverhalten von Kernschmelze: KATS 8-17,” Forschungszentrum, Karlsruhe, FZKA 6589, March 2001.
  58. W. Steinwarz et al., “COMAS spreading experiments with prototypic oxidic corium melts for optimization of spreading compartment designs,” ICONE7, Tokyo, Japan, April 1999.
  59. R. Silverii and D. Magallon, “FARO LWR programme, test L26-S data report, technical note,” EXV-CSC (98)-D007, 1998, EU 4th FWP. View at Google Scholar
  60. G. Cognet, J.-M. Seiler, I. Szabo et al., “The VULCANO spreading programme article,” EU 4th FWP, EXV-CSC(98)-D018, SARJ-98, 1999.
  61. M. J. Konovalikhin, T. N. Dinh, and B. R. Sehgal, “Experimental simulation of core melt spreading in two dimensions,” in Proceedings of the The 9th International Topical Meeting on Nuclear Reactor Thermal Hydraulics (NURETH-9), San Francisco, Calif, USA, October 1999.
  62. B. R. Sehgal and B. W. Spencer, “Ace program phase D: melt attack and coolability experiments (MACE) program,” in Proceedings of the Second OECD (NEA) CSNI Specialist Meeting on Molten Core Debris-Concrete Interactions, Karlsruhe, Germany, April 1992, NEA/CSNI-(92) 10, KfK 5108.
  63. H. Alsmeyer et al., “Experiment ECOKATS-2 on melt spreading and subsequent top flooding test and data report,” Forschungszentrum, Karlsruhe, FZKA 7084, January 2005.
  64. M. Fischer, O. Herbst, and H. Schmidt, “Demonstration of the heat removing capabilities of the EPR spreading compartment,” in Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium on Two-Phase flow Modelling and Experimentation, Pisa, Italy, September 2004.
  65. G. E. Wilson and B. E. Boyack, “The role of the PIRT process in experiments, code development and code applications associated with reactor safety analysis,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 186, no. 1-2, pp. 23–37, 1998. View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  66. D. Magallon, A. Mailliat, J. M. Seiler et al., “European expert network for the reduction of uncertainties in severe accident safety issues (EURSAFE),” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 235, no. 2–4, pp. 309–346, 2005. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  67. K. Nagashima, M. Alammar, and H. C. da Silva, “Application of uncertainty analyses with the MAAP4 code,” in Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Simulation Methods in Nuclear Engineering, Canadian Nuclear Society, Montreal, Quebec, month year.
  68. R. Ashley, M. El-Shanawany, F. Eltawila et al., “Good practices for user effect reduction,” Status Report NEA/CSNI/R(98)22, 1998, Paris, France. View at Google Scholar
  69. R. O. Gauntt, R. K. Cole, C. M. Erickson et al., “MELCOR computer code manuals,” Version 1.8.6, NUREG/CR-6119, Rev. 3, SAND-2417/2, Sandia National Laboratory, September 2005.
  70. SCDAP/RELAP5 Development Team, “SCDAP/RELAP5/MOD3.2 code manual, Vol. 1–5,” NUREG/CR-6150, INEL-96/0422, July 1998.
  71. Fauske and Associates, Inc, “MAAP4—modular accident analysis program for LWR power plants, vol. 2, part 1: code structure and theory,” prepared for Electric Power Research Institute, May 1994.
  72. J. S. Butler, D. Kapitz, R. K. Sundaram, and R. P. Martin, “MAAP4.0.7 analysis and justification for PRA level 1 mission success criteria,” in Proceedings of the International Congress on Advances in Nuclear Power Plants (ICAPP '08), Anaheim, Calif, USA, June 2008, paper 8200.
  73. S. S. Wilks, “Determination of sample sizes for setting tolerance limits,” The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, vol. 12, pp. 91–96, 1941. View at Google Scholar
  74. R. P. Martin and W. T. Nutt, “Perspectives on the application of order-statistics in best-estimate plus uncertainty nuclear safety analysis,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 241, no. 1, pp. 274–284, 2011. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  75. M. M. Pilch, M. D. Allen, E. W. Klamerus et al., Resolution of the Direct Containment Heating Issue for All Westinghouse Plants With Large Dry Containments or Subatmospheric Containments, 1996, NUREG/CR-6338, SAND95-2381.
  76. N. Zuber, G. E. Wilson, M. Ishii et al., “An integrated structure and scaling methodology for severe accident technical issue resolution: development of methodology,” Nuclear Engineering and Design, vol. 186, no. 1-2, pp. 1–21, 1998. View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  77. J. C. Helton, J. D. Johnson, C. J. Sallaberry, and C. B. Storlie, “Survey of sampling-based methods for uncertainty and sensitivity analysis,” Reliability Engineering and System Safety, vol. 91, no. 10-11, pp. 1175–1209, 2006. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  78. K. Chan, A. Saltelli, and S. Tarantola, “Sensitivity analysis of model output: variance-based methods make the difference,” in Proceedings of the Winter Simulation Conference, pp. 261–268, Atlanta, Ga, USA, December 1997. View at Scopus
  79. H. Glaeser, “Uncertainty evaluation of thermal-hydraulic code results,” in Proceedings of the International Mtg. Best-Estimate Methods in Nuclear Installation Safety Analysis (BE-2000), Washington, DC, USA, November 2000.
  80. R. P. Martin, “Quantifying phenomenological importance in best-estimate plus uncertainty analyses,” Nuclear Technology, vol. 175, no. 3, pp. 652–662, 2011. View at Google Scholar
  81. “U.S. EPR final safety analysis report,” Rev. 0, AREVA NP Inc., December 2007.