The AHP (1-9 Value Scale) Level Method to Analyze the Development of Logistics under the Perspective of Low-Carbon Environmental Protection: Taking Shandong Province, China, as an Example

Table 3

Analysis of AHP indicators for the development of logistics industry in Shandong Province.

No.	Index	Low-carbon logistics	Traditional logistics
1	Whether to use recycled environmentally friendly building materials	Yes	No
2	Utilization rate of warehouse	95.56%	77.41%
3	Fuel consumption rate	88.72%	68.97%
4	Green energy usage rate	93.36%	58.90%
5	Vehicle no-load rate	5.41%	32.48%
6	Combination rate of various modes of transportation	98.15%	74.51%
7	Reasonable transportation route planning	12.85% more than the theoretical transportation journey	33.15% more than the theoretical transportation journey
8	Utilization rate of green packaging	97.82%	84.10%
9	Waste recycling rate	92.11%	68.14%
10	Whether the product is overpackaged	No	Yes
11	Low-carbon new technology utilization rate	77.98%	61.15%
12	Logistics management level evaluation	9.5 points	7.0 points
13	Logistics cost chain index	Overall reduction 2.6%	1.1% overall reduction