Research Article
Bearing Fault Diagnosis Using a Support Vector Machine Optimized by an Improved Ant Lion Optimizer
Table 6
Model optimization and bearing fault diagnostic results at 2400 r/min.
| Methods | | | Time (s) | Iteration number | SV number | Testing dataset | Training dataset | Faults | Recognition rate (%) | Faults | Recognition rate (%) |
| EALO | 26.5027 | 6.4664 | 0.2656 | 3 | 22 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| ALO | 30.0000 | 1.7908 | 3.4479 | 100 | 27 | Normal | 94 | Normal | 88 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 100 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 98.5 | Average | 97 | Total average | 97.75 |
| GA-1 | 24.4322 | 5.4787 | 9.9083 | 100 | 21 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| GA-2 | 23.2381 | 7.7137 | 10.2449 | 100 | 22 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| GA-3 | 21.7289 | 8.6957 | 9.1041 | 100 | 23 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| GA-4 | 22.4615 | 6.4680 | 8.4840 | 100 | 22 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| GA-5 | 24.9011 | 9.3258 | 10.8618 | 100 | 24 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| PSO-1 | 30.0000 | 1.8006 | 6.9233 | 100 | 26 | Normal | 88 | Normal | 84 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 100 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 97 | Average | 96 | Total average | 96.5 |
| PSO-2 | 30.0000 | 1.7888 | 8.8493 | 100 | 27 | Normal | 92 | Normal | 88 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 100 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 98 | Average | 97 | Total average | 97.5 |
| PSO-3 | 30.0000 | 1.88131 | 7.6882 | 100 | 29 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 96 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99 | Total average | 99.5 |
| PSO-4 | 30.0000 | 7.4530 | 6.5468 | 100 | 24 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
| PSO-5 | 20.5845 | 9.0898 | 7.2608 | 100 | 23 | Normal | 100 | Normal | 100 | Inner | 100 | Inner | 98 | Outer | 100 | Outer | 100 | Ball | 100 | Ball | 100 | Average | 100 | Average | 99.5 | Total average | 99.75 |
|
|