Research Article

An Adaptive Framework for Selecting Environmental Monitoring Protocols to Support Ocean Renewable Energy Development

Table 1

Potential effects of offshore renewable energy developments in the United States considered to be of greatest importance based on results of a literature review and expert judgment (see Supplementary Appendix A). Effects are organized by ecosystem component and are paired with a proposed indicator of that effect.

Impact/monitoring objectiveIndicator

Benthic habitat and resourcesChanges to seafloor morphology and structure (compared to preconstruction)Increase or decrease in seabed volume
Changes in median grain size, or organic content(i) Deposition: decrease in median grain size, increase in organic content, increase in seabed volume
(ii) Scour: increase in median grain size, decrease in organic content, decrease in seabed volume
Turbidity during construction/decommissioningChange in water column turbidity
Change in target species abundance and distribution (e.g., species of importance)Change in abundance, diversity, % cover, multivariate community composition
Current speed/direction inside and outside farm Change in residual flow rates
Reef effects, colonization on foundationsIncrease in % cover, biomass of epifaunal organisms; increase in presence of nonnative species
Change in density, diversity, dominance structure of infauna Change in abundance, diversity, % cover, multivariate community composition

FishReef or aggregation effectsIncrease in fish abundance around devices, shift in species composition, increase in presence of nonnative species
Changes to abundance/distribution caused by disturbance or habitat alterationIncrease or decrease in fish abundance; increase or decrease in target species; shift in species composition; change in density, diversity, and dominance structure of fish species; increase in presence of nonnative species
Blade strikes/pressure gradients (tidal power)Observation of blade strike incidents
EMF effectsNot feasible to monitor directly—changes in fish abundance, behavior, or species composition are indicators
Installation or operational noise effectsNot feasible to monitor directly—changes in fish abundance, behavior, or species composition are indicators

FisheriesCatchability (catch per unit effort) during constructionCatch per unit effort increases or decreases for target species
Catchability (catch per unit effort) during operationCatch per unit effort increases or decreases for target species
Loss of access to groundsChanges in numbers of vessels fishing near or inside of the renewable energy area, change in the presence of fixed fishing gear inside of or around a renewable energy installation
Changes in species distributionShift in species composition, increase in presence of nonnative species
Reef effects (aggregation)Increase in fish abundance around devices; shift in species composition; increase in presence of nonnative species

AvianDisplacement/attractionIncrease or decrease in avian species-specific densities postconstruction in development area
Barrier effects—effects on foraging, roosting, migratory movementsMigrating or commuting birds avoiding developed areas
Collision mortalityBirds found dead or injured due to direct collision with infrastructure above the water

Marine mammals and sea turtlesVessel strikesDetection of dead or injured animals
Noise generated during constructionDetection of dead or injured animals; changes in distribution, abundance, or behavior of populations
Disturbance or injury during all stages of development, including from vesselsDetection of dead or injured animals; changes in distribution, abundance, or behavior of populations
Noise generated during operationChanges in distribution, abundance, or behavior of populations