[Retracted] A Comprehensive Review of Lightweight Authenticated Encryption for IoT Devices

Table 5

Authenticated encryption hardware performance metrics.

Algorithm	Family	Mode	Area	Power; (mWatt)	Throughput; (mbps)	Implementation
AES_GCM [167]	BCAE	GCM	9167 LUTs	1666	×	Zynq-7000 PYNQ
ACORN_v2 [25]	SCAE	×	0.035 mm^2	0.163	8	CMOS UMC 130
ACORN32 [60]	SCAE	×	0.0169 mm^2	3.130	34040	TSMC 65 nm
ACORN_v2 [25]	SCAE	×	476 LUTs	0.582	8	Zynq-7000 XC7Z020
ACORN32 [167]	SCAE	×	7342 LUTs	1646	×	Zynq-7000 PYNQ
ACORN [164]	SCAE	×	418 LUTs	9200	1225.5	Spartan-6
ASCON GMU [60]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	1408.4 mm^2	0.0235	3.310	TSMC 65 nm
ASCON [25]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	0.083 mm^2	0.655	106.67	CMOS UMC 130
ASCON [25]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	1312 LUTs	2.160	106.67	Zynq-7000 XC7Z020
ASCON [167]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	7726 LUTs	1648	×	Zynq-7000 PYNQ
ASCON [164]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	684 LUTs	×	60.1	Spartan-6
AES-CLOC [112]	BCAE	CLOC	5628 LE	×	400.7	FPGA cyclone IV
AES-CLOC [25]	BCAE	CLOC	0.544 mm^2	2.858	128	CMOS UMC 130
AES-CLOC [25]	BCAE	CLOC	2767 LUTs	3.766	128	Zynq-7000 XC7Z020
AES-CLOC-GMU [20]	BCAE	CLOC	0.0140 mm^2	18.79	6840	TSMC 65 nm
JOLTIK [25]	BCAE	TAE	1325 LUTs	1.380	20	Zynq-7000 XC7Z020
JOLTIK [25]	BCAE	TAE	0.178 mm^2	0.96	20	CMOS UMC 130
PRIMATEs [25]	PBAE	GIBBON	1187 LUTs	3.547	66.67	Zynq-7000 XC7Z020
PRIMATEs [25]	PBAE	GIBBON	0.106 mm^2	1.064	66.67	CMOS UMC 130
Scream-10 [149]	BCAE	TAE	17292 um^2	×	4577	65 NM CMOS
SCREAM [25]	BCAE	TAE	0.114 mm^2	0.842	128	CMOS UMC 130
Scream [25]	BCAE	TAE	2235 LUTs	4.106	128	Zynq7000 XC7Z020
AES-SILC [150]	BCAE	SILC	15675.5 GE	×	764.12	90 nm ASIC
AES-SILC [25]	BCAE	SILC	0.187 mm^2	2.345	128	CMOS UMC 130
AES-SILC [48]	BCAE	SILC	0.1031 mm^2	7.000	640	CMOS UMC 130
SILC-GMU[60]	BCAE	SILC	0.0677 mm^2	4.360	6400	TSMC 65 nm
AES-SILC [25]	BCAE	SILC	3004 mm^2	5.980	128	Zynq7000 XC7Z020
AES-SILC [164]	BCAE	SILC	1052 LUTs	9200	76.6	Spartan-6
AES-SILC [164]	BCAE	SILC	1198 LUTs	×	48.1	Zynq7000XC7VX485T
AES-SILC [164]	BCAE	SILC	1160 LUTs	×	59.13	Zynq-7000 XC6VLX760
LED-SILC [164]	BCAE	SILC	872 LUTs	8400	15.1	Spartan-6
AES-CLOC [164]	BCAE	CLOC	1604 LUTs	1089	68.7	Spartan-6
AES-CLOC [164]	BCAE	CLOC	1306 LUTs	×	45.72	Zynq-7000 XC7VX485T
AES-CLOC [164]	BCAE	CLOC	1282 LUTs	×	52.03	Zynq7000XC6VLX760
Aegis_128 [167]	BCAE	×	17323 LUTs	2139	×	Zynq7000 PYNQ
Aegis_265[167]	BCAE	×	19716 LUTs	2039	×	Zynq7000 PYNQ
Aegis-GMU [60]	BCAE	×	0.1661 mm^2	7.520	8650	TSMC 65 nm
DeoxysII [167]	BCAE	XEX	10681 LUTs	1738	×	Zynq7000 PYNQ
DeoxysII [60]	BCAE	XEX	531.91 mm^2	0.0988	18.63	TSMC 65 nm
DeoxysII	BCAE	TAE	14107 GE	×	×	×
AES-OCB [167]	BCAE	OCB	10432 LUTs	1683	×	Zynq7000 PYNQ
OCB-GMU [60]	BCAE	OCB	0.1442 mm^2	27.42	4920	TSMC 65 nm
NORX [60]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	0.1231 mm^2	19.51	57400	TSMC 65 nm
NORX [48]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	0.1039 mm^2	4.370	2400	CMOS UMC 130
NORX [164]	PBAE	Monkey duplex	1424 LUTs	1280	2989.0	Spartan-6
AES-JAMBU [164]	BCAE	JAMBU	191 LUTs	737	×	Zynq7000XC7VX485T
AES-JAMBU [164]	BCAE	JAMBU	244 LUTs	713	×	Zynq7000XC6VLX760
AES-JAMBU [60]	BCAE	JAMBU	0.3887 mm^2	3.110	3170	TSMC 65 nm
AES-JAMBU [48]	BCAE	JAMBU	0.0580 mm^2	3.390	128	CMOS UMC 130
Tiaoxin [60]	BCAE	×	0.0140 mm^2	9.360	1115320	TSMC 65 nm
Tiaoxin [48]	BCAE	×	0.2282 mm^2	11.68	4270	CMOS UMC 130
AEZ-GMU	BCAE	XEX	0.1186 mm^2	22.07	2980	TSMC 65 nm
Ketje_jr [60]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	0.0172 mm^2	3.270	14550	TSMC 65 nm
Ketje_sr [60]	PBAE	Monkey wrap	0.0276 mm^2	4.710	29090	TSMC 65 nm
MORUS [25]	SCAE	×	0.27 mm^2	2.830	256	CMOS UMC 130
MORUS [60]	SCAE	×	50965 um^2	×	114.8 Gbps	TSMC 65 nm
MORUS [161]	SCAE	×	179 slices 4122 LUTs	×	94117	FPGA Vertix-7
MORUS [25]	SCAE	×	4286 LUTs	4.899	256	Zynq7000 XC7Z020
COLM [60]	BCAE	Encrypt-linear	505.05 mm^2	0.0177	23.75	TSMC 65 nm
		Mix-encrypt mode
COLM [48]	BCAE	Encrypt-linear	0.3274 mm^2	12.08	580	CMOS UMC 130
		Mix-encrypt mode
COLM [164]	BCAE	Encrypt-linear	2521 LUTs	×	37.1	Zynq7000XC7VX485T
		Mix-encrypt mode
COLM [164]	BCAE	Encrypt-linear	2511 LUTs	×	38.9	Zynq7000XC6VLX760
		Mix-encrypt mode
COLM [167]	BCAE	Encrypt-linear	13861 LUTs	1796	×	Zynq7000 PYNQ
		Mix-encrypt mode