An Iterated Tabu Search Approach for the Clique Partitioning Problem

Table 2

Comparison of ITS with NS-R and NS-TS on the CPP instances of size 500.

Instance	Best value	ITS		NS-R	NS-TS
	𝐹	𝐹best−𝐹 (𝐹aver−𝐹)	Succ.	𝐹−𝐹	𝐹−𝐹
p500-5-1	−17691	0 (10.5)	1	30	0
p500-5-2	−17169	0 (1.5)	6	29	0
p500-5-3	−16815	0 (1.0)	3	92	129
p500-5-4	−16808	0 (3.5)	8	71	70
p500-5-5	−16957	0 (0.0)	10	53	51
p500-5-6	−16615	0 (2.9)	6	134	77
p500-5-7	−16649	0 (8.0)	1	59	71
p500-5-8	−16756	0 (0.9)	7	153	142
p500-5-9	−16629	0 (5.8)	4	17	77
p500-5-10	−17360	0 (0.0)	10	60	62
p500-100-1	−308896	0 (18.9)	4	9	1827
p500-100-2	−310163	0 (171.5)	2	1713	858
p500-100-3	−310477	0 (94.7)	4	2149	718
p500-100-4	−309567	0 (282.9)	1	904	796
p500-100-5	−309135	0 (41.6)	7	2528	0
p500-100-6	−310280	0 (66.7)	7	0	722
p500-100-7	−310063	0 (5.8)	9	1456	2088
p500-100-8	−303148	0 (344.0)	5	2205	1686
p500-100-9	−305305	0 (7.2)	9	1232	1110
p500-100-10	−314864	0 (7.6)	9	76	106
Average		0 (53.7)	5.7	648.5	529.5