| | Author |
Levine,
1980 [22] | Bodlund et
al., 1993 [14] |
Bodlund and Armelius,
1994 [15] | Cole et al., 1997 [11] |
Haraldsen and Dahl,
2000 [16] | Hepp et al., 2005 [12] | Madeddu et al.,
2009 [13] | Hoshiai et al.,
2010 [9] |
This paper |
| Diagnostic
criteria | DSM-
III | DSM-III-R | DSM-III-R | DSM-IV | DSM-III-R/IV | DSM-IV | DSM-III-R | DSM-IV | DSM-IV |
| Assessment
method | Clinical interview | SCID | SCID
screen | Clinical
interview | SCID-II | SCID-II | SCID-II | — | SCID-II |
| | Sex | | MtF-10
FtM-9 | — | MtF-318
FtM-117 | MtF + FtM-86 | MtF-20
FtM-11 | MtF-34
FtM-16 | MtF-230
FtM-349 | MtF-21,
FtM-9 |
| Total
sample | N = 51 | N = 19 | N = 18 | N = 435 | N = 86 | N = 31 | N = 50 | N = 579 | N = 30 |
| Prevalence
of PD | 66% | 3 (30%)
6 (67%) | 33,3% | 18 (6%)
5 (4%)
4% MtF, 3% FtM | 8 (40%)
4 (36%) prevalence of PD 19,8% | 42% | 20 (77%)
23 (23%) | 41 (19%)
38 (12%) | 20 (66,6%)
comorbid PDs 13 (46,6%) |
| Main
results | | Mainly
cluster B or C PDs | Clusters
B (22,2%),
C (11,1%), and
A (0%) | Clusters
A (schizoid PD) and
B (borderline PD) most frequent diagnosis | Clusters
A 5,8%,
B 8,1%, and
C 5,8%, NOS 0% | Clusters
A 16,1%, B 22,6%, and
C 19,4%, NOS
6,5% | Clusters A 2%,
B 22%, and C 12%. NOS 16%
No differences in psychopathological profile
and severity between MtF and FtM TS | Adjustment
disorder (6,7%), anxiety disorder (3,6%), and
mood disorder (1,4%, 8/579): all were associated with histories of suicidal ideation (in FtM, but not in MtF group) | Clusters A
and C (paranoid PD—43,3% and avoidant PD—26,7%). Differences in relation
to biological sex in GID group versus heterosexuals (MtF: paranoid, schizoid, borderline, and avoidant PD; FtM: paranoid
PD) |
| Sample
characteristics | Patients requesting
SRS | Transsexuals,
for example, GID (DSM-III-R) | Transsexuals, for example, GID (DSM-III-R) | Patients
requesting SRS | Mixed sample,
pre- and post-SRS | GID
(DSM-IV) | GID
(DSM-III-R) | GID (DSM-IV) | GID
patients
(DSM-IV) |
|
|
